buyer wants a refund
I sold a flash light nov 24. My description said it was cracked and untested. I even took pictures of it the crack. The buy wants a refund. I messaged them and told them it was cracked and untested. The next thing I know I'm supposed to print a return label. I don't want to refund them!! Is there a person I can talk to on the phone anymore?
houseattic
19 comments
gone.c-33
You may have mentioned the crack but your listing also said “This will work great to light up your path during camping, hiking or boating.â€
If the flashlight didn’t light anything up, then it’s significantly not as described.
johnrj1226
You sold this item as New Other Condition for ~ $35 + ~$10 Shipping - think you should ask the buyer to return for refund
"New" means "undamaged" read this link from eBay.
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/listings/creating-managing-listings/item-conditions-category?id=4765&st=3&pos=1&query=Item%20condition%20by%20category&intent=Condition%20D&lucenceai=lucenceai&docId=HELP1421
eBays money back guarantee has the buyer back.
asset_liquidators
Actually eBay's "New (other)" is a bit contradictory in it's description but there is NO WAY I would have listed that in any other category besides "Parts/Not Working".
momtoabeautifuldaughter
@houseattic
kensgiftshop
@houseattic
If it was damaged, why did you list it as new?
Accept the return and provide a shipping label.
luckythewinner
You chose New (Other) as the condition.
eBay's definition of 'New' does not allow you to amend that definition and contradict it.
You are in the wrong. Accept the return, apologize, and learn from your mistake.
momtoabeautifuldaughter
You will need to pay for the return and also give them a 100% refund when you receive it back.
You listed an untested cracked flashlight as NEW.....if I was you I'd just refund without return and learn to not lie about item condition.
caldreamer
Doesn't matter if you speak to EBAY Customer Service Rep....they will just tell you that you have "no option" but to refund the customer. You can choose to give them an immediate refund (they keep the item) or you can make them return the broken flash light (at your expense of course).
momtoabeautifuldaughter
You listed this as New?? You need to fully refund them upon return.
You can't list an untested flashlight with a crack as new
youn2240
Yeah you were definitely stretching the truth about new there. and you said it would work in the description" This will work great to light up your path during camping, hiking or boating." you sold someone trash and this is what happens.
stainlessenginecovers
As @asset_liquidators stated, you did NOT list the flashlight correctly.
1st- you listed as 'new' which means NO defects
2nd- you should have stated those issues in the Title
3rd- how can a flashlight be 'untested' and yet you listed it? Buy a battery and test it before listing or consider it garbage and throw it away- which is now what you should do when you get it back or..
Just refund without getting it back and save the return shipping cost.
After all, who wants a Flashlight that 'might' work and now proven to NOT work?
12345jamesstamps
Customer service is not going to be of any help. It would only cause a lot of more frustration.
Buyer opened a claim for a refund already...although you do returns for a limited numbers of days a buyer can do a return for 30 days. And buyer doesn't have to pay for return shipping.
I assume buyer stated item not as described for you getting stuck with return shipping.
If you looked at item for sale on an iPhone eBay APP...the description would not be seen right away.
We now have to put something in the title of item for sale...I use the words "Read the Description!" in some of my titles. I see the specifics as 'New Other' in your specifics but I think of that as new...it doesn't say a 'crack'.
I don't think there is anything you can do but give a refund...just my personal advice.
Is it worth it for a return and pay for shipping? A question to ask yourself.
Has buyer done anything else to it?
Your photos do show the cracks...would that help. Probably not.
Doing nothing the buyer keeps item and gets a refund...and hurts your account somewhat.
What kind of feedback will buyer leave also comes into play is a factor.
Using the 'new other' probably didn't help.
Unavailable member
@houseattic
You received answers to your previous thread https://community.ebay.com/t5/Returns/is-there-a-way-to-TALK-to-ebay-for-help/td-p/34833291
asset_liquidators
You should have listed that as Parts/Not Working. It should not have been listed as New (other).
Your buyer probably saw the word "new" and didn't read any further. I am not saying it's right (because it's not) but that is probably what happened. I would also put the word CRACKED in the title in capital letters.
Just accept the return and send them a return label. It's not worth fighting the return over a $35 item.
I know it sucks but it is what it is.
bonanza125
You are required to accept the return and upon return issue your buyer a refund. If you do not do this then Ebay will step in and you will get a defect. You can set up a call through chatbox where Ebay would call you back however you will be wasting your time. Accept the return. Get your flash light back and sell it to someone else. This buyer doesn't want it.
klhmdg
No.
IF the buyer files a Not as Described per the eBay MBG, you either supply a return shipping label or refund.
If you do nothing eBay will refund the buyer from your funds, you will not get the item back, you will still pay the FVFs and get a seller defect.
It doesnt matter what your listing says or doesnt say.
You should also put all issues with items in the condition. Most buyers now use cell phones and the description is hard to find.
Unavailable member
Accept the return, issue the return label. Refund when you receive the item back.
What you don't want to do is get eBay involved, they will just refund the buyer from your funds, let them keep the item AND give you a juicy defect for cases closed without a seller resolution.
FYI, if your buyer opened a return for not as described you will be refunding in full and paying for the return label. Your 14 day return policy only works for remorse returns.
wildcherrypink
Ebay, most of the time is not for the seller even when you clearly state it in several places of your listing. The buyers know that they just have to select "not as described" even though that is not the case a lot of the times and they will get a refund. Ebay doesn't investigate the claim before refunding. That is the same in selling clothes when a seller puts the measurements and they want a refund because it doesn't fit. It is a poor excuse for someone to buy using their cell phone and not reading the description entirety before buying. That lands on the buyer not the seller. I have had where people want to return a item and it clearly states in the title and in the description everything about the item. People need to read and be held responsible if they didn't. That is my thought on it.
youn2240
this isn't the same thing at all. this is a seller that was selling literal trash as a new item and then losing money as they should because it makes the customer not want to use ebay anymore. that flashlight is in absolute horrible condition and to act like it's fine and new is crazy. This is exactly the type of scenario that gives eBay a bad name which lowers the customer base willing to buy here. just refund the money because you'll come out ahead instead of paying shipping to come back so you can throw it out as it should have been. that is a bad listing there is no way around it.