Buyer requested cancellation after shipping was purchased
As title states I purchased a label and boxed up the item when I get a message from the burr requesting a cancellation. It looks like I would be out the shipping fee, right? If that's the case I would rather decline. If he doesn't want it he can sell it again on eBay.
hobomojo
41 comments
kh-urvashi
Hi everyone,
Due to the age of this thread, it has been closed to further replies. Please feel free to start a new thread if you wish to continue to discuss this topic.
Thank you for understanding.
krazzykats
My eBay Shipping labels
derekc1
If you purchased your label through EBay, you can cancel it and get your money back.
baydealz
Good luck with that, you're taking risk. It's tough to accept a non-compliant buyer request, but the risk is all yours. You can not accept and hope he just receives and accepts or resales, but each of those steps have probabilities, all against us sellers. Ebay is a BUYER'S MARKET and most likely, he'll end up with your item and for FREE (after burning you). So you get no money and you're out the item. Don't risk it, you can most likely cancel the shipping. ONCE in a long while, if you simply contact them and say you can't (before shipping) they'll agree, but you're opening up to chargebacks (the new ebay way, and buyers know it), or dispute or 'not as described' claim.' You've already lost the transaction as soon as they flake. Mitigate the damages by stopping the bleeding by not sending, getting commission back and canceling the label.
dhbookds
@hobomojo
There's no way for us to tell if ebay punishes/sanctions buyers who cancel sales........buyers don't advertise sanctions. In the past we have seen a few buyer complaints about not being allowed to bid on auctions and having to make immediate payments "just because I didn't pay for a couple of things".......but those are very few.
But I see a bigger problem......in that, even after explanations of procedures/reactions, you are still "fighting" buyers being able to cancel sales....it's a fact of life that buyers change their minds.....in Brick and Mortar stores and on line sales. What you think is right or not right, frankly doesn't matter.....and if you can't accept that, selling may not be for you. The retail industry, as a whole, accepts cancellations and returns in most instances......best to "build in" the costs into your prices and simply handle them in a way that will benefit YOU....with graciousness toward the buyer.......so as not to damage your feedback or incur a " closed without seller resolution" defect.
One of the hardest things for new/and some old sellers to realize is that you are working within a system.....and what YOU think isn't necessarily true of the system or other individuals. Even if you establish your own website with your own rules of no cancellations/returns, if you use payment processors or accept credit cards, they have their own rules which will trump your rules. Buyers can request refunds on cc and paypal for up to 180 days after delivery........ So it's not only ebay/whoever.......it's the system as a whole.
For your own peace of mind.......you need to accept that.....or quit trying to sell.....
just my opinion
golfingaddict
Just as an FYI, even if you void the label, eBay will still consider it a mark against your record/dashboard
Tracking uploaded on time and validated
Ask me how I know? I could not get them to remove it despite the fact that I did everything right to help the buyer. The system recognizes that you printed the label and they don't care if it was voided or the buyer cancelled, they show it as not validated. It takes a bit of time to roll off.
krazzykats
I have to have my package at the post office by 3pm, to get on the outgoing truck by 10am the next morning. If I get an order after 3pm, it will not leave town until the day after, so no rush...our outgoing truck used to leave town the same day if mailed by 3.
New logistics that slow down the mail. 😑
baydealz
It's to your benefit. I used to box up and ship ASAP, even going to shipping location to drop off, in the ill-advised idea of 'customer service.' The odds of cancellation within 24hours is extremely high. The odds of a real customer noticing 24 hour 'faster service' are nill. eBay is broken, adjust appropriately.
krazzykats
I ship next day (Except holidays, weekends.). It seems to eliminate most of these "early" cancellations.
If a buyer is going to cancel, they usually do it within that time frame.
hobomojo
OPMy processing time is set to one day because i can't set it any lower. I usually ship within hours including holidays and weekends if I'm able and the post office is still open. The first buyer cancelled on me over night. The second one cancelled 30 minutes after they paid and I was already on my way to the post office.
mam98031
Once you are on the way to the PO or have already been to the PO and dropped off the package, clearly at that point you have to tell the buyer that the item has been shipped and you can't cancel the order. But be VERY professional and polite in the hopes of not upsetting the buyer.
I would recommend however to never ship within the first hour or a bit more after a purchase. You can slow your roll a bit. I know you are just trying to do a great job. But slow down a bit, you don't have to go that fast.
You simply don't need to be that fast at shipping. Shipping once a day is plenty. If you have something packaged to ship but the carrier hasn't picked it up yet or you haven't ran it to the PO, then pull it, cancel the shipping label and cancel the order for the buyer.
hobomojo
OPThat is not the impression I got from the replies here. It sounded like until I hand the package to a post office employee I am obligated to cancel the order or risk the buyer forcing my hand and returning it as NAD. I was actively debating what to do in the car but ended up turning around because I didn't want the grief of the buyer pitching a fit and getting ebay involved to force a return because i shipped the item before they could change their mind.
I ship the way I would expect others to operate in my shoes. I want the buyer to get their item as quickly as possible just like as the buyer I want what I bought as quickly as possible. It seems silly to purposefully wait a day or multiple days to ship a package on the off chance the buyer changes their mind. I ship in the afternoon and try to get things in before final pickup at the post office for the day which is around 4PM and the buyer purchased at 2pm today. But then again up until yesterday I was living in a world of ignorance where if you bought and paid for an ebay item that was it there were no cancellations and if the seller didn't accept returns you were **bleep** out of luck.
mam98031
@hobomojo
That is not the impression I got from the replies here. It sounded like until I hand the package to a post office employee I am obligated to cancel the order or risk the buyer forcing my hand and returning it as NAD.
A seller has the option to decline the cancellation request and you can if you want to. However you do run the risk of the buyer receiving the item and then filing for a return. That is a real risk. It usually isn't in the best interest of the Seller to decline a cancellation request if they can. Now if it is actually shipped, then of course the seller can't or shouldn't cancel the transaction.
I was actively debating what to do in the car but ended up turning around because I didn't want the grief of the buyer pitching a fit and getting ebay involved to force a return because i shipped the item before they could change their mind.
That was probably the best thing to do. FYI, Ebay would not get involved nor would the "force" anything unless you were non responsive to a Request for Return that the buyer filed.
I ship the way I would expect others to operate in my shoes.
Your expectations are too high and you'd likely be disappointed with most of us. I would not make multiple trips to the PO in a day. Now I often ship the same day I get the order if the order arrives before or during the time I'm packaging stuff for shipment each day. Then I will ship same day. However if it comes in after I've done my shipping for the day, it will ship the next day.
I want the buyer to get their item as quickly as possible just like as the buyer I want what I bought as quickly as possible. It seems silly to purposefully wait a day or multiple days to ship a package on the off chance the buyer changes their mind.
It appears you are assuming that sellers that have a couple days handling time are "purposefully" delaying shipping to their customer. That is not usually the case. I've not ever chatted with a seller that holds up shipping just because they can. There can be a multitude of legit reasons why someone needs a couple days to ship something, maybe a little bit more.
Now I did suggest to you not to ship so fast, I didn't mean to hang onto it for days. I thought I was clear before, but I must not have been. It would have hurt nothing for you to wait and ship the next day. You have a one day handling time. But as I said above I often ship same day if the order arrives in time to fit with my packaging and shipping schedule. I just try not to ship things within the same hour they arrive.
I ship in the afternoon and try to get things in before final pickup at the post office for the day which is around 4PM and the buyer purchased at 2pm today. But then again up until yesterday I was living in a world of ignorance where if you bought and paid for an ebay item that was it there were no cancellations and if the seller didn't accept returns you were **bleep** out of luck.
I don't know if you assumed that or if someone gave you bad information. Neither is true. If you assumed it, that is one of the worse things you can do around here as a newer seller. Assumptions can get you in big trouble. Always come here if you don't know something for sure, we will help.
Luckily this was a lesson learned that only cost you some of your time and a label. It could have been much worse.
mam98031
@hobomojo
The return policies options are as follows.
With option number 1, No Returns the seller can completely deny taking a return for a Buyer's Remorse Return Request. Or if they want to, they can accept the return and have the buyer pay the return shipping. If the seller so chooses, they can withhold the original shipping if it was separately stated on the listing [not free shipping] when it is time to refund the buyer.
On options 2 & 3 the buyer is responsible for the return shipping on a Buyer's Remorse Return. Plus, if the seller so chooses, they can withhold the original shipping if it was separately stated on the listing [not free shipping] when it is time to refund the buyer. As of October 1st 2019, sellers that are TRS have some additional protections as well as they can issue partial refunds if they use options 4 or 5 as their return policy.
On options 4 & 5 above, they are also known as Free Returns. If a seller that has either of those policies, they will pay the return shipping even on a buyer's remorse return. A seller can withhold the original shipping value from the refund if the shipping was separately stated in the listing [not free shipping]. Also, Seller’s offering options 4 or 5 have the ability to do partial refunds in certain cases if the item arrives back damaged, missing something or in a condition less than what it was sent to the buyer in, see the policy for more details, the link is below. In the cases where a deduction in the refund is taken due to damage or other authorized reasons for a partial refund, Ebay will protect the seller from negative or neutral feedback.
ALL OPTIONS [1, 2, 3, 4 and 5] are required to process SNAD claims without exception. Even if they are improperly filed and should have been a Buyer’s Remorse claim.
All return policies by sellers must meet or exceed what is stated in the Money Back Guarantee Policy!
14 day return policies are allowed in certain categories: Jewelry & Watches, Collectibles & Art, Cameras & Photo and Medical, Mobility & Disability Equipment.
For those with Free Return and/or TRS members with 30 day return policies, there are some added protection benefits, one of which is the ability to do a discounted refund under certain conditions.
baydealz
stop it...
mam98031
You have received great advice so far. You don't have to be out the shipping costs, just cancel the shipping label. If you don't know how to do that, just ask.
It is best to agree to the cancellation whenever you can so you don't have to deal with a return later which is more money and time.
mtgraves7984
If it was me, I'd accept the cancellation. Since it's recent, you can use the drop-down menu to the left of the label to 'Void' it. Seller Hub/Orders/Shipping labels
I'd add the user to my BBL, too.
a_c_green
No, if you have not actually mailed the package (i.e. it has not been scanned for Acceptance), you can void the label instead. It takes a couple of weeks or so for USPS to verify that the label was not used, but you will eventually be refunded for it.
No, it will never end well if you ship the item after the buyer has requested to cancel instead. You cannot force a buyer to pay and accept the item. He will be free to return it at your expense. If he's already asked to cancel, just void the label and refund the buyer. (Also add him to your Blocked Buyer List to avoid future headaches.)
sapphire_studio
You can void the shipping label in the shipping label section in the order section of your selling hub. You will get a refund on your label in a few weeks if you don't use it.
If the mailman hasn't actually taken the item you definitely want to always cancel if they ask. There's nothing stopping them from saying your item isn't as described and forcing a return which would take the cost of the return shipping label out of your funds.
hobomojo
OPI appreciate the advice about being able to void the label, that was my primary concern I'm not about to eat a $10 loss because the buyer failed to do any prepurchase research to ensure that what they were buying was compatible with their system.
I find it rather wild that there are apparently multiple ways a buyer can force me to accept a return over the fact that they were negligent and didn't verify what they were buying would work in their system. Many companies (newegg, Amazon, etc) do not allow for order cancellation after an item is prepared for shipment.
mam98031
Speaking only to Amazon, that is not exactly true. For all their 3rd party sellers they do allow buyers to request a cancellation. Just as here on Ebay, buyers can only Request a cancellation, it is still up to the seller to accept or reject the request.
hobomojo
OPEven buying items sold and fulfilled by amazon.com there is a point in the order process where you can "request a cancellation" but if it has reached a certain point in their shipping process they will not cancel it. I know because I've had amazon reject my attempts to cancel purchases before. You have to receive the product and then send it back.
Just like failure to pay there should be derogatory marks on buyers accounts for abuse of the request cancellation system. With all the advice provided here I feel immense pressure to accept buyer cancellation requests even though it is actively wasting my time and money to do so.
I have now been d*cked around by a second buyer in less than 24 hours who purchased my listing, paid for it, I bought and printed the label, and as I'm on my way to the post office he wants to cancel because he used the wrong payment method.
This is ridiculous, at what point am I allowed to take a stand and say to bad, your lack of attention and due diligence in your purchase is not my problem. I've now wasted hours of my time, gas, wear and tear on my vehicle, and I have two shipping labels that i have to wait weeks for a refund for all because buyers can't be bothered to pay attention to what they're buying. I've been an ebay member across several accounts for over 20 years and I have NEVER had a buyer request a cancellation before. I wasn't even aware this was a thing you could do. Between the ridiculous cancellation requests and the constant messages from users trying to low ball me on my listing when I don't even have offers enabled honestly makes me want to quit selling here.
kensgiftshop
You don't have to cancel, you can ship the order.
Buyer can receive it, take a hammer to it and file an INAD and return it for a full refund.
You would be out the item, money and return shipping.
albertabrightalberta
So you've tried to cancel on amazon, got rejected and ultimately had to return an item you didn't want yet you are upset that your own buyers did the same thing?
Have you never bought items at Macy's, Home Depot, Auto Zone, TJ Maxx, etc. and decided that you wanted to return it? Are you an indecisive buyer who didn't do your research before buying?
What are you going to do if you force the buyers to take delivery? Will you come back here next week to complain that the buyer (whose order you didn't cancel) opened a "not as described" claim on that same item because they didn't want it in the first place?
If you cancel, you lose nothing more than your time in having to resell the item.
inhawaii
If you haven't shipped it yet, it's not a RETURN.
hobomojo
OPThat line was in response to the multiple replies I got suggesting that if I opted to not accept the cancellation and ship anyway the buyer could essentially force me to accept a return by claiming the item was not as described or whatever excuse they can come up with.
inhawaii
You are correct.
Which is why it wouldn't make sense NOT to honor a buyers request to cancel.
hobomojo
OPOK but at what point does this become the buyer abusing the cancellation system? If I can just impulse buy whatever the heck I want and then just request to cancel it later at the sellers expense (whether that expense be time, money, whatever) where is the protection for the seller? at what point am i allowed to say enough is enough?
Another user replied above stating that even if I void the label I'm getting marks on my account for my shipping information not being validated so entertaining these cancellation requests is actively hurting my seller reputation in addition to wasting my time.
This kind of stuff should cut both ways. Buyers should be flagged for frequent use of the request a cancellation option and be restricted from buying or be forced to go through additional confirmations so that they aren't wasting seller's time with impulse purchases that they later regret.
adamcartwright
It's easy to void a shipping label before the item is shipped, and it's the wise thing to do when you already know the buyer doesn't want the item. Think of it this way -- the item is already packed up and ready to go for when it does sell to a legit buyer.
But I agree with you that frequent cancellations should be a criterion to block buyers, just like we can block based on unpaid item strikes.
sapphire_studio
5 days ago I voided a label for somebody that requested to cancel. It doesn't hurt my metrics at all because the sale is canceled.
 
 
I will also add that I already had it sitting outside ready to be picked up in a large mailer I had cut up to perfectly fit the item and keep it under 1 lb. I was just glad my mailman hadn't got it yet because I didn't want to deal with a return. It's sitting on my inventory shelf in that envelope and will be really easy to ship next time it sells. This is the feedback I got from her:
 
Just cancel and void the label 🙂
mam98031
OK but at what point does this become the buyer abusing the cancellation system?
Ebay has a formal way a buyer can request a cancellation within the first hour after they purchase something. After that hour, the buyer can just send the seller an email and request a cancellation. While I know you hate losing the sale, we all do when this happens, you should think of it as avoiding a bigger issue and costing you more money. It is better to honor their request if at all possible.
If I can just impulse buy whatever the heck I want and then just request to cancel it later at the sellers expense (whether that expense be time, money, whatever) where is the protection for the seller? at what point am i allowed to say enough is enough?
Cancellations are the normal thing on a transaction. Transactions usually go off without a hitch. If most of them didn't, there would be no reason for sellers to sell here. However cancellations are allowed on other sites too. Don't over think it. This isn't something you will need to deal with on a regular basis.
Another user replied above stating that even if I void the label I'm getting marks on my account for my shipping information not being validated so entertaining these cancellation requests is actively hurting my seller reputation in addition to wasting my time.
I missed reading that, but it is NOT TRUE. Well let me qualify that a little. If there were some bug in the system then maybe that could happen, but it would be rare. Normally cancelling a transaction or a shipping label does not negatively affect your selling stats. Heck I can't tell you how many times over the years I've had to cancel a shipping label for one reason or another, having nothing to do with a cancellation and they didn't create any negative impact on my account either.
gmzn4_16
Here is my situation.
Buyer requested to cancellation the order because of shipping mistake.
I accepted his request.
When refund to the buyer was processed I was charged shipping fee in order to reach the full amount.
Unavailable member
Old thread from 06-17-2024.
When you refund for buyer cancellation you don’t get to keep the shipping cost the buyer paid they get a FULL refund.