Blocked Buyer
In March I had a buyer buy some items from me. They received them with no issues. Beginning of April they buy some more items from me. I get a message from the buyer after they received the items saying that they were very upset and disappointed because 2 of the items were not what they were expecting. I sell DVDs CD, Books and 2 of the DVDs they ordered were "DISC & CASE ONLY". This is very clearly marked on the listings and it is mentioned a few times in the listing that there is no artwork. I even list these items in Acceptable condition. They were upset because they didn't know they were disc only. I decided to just refund the buyer without trying to argue with them. And after seeing the tone of their message and checking the feedback they left for others I decided to block them from buying from us again. BIG MISTAKE!
A few weeks later I guess they had tried to buy from us again because they left feedback on the first order they placed in March , (not sure why they picked that order). They had bought 10 items so they left negatives on all of them. They said I was a toxic seller, buy from someone else and said I banned them because they contacted me etc..
I contacted Ebay to see if they would remove the feedback. They only removed 4 saying the other 6 didn't violate the guidelines. All the Feedbacks said a variation of the same thing. I have contacted Ebay customer service 2 times about this but they said they can't do anything and repeated that the feedback doesn't violate guidelines.
I am pretty sure this affected our sales because they have basically ground to a halt.. I have contacted the buyer and asked if they can revise the feedback but I have got no response.
I just think it sucks that the one thing Ebay sellers can do to protect ourselves, blocking people, can backfire on us.
kh-gary
Hi everyone,
This thread has been closed at the request of the OP.
Thank you for understanding.
onefootflipper2
Those negatives have already scrolled off your first feedback page, I doubt they have anything to do with what you are experiencing now.
Without even deep diving your store some things are pretty obvious. You are a media specialist and your items have a 3 year sell through rate and are mostly being sold on razor thin margins.
Physical media and books is a category in long term decline and every week more and more titles drop to that price point where the charity sellers have them cheaper shipped than a normal seller can even send them out for. I have no idea what percentage of your existing inventory is now unsellable because of this, but I would wager it is much higher than you might think. Your newest listing is "Live from the Womb" used at $8.74, your competition is at $5.50 shipped for new sealed and not a single copy of this has sold in 3 months. The next new listing I see down the list is "David Spade take the hit", you are at 5.98, competition is at $4.08 and this DVD only sells once every couple months and there are 66 available.
Might be time to rethink the specialty. I don't understand the intricacies of trying to get people to do the buy 2 get 3 free special you have, but the few I examined that just had straight prices were unsellable.
Everyone is down in sales right now across all platforms and I think movies and books would be hit hardest at a time when the weather is nice and people are trying not to spend money.
super_sunny_sales
OPWe do price our items up slightly to encourage people to take advantage of our deal. We get our items cheap so we make more money when people take advantage of the deal because we save a lot on shipping.
Our sales do slow down a lot for summer but never this drastically and this suddenly. It does seem to have started shortly after we received the negatives. Yes, you can't see them on the main page but they still show in the feedback box..
fashunu4eeuh
If you show a stock photo that includes the artwork, then the buyer can be confused as to what they will receive. If you are using stock photos for pre-owned items, then you are in violation of the Picture policy. Used must only show the actual item.
I am not saying what this buyer did was right, only that they may have been justified in their disappointment to not receive what the photos depicted. Some buyers do not read the description, especially if they are buying on their smartphones. In addition, all information across the listing fields must match exactly. Any discrepancies can cause a Not As Described claim.
32 feedback revisions is a lot, even for the volume you are selling.
super_sunny_sales
OPyou are allowed to use stock photos with media items..
"Stock photos cannot be used for pre-owned items. Catalog images are acceptable, but not as the primary photo for pre-owned items except those in the Books, Movies, Music, or Video Game categories."
https://www.ebay.com/sellercenter/listings/photo-tips
32 feedback revisions from when we started selling in 2015.. That is an average of 4 a year... Feedback is meant to be left based on how a seller handled a situation. A lot of buyers will leave negative or neutral feedback before even contacting the seller.
doc-holmes
Can you clarify? You said the description said "disc and case only" but the buyer was upset they got the disc only. Did you not send a case?
super_sunny_sales
OPyes, I sent a case. They even included pictures in their message of the case... I am not sure what they were expecting..
This was their message.. "Very disappointed to get this movie without the advertised case. I specifically only purchase movies with their cases. It's cheaper to buy disc only. I want a refund for this and the other movie you sent without matching case."
What is funny is that I checked the prices of the two Disc only movies they got and what they paid for mine were way cheaper..
super_sunny_sales
OPthey had purchased multiple DVDs in the same purchase and those two were the only ones that said "DISC & CASE ONLY"
certifiedcitynet
Live and learn. We NEVER block a buyer until at least 60 days have elapsed from the date of his last purchase UNLESS he has perpetrated fraud. After 60 days, he cannot leave feedback.
But we try to screen potential buyers BEFORE they order. Many backbreaking buyers almost always message us prior to placing an order. This works to our advantage because we can check their feedback left for others. If they have left negs for multiple reputable sellers, we block them. Or if they make a $500 offer for a $2,000 coin that is worth $1,600 wholesale, we block them. Or if they seem unreasonable in another way, we block them.
But some backbreakers will just order without contacting you first. You will then need to endure their abuse until you can block them without fear of receiving a retaliatory neg as explained above.
But even if you block someone, he can still order through another account. You may want to message anyone whom you have just blocked with a warning that you will not accept any future orders from him from any of his accounts. If he sneaks in an order anyway, cancel it and have Ebay remove any retaliatory negs that the may leave.
super_sunny_sales
OPWe rarely have people message us before they order. I guess because we sell media items..
super_sunny_sales
OPThis was the second time this person had bought from us. After the message they sent I checked the feedback they left for others and knew they might be an issue. I wanted to block them from buying from us again. I assume that they left the negatives after they tried buying from us again and found out they couldn't. So I think it was a good call on my part to block them..
I have never really had an issue with blocking people before. I just think it is really unfair that we can get negative feedback for blocking buyers..
monster-deals
Those can all be removed but not with overseas call center help.
Tittwer or FB ebay for business
super_sunny_sales
OPI did contact FB Ebay and they told me the same thing has ebay customer support
super_sunny_sales
OPSo I just tried contacting Ebay twitter and got the same spiel. 🙄 They keep saying it doesn't violate guidelines and can't tell me why the other 4 were removed..
I guess I will just have to live with the feedback. It just bugs me because I bend over backwards for my customers..
12345jamesstamps
You might have used up your feedbacks revisions. You have 32 revised feedbacks.
You are allowed 5 feedback revisions per 1000 in a 12 month period....these include neutral as well as negative. So, I wouldn't question any neutrals in the future.
I am only allowed 5 revisions at the moment and haven't used any of them yet.
"Toxic" is a word that buyers shouldn't use and I don't think they can in feedback...you used up your feedbacks revisions unfortunately...which you can revise yourself. I also think customer service...those that may not understand that word trying to help you on the phone don't understand that word. Might want to call again explaining the definition to them.
And you can refund this buyer and ask for feedback revisions on his end. I know it might be a lot of money but it's up to you.
super_sunny_sales
OPI have around 9 revision requests left. Also those revisions are only used if you ask the buyer for a revision, not if Ebay removes the feedback.
I have chatted with customer service a few times and they have said the reason they won't remove them is because they don't violate the guidelines. Although 4 of the apparently somehow did.
I did refund the buyer for the 2 items he wasn't happy with and that was a few weeks before he left the negative feedback..
lightlily_arts
I'm only speaking for myself. When I read a seller's feedback and see that there are multiple negative complaints from one buyer I tend to ignore them simply because I know that buyers will retaliate. Especially when the rest of the seller's feedback is positive. The likelihood that all of their purchases were problematic is highly doubtful. Moreover, the fact they stated they were banned is a good indication the seller had a bad buyer. Nonetheless, I would still try to get their feedback removed since they didn't return all those items and it's clear the feedback was abusive.
inhawaii
General reply.
Some people/sellers say/think that once you reply to a negative feedback it can't be removed.
This is not true.
It can.
super_sunny_sales
OPThe customer service people made it sound like the decision was final and that nothing can be done...
I am essentially being punished for blocking a buyer. I brought that up with customer service and they didn't respond to that...
reallynicestamps
The phone reps have a terrible reputation for getting you off the phone as soon as possible even if that mean giving you the advice you want to hear instead of the advice you need to have.

https://www.facebook.com/eBayForBusiness/ — Message button in upper right on landing page.

https://twitter.com/askebay?lang=en

https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/How-do-I-contact-Customer-Support/m-p/32016431#M1783851 -> Automated Assistant, type AGENT -> enter. You will then get more options.


The social media Chat accounts are covered by trained eBay employees with some authority.
And you get a transcript so you can compare what you heard with what you were told.
super_sunny_sales
OPthanks. I have tried Facebook and Twitter Ebay and they both said the same thing. The feedback doesn't violate the guidelines. I explain that the 4 that were deleted said the same things and they say they can't speak for the rep who did that , they just know the feedback that is there doesn't violate guidelines..
I just noticed that Ebay for Business is a separate Facebook group.
super_sunny_sales
OPI have also tried Ebay customer support..
dqdistribution
I can confirm this.
I have given apologies on multiple negative feedbacks that were ended up removed.
asset_liquidators
Yeah that is what I remember hearing some time ago but I had no first hand experience with it. It is good to know that leaving a reply does not render it ineligible for removal.
slippinjimmy
I agree but it depends on your response, many times a seller responds with a comment that is essential shooting yourself in the foot, it can make you look worse than the buyer and lowers the chance eBay will remove. On the other hand a calm quality reply to a neg can actually increase your chances that eBay will remove.
dqdistribution
Did you go to all the listings and 'Report Buyer'. I'd say it's a misrepresentation. Not sure if that does anything. Sometimes different things like this go to different departments outside of customer service where someone could see the abuse.
super_sunny_sales
OPyeah, I did report buyer and explained why feedback should be removed.
Also the first customer service person I talked to said they would open a report about the buyer but still insisted that the feedback couldn't be removed, claiming that it was the "buyers experience"... (No, the buyer was just mad they got blocked and decided to retaliate...)
soh.maryl
What would they report the buyer for?
dqdistribution
Technically they went and gave feedback on transactions that had no negativity at all. Message transcripts can prove that, and the buyer did not attempt to return the product.
So I could see the reason : Buyer made a false claim
Since the feedback doesn't represent the transaction accurately. Now I'm not saying this will have any impact, I was just giving an option suggestion that might help remove the feedback.
super_sunny_sales
OPyeah I did report the buyer on the items they had an issue with from the other order.
inhawaii
Sorry this happened to you.
The only advice I can give is KEEP TRYING.
Sometimes you get different results with a different customer service person.
Have you tried asking ebay for feedback removal online? Sometimes that works. It's worth a try.
Good luck to you.
super_sunny_sales
OPyes that is what I initially did. I used the Ebay feedback removal . They only removed 4 of the 10...
super_sunny_sales
OPI understand that feedback can't be removed if it doesn't violate guidelines but why did 4 violate them and not the other 6 when they all said the same thing. Customer service couldn't seem to answer that question..
asset_liquidators
One I think wasn't removed because it is a neg but has no comment. The other five it may be because you had already responded to the negs? (I am taking a guess at that because I thought I had heard some time ago that if the leave a reply they don't remove them).
Either way, the feedback is not affecting your sales (it is coincidental). You have good feedback and the replies you did left were professional and to the point. Your buyer on the other hand comes off looking childish with a sense of entitlement.
super_sunny_sales
OPNo, Ebay removed the words on that one but left the negative feedback. Also I left replies after Ebay didn't remove the feedback and after I contacted Ebay customer service the first time.
asset_liquidators
Well that stinks that they removed the comment but not the neg. If the wording was eligible for removal then the neg rating should have been also. Sorry you are having to deal with this.
super_sunny_sales
OPyeah that part does not make sense..
Also they removed 4 feedbacks completely but they all said the same thing.. no one can tell me why those were removed and not the others...