Bogus Feedback
I got hit with Bogus feedback, That ebay would not remove, I got knocked down from 100% that I have had for years to 9.4, How many positive feedbacks will it take to get back to 100%?
meme6253
44 comments
I got hit with Bogus feedback, That ebay would not remove, I got knocked down from 100% that I have had for years to 9.4, How many positive feedbacks will it take to get back to 100%?
gamersbaystore
I would've never handled this situation the way you did. I would've apologized for them not being happy with their order, offered a full refund upon return and given them a return label.
The reality here is that your no returns policy just makes buyers apprehensive to begin with, and your response makes ebay 10X less likely to help.
I offer free returns, leaving the buyer no room to argue, and in my experience, ebay will often remove those negatives when you do what's necessary to make things right.
Your buyer makes it pretty clear they do not want the item. Your response was to give them a partial refund, that's not what they wanted. No, ebay is not going to help in such a situation.
If you do everything in your power to make things right, ebay will be 10X more likely to remove that negative feedback.
That has been my own experience anyway. In fact, ebay has removed every negative feedback I've ever received in my entire history of selling here.
ckimodog
@meme6253
C'mon...that feedback isn't going to hurt you at all. If anything it makes the buyer look a bit questionable. Shake if off, friend & look how many others are singing your praises. Hang in there.
Happy Selling!
bashort
this thread reminds me of something, who remembers toolhaus?
nobody*s_perfect
I miss toolhaus!
legalbeagle52
@bashort
I loved toolhaus!
I used it all the time, so helpful!
It really let you know who you were dealing with. I certainly miss it!
They kept threatening to take it down (financial reasons) and finally one day it was gone...
chapeau-noir
The feedback is so bass-ackwards, though, that unless one knows the situation it makes really little sense.
Working with the public, all you can do is your best and let a lot roll off your back.
maxine*j
If OP jumped right in to say he'd give a partial refund without giving the buyer a chance to further explain / ask / claim / discuss / negotiate / whatever, I suppose that could be called "unilateral" action on the seller's part.
Like you, though, I would just have ignored it, figuring future and potential buyers would do likewise as that neg sounds a tad irrational.
-
meme6253
OPVery Irrational
stainlessenginecovers
It used to be you needed 400 transactions...if you can do that in 90 days, it would 'reset', otherwise it's 1 year (whether you hit 400 or not).
Not sure if they still do it that way or not as average 150 items a month, 450 over 3 months during spring/summer- but many of my customers put their items in a 'cart' so 4 items count as 1 'transaction' which means I never hit that 400 mark in 90 days.
nobody*s_perfect
The 400 transactions in 3 months threshold applies to TRS status, not to feedback percentage.
stainlessenginecovers
@nobody*s_perfect I guess they changed it as it used to be for feedback as well because I contemplated selling some 'cheap' thing that I could get 400+ in 3 months, but that was 5,6,8 ?? years ago.
nobody*s_perfect
Feedback percentage has always been based on the previous 12 months, ever since they changed it from "all the feedback you've ever received" along with a big package of other changes in 2008 such as no negs for buyers and a 60-day limit on leaving feedback.
https://pages.ebay.com/sell/update08/rewards/index.html
https://www.ecommercebytes.com/C/abblog/blog.pl?/comments/2010/8/1201611437.html/16/300
bashort
2000 positive feedback with 1 neg is 99.95% which when you are only using 1 digit after the decimal point = 100%
nobody*s_perfect
We used to always have that calculation at our fingertips back in the days (pre-2008?) when eBay DID base your percentage on your lifetime feedback history. It was so discouraging!
broto_64
Early in the ebay days I felt like you, that a negative feedback was such a destruction of everything I had ever done right and I prided myself on how good I did things and how could a buyer be so callous and all that...
Then I learned a little something...
The reply to negative feedback is most often viewed by other potential and future buyers, and is thus my opportunity to shine in front of them. And because of that today I always use negative feedback as a way to show off my good customer service skills, with comments such as "Dear Buyer I am so very sorry you are not happy with your purchase, please contact us at once or open a return request so we can initiate a return of the bad merchandise and issue you a full refund, thank you kindly for your understanding and have a pleasant day."
Which sounds a whole lot better than...
"My buyer is a complete idiot that fits in the human category of people who can't be helped, which is very sad but yet they walk among us and here they are, destroying everything we have worked for our whole entire lives with their slanderous nonsense."
Because I learned is replies to feedback are rarely viewed by the buyer who left it. More often than not it's future buyers perusing the feedback who will read it, and I want them to read that I really tried to help the buyer and nothing more (granted it would likely also be a good idea if one actually did try to help the buyer).
On rare occasion that buyer will return to read their feedback after the reply is left, I have had it where such a buyer did actually open a return likely in response to my reply but it happened maybe once and it is truly rare. Many sellers who practice the same reply tactic have never had a buyer react in response to their reply but again I wish to reiterate it is very important to be positive in one's reply and to be the seller who did everything possible to help that buyer even after the negative feedback was left.
maxine*j
BINGO! How a seller handles one transaction that goes wrong tells me more about the seller than how he handles one thousand that go well.
-
retro_entertainment_collectibles
Wow that's the reply?
Oh my gosh.
For those buyers who actually read feedback that's just terrible. So like eBay has guidelines and rules for feedbacks. The buyer leaves one that seems suit their emotional being at the time and the OP leaves back a reply that breaks eBay's rules.
This is exactly why I don't gamble on Thoroughbred Horse Racing.
nobody*s_perfect
No that is not the actual reply, which you can easily see by clicking on the OP's feedback number: "Completely False & Unwarranted feedback, Customer never even allowed time for a resolution over their false complaint!, Please let my hard work & Positive feedback record speak for itself!"
broto_64
No, that was not their reply, I was setting my own examples to illustrate a point.
meme6253
OPI did not leave a reply like that.
retro_entertainment_collectibles
Isn't this a repeat thread?
Unavailable member
No….what gives you that idea?
retro_entertainment_collectibles
Because the last one was "I'm going to sue customers who leave me negative feedback."
maxine*j
The thread in which he states that he is suing the buyer for leaving the feedback:
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/Filing-Lawsuit-Against-Customer/td-p/34221900
-
meme6253
OPNo, The other is related to the same issue, But entirely different question
12345jamesstamps
Unless buyer does a revision in 30 days...you are stuck with it for a year. You would have to have hundreds of feedback to get it up higher...but will not be 100 % until end of a year.
The salt and pepper shakers are rather cute.
When a buyer has a problem and only has like 3 feedback...doing a partial refund might help in a future feedback scenario.
gb58
When sellers have a few thousand feedbacks, over years and years of selling, ebay should base the percentage on the total feedback received, rather than base it on a one year running total.
I don't see why ebay feels it's a good thing to impact a sellers feedback rating in this way after they have worked years and years to provide good service.
If a seller has cut back on their selling and are not listing/selling as much (not receiving as many feedbacks as they use to), but has accumulated hundreds of good feedbacks over the previous years, one negative can really impact their percentage, because it is based on 12 months, rather than their total selling record.
broto_64
I would agree and it's also getting harder with fewer buyers leaving feedback, however if that were the case then a seller wouldn't be back to 100% after just one short year either.
meme6253
OPI offered a partial refund
wastingtime101
It's not a matter of how many positives you get, it's a matter of how many negatives you have. You won't be back to 100% until you have no negs. In other words, when the FB ages off after one year, if you have no other negs at that time, you will be back at 100%.
Is this the same buyer you are suing?
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/Filing-Lawsuit-Against-Customer/td-p/34221900
meme6253
OPThat's Insane & completely unfair!
gb58
You can't get back to 100% with a negative on your record.
It will take 544 positives to get you back to 99.9%
brightlightbookseller
That's not true. After a year, it no longer counts toward the feedback percentage (although it will be available to see for those who spend the time looking). At that point, if they don't get any more negatives, they'll show 100% again next to their username.
gb58
That's what I meant, as long as the negative is there you can't get back to 100%. Once it rolls off in 12 months you are back to 100%.
I was assuming everyone knew feedbacks roll off from figuring into your percentage (both good, bad and neutrals roll off) after 12 months.
For someone who doesn't sell alot of items, as your good feedbacks roll off also, the negative can in fact drop your percentage even lower than it did at the point it was left.
For example, say you have 100 positives and 1 negative at the time the negative is left. That would be a percentage of 99%. So lets say in the next couple months 30 of your positives roll off, without picking up any new ones. Your running 12 month total would now be 70 positives and 1 negative or a percentage of 98.6%
So one negative can impact your selling even more negatively as the year goes on, depending on how active you are on the site.
meme6253
OPThat's even more bogus!
buyselljack2016
No, that's fact 🙂
How should it work?
Give sellers a mulligan or 2, or 3?
Perhaps, and it looks like, you had a numpty buyer that did not understand the whole process.
Sometimes we just have to move along.
meme6253
OPThat's Insane & completely Unfair!
chickadee8618
As you stated in your response to the negative feedback...
"Please let my hard work & Positive feedback record speak for itself!"
Perfectly said, if a buyer chooses to not purchase from you based on one negative over 1000 positives, I wouldnt want their business anyway. Dont let it bug you and put it behind you.
buyselljack2016
divide you positive feedback # by your total feedback # to determine that.
It will take many.
At your current feedback rate likely it will time off at 1 year faster than other positives would offset that 1 neg
Unavailable member
@meme6253
How did you try to remove it?
Did you go here?>>>Request to remove feedback
Mention in the comment box the buyer didn’t open a request to return.
I’ve had several negative and neutral feedback removed in this way, it usually takes minutes.
meme6253
OPDid all that
splendidthreads
Did he request a refund by opening a case? Where did the 3-day resolution period you mentioned come from if a case wasn't opened?
From the other thread, it sounds like the feedback was the opinion of the buyer and not bogus. You provided minimal information in the other thread and here, but reading between the lines and using the info provided, it appears that the following happened. My apologies if I've misinterpreted something.
The buyer bought a set of shakers that were described as “excellent†condition with a note to look at the pictures because you’re not an expert grader. From the pictures, it appears that they were in less than excellent condition. One could assume that when he got them he was not happy with the condition. He contacted you and/or opened a case(?). Most sellers would say return for a refund, and that would be the end of it.
You posted in the suing thread that you offered a partial refund. One could assume from what he wrote that he didn’t want the item or a partial refund. What happened after that? It's possible he saw your offer of the partial refund as your final response, and that's when he left the feedback, because he wasn't happy. Did you refuse a full refund and then he left the negative feedback?
chapeau-noir
What a strange feedback - anyone reading it will probably just scratch their head.
It'll take a year to roll off. Don't distress yourself about the loss of the 100% FB rating, it isn't that important and your sales will do fine.
maxine*j
@chapeau-noir
He is suing the buyer for leaving that feedback:
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/Filing-Lawsuit-Against-Customer/td-p/34221900