Buyer accused me of selling fake product — feedback removal advice?
Summary: blueapples_22 shared their experience with a buyer who accused them of selling counterfeit merchandise. Despite providing a refund and having the item authenticated, the buyer left harsh negative feedback. blueapples_22 requested feedback removal but is concerned about the appeal outcome. Participants, including dhbookds and pickapaper, praised the professional response blueapples_22 gave to the feedback. 44012 shared a similar experience and advised responding to the feedback professionally. Overall, the consensus was that blueapples_22's professional handling should not deter future buyers.
Looking for some advice from other sellers.
I had a buyer question the authenticity of an item through harassing emails. I know the item is authentic and had it confirmed through ebay and tried to explain that, but rather than argue, I accepted the return and gave the buyer a full refund.
I thought that would be the end of it, but the buyer then left negative feedback accusing me of knowingly selling fake merchandise, told other buyers to “beware,” and made some personal remarks about me as a seller. Mind you, before this we had 100% feedback and over 6000 positive feedbacks.
I requested removal because I feel there's a big difference between a buyer saying “I don't believe this was authentic” and accusing a seller of knowingly selling counterfeit merchandise. My first request was denied, but I called eBay and they submitted an appeal. They said I should hear back within 72 hours and felt confident it will be removed. I'm still worried.
Has anyone had luck getting feedback like this removed on appeal?
And if it's denied again, would you ask the buyer to revise/remove it, or just respond publicly and move on? The buyer was extremely rude and unhinged. If you look at our feedback, his stands out like a sore thumb.
Thanks for any advice!
duffy4444
Your reply to the negative FB was courteous and professional, yet to the point and without any animosity from you. I like the way you explained the comparison to the new and older LYMA formulations. It actually makes the belligerent buyer look uninformed and missing out on a good item.
Because of this, I don't think any prospective customers who look at the feedback, and your proper response, will be deterred from ordering from you. I sure wouldn't be deterred.
Cheers, Duffy
blueapples_22
OPThanks. This makes me feel better... 😊
44012
This same thing happened to me. No, I was not able to get it removed.
When you are done being upset (cuz I was) try to leave a very professional response to their feedback that will tell your story (brief, factual, to the point) and not scare future buyers away. EDIT: Well I see you did this already..... that is about all you can do. And block them also.
pickapaper
One thing I am uncertain about is whether you actually had him return the item or did you just give him the refund without a return. I realize that you would probably not be able to resell this but I would have had him return it anyway. I sure wouldn't give a buyer an expensive item for free especially when he is claiming fake but apparently doesn't know.
And I agree, your response to his FB is excellent.
blueapples_22
OPThanks, yeah I had him return it and we can resell it so thats good, but I just can't believe they would write such a harsh feedback, when none of it is true.
pickapaper
I'm glad you can resell it.
Anyone can see by your feedback that you are an experienced, calm, professional seller and this one numpty won't deter anyone from buying from you.
dhbookds
Very........very....good response to feedback.