Does "report this item" ever do anything? Presale related - automated AI response
I'm seeing tons of presale violations on this site, and reporting them gets an automated response:
What happened:
We looked into your report and didn’t find the listing to be in violation of our policy. This determination was made using automation or artificial intelligence.
A human never even sees reports apparently. Policy states that presales must be available within 40 days of the sale. Listings with an ETA months away get the same response, saying there was no violation. Presales for items that haven't even been made available for preorder by the manufacturer yet, with no ETA at all, get the same response.
In fact, every listing I've reported for any blatant violation gets the same response. There are so many scammers on eBay, and apparently there's no way to help clean it up if the tools provided by eBay don't work? Has anyone ever successfully seen a violation removed?
bbcardzman
The report this item is COMPLETELY WORTHLESS. As is EVERYTHING I have seen that involves AI. They take down my listings of items that there are literally hundreds of listed on eBay. I am fighting right now to list a 2" blue GI Joe gun on eBay that they took down. Funny how I already have many listings of toy guns on my site but those are OK just not this one. EBAY SUCKS WITH THEIR AI CRAP AND IT KEEPS GETTING WORSE AND WORSE!
ladymcquaid
Same. I keep reporting fake apple watches that I find and I get an automatic "no violations found" per their AI. It's maddening since I've been scammed with a fake watch TWICE now.
ckimodog
@delmarva_figures
Wrote: Has anyone ever successfully seen a violation removed? Yes...
I reported 4 items yesterday, all in the drugs, tobacco & alcohol categories which are prohibited big time. Sometimes the problem is the dishonest seller tries to circumvent the actual category by putting the item in a different category, which is search and browser manipulation or a misleading title in some cases. Another policy violation.
All 4 of those listings were removed and one of the sellers was naru'd. So yes, it does work.
Happy Selling
eburtonlab
Just because you got a form letter response to your report indicating that a bot could not find a policy violation in the listing does not mean that a human won't examine the listing at some point and come to a different conclusion.
The more independent reports eBay receives regarding a listing, the more likely that it will be examined in detail by someone other than a bot, I think.
Plenty of fraudulent listings I have reported have been removed, but I have no way of knowing if the removal was related to my report or someone else's report or some other entirely different reason.
My hope is that the more reporting data that eBay has to work with to train the bots, the more likely the bots will be to predict which listings will be problems sooner, which sorts of reports are correlated with serious issues and should be acted on quickly, and which sorts of reports are frivolous and should be ignored.
chevymontecarlo88
Does "report this item" ever do anything? Yes and NO
Yes if someone reports the item and NO if someone does not use it. If Yes, something will happen.
luckythewinner
Has anyone ever successfully seen a violation removed?
Yes, I have.
But removal often requires a manual review and eBay does not have unlimited resources dedicated to that task.
If eBay is anything like my company, they will triage and prioritize the reports based on volume. I suspect the more reports a listing gets from different members, the higher it moves in the queue.
By the way, eBay policy generally says they MAY remove a listing that violates policy.
redmodelt
"If eBay is anything like my company, they will triage and prioritize the reports based on volume. I suspect the more reports a listing gets from different members, the higher it moves in the queue."
I was going to post something along that line. One person reporting several times does nothing, it takes several people to do anything.
I have found that some reporting category's seem to get better results even with just one person reporting.
The drop-down list of choices were made to only fit a few situations. Often I have given up reporting because nothing in them fits what needs to be reported. The first two drop downs might fit, but the 3rd, nothing there fits.
kensgiftshop
It's not just AI.
I've reported listings and get the email saying they didn't find anything wrong with the listing and it was checked by a customer service agent.
Can report the listing a little later, then get an email saying it had been removed.
Don't know why the listing is fine one time, but a violation the next?
klhmdg
As long as eBay has AI looking at it, nothing will happen.
Everyone I have reported that was "looked" at by AI was No Violation.
I had 3 that had real people look at them and all 3 were removed.
eBay is shooting themselves in the foot with the AI thing.
I honestly think they dont care and this will only get worse.
delmarva_figures
OPI assume a human only looks at reports if it's a more serious violation, as in something that could put eBay in hot water?
eBay is getting their 13.25% fee (depending on the category) regardless, so they most likely don't care and some policies are strictly a formality. If AI can't scan a listing to find violations and fraudulent activity it's absolutely pointless.
valueaddedresource
@klhmdg while I'm definitely not a fan of eBay's recent trend of turning more and more customer service, trust and safety functions over to AI, I don't think we can entirely blame the bots for this one - eBay has been extremely lax on enforcement of their presale policies for many years, even before those recent AI developments.
In fact sometimes eBay will even be directly complicit, running promotional banners and marketing campaigns for presale items they know literally cannot possibly comply with the policy.
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/eBay-Promoted-Funkoween-Presale-Violations/m-p/31925487
I hate to break it to @delmarva_figures but the reality is this is one of those policies eBay has in writing for CYA (cover your...assets) reasons but very, very rarely actually enforces because they simply have no incentive to and in fact have perverse incentives to turn a blind eye or even encourage it to continue.
The biggest incentive eBay has is the way they report Gross Merchandise Volume (GMV) on their quarterly financial reports to Wall Street - something investors care a lot about.
eBay GMV is defined as "the total value of all paid transactions between users on our platforms during the applicable period inclusive of shipping fees and taxes." Once checkout is completed and payment is processed, it counts - regardless of whether it is later canceled/refunded voluntarily by the seller or refunded due to an eBay Money Back Guarantee case or credit card chargeback being filed because the item has not been delivered.
So it is in eBay's financial interest to allow these sales to be made even if they are against policy, especially as they are facing pressure to meet forecasts they've made telling Wall Street they expect to return to GMV growth by Q3 or Q4 of this year.
If some buyers end up getting caught out and left with no item past the eMBG timeline, they'll just shrug their shoulders and say "sorry, nothing we can do" - though that's not entirely true, they can and have issued "courtesy credits" to buyers in these situations in the past but it usually takes a lot of being a very loud and public squeaky wheel to get them to do it.
Unfortunately I believe the only way it will ever change is for enough buyers who are defrauded by these presale listings on eBay to file FTC complaints.
https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/business-guide-ftcs-mail-internet-or-telephone-order-merchandise-rule
https://reportfraud.ftc.gov/
However, given the cozy history between eBay founder Pierre Omidyar and many of the high level people at the FTC right now (including chairwoman Lina Khan)....I'm not holding my breath they will take any action any time soon either.
ed8108
In fact sometimes eBay will even be directly complicit, running promotional banners and marketing campaigns for presale items they know literally cannot possibly comply with the policy.
There is so much to forgive, will there be repentance on the part of ebay in our future, time will provide us the answer. Happy selling in these meantimes.
kbur8894
Very sad days 😔I have a Mattel Creations membership and still wasn;t able to get what i wanted . It was $140.00. Someone is trying to sell it and it was a pre-order so they don't even have it yet for$24,999.00 or best offer. I am so sick of these people who aren't even fans of these items getting away with this kind of behavior. I doubt anyone will buy it for that price but what is wrong with people ? I can inderstand them making some money off it but that is ridiculous. Everyone else on ebay is trying to sell this item for around $300.00 still too much. I am ready to stop buying from both places. Sad , sad times my friends. Try and have a nice day DB
epowerbargains
I reported sellers who were selling the "Weird Barbie" as presale 6 months or more before they had it in hand. eBay removed the listings but sellers simply re-listed it - so it was report, remove - relist. I finally gave up. One seller ended up getting shut down but not until after a number of angry customers were ripped off because the eBay and credit card protections had expired.
valueaddedresource
@epowerbargains sort of makes you wonder what happened to those amazing systems eBay had that supposedly automatically blocked or removed over 500,000 items during the pandemic doesn't it?
https://www.ebayinc.com/stories/news/we-are-actively-removing-price-gouging-prohibited-items-from-ebays-marketplace/
How We’re Removing Prohibited Items
We use a rules-based filtering system with algorithms that identify and block prohibited items and have a team of customer service agents dedicated to round-the-clock manual review to remove any listings not caught by our tools. The manual reviews include removing all listings for certain items, like masks and sanitizers; products with inflated prices; and products making false health claims, including test kits.
To date, this combination of enforcement efforts has resulted in the blocking or removal of over 500,000 listings in violation of our policy related to the coronavirus.
Funny how eBay can "get er done" when there's enough media, legal and regulatory scrutiny and oversight putting a spotlight on them but somehow it's an impossibly monumental task any other time....almost like it's a problem of incentives, not technology. 🤔
epowerbargains
I agree the technology is there and for some reason eBay did not seem to be able to track the fact that the sellers were ignoring the take down and disregarding the fact that they were not permitted to relist the removed item. It seems like without that enforcement piece the entire report and remove process has a big flaw. I say - relist it and get a warning - do it again and there should be a bigger consequence. The rules eBay has regarding pre-sale are there for a good reason to protect buyers and sellers should respect the rules, and eBay really needs to enforce them.
toysaver
I found a slew of listings to report a few days ago. I got immediate emails thanking me for reporting and then the next day a bunch of 'no violations found' notices. It seemed like the responses were automated as they came within minutes of each other, just as the reporting had been. I won't take the time anymore.