"Free Shipping" Isn't For Every Seller
Some of you remember when John Donahoe took over eBay and tried to destroy it so his buddies at Bain Capital could profit from hedging the stock. Luckily it didn't work, since we all still have this selling platform, but boy did he try! 😂 He completely changed the search algorithm from first-in-first-out and told everyone to start listing on their smartphones, even though the eBay app wasn't ready at all.
He told everyone to offer free shipping too, mostly because "Hey man, Amazon sellers do it!" And so began the Amazonification of eBay. The only thing that really came out of it was Etsy showed up and started cutting into eBay's share of interesting, uncommon non-commodity items.
I think free shipping is fine for some sellers, but I never liked it at all. I tried it and got burned dozens of times. I live in New England, and I know how much a 1.5-pound package costs to ship to Pennsylvania or Virginia, but I also know the cost to ship the same thing to Oregon or Texas is a lot higher. I'd wrestle with what to charge as an aggregate price: Do I calculate for New York or California? I hated it. And besides, most people can perform simple addition.
If you swear by free shipping and you sell even mildly hard-to-find items, what strategy do you use? I mean, if you're one of only three sellers on the entire internet who has the entire run of Donald Duck Comics number 1 through 50 and the box weighs 7 pounds and your copies are the best ones available, do you view that scenario differently?
telegraph_mercantile
4. Free shipping customers also return items more frequently. Is this true? I never thought to find this out. I always thought the shipping price is irrelevant to a buyer filing a return.
This has been true in my case. Out of the 53 sales we’ve made since switching to free shipping, we’ve gotten 4 returns:
2 “didn’t like itâ€
1 got misled by ambiguity in a title (and didn’t read the description)
1 scammed us by claiming that a shirt had arrived damaged when it was clearly damaged by them
Thanks to the folks on this board, I knew how to handle these returns (the first ones I’ve ever had).
tobaccocardyahoo
Were I to sell what @zobal99 sells at the prices he/she sells at, I would consider untracked free shipping.
I would not sell what @zobal99 sells so my opinion is irrelevant.
kibble-net
I stopped doing free shipping last December. I used to do it when I was selling more expensive goods, but these days the items I'm selling are of relatively low value compared to how much it costs to ship. Adding to that, the price can vary wildly depending on how far away the customer is located. Calculated shipping just seems like a no-brainer to me. Perhaps free shipping is viable if you're more able to bake the cost into your pricing, but for more bulky goods it's difficult to do.
Also - you can't deduct anything from the refund when you do free shipping and get a buyer's remorse return, that's probably important too.
onefootflipper
Free shipping is the worst possible choice for an everything seller that sells one off items that weigh more than 8 ounces.
There is exactly two one upside, and that is that it makes you show up more because some people tick the free shipping box. Some people claim that people might purchase multiple free ship items that you can ship together greatly increasing your profits. However people do the same thing with pay to ship items as well to the same results.
The downsides however are massive.
1. Much lower profit margins. You will be shipping frequently to the furthest shipping zones because your competition with calculated shipping is cheaper for closer customers.
2. Makes offers to watcher seem worse to the customer while actually being worse for you. You can also no longer blindly accept or send offers, you have to worry about actual shipping cost with every single item.
3. You can no longer safely run sales or maintain a regular markdown schedule without the fear of paying ebay to ship free products to customers.
4. Free shipping customers also return items more frequently. And since they are more likely to be far away you will eat even more money on returns.
5. Annual shipping rates change? Great, now you have to refigure your entire store, ONE ITEM AT A TIME.
That isn't even all of them. I had 8 major issues when I did a video about it, I just can't remember them all right now.
cyberontix
OPI agree with everything you said 100%. Especially #1 and #5. I'm so done with editing 1000-2000 listings in bulk or otherwise. I really just went along with the herd when I tried free shipping, despite the fact that I totally hated the idea.
iamalwaysright
meme6253
I do not offer free shipping, So I agree it is not for every seller, It's not for this seller.
redlinear
Probably best just leave the free shipping thing to experienced professionals
zobal99
I sell small stuff and have tried both ways. I found that free shipping has worked best for me.
tobaccocardyahoo
Free shipping is a tool for use in selling high volume, highly competitive, commodity products.
A seller who offers free shipping on collectibles with limited competition has not thought the decision through.
There are many sellers on Ebay and other marketplaces who never think any decision through, and sellers who feel they need to react to them.
I am a seller who does not treat shipping as profit center, uses fixed price shipping charges, and adjusts my fixed rates so that I break even on shipping charges and costs on a monthly basis.
My buyers are concerned with total costs and I prefer to have the traffic on all my listings and number of bids on my auction listings as high as possible since that seems to improve my views and sell through. YMMV.
bashort
Some people like "free" stuff so much that they are more than willing to pay more to get it.
I would just as soon have buyers who understand that nothing is free.
redlinear
I thought I was your favorite buyer? ðŸ˜
iamalwaysright
These are the buyers who will throw down swinging elbows just to buy a widget advertised for “$20 off from †instead of the same item just advertised at $30.
cyberontix
OPExactly. "Free shipping" on non-commodity items appeals to "bargain shoppers" who haven't figured out that ship costs are figured in when they sort on lowest price.
iamalwaysright
Managing free shipping these days is tougher than ever before because of the numerous times a year USPS raises their prices. If you get a high rate of remorse returns, free shipping is not the way to go.
cyberontix
OPYes, and every time the general rates go up, the loss one takes on a package that's traveling 2000 miles or more without charging any shipping cost go up proportionally.
telegraph_mercantile
[Made edits to the numbers below to correct some mistakes.]
After about a year of strictly Calculated Shipping, on November 2, we started offering Free Shipping on everything (and raised prices to include what the shipping might be from coast to coast).
We’ve sold 53 items since then. Last year during the same period, we sold 21 items. There are obviously differences in the types of things we’re listing (the addition of jewelry, for example, as inspired by @gurlcat ), but it’s still a big difference.
My favorite difference, though, is that we no longer get questions from buyers like: “Can’t you bring the shipping cost down on that pair of shoes? I don’t need the box, just ship me the shoes in a bag.†Or “It’s just a power adapter, why does it cost $7 to ship?â€
luckythewinner
He told everyone to offer free shipping too
I was never told to offer free shipping. I was asked to consider it, but I chose not to do it.
cyberontix
OPYou know exactly what I meant. Do you have to be transgressive every single time you reply to a post on this board? You should seriously be banned from this group.
jonathanbrightlight
Why should they be banned? There is was nothing false about what they said.
cyberontix
OPHe does it every time. I assume most people are well aware of it. I've literally never seen him post anything that wasn't unnecessarily argumentative, devil's advocation or some sort of troll. It's unconstructive and pretty silly to have to deal with a "resident troll" in 2025.
cyberontix
OPPut it this way, I'd love to see him try that stuff on one of Reddit's eBay groups. He'd be banned so fast his head would spin. I imagine most of the regulars have him muted, which is what I need to do I suppose.
redlinear
If a person walks in here wanting something, it's $25.00
It's not $15 plus $9 labor to go get it and $1 for a box to put it in so it doesn't roll around in the car on the way home.
a_c_green
@cyberontix I offer Free Shipping on any item whose packed weight is less than one pound. I use Calculated Shipping (buyer pays) for all items over one pound in shipping weight.
My reasoning is that for small lightweight items, the buyer knows it shouldn't cost a ton of money to ship it, so I roll the shipping into the item price and keep things simple. For items with more size and weight (i.e. one pound or more), I think the buyer expects to pay something for shipping that, and using the Calculated method ensures that the buyer will only pay what's required to get it to his doorstep. That way, a buyer who's in the next town over doesn't see a shipping charge that could propel it halfway across the country.
mr_lincoln
@cyberontix
I agree, Free shipping is best in my view for small light weight items decently priced to absorb the cost of shipping to the furthest shipping zone but maintaining the Seller's profit margin.
I use Calculated shipping and accurate weights and package dimensions. Last year I compared some shipping costs Buyers would see on some of my typically 2 lbs items in an approximate 15 x 7 x 4 box. West coast Buyers would see $ 15.70 to $ 16.70 while more local customers would see less than $ 10.00.
-I don't offer Free shipping
-I don't use Best offer
-I don't add Buy it now to Auctions and my starting price is the lowest I will sell on One bid and hit my target profit margin
However one thing I did change earlier this year was I offer a 20% discount on shipping costs which can be set on this page in the Account settings - the Rates and exclusions section: Shipping Preferences
I have always viewed shipping as a break even proposition.
My only complaint doing this is I would prefer setting a percentage OVER Commercial rates instead of eBay's Discount % coming down off Retail shipping rates. That way I would always be covered regardless of what Buyers pay. Coming down off Retail means from time to time on larger and heavier items and depending on how far they have to ship my cost winds up being such that with what the Buyer pays and the fees I am charged I lose money on the label. It is just the way the math works out with regard to the three items I mentioned, weight, dimensions and distance.
However, prior to offering the discount I was constantly sending partial refunds to Buyers for the shipping overage. The coast to coast examples of $ 15.70 and $ 16.70 above meant MY discount cost from eBay was $ 9.21. I would refund a good portion of the difference but still owe eBay fees on the total plus sales tax (where applicable) they paid.
.
loose_goose_garage
I offer Free Shipping so I don't need to weigh and measure each item before listing to get correct calculated shipping. I am also in New England, so I understand the cost difference in shipping to West Coast vs. East Coast.
I can roughly estimate the cost to ship to the extremes (ie: The other side of my state vs. Washington State) from experience. When I factor in the shipping cost to item price, I settle somewhere in the middle to farther away range from me. If the item is being shipped closer, great, I make a few extra bucks. If it's going farther, it costs a few bucks more. At the end of the year, it averages out pretty well so I am not overly concerned about a few bucks here and there.
And FWIW, some buyers can't do math when browsing items, so this way they see the item price and that is the price (excluding Tax obviously).
Some see an item for a good price (lower due to shipping being separate), but then the shipping cost and tax are added on at checkout and all of a sudden that 'good price' doesn't seem so good anymore.
Just my $.02 (or do I have to round up to $.05 now?)
bashort
I use calculated and just estimate the weight and dimensions when listing.
stainlessenginecovers
I would think an item that is $200 or more should be Free Shipping.
Also during the Holidays as that is what most other websites are doing. Come January, back to business.
soh.maryl
That sounds like a rare collectible, in which case it would not be necessary to offer any adornments to get lots of bidders, would it?
my-cottage-books-and-antiques
@cyberontix If I had the comics you mention, no, I would not use Free Shipping.
I can see offering free shipping for some things, but for something like that, I don't see any real value in it.