Barely Vintage Items Being Listed As Antiques...Why Is It Allowed?
I am so tired of seeing listings from sellers who claim their item is antique, and/or from some specific pre-20th-century period, when the item is circa 1950s or even later. It's easy to research these things, and I feel these sellers are deliberately fraudulent in their listings in order to take advantage of people who don't know how to do the research. Ebay should have a way to report these listings, but their report system has no choice in the drop down menu that would cover misrepresentation. Do they just not care about this?!
It seems I'm seeing more and more of this misrepresentation of vintage- and antique items coming from higher-volume sellers who ought to know better. I research my items thoroughly, and if I can't find the info myself, I will turn to a reputable appraiser to help me out. I simply won't list it until I can be sure I'm not misrepresenting it. There is just no excuse for claiming something is over 100 years old when it's barely as old as me, and pricing it as if it's rare and nigh priceless. This kind of behavior hurts ALL sellers, because it makes buyers distrust even the honest sellers. If you want to ask a high price for something that isn't worth that much, fine. Do that. But don't list it as a rare antique when it isn't. That's just dirty.
kh-cathy
Hi everyone,
Due to the age of this thread, it has been closed to further replies. Please feel free to start a new thread if you wish to continue to discuss this topic.
Thank you for understanding.
bashort
ebay could not possibly make the determination if a item is listed as the correct vintage.
This is what returns, the money back guarantee and feedback are for.
nolanjamesantiques
I agree. I’ve actually been seeing counterfeit items listed as antique Sevres jewelry box, etc. I told one seller who is from a large auction house in NYC, assuming they had no idea. The woman got defensive. I thought she’d thank me. It was a $50 Andrea by Sadek porcelain box - listed as an circa 1800 - 1850 French Sevres box, listed for thousands of dollars. I’ll try to add a pic.
trainup027
If they did try to police all the listings, it would probably be enforced unequally, cause massive headaches, and perhaps in the end everyone would be banned from using either the word vintage or antique, serving no one and inconveniencing many. Scammers would find another way to scam. I agree it's a problem when people are unethical in their description. I'm sorry you've encountered so many of these listings and know people who were cheated. That's not cool. But the people who do it either don't know or don't care that they're lying.
chacfa_xuqazhrbwo
Seller has many Amazon products listed has vintage when they are not.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/304805959655?mkcid=16&mkevt=1&mkrid=711-127632-2357-0&ssspo=9sdub8KlShq&sssrc=2349624&ssuid=dmUPZLuNSs6&var=&widget_ver=artemis&media=COPY
https://www.amazon.com/Statement-Rhinestone-Hinged-Bangle-Bracelet/dp/B075F8LMNS?ref=d6k_applink_bb_dls_failed&dplnkId=3ac769fe-0d9c-473a-8237-ac6616ac9d4d&th=1&psc=1