How to handle Very High “Item not as described†rating
Hello ebay community,
For the first time I have a very high return rating for "cell phone" category. I sell high priced phones ($800-$1500) and the extra 5% fee is costing me an extra $50-$100 each phone that I only profit around $20-$30. I'm losing big money on every sell. I calculated this is going to cost me $10,000 to $15,000 in extra fees this month! How should I handle this? Should I stop selling the phones until it goes back down? It's a highly competetive market so if I raise prices I won't sell any. Any advice?
worldwide_ship
34 comments
yourtech4less
I had not seen that your margins were so slim, you need to shift to a less risky category in my opinion or find a way increase your margings if you wanna stick to this category because electronics are very tricky/risky if you don't have good margins to take a hit when things go south.
yourtech4less
It is a seasonal thing, January-February returns always spike up right after the hollidays, it is a "TRADITION" and if you have a buyer pays return policy, then they will use not as described instead of buyers remorse just not to pay for return.
zoda99
@yourtech4lesssaid: It is a seasonal thing, January-February returns always spike up right after the hollidays, it is a "TRADITION" and if you have a buyer pays return policy, then they will use not as described instead of buyers remorse just not to pay for return.
This isn't exactly true. I sell cell phones and every return I've ever gotten for them were remorse returns paid for by the customer.
yourtech4less
I don't see a single phone on your current listings, if you sell one phone every couple of months, you will rarely have any returns, If you sell a few dozen or dozens in a Month, your returns will proportonionally increase.
farmalljr
At the end of the day, it does not matter how eBay calculates your returns against your "peers". It's probably a bunk formula anyway. The deal is, you will be below standard for 30+ days. Why on this green earth, would you sell for a loss? You like throwing away money? Are your a charity or a business?
I ask that because no business I know of, especially a small business, can run at a loss very long. 12-15K in the hole in a month is a lot of money. And there is no guarantee in a month you will be back to at least above standard. So why would you continue to sell something with extremely low margins and now zero profit at all? Eating through what you have saved just to "hope" to get in a better place, when everyone is having problems with returns, is a fool's errand.
Little sellers are never going to crush the big sellers. They have the bank to sell at a loss to get rid of you. When you are selling on a few percent margins, it's your sign the category is not for small sellers. You have no room and no bank to survive the ebbs and flows.
asset_liquidators
I am not trying to sound mean but honestly, if you are selling items at $800-$1500 and only making $20-$30 off each sale then that is a really bad investment especially in a high fraud category such as cell phones.
One scammer claiming "not as described" and returning a rock or some other useless object instead of your actual item (phone) could potentially take you up to 75 future transactions just to recover that $1500.
worldwide_ship
OPOne scammer claiming "not as described" and returning a rock or some other useless object instead of your actual item (phone) could potentially take you up to 75 future transactions just to recover that $1500.
You're absolutely correct. Fraud has been the bain of my existence. I've been limitied on every venue I sell on due to "box of rocks" fraud returns. I've been audited, asked to supply tax returns, government documentaion, supplier information. In 2015 I even had the Dept of Justice send me a letter saying I shipped to a known terrorist! I'm just honest, file all my police reports, go to the post office and get documentaion, use survaillance footage/weight discrepenices, and I'm able to get my money back one way or another. Again, I've been doing this 15 years and it's not easy!
pls-consignments
Interesting. Too many questions to ask, so I'll just say that it could be one, or the combination of two things...
1) You are using AI to write your descriptions
or,
2) You, and other used cellphone sellers are being impacted by the current cell company wars that are competing for new business by giving brand new phones away...Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile, US Cellular, etc.
FREE iPhone 15's FOR EVERYONE!!
monster-deals
Yes
inhawaii
How to handle Very High “Item not as described†rating
That's a easy one.
Describe your items better.
soh.maryl
This is so simple that I'm sure you have thought about it: You have to figure out the reason that so many buyers are claiming NAD.
worldwide_ship
OPThis is so simple that I'm sure you have thought about it: You have to figure out the reason that so many buyers are claiming NAD.
I've been going through all the returns. Most of them are out of my control...
I don't like the camera
The item arrived cracked
The phone is locked (I recieved it back, tested it with my simcard, and it was unlocked!
Volume isn't loud enough
Etc
Yes some of the returns are my mistake like me missing a scratch. I just don't understand how "compared to my peers" I'm having way more of these issues than any other phone seller. Now I'm just venting
iamalwaysright
If you over analyze it I’m sure you’ll find some ways that you can control and limit some of these returns. Phone arrived cracked for example can be resolved on your side if you choose to. You can always package the item better to the point of even “overkill†to ensure this reason doesn’t get used for a return again.
I agree and I don’t like the way we leave it to ebay to determine our “peersâ€. For instance all of my listings are multi variation and I get a good number of my SNADs from buyers not knowing how to correctly choose something like “black/large†and file SNADs when I send them the black medium they ordered. Yet my peers don’t necessarily run MV listings thus having a SNAD advantage on me.
Perhaps ebay changed your pool of peers, could that be possible?
sextons-sweet-deals
three things stick out.
1. I don't see any active listings.?
2. you state: I calculated this is going to cost me $10,000 to $15,000 in extra fees this month!
3. you also stated: I only profit around $20-$30. I'm losing big money on every sell.
The math and sales model does not add up.
worldwide_ship
OPThe math and sales model does not add up.
I just calculated it as the average cost of the fees for the day. Today it has already cost me $200 in extra fees. By the end of today it could be around $400-$500. $400 x 30 is $12,000 in extra fees for the month.
fab_finds4u
redlinear
In the past, I'd tell YOU to do something differently (better) in order to stop the returns.
HOWEVER, I'm experiencing more than normal returns on two ID's.
And have talked to several other sellers that have called and asked me "What's up with all the returns lately?"
One of them is closing down due to returns getting out of hand. And I'd re-hire this seller in a heartbeat if he wanted to come back and work for me (he's one of those people that doesn't miss a thing when listing items. Extremely good and accurate).
My returns have little to do with the item, or me.
I think A-LOT of what is happening is "offers and promoted items", because I see it when I buy items.
Somebody runs a search, adds a few of the items to their watch list, finally thinks they found "the deal", and buy it. And item gets shipped.
Over the next few days, they receive offers from other sellers for less $$. As soon as the item arrives, they file a Return and claim Not as Described in order to circumvent return shipping costs. (and save face...IE: your fault, not mine).
eBay has taken for sure done transactions and thrown other things (items and prices) at them from every direction, after the fact.
It's a wonder any sale sticks any more.
fern*wood
I'm sorry for you predicament. I can't get past the line where you state you only make $20-$30. on an item that sells for $800. to $1500.00. The risk in this would be so off the charts for me. I'd start looking for a new line of items to sell here that isn't so risky.
broto_64
It's usually the case, sellers who sell in such volume fall prey to the trap that they'll make it up in the long run.
But with defects quite the opposite is true, the less you sell the lower your defect rate will be, it truly is a simple numbers game. So to increase profit and decrease defects (and remain or get back to TRS+) the simple solution is to raise prices by a good 10%.
A 10% increase in prices will decrease sales, increase profits, and allow the old defects to slide off the chart over time as fewer new defects come to take their place. As well, a decrease in sales frees up time that a business owner can spend reviewing and polishing up their methods.
worldwide_ship
OPA 10% increase in prices will decrease sales, increase profits, and allow the old defects to slide off the chart over time as fewer new defects come to take their place. As well, a decrease in sales frees up time that a business owner can spend reviewing and polishing up their methods.
This is what I'm thinking about doing. I'm thinking about raising prices 5%. That will pretty much take me out the market temporarily but I'd rather that then give ebay $10,000-$15,000. That way I will split the difference and take less of a loss and hopefully a sell with trickle in here and there.
fab_finds4u
Don't think about raising prices when you should be thinking about slashing prices to get some fast sales.
Let buyers know it's a today only or week-end only sale so they'll be motivated to buy now while it's on sale.
The object should be getting away from below standard which causes a penalty. The only way to get away from being penalized is to sell as many or more items with no defects or returns. You need to lower your return rate.
I'm afraid raising prices 5% would not be helpful.
iamalwaysright
I’m sorry to ask, but how does lowering your sales volume lower your SNAD defect rate? Isn't it rated proportionally? Simply lowering your volume and doing nothing else will not change your defect percentage at all. The only way I see this to be true is if you lower your volume to zero.
worldwide_ship
OPI'd start looking for a new line of items to sell here that isn't so risky.
I hear that a lot, but I've been doing this successfully for 15 years. The competition is simply too tight in this category. I have to compete with major retailers for this inventory and this profit. This is the first time having the issue with returns though.
farmalljr
Were it me, I would not sell something at a loss. I would find a venue someplace else to sell it so I can make a profit. Otherwise you would be better off to stop selling those items and liquidate the inventory for at least your costs in it so as to NOT lose money.
luckythewinner
Were it me, I would not sell something at a loss.
That makes sense if you don't already own the merchandise.
But based on the numbers the OP gave, selling $1K phones where the 5% penalty fee causes $12k in extra fees would indicate he is selling somewhere near 200 phones a month.
So I suspect he may have significant existing inventory.
worldwide_ship
OPSo I suspect he may have significant existing inventory.
Yes correct. I have a lot of phones here. Currently going through my returns to figure out what happened but I don't see anything different than previous months. Maybe my "competitors" suddenly started getting less returns. Great idea from ebay though. They have to be making a killing off of these fees.
theteamsetguy
@luckythewinner ,
My public school arithmetic says 5% of $1,000.00 is $50.00 and not $12.00.
buyselljack2016
@worldwide_ship
You need to determine why "you" are "very high" compared to your "peers".
"You" need to decide if "less profit" until you drop from "very high" is the better choice than "no profit" (not selling any) until you drop from "very high".
playwithitagaintoys
Advice would be to describe your items correctly so you don't get item not as described returns.
worldwide_ship
OPI greatly appreciate this advice. You are an asset to the ebay community 🙂
luckythewinner
For the first time I have a very high return rating for "cell phone" category.
Have you examined your business model to see why you are attracting so many returns?
Should I stop selling the phones until it goes back down?
Are these used phones? If so, don't used cell phone prices degrade over time as new phones are released? If so, I would be worried that if I waited, my inventory value would degrade and make them unprofitable even without the added fees.
worldwide_ship
OPHave you examined your business model to see why you are attracting so many returns?
My business model hasn't changed in years. Same suppliers, same listings, same phones. I just had a bad month of returns for some reason.
Are these used phones? If so, don't used cell phone prices degrade over time as new phones are released? If so, I would be worried that if I waited, my inventory value would degrade and make them unprofitable even without the added fees.
Yes they're used. So I guess just bite the loss and keep it moving?
broto_64
Well there you go, many businesses have gone under for failing to keep up with the changes.
Failure to accept responsibility and lack of motivation in terms of finding the reason so that it can be prevented would be another.
luckythewinner
My business model hasn't changed in years.
eBay, the competition, the marketplace, and buyers can all change over time. So even if you business plan has not changed, it might still need to be revisited.
I just had a bad month of returns for some reason.
That is new information. Was there any 'theme' to reason for the recent spate of returns?