eBay deceptively overcharging .35 insertion fees by claiming you can "list it for free" in app
eBay is engaging in exceptionally deceptive business practices by falsely claiming you can "list it for free" in their mobile app. At the start of a new month (Feb 1 2025), I wanted to list an item. Though I had 250 items already listed, I was surprised to see that in the app it was telling me that I could "list it for free" right before I published the listing, and there was no insertion fee mentioned at all. I then listed a total of 10 items, and with each item, it said "list it for free" at the bottom of the page right before publishing the listing. I have screen shots to proof this as well.
Later in the day, I logged into my account and at the home page in the app it showed that I had a negative / due balance of $3.50 even though with each of the 10 items I listed, the app claimed that I could list it for free. I then logged into the browser to see what happened. What they did here and it was extremely shady and deceptive: they added 10 insertion fees (.35 cents each) to the first 10 items in the set of 250 items that I previously listed, in hopes that I would not notice they added the insertion fees there (as opposed to the newest 10 I just listed). When I chatted and requested that they reverse and they refund these fees for deceptive business practices on their end, they refused.
I am dismayed by how dishonest and deceptive eBay has become by trying to over charge sellers insertion fees, even when the app tells them they are listing it for free. They are going backwards and adding insertion fees onto the first 10 items you listed of your 250 "free" listings, in hopes that you wont notice.
SHAME ON EBAY. Be up front and honest with your sellers about whether or not you are going to charge them an insertion fee and don't bury it in their invoice, or deceptively add it onto other items that were previously listed as "free". Yet another BBB complaint will be filed for corrupt and dishonest business practices.
toysaver
Could be worse, they have no obligation to offer any free insertions at all. You're getting $87.50 worth pf free services. If it cost 3.50 to understand the timings and constraints, you got off easy.
mspanda1298hxb
I called repeatedly, because the insertion fee scam is purposely misleading. I was told that in the promotions section of the seller hub, it shows listing used and listings remaining. They said as long as you sow listings remaining you are good to go for the additional amount listings remaining. This is intentionally deceptive. What they don't tell you is, you need to look and see how many listing are due to automatically relist. These re-listings (or roll overs) are subtracted from the number of listings remaining. I got hit with 53 insertion fees because I was not aware of this scam. 53 items rolled over in the last few days of the month. Ebay does nothing to support the sellers. Deceptive fees, no protection form unwarranted negative feedback, no protection from unwarranted return requests. Futile to get fair customer service results. Ebay has become a bureaucratic, stressful, frustrating, denigrating experience.
Oh and another fun fact, if your sales exceed $2500, all sales are now reported to the IRS as income. I know they did not set the amount, but wouldn't it be nice to be made aware that the amount of sales reported to the IRS decreased by 50% for 2025! I was already over the limit by the time I found out!
lacemaker3
@mspanda1298hxb,
The information was available to you. It was not hidden.
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/fees-credits-invoices/selling-fees?id=4822#section1
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Announcements/IRS-confirms-5-000-reporting-threshold-for-Form-1099-K-for-tax/ba-p/34814816
teavyellow
OPUpdate 2/7/25: I called eBay a couple days ago about the situation which they apologized for and said that they would credit the $3.50 fees. Mary Joy, who I spoke to, said the credit would appear in a few minutes but it has already been two days since I called and the fees still have not been credited.
fern*wood
Cute fur babies in your avatar. Sounds like they wanted off the phone.
wastingtime101
It was user error but eBay was nice and gave you a courtesy credit for the negligible dollar amount. I'm surprised the time it took you on the CS call was worth the $3.50.
finerartgallery
Ebay is going down hill.
finerartgallery
Terrible company.
mtgraves7984
@teavyellow
I haven't sold since Spring, 2024, but I am recalling as @chapeau-noir and @chevymontecarlo88 are. I would offer to try what @dryophelia suggests and grab those screenshots. (I'd expect that the $.35 would be showing at the bottom, too.) Don't forget to save your 'test run' as a Draft. Curious to know if you could replicate it. 🤔
teavyellow
OP 
When I listed the items, it said “list it for freeâ€. This was the case for 10 listings. There was no mention of .35 cents, or any insertion fee at all.
fern*wood
That sounds like an offer to revise your listings and donate part to charity in order to list them for free.
bdmh-enterprises
I don't know why this is so hard to understand. Free insertions roll over at the beginning of the month. Your listings renew 30 days from when they were started. When you listed the item from the screen shot your OTHER listings had NOT relisted yet so you had free insertions available and those 10 listings were inserted for free. THEN when your OTHER 250 listings renewed you only had 240 free insertions remaining. Therefore you were charged insertion fees for the last 10 listings..
chapeau-noir
Yes, its been mentioned a few(!) times, but that doesn't appear to be what happened though.
lacemaker3
It appears that OP has been ending his good 'til cancelled listings early, and relisting them manually. I don't think he was considering that doing that will use up one of his available free-insertion-fee-listings for each of them.
That's the only explanation I can see for all of his 250 free-listings having been used up so early in the month. There were some listings that may have renewed normally on the 1st and 2nd as well.
He ended 10 listings early yesterday, which had just been started that day, and it left him with a total of 250 active listings. The 10 were visible in a completed search yesterday, but are now hidden as usual.
wastingtime101
The response by @lacemaker3 is correct. OP manually ended then used "relist" on all of their items - I checked the dates. Some of them they relisted more than once and ended duplicates (like the Elvis bottles).
I'm sure they did indeed see list for free on the first 250, until they got to the last 10 and by then they were on auto-pilot and didn't see the fee.
If the seller goes to their promotional offers pane on seller hub where it says used / left = 250 / 0 and they click on the 250 they will get a list of the 250 item numbers they listed for free, and the 10 items they're being billed for won't be on that list.
It's a $3.50 user error. Not the end of the world.
inhawaii
So it's user error/misunderstanding and NOT ebay being deceptive and trying to steal 35 cents?
tobaccocardyahoo
When some of the rolled over listings were subject to an insertion fee there was no opportunity to be told you were going to pay one. This is fundamental to the way good until cancelled listings work.
No fraud, no deceit. Another seller who does not understand the fundamentals of Ebay listing.
teavyellow
OPNope, just letting the eBay community know about how eBay how overcharged my account. This may very well be a glitch on their mobile app that they need to fix. Rather than apologies or fix the mistake, the AI bot disregards your inquiry and blindly re-states their fee policy which I am well aware of.
Terrible company, with zero seller protection or customer support.
fern*wood
What date did you add your 10 new listings? What is the date you initially listed the ones you were charged for. There is a place on the hub under promotional offers that will show you a running total of how many of the 250 are used up for the month and how many remain.
If you listed your 10 before enough of the original listings you had rolled over for the month, they easily could have been zero listing fees if not all the 250 were used quickly. The rollovers hit one month from the date you listed them originally.
luckythewinner
I believe you have a fundamental misunderstanding of how free insertions work.
chapeau-noir
I think @teavyellow is saying that at the bottom of the listing just before publishing, it was still free insertion. Doesn't it usually at that point tell you if there are any charges? It should actually have said .35?
chevymontecarlo88
If that is the case, the OP does have a point. Can anyone confirm?
teavyellow
OPYes, you are correct. They actually lied and instead of listing it for free, they tacked on insertion fees to item 1 - 10 out of 250 that I first listed in Jan. I closed by store last year because they offer zero seller protection and they will not refund you or reimburse you if they make a mistake and overcharge you selling fees. Again, they have really gone downhill as a company and they really don't care how long you've been a member.
Each time I chat, the AI bot thanks you for however many years you've had an account, and then will go on to re-state policies that are already on their website. They don't actually acknowledge you or address their mistake. The chat agents literally just ignore your questions and they blindly re-state the same response.
petercrowell_artgallery
you are right....it will be the amount for the listings however you list, over the 250 free ones, plus...also...if I am correct, eBay then charges you the 35 cents, when the item actually sells, in the billing amount details for the sold item...I think.
nobody*s_perfect
No. The insertion fee is charged when the listing begins, not after it is sold.
dryophelia
@teavyellow
If you already had 250 listings, adding the 10 new listings would incur a charge.
Ending the listings won’t result in a refund.
At the end of the next month, look at you 250 listings and decide if some are not worth relisting, end them. Maybe choose 10 that have not sold for months, and add 10 fresh listings.
teavyellow
OPLike the above comment, you are missing the point entirely. I am well aware that above 250 they charge an insertion fee of .35 cents, which is usually stated at the bottom of the listing when you go to list on the eBay app. Instead, deceptively, it said "LIST IT FOR FREE", in all caps. Instead of listing item 251 for free, as they stated, they took item 1 out of 250 (the first item I listed at the start of Jan) and then tacked on an insertion fee to it. That is deceptive and dishonest.
dryophelia
@teavyellow
Have you tried again. You don’t have to submit the listing, but take screenshots after every step to see if is still there? Having those screenshots will help with your case, should you reach out to eBay.
bdmh-enterprises
You're aware that listings automatically renew every month right? And that when that happens that counts as an insertion? So, again, you list your 251st item on Jan 1 and it's free, then after that your 250 OTHER listings renew, the first 249 of which are free then the last one gets an insertion fee because you've used the 250 allotment. That's how "rolling" works!
bdmh-enterprises
The free listings roll over at the beginning of the month.
So, say you listed 250 items on Jan 3, that uses all your free listings for Jan. Now on Feb 1 you again have 250 free listings available. You use 10 of them and they're free. Then on Feb 3 your original 250 listings automatically relist and you will be charged for the last 10 since you now have 260 active listings. Nothing deceptive at all..
teavyellow
OPIt is indeed 100% deceptive and dishonest on eBay's part. They claimed that my item was going to be "listed for Free," but later they manually tacked on insertion fees on 10 different items entirely. If an item is going to be charged an insertion fee, it should be stated so prior to publishing the listing, in this case, it said LIST FOR FREE.
If this is a glitch on the mobile app, they should be willing to credit me rather than charge fees on other items that were not even listed recently. When you contact them, you get an AI bot that just reads off their policy statements, and ignores your inquiry.
I've been with eBay over 20 years and they have really gone downhill as a company. This is only one example of how they have adjusted invoices in a deceptive and dishonest way in order to overcharge sellers.