Buyer tries to blatantly extort me, eBay refuses to remove negative feedback
I just saw that eBay announced their feedback removal system is now more 'fair'. The ironic timing could not be more incredible to me. Here's the thing:
I sold a radio transceiver to a buyer at the beginning of the month. They sent me a message claiming it was not a CB radio, and that they specifically wanted $20 back. I asked them to return the item and I'd refund them in full. Here's that interaction. Note that there was no communication before this.
Crickets. Several days later, they left negative feedback.
I reported this to eBay and asked to have it removed. They denied the request, saying the buyer wasn't violating policy.
.....Really??? Huh. So the buyer who messaged me and asked for $20 off the bat wasn't violating ANY policy?
Honestly, it's not surprising. I'm sure eBay hires as few people as they can get away with to handle as many cases as possible (all while probably paying them a pittance), and they speed through each one as quickly as they can. I've reported illegal items (related to cockfighting) many many many times to eBay, and they will often refuse to take down an item that's the EXACT same item they took down a day before. It seems like it's just a dice roll and depends on if the case goes to someone who knows what they're doing/pays attention/is knowledgeable and sympathetic/etc. I dunno about anyone else, but that seems pretty arbitrary to me.
I followed up through a chat with a customer service rep. They informed me that the feedback revision request can't be appealed unless the buyer opens up a return. I think the likelihood of that happening is very low. If you take a look at the other feedback they've left for other sellers, it's almost entirely negative or neutral. My guess is that they don't actually want to return the radio, they just want to complain about it until I give them $20 off. In other words, they want to extort me.
As for the claim the buyer made, that it's not a CB radio? 'CB radio' was a keyword I added to the title because I figured it was one. I'm sure people who know more about radio transceivers can correct me if I was wrong on this, which I probably was. However, I also made it VERY clear what model this radio was, so I thought that anyone buying it would probably know a lot more about it than me. Regardless, I'm fully willing to own up to mistakes I make (I'm only human after all, so it inevitably happens now and then), and let the buyer know I'd refund them in full if they returned it. After I messaged them saying this, they completely stopped communicating with me. I messaged them again after the negative feedback, letting them know they could still return it for a full refund, and have received no response.
I can deal with one negative feedback, but it's truly remarkable to me that eBay is announcing that their feedback system is somehow more 'fair' now. I truly hope it is, but for me, that could not be further from the truth. This is not the first time I've gotten this kind of reactionary feedback from a buyer, but I've almost always been able to resolve it with the buyer, and when the buyer refuses to communicate, eBay has been good in the past about removing the feedback. This time, when a buyer is blatantly trying to extort me for $20, violating policy, eBay has nothing to say.
thekulamoa
OPIt’s so wild to me how some people will agree with the assessment of one eBay employee, while arbitrarily dismissing the assessment of another. Ultimately, we can argue till the cows come home about what constitutes extortion, but ultimately, it doesn’t really matter. You should look at the situation and be able to use your own judgment, instead viewing everything, including basic human decency, through the policy of a multi-billion dollar corporation that could not care less about you as an individual. If I showed this situation to anyone outside of this forum, and they understood the full context, most of them would think that the buyer is rude, demanding, entitled, unfair, refused to communicate, and misused the feedback function. Many people (myself included) have also had bad experiences as a buyer, dealing with big companies that don’t give a crap about them, so they might have some sympathy towards the buyer. However, you have to have a gold medal in mental gymnastics to defend how the buyer handled this. If eBay backs that up in any official manner (jury’s out on that one), then, quite frankly, they have awful rules that should be changed.
The attitudes expressed here are, in my opinion, a reflection of a larger issue in our society, one of mistrust and cynicism towards each other. My deeper point is that it’s really sad that some people are so concerned with defending the rules of a massive corporation (that doesn’t ultimately have their best interests at heart), that they don’t realize how important it is for people, individuals, to have a little trust in each other, to simply support and listen to each other, even if they don’t always agree. Many of the replies to this thread have been illuminating in their vitriol, bad faith, or simple insistence on the idea that eBay is always right, and some replies have been full of humanity, humor, empathy, and in solidarity with their fellow humans.
I approach all buyer interactions with as much humanity as I can muster. I never want to exploit or shortchange anyone. Never was I rude, mean, or unfair to this buyer (some of you will say that I was being mean by leaving them 'negative' feedback, but then, those same people would also say that if someone kicks you, you should just lay on the ground, shut up, and never tell anyone about it ðŸ¤), and ultimately, though I do not agree with it, the negative feedback will remain, and will not ruin my day. But at the end of the day, we need to be able to set everything aside and just view each other as fellow humans. People reading this thread now can view all of the communications I’ve had up until this point with or about this buyer, and are capable of making up their own minds. Hopefully it helps others in a similar situation, and I think those situations are unfortunately becoming more common, no matter how hard we try or how 'perfect' we try to be. To anyone else, I genuinely hope that if something like this happens to you, eBay affords you the time and consideration you deserve, but if they don’t, maybe we can afford that to each other.
robbie31415
The outsourced reps tell you what you want to hear.
It's just what they do.
Realistically the rep should have just apologized that you feel the way you do about the situation and asked for the information.
After review they inform them that since it was already reviewed they have no ability to make adjustment.
Cs reps hands are pretty tied at the moment.
The fact they didn't do anything was the only appropriate action as they shouldn't.
However all the lying to try and show they are on the side of the person they are talking to is wrong.
Basically I don't trust a word the outsourced reps say.
mam98031
Was it a person? IDK
albertabrightalberta
Although I think the buyer knew exactly how to word her request to avoid committing feedback extortion and I do suspect that was the implication, I don't agree that it qualifies as extortion.
The following is an example of feedback real extortion, one for which I DID get the feedback removed. The buyer had left feedback then sent the message. (I reported it and didn't give in to the partial refund request.) I think you'll see the difference.
"The item came with pen marks on it and their was no mention of the defect on the item. I could not get pen marks off. If you are willing to return part of the cost of item, I will change my feedback."
EDIT: This was my post from when it happened.
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/For-feedback-extortion-question/m-p/32498568#M1890044
robbie31415
That's pretty much it.
They didn't word it to be clear evidence of extortion.
Ebay won't act on assumption, or what it could be.
mam98031
I agree. I've been trying to explain this to the OP since the beginning of the thread. But they feel passionately about their position and they have a couple posters that agrees with them and is supporting their position, so it makes it harder to try and get the OP to understand.
Then the Chat they had just a few posts up thread is rather alarming to me. Not only with mis-information but a statement made by the AI or person "I see ---- that is clear extortion and they are just ruining sellers lives"
albertabrightalberta
But we see it all the time on these discussions @mam98031 . OPs come and look for replies that agree with them and that's all they need. Think of how frequently they get bad information, check that as the "best answer" and go with it!
mam98031
We do, that is true @albertabrightalberta . We aren't trying to hurt the OP in any way or cause them more stress. It is exactly the opposite. I know they feel passionately and firmly believe their viewpoint and I respect that completely.
The Chat they had with Ebay customer service had misinformation in it, but because it fits better with their opinion of this transaction it just makes their belief even firmer. I'm not even sure they were talking with a human. It reads to me like it was the AI. However I certainly could be wrong about that.
We are just trying to get the correct info to the OP, but they view the posts as anything but that.
jupiter_collectibles
I had a buyer message me through eBay demanding I pay their import taxes on their item or they would leave bad feedback. eBay let them do it and I got extorted and they still left negative feedback. It's a pathetic system that needs to go.
thekulamoa
OPI guess it would be a good idea to share the exchange I had with eBay customer service. My name, customer username, and order number have all been redacted, otherwise this is the full chat. This CSA agreed that it's extortion, but said that the feedback removal request cannot be appealed unless a return is opened. If that were to happen, it could be appealed after the request is closed.
For anyone else facing this issue, I would highly recommend that instead of going through the normal feedback removal request (that can be found here: https://www.ebay.com/sellerhelp/feedback), go through eBay chat or email first, and talk with someone so that they can review it alongside you. This way, they don't just fly through the request without properly looking at it.
gurlcat
That was a great exchange. You explained the situation well and you got a good rep to look into it.
I'm curious, after he said "That is clear extortion and they are just ruining sellers' lives" (I guess he looked at the feedbacks left for other sellers too) ...... did it make you more or less upset that he couldn't remove the feedback?
mam98031
It's an AI, not a real human, or at least I think it is.
thekulamoa
OPHonestly? It was nice just to be backed up. It's still upsetting, but...I guess I feel like being too upset about it now, after having it made clear that it can't be changed, would just be giving this giga-corp even more of my time, energy, and sanity (similar to letting a controlling/abusive/gaslighting person negatively impact my life and emotions after they're out of my life). As of now, it is what it is, I can't make said giga-corp more ethical, but it certainly helps push me further away from eBay and towards other places to sell (and buy). It was way more upsetting coming to this forum to commiserate, only to have people here gaslight me, lol (until you changed the conversation towards the positive!).
I've had bad buyers like this in the past, and either been able to work it out with them (especially in cases where it was a mistake on my part!), or have eBay remove unfair feedback (no back-scratching arrangement required, just being honest and having receipts on buyer behavior). But now, they just rip reports as quickly as possible (cause it's probably people being paid pennies to look through a mountain of reports so eBay fatcats can pocket more money). BTW tooootally unrelated but did you know eBay's current CEO was COO of Walmart.com? You know, Walmart, another incredibly ethical and generous company who just loves helping out the little guy. 😋
gurlcat
OH GOOD, I'm glad because it made me feel better by proxy just reading it! No matter how unfair something is, it always feels at least a little better to have just one person looking at the same thing and being like "Yeah, this IS 'bleep'ed up!" -But having an employee say it would really hearten me, even if they couldn't fix it. To me the only thing worse than suffering an unfairness is salt-in-wound gaslighting, like you must be crazy to think it's unfair, in fact you deserved it.
mam98031
I'm sorry the AI [could be a human, but I doubt it] gave you so much bad information. I know you don't agree with me and that is fine, but your buyer did not DEMAND anything, they ASK about a $20 refund. Nor did they threaten anything if you didn't give them the $20. So I get it, you believe it is extortion, but you and the AI are mistaken.
Also the stuff the AI said about the buyer would need to file a Request for Return before you could appeal the feedback is also not a thing. There is no such policy. I'm sorry you were mislead.
american-photography
If you don’t know what you are listing, then you shouldn’t be listing it.
Since you mislead the buyer, they have every right to leave negative feedback and file a NAD.
Ebay did the right thing by NOT removing the feedback.
suite_vintage
Yep, we can start packing our bags. eBay is blatantly using feedback scores to show buyers but then turns around saying 1-2 negative is no big deal. I can already see the results of this. Feedback Update: "Removal requests will be reviewed individually by our customer service agents". But then say no policy was violated. Why even bother, no clear rules here. Maybe eBay could start treating smaller sellers a bit better instead of treating everyone as some LLC or corporation. We all are not perfect, most do the best we can to make a little money cause most are watching instead of buying.
vintagecraze50
OK we sell fine jewelry anywhere from 179 to 500 bucks. Say I make an error and sen them by mistake the 179 ring and they bought the 500 buck ring. OOOO my bad. They message me saying HEY give me 600 buck off for this because you made a BOO BOO. HECK NO. SEND IT BACK PLEASE!!!
robbie31415
You clearly have the right to reject that.
They clearly have the right to leave negative feedback all for an issue that was your "BOO BOO".
The entire negative experience started by your error.
Negative feedback is warranted.
vintagecraze50
I GET THAT. I would accept the negative feedback here because of my error. But I would NOT do a partial refund.
thekulamoa
OPJust gonna leave this here, since many of you (and apparently some eBay employees...) seem to need some educating on eBay's actual policies. I'd like you to note that eBay does not in fact say that you can't demand a partial refund. You actually can't even REQUEST a partial refund, not without returning the item. The more you know!
From here.
As I said before, this was confirmed by a customer service employee, who said that the feedback should have been removed (but can't now, due to eBay's OTHER policy that apparently prohibits appealing a feedback removal request unless a return is opened...lol). If you're going to be throwing the book at me (as if the policy of a multi-billion dollar company dictates what's actually moral), at least know what it says.
@gurlcatMy condolences. 😔
vintagecraze50
YEP, THEY CANNOT ASK FOR A PARTIAL REFUND.
mam98031
@thekulamoa
Behavior not allowed and Feedback not allowed are two completely different things.
https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/feedback-policies/feedback-misuse-policy?id=5030
vintagecraze50
Maybe they think if they dirty your feedback you will give in and give them money and then they get the item they obviously do not want but it’s ok if they get 20 bucks back. CRAZY.
vintagecraze50
“I want ebay to fix it†is what they said in that negative feedback. FIX IT? HOW? You offered them a full refund. THE BUYER GOT THE FIX FROM YOU.
vintagecraze50
THEY WANT EBAY TO FIX IT By forcing you to partially refund. Which by policy, you do not have to do.
robbie31415
Oh yeah the feedback should be removed when your title clearly says it's a CB radio when it isn't.
The buyer is so much in the wrong.
Imagine leaving negative feedback when a seller makes a big mistake such as this.
Buyer should be grateful for what they got.
🙄🙄🙄
vintagecraze50
Ebay policy is that you cannot demand a partial refund. You offered them a full refund.
kensgiftshop
If that's the message they sent, they didn't actually say they wanted a $20 partial refund.
They might have hinted at it, but didn't say it.
gurlcat
The silver lining: A 99.7% positive is better than a 100%. Couple reasons:
1. There are buyers who don't trust 100's; they think a seller who has lots of sales but no bad feedback must be getting their negs removed via some back-scratch deal with eBay behind the scenes, therefore they have a license to abuse buyers with impunity. -By the way, this is a belief I thought was pure hokum, conspiracy theory nonsense, until just about a week ago. -I learned of a seller who does indeed appear to have that exact back-scratch thing going on.
2. 100% positive is a bright red target for buyers who attempt to get partial refunds as routine. And why not try to get an after-sale discount, when there are definitely sellers who'll do it .... might as well try, right?! And who would be the most likely sellers to cave? Which ones have something they'd really like to keep? -Sellers with 100. By the way, your reply to this neg was MUAH! -chef's kiss. Now partial refund scammers will have something to read that shows them you don't play that game, and they should move along. Meanwhile good buyers will see that you offer full refunds for return and you are open to communicate.
My 1 neg is about to fall off any day now, but there'll be no champagne cork flying in this house about it.
thekulamoa
OPYou're absolutely right, and you kinda just made my day (especially after getting gaslit from a bunch of other people about how I didn't kiss this buyer's a$& enough). Looks like your one neg did fly off into the ether already, so, congrats!(?) 😅
gurlcat
😳

<Goes to check>>>>
NNNNNNNOOOOOO!!!! 😩
gurlcat
You ready to see some hilarious sh? -Strap in, because you're not going to believe this. Remember how I said 100% positive makes you a target for partial refund scammers? Remember how I said I did not look forward to losing the one negative I had, then you pointed out that I already had lost it? -Well check this out, and note the dates.



Now, I honestly cannot remember the last time I got a message from a buyer expressing any dissatisfaction whatsoever, never mind appearing to fish for a partial refund, never mind naming their price.
But lookie look at what dropped in my lap today!
Now that lot is absolutely ALL sterling silver. -This buyer is also a reseller like me, and they have simply decided they would like to cherry-pick the pieces that are the most resellable, but that's not how mixed lot sales work, sorry. And precious metal content aside, any reseller could have tried to extort me for the same (unstated, real) reason with any regular plastic & glass costume jewelry lot, wanting to minimize their investment after the delivery, by claiming some portion of the pieces aren't as good of "quality" as they hoped or whatever. -And I did have one return based on that complaint several months ago, but it was just a straight return, performed wordlessly, exactly as designed with button-click simplicity, and which I WELCOME. But I definitely didn't get any non-return messaged complaints during that whole year that I had a neg on my record.
Unfortunately I see zero negs left for others, by this person. DANG IT! So I suppose they are probably just going to try to argue, which is exactly why I cannot stand this carp!
thekulamoa
OPNo freaking way! I'd laugh if it wasn't so aggravating. 😬 OK, no way the people who were defending my problem buyer could suggest in good faith that that buyer isn't trying to extort you. I know I just spent a thread pointing out how eBay is bad about following their own policy but...I would definitely report this person ASAP. They're directly asking you to pay them a specific amount of money, so that's for SURE against policy, and if you talk to someone who actually knows what the company's policy is, well...actually tbh I don't know what they'll do. Maybe they can at least prevent the buyer from leaving you a neg?
gurlcat
So just to reiterate message ^message #70, this buyer (nor yours) fit the description of feedback extortion, because neither mentioned feedback in their messages. YES the negative feedback you received as a result certainly seems like revenge for not giving the partial refund, but you can't prove they intended for you to fear a neg at the time that they wrote you, in fact it literally may not have even occurred to them until after you refused.







BUT, as stated in the policy that you posted earlier in the thread, the act of requesting a partial refund alone is a violation, and I think it's highly possible you are right about reporting it before getting a neg, that having it on record could be instrumental in getting a neg removed if it does happen.
So about this sterling lot buyer -I replied as you did, that I would accept a return for a full refund. Well, Wednesday the buyer replied
Definitely some wonky English, but it sure looked like she expected the refund before returning, right? Well, considering she has 250 feedbacks and 47 items sold, she may not be an ace veteran but she surely knows that is not how returns go, but who knows, could be the English non-fluency thing. So I just ignored it. But then this morning she wrote again, this time making it very clear what she was trying for. I mean why not? -I MIGHT be that stupid, right?
So, this time I wrote to "inform" her that the buyer must initiate the return in order to get the shipping label, then return the items and get a refund. If she didn't know how to do it before, she sure figured it out fast, because just a couple minutes later I got the 'Return requested' notification. -But it's interesting how the supposedly-fake pieces went from "most" in her emails, to "almost half" in her Return Details comments.
So whether it's most, half, a few, whatever -I have a very strong feeling I will not receive all the pieces back. Hopefully I'm wrong about that, but if not, then how many and which pieces she kept would show who is actually stupider; her or me. And it very well could be me, because if she kept a bunch and/or the most valuable ones, the most I can deduct from her refund is 50% ($80, which is more than the $60 she was asking for). But at least I would have some of the pieces back. -Yeah she said she was going to send the "fake" ones back if I sent the $60 but no reason to trust that. Oh, and by the way, even with this official return she could send nothing but a dog turd and I would still have to refund her half (plus she could get the other half from eBay's pocket, if she knows that trick).
So, no telling where it'll go from here. But THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR REMINDING ME TO REPORT HER. And no need to talk to a CSR for that. If you didn't know, you can do it in writing which is even better because you have sharable proof that you filed it. If you just type 'report buyer' into the help and contact search, you'll get a handy blue button to click, followed by menu and text box steps.
thekulamoa
OPUsing that form to report them is a good idea for sure. However, it IS kinda unsatisfying because you'll never hear back from eBay about the report, so you'll never know if it does anything. And as I know from my own experience with reporting buyers, feedback, and illegal items, eBay is incredibly arbitrary when it comes to what they actually DO with these reports. I'd definitely recommend, if you want to spend the time doing this, to chat with an actual customer service rep and see what they can do. I also say this because that's what I wish I'd done BEFORE asking for the negative feedback to be removed, as they may have reviewed it a little more carefully if I was directly talking to them.
I'm sure you already know how to do this, but I'll put it here for anyone else who's wondering - eBay has made it harder to get in touch with them, but if you go to eBay's customer service portal and click on any of the articles, there should be a chat box in the lower right corner. Just click on that, and tell the chat bot that you want to talk to a human, it should get you in a chat with a rep, or let you email them. Chatting with them in real time and going through the issue and seeing what they say would probably be the best option.
Your situation sounds like a potential ticking time bomb, where the customer just wants to create trouble, so hopefully it works out and you don't end up losing a bunch of money. Honestly, it almost seems like getting a negative feedback would be preferable to dealing with such an awful customer (especially now that you're back to 100%!). 😓
gurlcat
Well you know my stance on that, LOL.
When I got that complaint message just a few days after my 100 was reinstated, the first thing I did was kick myself for back when you told me I had 100, how I replied "Noooo!!!" -I meant to also put in writing "Now just you watch, I will start getting partial refund fishers again, probably no more than a month before the first one!" -but I forgot, after playing with the "Nooo!" font size and whatever (I have ADD if that wasn't obvious). -Little did I know, my first fisherman was going to buy from me that very SAME DAY.
My second thought? -Oooo, PLEASE NEG ME, scammy German chick!!! It would be so perfect if she does, because then I won't just have 'a' neg; I'll have one to which I can specifically reply about how I don't do partial refunds. That would assure me another blissful drama-free year, at least in that regard.
mam98031
However, it IS kinda unsatisfying because you'll never hear back from eBay about the report, so you'll never know if it does anything. And as I know from my own experience with reporting buyers, feedback, and illegal items, eBay is incredibly arbitrary when it comes to what they actually DO with these reports.
That would be private account information and Ebay doesn't share that for buyers or sellers. It is like you said, they don't share with you what they do when you report a member for anything, so how do you know that Ebay is being "incredibly arbitrary" when reporting members for whatever reason. You appear to be assuming that since you can see or aren't told what Ebay may have done, they didn't do anything. That would not be correct.
I realize you are upset and you feel that Ebay should remove the feedback the buyer left. But it doesn't fall under any of the rules to get the fb removed. I know you insist the buyer tried to extort you, but they didn't at least no per the email from them that you shared here. If there is more, you haven't posted it.
In that email the buyer did NOT Demand a thing. They asked for a $20 partial refund, but the did not demand it or threaten you with any action on their part if you didn't comply.
eBay has made it harder to get in touch with them
On each Ebay page there is a link to contact Customer Service at the top of the page and again at the bottom of the page.
I would suggest that you contact Ebay for Business on Facebook, Instagram or Twitter for the better trained CSRs.
Here are your options for contacting Ebay Customer Service. Please be aware that for social media CS, you send them a Private Message and briefly explain what your problem or issue is. Feel free to leave your Name, address, phone number and/or your email address in this message. It is private and secure and it may help to speed up the response for you.
https://twitter.com/askebay
https://www.facebook.com/ebay
https://www.instagram.com/ebayforsellers/
Your options will be on the left. If you use the link below you can only get to the Automated Assistant or Chat box type AGENT in the box and hit enter. You will then get more options. Not all options are available 24/7. It will depend on staffing available. So sometimes you can request a call back and sometimes you can't. Sometimes you have the Chat option available and other times it won't me. If it is important to you to use one of those options, just try back later.
If you use a cell phone or other mobile device, you may need to turn off your Spam filter so that Ebay can call you.
If you are a seller outside of the US or Canada, you will need to use the Chat Option.
https://www.ebay.com/help/eua?id=5275&mkevt=1&mkpid
https://www.ebay.com/help/home
vintagecraze50
Gurl Cat MUAH AND MEOW TO YOU!
the-fan-van
"A 99.7% positive is better than a 100%."
That is the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard.
gurlcat
If you say so !
deanenesthings
I’ve had 100% rating for over a decade on this account. I too was just threatened with a negative feedback if I did not give a partial refund. I immediately contacted CS and was told not to worry, any negative feedback would be removed because item was about size and shown clearly next to a ruler. ( Diamond Huggies ) I refused the shakedown and ignored buyer once the extortion message came in. Neg was left claiming I enlarged pics ( on diamonds- lmao. Most buyers demand zoomed in pics to see clarity and color!) So I requested removal. Denied stating it was INAD - when no return request was opened for INAD??? I then escalated to the “ offline team†which immediately denied the request to remove because eBay didn’t want to get involved in a buyer’s opinion.
Another thing-I thought a buyer had to wait 7 days to leave bad feedback? Guess that changed too!
So I’m furious. I buy & collect way more than I sell. Ended all of my listings, made FB private, returning items.
So beware. What stuck out to me was “ Buyers don’t expect to see 100% positive feedback “ in this new garbage update.
mam98031
I'm going to start my response with a pet peeve of mine. I don't think ANY member should be allowed to have Private feedback.
Now moving on from that, You have private feedback, so I'm unsure how you were able to sell on the site since private feedback isn't suppose to be allowed for sellers.
Since we can't see what exactly the buyer said, it is hard for anyone to try to help or give you any ideas of what you might be able to do now.
The seven day rule is ONLY for sellers that are TRS. There has been no changes with this rule, you simply are not currently TRS,
What "new garbage update"? What are you referring to?
gurlcat
You took down all your listings because of one negative? I can't wrap my head around feedback being more important than anything else here, but different strokes I guess.
EDIT: Wait, when you say "Returning items." -you mean you're returning things you bought from other sellers because of this neg from a buyer? What did those sellers do to you?
gurlcat
I sympathize more than most of your prior respondents, and up until a day about a year ago? (I'll get back to that in a minute) the only thing I might have asserted would be about the negative comment in your positive buyer feedback. -I wouldn't have shamed you for it, but I might have asked "Is it worth it?" meaning, is it worth getting in trouble to leave a comment that probably nobody will read, and even if they do, probably not have any use for it?
But I won't even ask that, not now.
Now? Story time! A while back (roughest guess: a year ago, but who knows, the pandemic ruined my sense of time worse than it already was) .... I had a question from a buyer and after answering I went to see their feedback left for others. I can't recall if there were lots of negs, and I can't remember what any of them said, but I guess I was feeling rabbit-hole-y so I followed at least one of them back to the seller they left it for, and saw that the seller had left a neg/pos comment for the buyer -and BOY HOWDY was it a sad tale. Said the buyer pushed for a nonsense partial refund (just like yours) and then did a return but returned junk instead of what they purchased.
My item was nearly identical to that sale; it was what this buyer shopped for routinely, so I immediately put the buyer's name in my BBL. I felt so lucky to see that and was so grateful for what the seller wrote, that I actually emailed to thank her! She replied swiftly that the situation was even worse than the comment character limit permitted "Oh I didn't even say the half" and proceeded to give a fuller, even more nightmarish picture of what a piece of dog doo doo that buyer was. And I had no reason to second-guess one word of it being true, because it happened months before yet the seller told it like it was yesterday, like she was still feeling it, you know?
So I got to thinking, what would've happened if that buyer had reported her for posting the neg/pos? Comment deleted obviously, but I carried a sense that it might be more, like punishment for the seller, but what? I couldn't find the answer in Help. So what did I do? -Why, come to ask the Community of course! Lord have mercy. Those who did try to answer cited policy but it seemed eBay would sanction the behavior only if the seller did it "enough" times, and I wanted to know how many times that meant ... well, nobody knew that, so then teeth started really clenching. At one point a khoros employee gave the finger wag for "a bit heated" discussion. Then a blue was tagged and they just cited the same vague policy speak. So I was like, "So .... nothing would actually happen to a seller if they got caught doing it just once? Cool." Or something like that. Then it was rippin' hell cats mayhem. Psssst .... don't tell anyone, but I enjoyed it very much. I swear I'm a nice person! But there's just something about a hissy fit I can't resist watching now and then. And that's the only one I ever started.
I think.
So to sum up: Treat every buyer like your favorite relative! Every single one of them!
Except those ones.
thekulamoa
OPYour story got a big smile from me, thanks for sharing, you're an absolute gem! ðŸ˜
I've actually avoided a couple buyers in the past by seeing a negatively worded positive feedback a seller left. Most of the time, it's pretty pointless, but sometimes it really does help people out.
vintagecraze50
GURL CAT is one of my absolute favorite posters on here. I am always delighted by her responses.
1funkydude
You sent an item that didn’t match the title/description. That established, I’ve a business question for you:
At $22 shipping on a $45 item, why wouldn’t you refund the $20 for which they asked instead of eating the cost of both the original and return shipping?
thekulamoa
OPThe item DID match the description, photos, and item specifics. The only thing, according to the buyer, that didn't fit, was 'CB radio' in the title. But I digress.
I would be willing to consider a partial refund if something was really off with the order. However, immediately giving a $20 refund to anyone who asks, without talking it through with them and considering the different options, that would be ridiculous and bad policy. I would have happily accepted the return shipping cost, refunded the buyer, then sold it to someone else for the same price.
For me, this is also a matter of principle. I do not just immediately shell out a specific amount of money a buyer asks for. I always want to work things out with buyers and find a solution they're happy with and that feels fair. I want to reach out to buyers at a human level and make sure they know I'm also human, and am not trying to scam them, and will work with them until we can both find a solution. I will NOT be intimidated into issuing refunds immediately, without talking it out. This buyer reached out in bad faith, refused to communicate after my initial message and proposal to return it, and then left negative feedback.
If you get a message like this from a buyer, your initial reaction should not just be to give in to their every demand, though I totally understand if you do if you have less feedback and more to lose. I used to go along with buyer demands much more easily. A buyer asking for a SPECIFIC amount right off the bat points very heavily towards them fishing for a discount for an item they do in fact want. This behavior has increased a lot in the past few years, as people are used to getting free refunds/returns/etc from big corps like Amazon. If they really have an issue with the item, and/or if something was really off in the listing or with the item, it sometimes absolutely does make sense to give a partial refund. But if they're totally unwilling to work with you AND unwilling to return the item, this points strongly towards what is essentially extortion, wherein they do actually want the item, they just didn't want to pay the full price for it, and will punish you for not complying.
If someone who acts in such bad faith leaves me negative feedback, so be it, I'm willing to deal with that. I will not grovel for the approval of a buyer like this. If they wanted to reach out again and work with me, I would absolutely work with them even now and accept a return. The fact that eBay is so arbitrary in removing said feedback is disappointing, but not surprising.
Tl;dnr: Some things are worth paying for, as a matter of principle, and to keep consistent policy/prevent buyer abuse in future.
fern*wood
I feel you did the right thing by telling them to return for a full refund, but I don't see the $20 request quite the same. I would have looked at that as an out to avoid a return for a mistake I made in a description. I don't tie everything to feedback in the way many sellers do. Feedback isn't as important to me at all compared to saving a sale.
It was difficult enough to get ebay to remove feedback when a buyer spelled it out they were going to give you bad feedback unless you did such and such. Their message didn't say anything about feedback, but you felt it. I doubt ebay will feel it.
mam98031
@thekulamoa
"I just saw that eBay announced their feedback removal system is now more 'fair'. " That isn't what the announcement said. But they did say they are going to be making some changes that they said would be good for sellers, however they did not say when they were coming or what they were. Well except for one example.
Unfortunately under the current rules that feedback isn't removable and the messages you receive are not extortion either. If it was, then the FB would be removable under the rules, but all they did was inform you of what they received, or what they said they received. That certainly doesn't mean it is true. But it still is not extortion that you can prove.
Now asking for a partial refund is something the buyer can't force you into, but unfortunately they didn't mention that in the feedback. If they had, then it would be removable too. It appears your buyer was very careful in how they worded stuff to stay just under the wire. But your buyer never said either give me the partial refund or I'll leave you a negative feedback. That is extortion. A simple request for a partial refund is not.
Did you happen to review the buyers feedback LEFT FOR OTHERS. Now if when you view that you can see a consistent patter of them doing this to other sellers, you might have a case for Feedback Abuse which might get the feedback removed.
Because Customer Service did not give you the answer you wanted or believed you should get doesn't make them bad or incorrect. It means you simply did not agree with them. I get it and I understand your frustration, but the buyer did not break the rules in a way to get you what you want.
thekulamoa
OPThis buyer does actually have a consistent pattern of abuse. They've left mostly negative or neutral feedback for other sellers. Because of this, I felt confident that eBay would remove the feedback. However, after the removal request was denied, I chatted with eBay support, and they essentially said that I was right, it absolutely violated policy, but it can't be appealed unless a return is opened. As someone who's made tons of reports of illegal items on the platform (of cruel, illegal cockfighting supplies), I know how arbitrary they can be, as sometimes the exact item taken down the previous day will be left up by another employee reviewing it. The feedback system is likely the same, and eBay likely gives a massive workload to people who do this job, forcing them to sift through tons of requests every day, which means they can't give these requests much individual time. Most big corporations do this now.
I disagree that it isn't extortion. They asked for a specific amount of money from me, and, while they didn't threaten to leave negative feedback, once they did, this gave them leverage. Many sellers, including myself in the past, would message them and offer to refund at least part, if not all of the order, just to have the negative feedback removed. That's not a route I want to go down, I'd rather just keep the negative feedback.
robbie31415
Technically them telling you they would accept less for the item post sale is against policy.
But that policy isn't feedback policy and they didn't threaten you that if they don't they will give negative feedback.
So even if they are technically in violation of A policy, it's not technically the feedback policy.
The feedback itself doesn't appear to violate any policy.
So I don't see grounds to have it removed.
animal-house-8
Man I would have loved to get a nice VHF instead of a cheap CB....LOL, Mistakes happen the guy should have just returned it with no issues.
thekulamoa
OPYeah, all the people jumping to defend this buyer (for reasons I still can't fathom) fail to actually look up this item and realize that it's worth what they paid or more. Why would I refund half the item cost, when I could have it returned and sell it to someone who wants it, while also resolving the issue the buyer has by giving them ALL of their money back? The truth is, they very likely don't actually want to return it and knew exactly what they were getting, they just want a $20 off coupon. I have no problem issuing partial refunds for mistake, but will not do so if a buyer refuses to communicate or work with me at all and acts in such bad faith.
mam98031
I think you may interpret some posts that are condemning this buyer as defending them. That certainly isn't the case. The buyer could have and should have worked with their seller but they didn't and the OP is having to deal with the aftermath.
Unless there are other emails from the buyer, the one the OP shared is not an extortion email. They may not have been correct, but it wasn't extortion, the buyer demanded nothing. I do agree with you, I think the buyer was just looking for a partial refund too, however they sure didn't give the seller much time to react.
animal-house-8
I have many many times a buyer will say this just isn't right or I didn't like this or that can you give xx amount of money back. I always say we take returns only sorry, I would say most of the time buyer just doesn't return it they were just trying to get money back using the treat of negatives if you do not. So one time a guy then bought 10 more things returned them and left 10 neg feedbacks just because I would not refund him $25. Ebay refused to do anything. So all you can do is block them but that doesn't always work if they have multiple accounts. After a year they all go away and now I have none till next time.
Unfortunatly you really can make way more money being a scammer than an honest person cause of ebays non-seller protections.
thekulamoa
OPHoly cow, that's unreal! I'm so sorry you had to deal with that. One negative from a buyer who refuses to communicate or work with you at all is bad enough, but ten!!! Wow. eBay is one of the least seller friendly platforms out there, and even these forums reflect that (I expected some negativity here, but the lengths people will go to defend entitled behavior is pretty breathtaking). I hope it all worked out for your OK in the end, but I imagine getting 10 negatives that weren't removed would hit anyone hard.
mam98031
Not knowing what they actually posted for fb it is only a guess if it could or couldn't have been removed.
I respect that you feel Ebay is one of the least seller friendly platforms, but from my experience I think that prize goes to Amazon for 3rd party sellers.
Keep in mind that negativity is pretty much the foundation of any forum like this. We do occasionally get feel good stories, but they don't get very much activity on them.
albertabrightalberta
Truly insane to complain about a seller leaving negatively worded positive feedback after the buyer: 1. Tries extortion
@thekulamoa
I don't read the buyer's request for a discount as extortion. Feedback extortion would be if the buyer threatened to the effect of, "If you don't reimburse $20, I will leave negative feedback." The buyer's request is because YOU made the error in YOUR listing.
The buyer username has been removed from the screenshot to comply with forum rules. However, their username can be viewed with literally one click on my feedback score.
No, we see the buyer's anonymized ID as "Buyer: e***e (4)"
thekulamoa
OPThat is just a truly remarkable thing to say. Someone messages, asks for $20, I say I'll give them ALL their money back if they return the item, and then they leave negative feedback without opening a return or contacting me again in any way. Doing this is called feedback extortion, and is absolutely against eBay policy. When I contacted eBay afterwards, they confirmed this and said that I'd handled the situation professionally. Even now, I would still be willing to work with this buyer and refund them in full. However, refunding them a specific amount they demand, after they refuse to open a return, and leave negative feedback, that would be absolutely insane.
I have learned one thing today. Don't post on a forum full of entitled people who want the ability to do the same thing as this buyer without consequence or any judgement.
Yep, you're right, I forgot about that. Good I guess?
1funkydude
Extortion would require the buyer letting you know the consequences or your refusal to comply will result in negative feedback. That doesn’t appear to be the case here.
vintagecraze50
I say again. Buyer says in feedback I am going to tell ebay like a 2 year old about you not giving me my 20 bucks back.
vintagecraze50
E=X-T-O-R-T.
vintagecraze50
Kinda right but kinda wrong. The buyer left feedback that is asking the buyer to do something they are not OBLIGATED to do on here.
vintagecraze50
“I will send a note to ebay and tell them blah about the 20 bucks you are not going to give me back†Kinda Distorted as in distortion.
buyselljack2016
Seems like the buyer offered a possible solution to your mistake.
So, I guess I am not well informed. A policy violation?? for the buyer suggesting a partial refund for the mistake??
vintagecraze50
THEY CAN ASK FOR THE PARTIAL, but the seller is under no obligation to give it. The seller did the right thing there just saying they would fully refund. AND, what in the world would this buyer even want to keep this item if it is not what they wanted.
jameshen1
I felt bad for you that the buer tried to get a partial refund rather than returning for refund and then left you a neg. Then I realized you didn't know what you were selling and called it something it was not (CB radio). Then you violated policy and named and shamed the buyer. Then finally, you violated policy by leaving negatively worded feedback for the buyer. When called on that being a violation, you admitted you knew that but did it anyway.
I no longer feel bad for you.
albertabrightalberta
Add to that the fact that in post 8, you linked to an outside name and shame website! You know what they say about karma.
thekulamoa
OPTruly insane to complain about a seller leaving negatively worded positive feedback after the buyer: 1. Tries extortion 2. The feedback removal request is denied by eBay even though the buyer violated eBay policy 3. The buyer leaves negative feedback and refuses to communicate in any way. Of all the things to latch onto, your issue here is with me trying to warn other sellers of this buyer? That's pretty remarkable.
I hope that if you ever receive negative feedback, you're afforded more understanding and grace by eBay than you extend to others.
The buyer username has been removed from the screenshot to comply with forum rules. However, their username can be viewed with literally one click on my feedback score.
vintagecraze50
I hear what you are saying with what happened with this transaction. Even of you made a mistake, you are not obligated to PARTIALLY REFUND ON HERE. YOU OFFERED THIS CUSTOMER A full REFUND for an item that was OBVIOUSLY not what they wanted. If you made a mistake listing it OK, but you tried to resolve it well.
thekulamoa
OPTo be honest, I kind of think they DID want it, but were fishing to see if they could get a discount from me. If they didn't want it, they could just open up a return, and since there was an error in the title, I'd reimburse them for the return shipping as well. So, either they do want it but are pretending to be outraged, or they're just new to eBay/unaware of how to use returns. Who knows. At this point, I don't really care, as it seems that they have no intention of communicating or returning anything.
vintagecraze50
Good job. But the feedback probably is not going to be removed based on the fact that they allegedly got an item not as described. So that is why Ebay probably will not remove it. But you never had to do the partial for sure.
kensgiftshop
Or, they'll just go to their funding source and do a charge back.
fashunu4eeuh
@thekulamoa wrote:
â€The buyer username has been removed from the screenshot to comply with forum rules. However, their username can be viewed with literally one click on my feedback score.â€
How? All buyer User Names can only be seen by the actual seller. Everyone else sees a scrambled ID.
vintagecraze50
AH kinda not right—buyers CANNOT demand a partial refund on here. It is a policy on ebay. Can you even FATHOM the money sellers would loose if THEY DID NOT MAKE THIS A POLICY ON HERE.
klhmdg
Try FB eBay for Business.
You can leave a private message on messenger.
They are sometimes more helpful.
I do agree that the FB should be removed (but who am I)
I hope eBay will eventually let us know exactly what qualifies for removal.
You cannot leave a negative FB at all for a buyer.
thekulamoa
OPI'm quite aware. I've been on eBay since it was possible to leave negative feedback.
As for the eBay facebook suggestion, it would have definitely been best to go that route before trying to get the feedback removed, because I did actually chat with eBay, and they informed me that the feedback removal request can't be appealed unless the buyer opens a return (which I doubt they'll ever do).
albertabrightalberta
If you're aware, why did you do it?
downunder-61
No, you have been here since 2010 - negative FB has not been allowed since 2008
thekulamoa
OPYou realize people can have multiple accounts, right?
kensgiftshop
So you know it's a policy violation to leave negative comments in buyers feedback, but you did t anyway.
albertabrightalberta
You also need to read the rules regarding leaving feedback for buyers. Buyers can only be given POSITIVE feedback with a POSITIVE comment.
albertabrightalberta
So you are purposely showing the buyer's name to shame them? You might want to review the community rules, specifically with regard to naming and shaming.
thekulamoa
OPNope, I'm suggesting they be added to a buyer block list, which are publicly viewable. Check out this buyer's 'left for others' feedback, and you'll understand why as a seller, it's best to block them.
doc-holmes
Blocked buyers lists are not publicly viewable.
thekulamoa
OPThere are several publicly available buyer blacklists, including this one: https://badbuyerlist.org/
I'm careful not to share the buyer's actual name, address, or any other info, but the username can be easily viewed simply by going to my publicly viewable feedback.
bonjourami
"I'm careful not to share the buyer's actual name, address, or any other info, but the username can be easily viewed simply by going to my publicly viewable feedback."
You dont seem to be aware that only you, the seller, can see the buyers id in your feedback. For the rest of us, the id is encrypted, and we cant read it.
thekulamoa
OPIf you read the whole thread, you'll see that I realized and acknowledged that (it totally slipped my mind). I personally feel that other sellers should be warned of this buyer and should have the choice to block them, but I'll respect eBay's forum rules and not post their username.
adamcartwright
Your feedback does not show the buyer's ID. That is not public info.
All it shows is:
kensgiftshop
Maybe the other sellers didn't describe their item right either?
broto_64
That may be against policy, as well my reply to the feedback would have been:
I am so sorry, I did offer a full refund upon return of the item when we first communicated, this offer stands: You have 30 days from receipt of the item, please if you wish to return it I will issue a full refund. Thank you so much for your business, have a pleasant day.
Then if their feedback left looks like you says it did, I would block them.
Because that buyer isn't coming back to read the feedback reply, but future buyers see it and they had nothing to do with that transaction but it is our opportunity to show them how we handle problems, and unfortunately a negative connotation or a fighting stance does not show well.
Last but not least I saw no extortion happening. The buyer merely said they would contact ebay about the problem, they did not for example threaten to leave negative feedback unless they're given a refund (which that is feedback extortion and against policy.)
dhbookds
You claimed it was a CB radio.....it apparently was not?
thekulamoa
OPPlease read my entire post instead of skimming over it.
tobadger
Like a lot of sellers, they're often clueless about what they put up for sale. Some are now going to AI to write their copy. I'd give you a negative too. Granted, buyers should also do their research and avoid a lot of problems. But then, eBay isn't what it used to be.