Authentic NM MTG Card Rejected by eBay Authenticators
I wonder how many others have experienced this same issue. I had my first run-in with "eBay Authentication Guarantee" with a beautiful full art foil MTG card that I sold. The card was removed carefully from the fresh pack, which came from a collector booster box, near mint condition (actually mint but I always list as near mint to be on the safe side), and was placed in a penny sleeve and inside of a top loader. I listed the card and it sold, but when I went to purchase a shipping label I was directed to send the card to "authenticators" rather than the buyer. I thought it was strange but not concerning, and I securely packaged the card and sent it to the authenticator.
Just this afternoon, I received an email from eBay saying that my card failed authentication, with the message "Raw- Surface does not match the listing: Fail". I am stunned, and not only is there no way to reach the authenticator for a better explanation, I can't seem to reach eBay customer care either. Looking over the listing, I cant figure out how the near perfect card does not match what I said.
Does anyone have thoughts on how I can proceed? Is this the beginning of the end of people selling raw cards on eBay?
kh-vince
Hi everyone,
Due to the age of this thread, it has been closed to further replies. Please feel free to start a new thread if you wish to continue to discuss this topic.
Thank you for understanding.
thecollection5
I also just randomly received notification that two of my authentic cards failed the authenticator. I have no idea why other than "Please update your listing to accurately reflect the surface of the card." I have been selling for over a decade the same types of cards with no issue whatsoever. The cards are listed as used and I don't list damaged cards. I cannot get an explanation of the fail reason either. I need more details so I can prevent further fails. This authentication program is a horrible failure. I need to look elsewhere now to sell cards.
tinymusic
Identical situation just happened to me with an MTG card. Really jarring and frustrating. EBay makes us use an authentication service but then gives us no ability to follow up or as my questions? If that’s the case then they should be crystal clear in their explanation as to WHY the card failed. Like what part of the description did they question? Ugh.
When they returned your card was it in the same condition as when you sent it in?
anthonchave13
I just had this issue, i sent out a card i near mint and they rejected it. When i got it back it now has a scratch on the surface that was clearly not there before.
 
anthonchave13
 
 
silverstatetreasureboxes
@scigrl35
Boy, scratching my head here. OK the card collectors jargon for raw is ungraded. You had your card listed as used when you state it's fresh out of packet.
I wonder if that has something to do with the authentication failing to match listing. I didn't see where you had listed near mint anywhere on that listing.
mtgraves7984
@silverstatetreasureboxes... I was right there with you when I read the listing. Then, I read the OP's statement from eBay... ""Raw- Surface does not match the listing: Fail". "... and I don't get it.
@scigrl35
The Authentication Service for shoes and handbags, etc., seem to be fraught with issues. I wonder (and certainly hope not) that the Card Service might be, too?? They'll send it back to you, right? If so, sell locally.
Good luck and good golly...
silverstatetreasureboxes
@mtgraves7984
Oh I forgot about the handbag one, so we have 4. I know MT it doesn't make sense to me either.
I ran across a site for Sneaker Con in Vegas because I'm local ( it's who does the authentication here) it was for a job called authenticator specialist ..you know what the qualifications were? 18 yrs old and 1 year experience with e-commerce. Nice!
wrong66
Incredible!!
besen-charl
Just had that happen to me Recommended by the authenticator-->
I assume they did not believe it was never played or just old from being in a binder for over 30 years?
Any way to avoid this or do I just list everything as is and refer to the pictures with no reference to age or condition, any help is welcome at this point.
https://www.ebay.com/itm/275710235531
Please update your listing to accurately reflect the surface of the card.