got AI to help with a listing
Summary: bashort shared an experience where they used AI to help list an item on eBay, only for it to be removed because it resembled a police item. krazzykats suggested its appearance might have triggered eBay's policies. tobaccocardyahoo advised that dealing with such issues might not be worth the time due to the limitations of AI. industrial_sales_nw_ohio questioned the item's relevance to police equipment, while christworks discussed AI's tendency to align with user expectations. Overall, the discussion highlighted the challenges of using AI to navigate eBay's listing policies.
I asked Chat GPT how to describe this perfectly ebay legal item so that ebay AI would not take it down.
I did exactly as suggested, got taken down anyway after a few months
120 Volt Industrial Blue Signal Conduit Mount Strobe Light Electraflash 141ST
inhawaii
Apparently my AI is smarter than yours.
There is no way to guarantee that eBay will never take down a listing, because eBay routinely enforces automated filters, intellectual property (VeRO) takedowns, and strict prohibited item policies.
bashort
OPOf course there is no way to guarantee anything.
eoma689485
To quote The Twilight Zone...
"wish it into the cornfield"
"It's a good thing you done, Anthony. A real good thing."
christworks
@bashort You should research AI sycophancy. Don't use AI to do it. 😉
These systems can subtly and easily be manipulated, even if that isn't your intention. They want to please their users and, much like eBay phone reps, will tell you what you want to hear. In this case, tell you the sure fire way to not have your listing removed becasue it knows your end goal is to list the item and it is supposed to help you do that. If you had pushed back and asked it to verify the information it gave you and compare that with eBay policy, it likely would have told you not to list it at all because eBay's AI may not be able to understand the difference in what is allowed and what isn't allowed.
ChatGPT specifically has multiple settings you can control so that is provides more objective data, but even then the more you use it, it still wants to please you and to it, giving you bad information to achieve your end goal is the way to do it.
How you present problems and questions can also influence how it answers.
industrial_sales_nw_ohio
That's a industrial machine light? How is that police related?
bashort
OPit absolutely is not a police item. Apparently ebay AI says that all red and or blue lights must be police related
dbmm-media
and you found out why it is called ai slop
krazzykats
My guess is its looks very similar to police lights?
Police-related items policy | eBay
Could it have been removed for that?
bashort
OPYes, they say it is a police item and it does look similar
tobaccocardyahoo
Is this item worth the time you are spending trying to get it listed?
You have a higher volume of sales than many of us. My experience with AI searching based on image is that it is useless unless I interact with the agent and eliminate the false matches.
It is likely that Ebay's agent is no smarter than ChatGpt or Google Lens or other agents. IMO you are wasting your time dealing with this. And Ebay has managed to reduce their costs and policy violations at a trivial cost in incorrectly blocked listings. Your listing is collateral damage associated with a safety improvement on the site.
I gave up trying to overcome such issues before the AI revolution because human intelligence was inadequate to overcome false listing restrictions, both on Ebay and Amazon.
Few items I list are worth more time than it takes when they are successfully listed on the first try. And those that take more tries than one usually are taken down later.
bashort
OPI am not "dealing with it" I listed it months ago and it got taken down, I am not going to appeal it
but what I am going to do is take the opportunity to mock ebay's AI follys
tobaccocardyahoo
You right as a seller. Enjoy.