Final Value Fee Refund
Summary: ngemah shared their experience of selling sinks on eBay, where both the initial and replacement sinks arrived damaged for a buyer. Despite refunding the buyer with eBay's assistance, leading to a loss of the Final Value Fee and a transaction defect, they are struggling to find a resolution. tobaccocardyahoo, bonanza125, and other participants pointed out that eBay's intervention in processing refunds usually results in sellers losing the Final Value Fee and advised ngemah on the importance of packaging, handling refunds manually, and familiarizing themselves with eBay policies. The discussion also touched on how seeking eBay's help can complicate matters and the importance of using insurance and proper packaging to prevent shipping damages. Participants suggested focusing on proper claims and understanding the seller's responsibilities better to avoid such issues in the future.
Hi,
I recently sold a $650 sink on eBay, which the buyer received as broken.
I sent a replacement sink to this same buyer while he had a return open for the original order.
I had sent him a message that having that sink returned to me will be an extra cost, so he should wait till he receives the replacement.
The buyer reached out after three days of sending the replacement sink to check on the status, and I realized that the replacement sink was again broken in NC, which is where he resides, and I shipped it from AL.
I was on a medical leave at this point, so I called eBay to help me refund the buyer so that if he gets an alternative, he can buy it;
If not, he can wait till I am back, then I can have the sink shipped from my GA location to him in Bern, NC.
I was planning on making that trip there myself from GA with the replacement sink once I am back.
I called eBay, and the agent helped me facilitate the refund to the buyer, but now I am out of the Final Value Fee for the sales, as well as getting a defect for the transaction.
That doesn't sound right, especially if I am doing everything in my power to make this buyer happen, even though they escalated the return into a case after the second sink broke.
In part, I think the buyer made the resolution harder for me because I did everything in my power, and now I am out of 2 of my $650 sinks, as well as eBay keeping my Final Value Fee.
Now I feel bad because the buyer keeps writing me to find out if they can buy that one sink I promised them, but I just told them I will only sell them the sink if I get that defect removed, as well as my Final Value Fee returned to me.
What else can I do to make eBay give me back my $88 final value fee?
I had an agent tell me they have made a back office claim to reverse my final value fee and that it is awaiting a manager's approval, and this is like 2 weeks now, yet no final value fee refund.
luckythewinner
In order to receive seller protection and get your fees refunded in an INAD case, you must follow eBay's processes. "I was planning on deliver it myself when I get back" is not one of the processes that receives seller protection.
tools*
I assume the sinks are in the manufacturer's packaging, which in many cases is insufficient to protect something as brittle as porcelain in shipping. The product box is likely designed to survive stacking and shrink-wrapping on a palette with short-haul freight delivery, but not single-box, rough courier handling.
mam98031
Why do you think the buyer has any power to get your defect removed or fees refunded? Why would it be their responsibility anyway?
It is simply the rules we all live by. You were unable to satisfy the buyer's purchase with the product they purchased, so you refunded them. That was the right thing to do, but that is the fault of packaging, shipping or something, but not your buyer and not Ebay. Hopefully you had insurance on the packages or at least you should have. File the appropriate claims to get as much funds refunded to you as possible. That is the proper route.
You did what you could as a seller in your position. You provided great customer service. Even great service isn't always enough and it is VERY important for sellers to understand the rules in which we all must abide by on the site. If you need links to any of the rules that apply to this situation, just ask.
albertabrightalberta
Whether it's the buyer or you, asking ebay to step in is what cost you the FVF and earning you a defect.
You should have just issued the refund through the order.
I'm sorry but that's on you. Whether you're packing and shipping or if it's your supplier, it's not getting packed well enough to prevent damage.
ngemah
OPI couldn't issue the refund through the order because the buyer escalated the issue into a case by mistake.
mr_lincoln
Hi @ngemah
I see a $ 700 sink you sold but when I open the listing the price drops to $ 350. The listing shows there is one left. I think the bigger issue is how you are packing that item for shipment. Two getting damaged in shipment sort of points to inadequate packing on your end.
Are you filing insurance claims with the carrier for damaged items?
ngemah
OPNo, I didn't have insurance the first but I did the second time. I have been selling these sinks, and this is the only time that it broke for me out of the 5 I sold so far.
mr_lincoln
@ngemah How are you shipping them without insurance???
ryry-jj
Any time you or the buyer asks ebay to step in, it will cost you.
Personally, i treat each item as a separate transaction, finish the first one by issuing the refund then relist and the buyer can buy again.
CS doesnt tell you everything, and sometimes they dont tell you anything ...you asked for them to step in and they did, you needed to know that would cost you.
Some of the worse advise eBay sells on us it to "work it out with the buyer/seller"...nope its all automated, follow the steps to get to the result, and its one step at a time
bonanza125
You made some mistakes here. When you called Ebay and when the agent helped you facilitate the refund for the buyer that is a No No. That means Ebay is stepping in and that will put a defect on your record. You as the seller needed to manually issue the buyer a refund in the time frame required under the policy. You also made a mistake sending them another sink. Personally I wouldn't be selling fragile items like a sink online unless I was professional enough to know what to do when an item gets damaged and contacting the carrier. The only thing you can do is wait for Ebay to refund you the $88 if the manager approves it. It could take a month and there are no guarantees that is happening. As far as the buyers request to purchase another sink I would just move on from that buyer.
ngemah
OPThank you for this insight.
tobaccocardyahoo
When Ebay steps in to process a refund because you did not, the FVF is not refunded.
It is all automated. As a general rule, exceptions to policy and procedures are rare or non-existent. Optimism is not in order.
ngemah
OPBut I called and spoke to the agent to process the refund, though.
She could have told me all this before processing the refund, then in that case I would have left the return open until I am back to send the new replacement or have the buyer send me the sink stand for me to issue a full refund.
soh.maryl
Am just dazzled that the buyer is still dealing with you. If the first one got broken, why would he give you another chance?
tobaccocardyahoo
The agent you spoke to probably had no clue what happens after he took whatever action he initiated.
These are usually contractors in undeveloped countries who have no experience other than what they have done and what the people who contacted them told them.
Sellers who have actually read Ebay's help information are better informed than these CSRs, many experienced Ebay sellers have more detailed understand of what the processes and procedures are.
Contacting support is not included in many seller's strategy for dealing with the problems they face in selling online.