HOW exactly can eBay claim seller protections don't apply to chargebacks?
TLDR: buyer bought item, took parts off it and charged back. Shipped back incomplete item (entirely different shipping weight).
I provided loads of evidence (pictures/videos/tracking) but CCC decided in their favor (no shock). They never ever opened an eBay dispute.
This seems like a case where sellers should be protected because:
1) buyer skipped eBay’s own dispute resolution system. Obviously on purpose. This should immediately protect a seller and result in a strike against the buyer.
2) I never entered into a legal relationship with anyone other than eBay. If I had a merchant account and there was a dispute I’d be dealing with the chargeback. I could communicate with the CCC and defend myself. I have zero proof that eBay even provided the evidence to the CCC.
3) eBay suffered no losses here. I sold the item for $500, received around $400 after fees and the entire $500 was withdrawn. So basically I’m at a $200 loss over and above the auction amount when you add their fees and include shipping.
basically I can buy anything on eBay, charge it back without opening a dispute on their site, typically get my $$$ back as CCC usually side with their customers, and no repercussions from eBay? Sounds pretty sweet to me. 🙄
vintagecraze50
One more issue. I cannot imagine what would happen if ebay allowed sellers on here to dispute their own chargeback. Many sellers here may not be as savvy as you and know the correct way to rebuttal a chargeback. There are many chargeback codes you must be familiar with and you must know how to construct a rebuttal that is convincing the the card company. Many here why sell infrequently or have never run a business would not have a clue.
vintagecraze50
You should look at the statistics on all chargebacks and see how many are actually won by merchants. I did some big research on this once upon a time and found that the majority of these chargebacks are exceptionally hard to win. Then all these chargeback companies came about like chargeback 911 and others where merchants pay them to handle it. I would muse that even then a lot of merchants loose. Again, until they charge the laws regarding chargebacks, the illegitimate ones will still prevail at too much cost to merchants eventually. These larger companies give a hoot about loosing these becuase they make so much money on all that they sell. They should start giving a hoot, and shouting at their congressman.
champuchinonu1
@audiovideo2000
" basically I can buy anything on eBay, charge it back without opening a dispute on their site, typically get my $$$ back as CCC usually side with their customers, and no repercussions from eBay? Sounds pretty sweet to me."
Thats true. This is exactly why lots of sellers are leaving/closing their stores/accounts on Ebay. Anyone can play this trick here.
So what does 30 day MBG means ??? Nothing. Buyer is King and Chargeback is Prince.
Scammers can scam you for 180 days on Paypal.
Scammers can scam you for upto 1 year with few banks.
Ebay won't do anything to save/help you in INAD/SNAD chargebacks .
Better save yourself from headache .
dbfolks166mt
Pretty simple answer. EBay can not override federal or state laws by simply creating a policy and chargebacks are governed by federal laws. EBay does have some limited seller protection against chargebacks for domestic sales and the seller is fully protected from chargebacks under the international EIS program. In some of the domestic instances and the EIS coverage eBay may be covering the seller but refunding the buyer out of their own funds.
https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/selling-policies/payment-dispute-seller-protections?id=5293
champuchinonu1
Sure . But the real problem is Ebay CSR continuously lying to sellers about Seller protections. That is the problem.I have had conversations where they assured me upon inquiring that even INAD/SNAD chargebacks are fully supported /protected , since i was skeptical of their seller protections after reading so many horror stories here .
Also , i was told that since chargebacks are the "Cost of Doing Business" plz include this loss when you price your items . What does that imply? It implies " PUNISH YOUR HONEST CUSTOMERS FOR SCAMMERS". I will never do that to my honest customers, period. Simple. Ebay is a terrible platform.
vintagecraze50
Ok let’s be fair here and there have been times for me that ebay has awarded me my funds back in the seller protection. These are done on a case by case basis. So, they are trying to help as best they can. THE REAL PROBLEM lies with the banks and the federal govt who allow people to chargeback BEFORE they contact the merchant. THAT’S THE PROBLEM.
vintagecraze50
IN ADDITION. I am not playing games with the buyer in any way as I allow automatically approved returns for any reason including a Martian jumped out of the box,and give free ship back on everything I sell on here. So, technically, there is NO REASON for a buyer to chargeback Bon me. But, they still can because of the laws.
mpdsgt202
Last one I had did a return request, I agreed, they got mad they would have to print a label and did a chargeback. Out shipping x3 and will not get my item back. So they keep item and I pay them to do it. I have no recourse whatsoever.
champuchinonu1
@mpdsgt202
Spot on. Thats the best answer. Exactly this. Scammer would not return your stuff or would return you damaged products/empty boxes or simply nothing at all. Ebay still sides with them. Off course, there's no recourse when it comes to dealing with scammers on Ebay.
champuchinonu1
@vintagecraze50
There were sellers who received empty boxes, different products on return just like the OP. There are lots of scenarios. No one wants to play games. Honest buyer would return the same product, not something that was not sent to them or in altered condition.
vintagecraze50
Right for sure, But. Most people are honest. They do not do this type of stuff. But there are growing problems with the naughty one’s for sure.
vintagecraze50
I hear YA LOUD AND CLEAR, but this is not exclusively where these chargeback nightmares happen. They happen much more frequently online i would gesture, and everywhere where products are bought and sold. Merchants on their own have the ability to rebuttal the chargeback themselves and privy to info not avail here though.
sextons-sweet-deals
I see your point, but why did the buyer ship back if they just went to their C.C. to file a claim?
Shipped back incomplete item (entirely different shipping weight).
Did they request a return between just you and them (no eBay case opened), and then sent you junk back / less weight and then file a case with their C.C.?
champuchinonu1
" I see your point, but why did the buyer ship back if they just went to their C.C. to file a claim?"
Exactly, i believe since the chargebacks are on rise, now the cc /banks want buyers to send back the item. So scammers are just following their evil trail , now they do send back packages but a complete different products or damaged for parts products, even empty rock filled boxes. Also , these days the scammers are using some random state owned town village addresses as their " From" address. Its so easy .
sextons-sweet-deals
just not sure the C.C. really cares to get involved with eBay and actually instruct the buyer to ship back.
Could this be the new scam? Skip eBay's open case process, file a false claim with C.C.?
If this is a new scam, I would hope the C.C. is keeping count on their C.C. holders of such claims and maybe eventually closing their account and for any future related accounts / business.
Wonder if the O.P. giving us all the details?
champuchinonu1
I have seen worst, even people changing status from not received to INAD ( terrible). Even few transactions being somehow not recognized by the buyers, even when buyer bought it on Ebay and offcourse through Ebay.
Most wise scammers don't even consider Ebay, they wait 2 to 3 months after sale, then directly go to their banks for INAD, SNAD, transaction not recognized and transaction not authorized. Paypal give 6 months to open dispute ( to scam honest sellers) , few banks even give upto 1 year for such practice
C.C and Ebay both don't care. That's why sellers are leaving since they don't get promised seller protections Plz check Eaby Inc San Jose Corporate office reviews for better understanding of what's going on. It is going to get worse this year. Can't deal with this anymore.
Few people argue, well let them offer return for refund, then all you get is different product, few parts take out of pcs ,for part products and sometimes empty box with some junk for weight purposes.
luckythewinner
I never entered into a legal relationship with anyone other than eBay.
Correct. And your user agreement with eBay managed payment explains how charge backs will be handled.
If I had a merchant account and there was a dispute I could communicate with the CCC and defend myself.
Correct. But your user agreement with eBay managed payment explains how charge backs will be handled.
I have zero proof that eBay even provided the evidence to the CCC.
Correct.
basically I can buy anything on eBay, charge it back without opening a dispute on their site
Fortunately, most buyers do not do that.
soh.maryl
Since a chargeback is done through the buyer's credit card, not through eBay's MBG, would assume eBay has no way to prevent a chargeback since the action is entirely out of eBay's control.
audiovideo2000
OPthat’s my point, sellers are NOT protected if the buyer skips eBays resolution process. They knew if they went through the eBay resolution and I issued a return, they wouldn’t get the full amount back when they sent back the item with replaced and missing parts.
So why bother opening a claim with ebay? Skip the middleman.
I don’t have an issue with eBay making a ruling. eBay said “wow, this is excellent evidence of fraud.†But I have zero proof
any of that was sent to the CCC. And ebay has allowed the buy to keep buying.
champuchinonu1
Spot on and so true. This is exactly what Ebay does. Lots of people jumping of this sinking ship. Move to other platforms for better outcome.
kensgiftshop
Yes they would, you don't quality to deduct anything from their refunds.
champuchinonu1
Sure, but the real wrong here is that Ebay allow those scammers to do it , do it with so ease and don't do anything about it. They don't investigate, actually they don't want to. If anything goes wrong, most of the times sellers get the blame. This promotes the scammers to keep doing it again and again. On top of that promotes their false " Seller protection " promises which never protect sellers if the buyer opens INAD , SNAD chargebacks even after 3 or 4 months later. Ebay has no way , i don't think so, sure Ebay has lots of ways, they just don't want to. Move to other platforms as i have heard few friends doing better on those after leaving here .
siamjane8
I would state that when ebay became the legal merchant of record- THEY assume the responsibility of the chargeback. Ebay wanted all the benefits of controlling the money and making interest on it throughout the whole process (this is no longer disputable as ebay finally updated the TOS stating clearly that they collect interest on the held funds and are under no obligation to forward the interest to the seller).
Ebay (merchant of record)now sells the the product to a buyer, then facilities and collects the money into their account. They are in effect buying the item from a seller and then taking their fees and then paying the seller for the goods and shipping out the item after the fact.
Managed payments is a business- it comes with good and bad like all businesses, but ebay wants all the good and passes the bad on to sellers in cases like this. If ebay paid for these issues like they should- they would negotiate better terms with the CCC because it would be effecting their bottom line.
With Payapal- it was a peer to peer payment platform. Buyer to seller direct- Seller sold goods and received payment from buyer. That was faster and better and cheaper and had more protections...... but the bad was we as sellers were the merchant of record and bore the responsibility of the bad along with the good.
When a chargeback happens through managed payments- there is no proof that it is even legitimate. ( to be fair i do think they are legitimate- i dont believe ebay is making false claims of Chargebacks for profit).
If seller is liable for the chargeback then we should be able to have the actual CC documents available and the be able to address the claim. That is not the case. Ebay support will tell you that they do not have to show the seller anything-this makes no sense if the transaction was between a seller and a buyer. Remember that the excuse of we are just a money processor does not fly- Aiden is the processor for ebay and managed payments is the entity that holds and controls the money.
If ebay had skin in the game- Chargebacks would be handled better. Me, as a single seller against multi billion dollar CCC like Mastercard and Visa has no power........ but a company the size of ebay that moves so many billions of dollars SHOULD have negotiating power to protect its customers against false and fraudulent chargebacks.
vintagecraze50
Chargebacks on here on the most dreaded and deadly things I deal with with rather high value items. I agree there needs to be if they can a better system in place to address them. I fear nothing worse on here than that.
champuchinonu1
@vintagecraze50
May be with you. There are lots of people like OP who were never provided with any seller protection .If we have to be fair, lets be fair with everyone.
vintagecraze50
I agree. That would solve any of my fears for sure. Sure wish they could.
ittybitnot
HOW exactly can eBay claim seller protections don't apply to chargebacks?
@audiovideo2000
How? The same way they have for years: "It is the credit card company and nothing we can do."
In your case, even if the buyer filed an eBay claim instead of a Payment Dispute, the results would have been the same. eBay does not offer seller protection or intervention for 'not as described' issues. Your item becomes whatever the buyer says it is as soon as they select a reason from the dropdown menu.
champuchinonu1
" Your item becomes whatever the buyer says it is as soon as they select a reason from the dropdown menu."
Exactly this. So you are at mercy of the buyer , buyers know it very well. They can even prove you sent them a completely different product with complete comfort. For example, seller sent buyer an IPhone and its turns into a barbie doll upon receiving ( sometimes they are careful with some very small rocks for matching the weight as listed on the shipping label). The ebay will side with buyer on INAD / SNAD cases if opened through Ebay.
A wise scammer knows to open chargeback after 30 MBG days are over, so they don't even have to consider wasting their time with Ebay and go directly to their CC bank. Ebay doesn't backup INAD/ SNAD chargebacks. Ebay will lie to you, make every excuse they can not to cover it. Plz also note, few sellers also work for Ebay and give out wrong information about how well their cases were handled and how good of a platform this crap is. Beware of that too.
Ebay knows it , will always let it happen. Its their screwing policy for sellers set forth in San Jose corporate office. You agree to this crap, sell on Ebay.
fashunu4eeuh
@champuchinonu1
Your attitude towards eBay is contradictory. You hate the platform, denigrate it, and advise others to leave. Yet, looking at your feedback, you are a Top Rated Seller, a long-time successful member who has been here since 2009. Your buyers are very complimentary.
You are benefiting from the fruits of selling here. Why the vitriol? No one is stating that eBay is without problems. There are serious issues. But it is obviously working for you on some level, or you wouldn't be here. You would be taking your own advice. Yet, your actions do not align with your professed thoughts.
Saying one thing and yet doing another undermines one’s credibility.
Credibility is further stretched with comments like this:
“Plz also note, few sellers also work for Ebay and give out wrong information about how well their cases were handled and how good of a platform this crap is. Beware of that too.â€
champuchinonu1
@fashunu4eeuh
If stating the facts means its denigrating, then let it be. Plz google Ebay San Jose corporate office , you will definitely learn the true meanings of "Denigrate".
"You hate the platform, denigrate it, and advise others to leave."
I have already left this scammers paradise. I don't know what makes you think i am still selling on this platform. Plz check my listings , are there any listings. Sellers are leaving for the past decade. Am i responsible for their actions too? Did i tell them to leave
Your own assessment is so contradictory. Rather than pointing out the problems , you are pointing at me. Where is your credibility that you still think i have not left this platform and suggesting other people to leave.
They are leaving beacuse of Ebay worst policies., not because of me.
Your owns statements are too contradictory.
fashunu4eeuh
@champuchinonu1 wrote:
"I don't know what makes you think i am still selling on this platform."
As of Tuesday (3 days ago), you have no listings up. However, you sold 123 items in the last 90 days. Your last sale was on Monday--4 days ago. You have had multiple sales over the last week. That sounds like selling to me.
"Rather than pointing out the problems , you are pointing at me."
It is your post. I responded to it.
"Where is your credibility that you still think i have... suggesting other people to leave?"
"Did i tell them to leave?"
Well, you have responded numerous times to this thread, and stated multiple times that sellers here are leaving and that they should leave eBay. See Post #12 ("Move to other platforms as i have heard few friends doing better on those after leaving here."), and Post #13 ("Move to other platforms for better outcome.").
"They are leaving beacuse of Ebay worst policies., not because of me."
I did not suggest they did.
"If stating the facts means its denigrating, then let it be."
But it is not fact. You told another poster that there are paid eBay shills in the forum who spread falsehoods. You have not supplied any evidence or supporting facts to back up such an allegation and conspiracy theory.
"I have already left this scammers paradise"
Not really.
I think we are just going to have to agree to disagree.
champuchinonu1
@fashunu4eeuh
"I have already left this scammers paradise"
Not really ???. . If you think so, unfortunately i have no control over it.
If stating the facts means its denigrating, then let it be."
You pointed it out as Denigrating. Not me . Check out Ebay San Jose Corporate office, did you?
" Well, you have responded numerous times to this thread, and stated multiple times that sellers here are leaving and that they should leave eBay"
Again, they are leaving because of Ebay policies, not me. . Ebay is laying off 1000 employees in a week. They are also laying off unspecified number of contract employees too. Does that make any sense to you? Why a company layoff its employees?
" Its your post"
I like to point out problems, not specifically any person/anyone.
Ebay is down to 9.7 billion revenue, every year they are losing it . Why?
Ebay has to pay 59 million in settlement since they claimed they sold some stuff that could make illegle drugs? LOL.
Ebay revenue is 9.7 billion vs Amazon has 513 billion ( 23 % comes from third party sellers). Most are those who left this sinking platform made better on amazon.
Another lady was arguing with me that there are 1 million sales everyday on Ebay , and Ebay has 30 million sellers. Divide 1 million to 30 million according to her, then subtract ebay commision. What is left per 30 million sellers. 🤣🤣. Even she had no clue that not all of those 30 million had sold anything on a given day.
Even she didn't know the accurate number of sellers , its 18.3 million.
then she claimed, there are 2 billion transaction per day, so those 2 billion transactions sum upto only 1 million in total sales everyday.😆😆.
I sold 123 items not because of Ebay but because of my loyal repeat customers. My loyal customers are willing to keep buying from me if i go to another venue on that venue. I have great respect for my loyal set of repeat customers . Its called customer service/ loyalty and honesty with my buyers.
3 days ago ??? you asked me today, i closed selling almost 5 days ago/ closed my store/ delisted my listings. I am completely done with Ebay, no selling or buying on this platform. I believe i answered you today. You still believe i am selling on Ebay?
Last, Ebay runs on sellers not like Amazon that has its own huge inventory of products, they don't even need third party sellers.. However , Most people buy confidently on Amazon than on Ebay.
I have quoted facts here, these are the facts, again, if someone leaves Ebay thats their own decision, you and i can't change it.
Again, punishing your honest customers because of scammers and charging more your loyal customers since you got scammed and now had to include that loss in your pricing and then passing it on to your other customers who had nothing to do is definitely not the right thing.
champuchinonu1
How would you relate to this conspiracy theory?
You still think its also a conspiracy theory ???
https://www.dea.gov/press-releases/2024/02/01/ebay-pay-59-million-settle-controlled-substances-act-allegations-related
The United States alleged that eBay did not comply with these CSA requirements for thousands of pill presses and encapsulating machines that were sold through its website, including high-capacity pill presses capable of producing thousands of pills per hour. The United States’ investigation further found that hundreds of eBay’s pill press buyers also purchased counterfeit molds, stamps, or dies, allowing them to produce pills that mimicked the products of legitimate pharmaceutical companies, and that many of eBay’s pill press buyers have been successfully prosecuted in connection with trafficking illegal counterfeit pills.
“Through its website, eBay made it easy for individuals across the country to obtain the type of dangerous machines that are often used to make counterfeit pills. Our investigation revealed that some of these machines were even sold to individuals who were later convicted of drug related crimes,†said United States Attorney for the District of Vermont, Nikolas P. Kerest. “Our office is committed to holding accountable those who have contributed to the devastating fentanyl crisis we are facing in our communities. Today’s settlement is an important step to ensuring that e-commerce companies do their part by complying with regulations that are designed to protect the public.â€
Seriously.
fashunu4eeuh
@champuchinonu1
I said absolutely nothing about the above information you are referencing. It was not part of the discussion.
I asked about the specific conspiracy theory you proffered in your post #16 regarding your accusation that the forums are populated with eBay-paid “plants†that spread false information about the platform.
As for the above report, eBay is a giant global behemoth. It has problems. Never said it didn’t.
But moving ahead, I can see this dialogue has veered off the tracks and serves no one. As i proposed before, i think we are just going to have to agree to disagree. Have a good evening.
dhbookds
Ebay does protect sellers from chargebacks claiming Non Receipt (if you have tracking that shows delivered and have used the signature required, if applicable. They also protect against Unauthorized claims, if mailed to address on file.
toomuchstuffagain35
They also protect the seller from chargebacks IF an ebay claim was filed first and lost by the buyer for the same reason as the chargeback.
Of course that doesn't help if the buyer claims a different reason for the lost ebay claim than what they use for the chargeback.
luckythewinner
HOW exactly can eBay claim seller protections don't apply to chargebacks?
By including it in a user agreement that you acknowledge before listing.
This seems like a case where sellers should be protected because buyer skipped eBay’s own dispute resolution system.
May sellers post here about things they wish eBay did.
I never entered into a legal relationship with anyone other than eBay.
Exactly. And the legal agreement you entered into with eBay spells out exactly how eBay will treat you when a buyer files a chargeback.
eBay suffered no losses here
But they would suffer a loss if they offered you seller protection and reimbursed you. Which is why they don't offer it.
audiovideo2000
OPI have read their user agreement in the past and saw nothing concerning chargebacks. Where is this?
fashunu4eeuh
1) eBay cannot protect sellers automatically against chargebacks because some chargebacks may be warranted when a seller defrauds a buyer. Not every chargeback is from a dishonest buyer.
2) Anyone using eBay has a obligation both to eBay and the buyer. Sellers also enter into legal binding contracts with the customer when they purchase an item. So it is not only eBay that sellers have a legal relationship with.
Final thoughts:
Buyers are free to seek satisfaction thru whatever means are available to them, including chargebacks. They are under no obligation to open an eBay case first.
It is not just chargebacks that can be “sweet.†Virtually any buyer can steal any item off eBay by opening a bogus Not As Described case. It is the main risk in selling here, as eBay protects the buyer’s interests first and foremost. Sellers must guard their own.
farmalljr
Yes, I suppose you COULD do that. But if/when it ever caught up with you and you were charged with fraud, the prison time/fines/restitution wouldn't be a joke.
Do most people who do it get caught? Probably not. Should eBay change the TOS to be more fair? Absolutely. Apparently right now that's not in eBay's interest. Seller's foot that bill, not eBay.
If you want something to change, it will need to be done on a legal level. Billions are lost every year to fraud. The big retailers would like to see things change too, but can't see to get anyone to care about it.