How would you do this combined shipping discount/refund?
Summary: inhawaii asked how to handle a shipping refund for a customer who overpaid due to multiple separate transactions. Various participants shared their methods: some prefer doing a single lump sum refund for simplicity, while others divide the refund across transactions to maintain accurate records or in case of disputes. mam98031 mentioned considering transaction fees when issuing refunds, and powell-collectibles expressed not giving refunds unless requested. Ultimately, inhawaii decided to issue three refunds of $4.40 each.
A customer bought 4 items from me separately without checking out.
The items are $8.40 S&H for the first item, $4 S&H for each additional item.
She paid $8.40 X 4 = $33.60 instead of $8.40 + $4 + $4 + $4 = $20.40.
I'm going to give her a combined shipping discount/refund for the over payment.
My question is...
Do I give her one lump sum of a refund of $13.20, if so which order shall I attach it to?
-or-
Do i give her 3 refunds of $4.40 each?
1st sale - no refund
2nd sale = $4.40 refund
3rd sale = $4.40 refund
4th sale = $4.40 refund
iamalwaysright
This. That way the buyer can't abuse the returns process and ultimately get more bang for their buck.
inhawaii
OPDone.
The buyer received three $4.40 refunds.
Thank you!
powell-collectibles
When I had my stores, I’d always have order discounts. And when I’m charging for shipping, I do have combined shipping enabled. Those are the discounts that I give. If and when a buyer purchases a few items in separate transactions and doesn’t take advantage of the potential to combine and doesn’t check with me before or even after the sale on a discount, I keep everything. That’s my money – not his. If the buyer doesn’t care about a discount, I don’t either.
I know, I know – some will tout the benefits of giving away your money. Truth is that buyers really don’t care about your “honesty” – they want cool items that that they can’t get elsewhere, or at least not as conveniently as from eBay. Heck, I’m not really sure how it isn’t “honest” to not give an after-the-fact, unearned discount.
I get plenty of repeat customers that just don’t care about combining orders. I have explained to a couple of guys again and again how it works – they don’t listen and must not care. So, they can pay full price – no issue there. Oh, and yes, I do ship all in the same box when a buyer purchases over multiple orders. Again, that’s my money.
mam98031
This happens to me all the time. I assume you are saying you received 4 separate payments. When this happens to me and assuming you mean 4 separate payments, then I send the buyer a message explaining how this affects the fees a seller has to pay, so my refund on overpayment of shipping is not as good as it would have been if one payment had of been made.
So if it was all separate payments, I reduce what I would have usually refunded them by 35 cents to cover the 30 cent per transaction fee and the selling fees associated. So for the 1st sale, no refund and for the other items I would refund $4.10 on each payment.
Now if I got it ALL in ONE payment, the above of course wouldn't apply and I would refund as you stated above. Even when I do this, I send a message to the buyer explaining that I will be refunding them, how much the refund is and I explain why. I do that because by voluntarily refunding buyers for overpayment of shipping when they have NOT contacted me, often turns into a repeat customer. They are so thrilled by the honestly they come back. So I try to help them understand what to do when they want multiple items.
I also have this stated in my listing as well. Fell free to use this info or discard it. It is simply info to consider. It has served me well for years.
luckythewinner
I generally spread it across all four transactions. That way if the buyer disputes any one of them, at least I save a little bit no matter which one I am refunding.
pickapaper
I also have this happen sometimes and I always divide the refund between the number of items purchased rather than doing a lump sum against one of the items. Just my preference.
I've never had it happen so do not know how it would come out but I always wondered what would happen if a lump sum refund is given against one item and that particular item is returned.
duffy4444
I run across this situation quite often, mainly with separate multiple sales of dinnerware pieces.
The difference between what she paid and what you can ship for is $13.20 in her favor. Combine the items when you get the shipping label, then refund whatever amount you want to split the difference into. I think you can have eBay automatically divide up the difference between all of the items when you refund, or you can choose to split the difference and take it off the first item if the math works out.
Cheers,Duffy
shire123
@duffy4444 As far as I know the only way that ebay will divide the refund equally between items is if the buyer has bought them by using their cart. If each purchase was separate, then you need to refund each separately.
shire123
Depends on how you wish to keep your records. It won't make any difference to the buyer.
The first lump sum way is the easiest for you.
The other way with 4 individual refunds keeps your ebay records accurate for you by showing the "real" results of each transaction.
When I get these situation I always do the individual smaller refunds so when I go back and look at my sales the net from each sale truly reflects my proceeds.