Buyers who are looking for a Penpal
Summary: sin-n-dex shared an experience about a potential buyer who seemed more interested in socializing than transacting on eBay, speculating that the buyer might have been looking for a penpal or trying to gauge his stamp knowledge. tobaccocardyahoo, gurlcat, and sin-n-dex discussed possible reasons for the buyer's behavior, including that the buyer might be considering selling on eBay or testing seller knowledge for potential deals. The conversation also touched on participant past experiences in online forums, where apprehensions about being flamed were mentioned, illustrating the complexity and unique challenges of online selling and interactions.
I consider exchanging pleasantries and getting to know a customer a bit while sharing a bit of information, to be a regular part of my business. People tend to be a bit social in coins and stamps, and at the clubs the collectors are all trying to get in good with the dealers so they can ask for discounts. All this is OK, and I see it every day.
I did get one though that I'm not sure was looking to make pleasantries to get a deal, it was a little off...
It started with "is the price negotiable?"
I sent an offer, and replied "I've just sent you an offer"
Then he says "where did you get the stamps, are you a collector?"
I reply "I'm not a collector, we run an antique shop and sometimes we get stamps to sell"
It kind of went like that for a few messages, and I'm thinking to myself "dude, do you want the stamps or not?" He keeps sending messages to ask questions, but the questions are not relevant to making the sale, and then he goes silent and doesn't buy the stamps. Before going silent his last message said something like "oh I thought you were actually a stamp collector", DUDE, what does that have to do with asking for a discount on the stamps? I have stamps, they're up for sale on eBay, are you buying them or not? (This is what I'm thinking, I just stopped replying).
What difference does it make if I collect, don't collect, deal, sell stamps at shows, have a stamp store, know other dealers in the area.... and all that stuff I got messages about. Sounds to me like he wanted a penpal, but since I'm not an avid stamp collector he lost interest and moved on to another listing.
C.
gurlcat
Just a guess, but he may have been trying to get a feel for your stamp knowledge, as a gauge of how much he could lowball you, not on the listing for which you already sent him an offer, but other ones. Like maybe he's gotten great deals by finding sellers who were not collectors but just storage unit pickers or family inheritors who didn't know much about stamps and were clearly struggling with pricing/describing, etc. so he found them amenable to accepting a bulk offer for mulitple listings, just to get them off their hands.
sin-n-dex
OPThat's actually a very good guess, although he didn't try to low ball me or ask for discounts on any other items, he just kind of went away. I actually don't have lots of stamp knowledge and someone probably could lowball me on stuff and I'd sell, but I have some better knowledge with Canada and Great Britain stamps. No knowledge of US stamps whatsover, I think I under price because those always sell no matter what price i put on them (must be all the varieties, and I'm not going to sort that out when we're not paying a premium on the collections).
gurlcat
During the period when I was obsessed with coins, I'd occasionally get some stamps in 'junk drawer lots' that also included coins. I briefly considered learning about stamps too ... but only very briefly, because I was already having to retain so much info about coins, and when I took a look at the stamp hobby, it appeared just as complex.
There's only so much nerding out I can do at one time.
sin-n-dex
OPI wasn't too into stamps either (I had a collection of ones I took off of packages from all the online ordering I was doing 20 years ago, but it's not a serious collection). The shop started getting random stamp albums coming in with other stuff and he has a "take all" policy so the person coming in doesn't feel like their stuff is being cherry picked, we just offer a price for all, and don't calculate a price for anything we don't think we can sell.
I tried to make up lots of stuff, and I was selling them... so then I started seeking out stamp collections to take apart and reassemble. It was lots of fun, but stamps aren't really selling for me anymore.
C.
tobaccocardyahoo
Consider the possibility your pen pal is considering a new career selling on Ebay.
sin-n-dex
OPI would think the forum is a better place to hang out for that info.
gurlcat
Definitely! But I don't think a lot of eBay members are even aware of the forums, especially buyers.
tobaccocardyahoo
Some of them who are aware are afraid of being flamed, so they might lurk but will not post.
The current Ebay forum is a lot tamer than past Ebay forums.
gurlcat
So I've heard. The morbid side of my curiosity makes me wish I could see a sample of the old meanness. 😆
sin-n-dex
OPI joined the forums in 2016, and lurked for a few months before posting. I messed up on an order and got flamed by a past member. I had sold 10 items, combined the order and the buyer paid. I was missing one item. The buyer wanted to cancel the other 9 items as a result of me missing the one item (which was his reason for buying), so the question was how to not get 9 additional defects for cancelling (at the time I was only able to cancel the order, but I was able to give enough of a refund for a missing item... don't remember the technical, but it was reason like that).
So this member says "so you think you can miss one item and avoid getting nine more defects when you cancel?" I replied "yes that's what I think, now tell me what to do on the site to make that happen." Didn't get too much flack on that situation after that, but I did sort it out with the buyer and he took the 9 items and I sent a replacement for the missing one.
So I can understand how some sellers post once and run after reading the replies.
C.
gurlcat
How do you remember so much detail from a 2016 sale/forum post?? 😲
I've had to dig to refresh the details from situations as recent as a month prior! -Especially if they were unpleasant ones. My mind is apparently very keen to delete bad memories.
sin-n-dex
OPBecause 8 years later he bought more stuff and I accidentally shipped his order to an overseas buyer and had to go to the shop to track down everything he bought (I refunded the order, but shipped him all his coins, it just wasn't exactly what he ordered). When I found out I did this, I checked my email for his user ID because it sounded familiar, and I called my business partner and said "oh no, not this guy again".
I had asked him to guess who the buyer was whose Japanese coins got sent to Europe, and my business partner said "was it that guy whose order you messed up 8 years ago?" Good guess... I mess up to infrequently I tend to remember.