Are there FF's for Canada? If not, why not?
Summary: gurlcat is curious about the lack of Canadian buyers using U.S. freight forwarders (FF) despite high shipping costs from U.S. sellers via the EIS system. mam98031 and others explain that FF's are responsible for customs duties, which may deter use. Some participants, like grann-4629, share experiences with high shipping costs deterring purchases. chapeau-noir and others note that logistics and profitability impact the establishment of FF services for Canada. sin-n-dex provides insights on using U.S.-based mailboxes and FF-like services, highlighting issues around cost and tax reimbursement for businesses versus individuals.
I have heard repeatedly that EIS is prohibitively expensive for Canadian buyers from US sellers, and I'm inclined to believe it because I get only 1 or 2 Canadian sales a year, at most. -And those ARE EIS, so apparently the buyers find the items worth the big shipping expense. But here's what I don't get: why don't I ever have sales to buyers with Canada as their location stated in their account, but with my ship-to address being somewhere in the U.S. ... as in, a Freight Forwarder?
I would think this would be even more common than FF businesses who ship to Europe, Asia, etc. because we share thousands of miles of border, and there are lots of Americans who live near it and cross it regularly for work and whatever. Even if it would be illegal to carry packages over the border (I reckon it probably is), the proximal location still might be advantageous somehow.
And if nothing else, what I've heard about EIS's (sometimes sky-high) forwarding prices is they don't always choose the lower-price international shippers. -Which also sometimes applies to other countries, which is why a lot of European, Asian, etc. buyers DO use a FF instead of EIS, because the FF's shop around for each customer to find the cheapest shippers possible, so cheap that even with their own service fee charged to the customer, the total cost is still cheaper than EIS. Hope I'm making sense, sorry so wordy. But anyway yeah, wouldn't this also potentially apply to Canadian customers? Are there not a myriad of intra-continental shippers competing for US <--> Canada business?
Is there some A-HA explanation I'm not aware of?
@sin-n-dex @sakic92710 @grann-4629
gone.c-33
66% of canadians live within 100 kilometers/62 miles of the US border, most of them go for a P.O. box or a locker box in a UPS store or similar place near the border.
In Canada, the bigger issue isn't so much sellers refusing to ship internationally or the cost of doing so but the very low $20CAD/$14USD threshold for merchandised to be assessed taxes and handling fees.
Canadians will go pick up the packages, discard the packaging, cross back into Canada and hope for the best. If you turn it into an overnight/24h trip, you can declare up to $200CAD/$140USD worth of merchandise back into Canada duty free.
gurlcat
OP"to be assessed taxes and handling fees" -by whom? Taxes: the government, I assume. But handling fees??
gone.c-33
Reasonable handling fees by Canada Post, outrageous ones by UPS/FedEx. Like $8 vs. $45 for the same thing. đŦ
reallynicestamps
The $20 de minimus was raised some years ago to $150 for the USA. And CBSA and the post office basically ignored anything under $100 because the cost of assessing duty would be higher than the duty collected. (CBSA officers earn ~$80K annually or $44Cdn an hour --$0.73 a minute)
gone.c-33
"Above $20: duties and taxes apply when imported from any country, including the US and Mexico"
https://www.cbsa-asfc.gc.ca/services/cusma-aceum/lvs-efv-eng.html
¯\_(ã)_/¯
It's been a long time, and maybe the local CBSA workers had something against me, but I routinely got the $8.50 fee for packages valued under $100.
reallynicestamps
It has been a long time. I can't remember when the Canada Post fee was that low.
It has been $9.95 for over a decade.
And the Canada Post fee is not duty or tariffs, it is a service charge -like the custom brokerage charged by UPS or FedEx
sin-n-dex
There are FF's for Canada, the one I am signed up with is called Shippsy. They are a sister company of Stallion Express (my USA bound shipper, they share a building, but Shippsy is designed for you to set up an account to upload your invoices and have pacakges sent northbound).
You can legally bring packages back. My boss at the shop does this regularly, including collecting my eBay envelopes (for my dot com store which have expensive shipping on them if not mailed to the US). I give him a copy of the invoice when he goes down, and it's in his paperwork for when he comes back.
They may or may not check the car. He said there's usually so much stuff in there that they're mostly taking his word that all invoices are there (this came up when he forgot the invoice for the bubble mailers, which were zero dollars, thus no taxes). It's not duty Canadians pay, it's sales tax (13% where I live). If you are a business, you get all that sales tax back on anything that can be construed as work related, so people like me and my boss don't care what we have to pay, we just get a receipt and claim it back in our next filing. No motivation to lie, we get nothing out of it.
If you are a private person buying for individual reasons, you do not get the taxes back, and lots of people try to lie. They say they're going shopping, declare the food (which is tax exempt), and Canadian customs will ask "did you go to a USPS location while you were over?" (or something to that effect). They ask me, but I live too far from the border to bother having packages shipped there myself, if it's for my eBay business I use my boss' UPS box, otherwise I do usually opt to ship with EIS.
Whether I use Shippsy for personal stuff or EIS, I still have to pay taxes. There's a handling fee to bring each package across. I buy dresses and clothes for work, so I pay around $25 USD in fees with EIS which works out to about what they would cost with Shippsy. Perhaps shippsy is $5 cheaper, but for the volume I do (3-4 packages a quarter) I have never bothered to use my Shippsy account.
Also things like coins, stamps and food are prohibited with Shippsy, and that's often a lot of what I want to buy. Furthermore lots of the things I buy on eBay don't come from the US either, so the Shippsy account is not useful for those.
mario9342
thank you
adamcartwright
For what it's worth, I've made two EIS sales to Canada.
Both about $10.
gurlcat
OPThey must have really wanted those items, because I guarantee the shipping was wayyy more than $10.
reallynicestamps
Consumers buy outside their own country because The Thing is not available in their own country.
Cost is secondary.
tobaccocardyahoo
The cost of EIS shipping to Canada is higher for the same size and weight 4oz order than the cost to the UK or France.
I attribute it to the cost of Ground last mile delivery. Although close to the border destinations are easy to reach, the cost of tracked shipping from a dependable carrier to much of Canada is likely to be substantially higher than we US sellers find unacceptably high.
Before EIS, I stopped shipping to Canada. Customs clearance fees were too high with independent carriers, and Canada Post was unpredictable in their delivery times. I did not miss the business, though I missed interacting with some of my buyers.
Many of the recent changes in USPS service echo the long term practices at Canada Post.
fm2000
Some Canadians who live near the border do have freight forwarders of sort, they have a private mail box at a business and they cross the border to get it. Won't save on tariffs (if they declare of course), but it would save greatly on carrier costs, which is the huge expense on items of small value going cross border (also avoids any UPS "brokerage fees" which some are slammed with if an unknowing seller uses UPS.) I get a few of those borderside "freight forwarders" a month. I actually could have sworn I sent something to Quebec to a freight forwarder in northern NY who took it across the border themselves a few weeks ago.
gurlcat
OPYeah way back when I sold live fish I had a Canadian buyer with a mailbox in northern Montana. It kinda blew my mind, picturing the little fish I netted out of ditches here near the Gulf Coast going and living in a tank with snow and bears and moose outside. đĨ°
grann-4629
My son just finished digging a huge pond at the back of his property. It is filled with rainwater, has a fountain and a waterfall from a smaller pool. The water is constantly moving and he stocked it last year with tiny goldfish. It's deep enough that they survived the winter under the ice.
They are now over 4" long. He also has an exotic tortoise who lives inside but visits the pond occasionally with supervision. He's now looking for local turtles. Birds are always hanging around.
He built an arch out of dead trees at the edge of the pond where he got married last week. It's a nature refuge on his own property đ¤
adamcartwright
I've always wanted to put a pond in the yard and stock it with fish, but with all the raccoons and coyotes passing through, it would basically be a smorgasbord.
grann-4629
@fm2000
I did that when I sold stuff. The border is only 50 miles away (I'm old and don't like kms). I could ship stuff to US buyers from a US location at a decent cost while my partner walked around Target.
Never had any hassles with the Customs people ... they were much friendlier to Canadians then.
Also, there was none of the Country of Origin stuff or tariffs then so I could pick up cheques and money orders at my PO box there in US currency. Times were good.
reallynicestamps
And we could buy in loonies and sell in US dollars.
grann-4629
I'm thinking way before Loonies and Twonies when we had paper $1 and $2 bills, but you get the idea.
reallynicestamps
The loonie came into use in 1987.
Fun story. My mortgage had a final payment due in late 1987. The bank teller said she just needed "one eightyseven " to pay it off, so I pulled out my chequebook.
She clarified that she meant $1.87, and I was able to pay the mortgage off with change including a shiny new loonie from my purse .
sin-n-dex
If you have a USPS box, you have to check it often. They give your name and address to advertisers and your box will be filled with spam from that. You can't turn it off, and you have to go there often to collect this garbage mail. I found this out when I wanted to sign up, they said Canadians only come when they have a package to collect and don't clean out the junk in their regular mail slot, so they have to give us bigger boxes or charge us overflow for holding our junk across the counted. I'm not sure if this is all still true, it was true 20 years ago.
If you go with UPS (like Mail Boxes Etc business), you can use their address like a street address for deliveries that they don't want to ship to PO Boxes, it doesn't have to be shipped USPS. You're supposed to go once every 15 days to get packages, but our shop does so much business there they let us come down once every 2 months to get our packages (which will fill up the back of the car). He lets me use the address so long as it's business related and I can provide an invoice. I order eBay envelopes which cost zero, so it's no problem for them, I just need to give them a copy of the invoice to show customs when they come back.
grann-4629
I read here somewhere that flyers and non-addressed mail is not allowed to be put in mailboxes in the US ... something about ownership of the box or? It was never an issue when I did it.
I was doing mostly video trading stuff then that I started before the internet and email came around ... when mailpersons actually delivered mail from my US friends in less than a week, and we had home delivery on Saturdays then. It was a great hobby that is probably too expensive and regulated to do now.
fm2000
Only the USPS is allowed to put things in mailboxes, so if you want to put stuff in people's mailboxes (flyers and such) you have to pay postage.
grann-4629
Advertising is all we get in our mailbox these days. It sucks, but it does provide work for the delivery people.
chapeau-noir
Some Canadians who live near the border do have freight forwarders of sort, they have a private mail box at a business and they cross the border to get it.
Blaine (north of Bellingham, Washington) is like that - the entire main street is lined with mail shops, with various signs boasting of their competitive prices. I've ridden my bike up there and also done various runs, and it has never changed down through the decades.
grann-4629
Well, I posted a while ago about an offer I received for an item on my watchlist. The cost of the dvd set was perfect but the seller was using eIS and wanted over $80 US to mail them from New Jersey to Manitoba! He was shocked when I showed him a screen shot of his shipping info on his listing. I don't know if sellers can see that on their own listings, or this seller didn't know.
The seller did contact me. He was able to resize the package and could bring the shipping down to around $33 US ($2.9 Million in Canadian dollars) to mail it ... still way more than my budget. I had to decline.
A fellow Canadian has explained why the cost to mail a single DVD from USA to Canada from a seller using eIS could be around $19 US ... that is just over $27 C. to me.
I buy the same stuff from Canadian sellers where the actual postage is around $5 and I pay, on average, around $7 .... that's OK
The few times I have purchased from US sellers, it was non-eIS shipping that I could afford. The one time an item was shipped to me using eIS everything went perfectly and my landed total cost was fine for the item I really wanted.
mam98031
You are funny. While it is horrible right now, the exchange rate is not that bad between the US and Canada. $33 US in Canadian dollars is around 47 Canadian dollars.
With what the OP is talking about, EIS would have nothing to do with a seller in the US shipping to a FF in the US. Any tariffs or custom fees are between the buyer and the FF. The Ebay seller would not be involved, nor would EIS.
grann-4629
Regardless of the amount that goes way up when you buy a $400 item. I am saying that even a minor $47 converted is way too much to mail a set of DVD's.
btw ... I am in Canada where both the seller (who chooses to use it) and eIS (that is it) would be involved đ
mam98031
EIS is only involved if the seller is shipping directly to a buyer in a different country. It is never used if it is a seller shipping to an FF inside their own country. It would be the FF that actually ships to the buyer outside the country. However using an FF will not save the buyer from having to pay tariffs, it only saves the seller from having to deal with it with the buyer. The FF still has to follow the laws.
I'm not defending the tariff amounts. Nothing in my previous post even came close to stating that. I agree with you, it is way too expensive for buyers.
powell-collectibles
Exactly - and that is where a FF might help. They can actually get it to you cheaper.
gurlcat
OP@powell-collectibles do you see [this] reply?
chapeau-noir
There hasn't really been a necessity for an FF to Canada before. Establishing freight forwarding takes a lot of logistics (aggregate, carriage, import clearance, regular customs protocol, forward shipping, etc.) so it may not be something that is considered profitable enough, particularly as fluid as the situation is.
gurlcat
OPIf by 'fluidity' you mean the kooky whims of Tariff Man, certainly that does complicate everything, but I'm talking about even before 2024, I saw buyers and sellers talking about Canadians preferring sellers who handle their own international shipping rather than EIS, because so often it made a huge difference in total price. So presumably (and maybe I'm wrong to presume) that's because such sellers would make an effort to find the lowest-price shipper, whereas EIS's choices are based on who-knows-what.
Oh! And let's not forget the fact that most 3P platforms (Mercari, Posh, Etsy, etc) don't even have an EIS-like service, so Canadians wanting items from US sellers in those platforms would just be SOL.
I don't know, it just seems like there's plenty of profitable business sitting on the table, but I guess if that were true the FF's would exist.
reallynicestamps
Since eBay does not actually require tracking * at one point a lot of my shipments to the USA were simple lettermail. Safe delivery for less than a dollar.
Customs and postal services have doubled down and now require package rate mailing and customs information. While those usually included tracking, those rates are higher.
*Sellers may want it because they get a lot of INR claims. Buyers may just like the warm pink fuzzies tracking gives them.
chapeau-noir
For a long time shipping to Canada, anywhere in Canada, from here was so cheap. I had loads of Canadian customers buying my goth/cyber stuff, vintage hats, etc. Then the shipping tariffs just exploded. I was using EIS for Canada, too, simply because I had so few items left that I just didn't bother setting up separate shipping - I should for my various bike parts, etc. though. I'd always just ship without EIS to Canadian buyers if they asked.
grann-4629
They don't need to have an eIS-like 'service'. Whatever happened to the days when we would buy a stamp, take 10 seconds to fill out a Customs Form and drop it in the mail. Out of the hundreds of times I sent and received mail this way nothing ever got lost.
Ahh progress ....
gurlcat
OPA ... stamp? For 3D packages?
grann-4629
@gurlcat
most of the time it was stamps đ
My last delivered purchase:
gurlcat
OPO .... kay ..... but did you buy them on Mercari, Poshmark, or Etsy, like I was talking about (and what you replied about)?
reallynicestamps
Of course, it helped (helps) that philatelists are painfully honest. Seriously. Most coin or card dealers would plotz if anything like circuit books were suggested in their hobbies.
For those who are not stamp collectors- A circuit book is a small paperback in which a collector puts stamps they want to sell with prices, and sends to the first name on the circuit. That collector takes what they want, pay the circiut organizer, and send to collector #2. There can be a dozen or more names on the circuit. The books can be worth hundreds of dollars. They are rarely tracked.
Like a PTA telephone tree.
grann-4629
I remember collecting stamps when I was a child. I would buy them 'On Approval' from large stamp companies. Most of the time I forgot to send them back and my Mom ending up paying the bill.
Wish I had those collections now. âšī¸
I also collected records and 8 track tapes from Columbia House ... with the same results.
Wish I had that vinyl collection now. âšī¸
As Mel said: "Life Sucks" đđđ
mam98031
Yes, but that isn't going to resolve the tariff issue. If a Canadian buyer has the US seller ship to a FF, then it would be the FF's issue to make sure that the buyer in Canada pays the tariffs due in order to ship it to their country, just as it would be for any shipment to any country that have tariffs. And sadly there are a lot of them.
EIS has nothing to do with shipping to an FF.
chapeau-noir
I didn't see anything in the OP that said EIS has anything to do with FF. Just wondering why FF isn't used for transhipment to Canada. It's a good question.
grann-4629
Just wondering why FF isn't used for transhipment to Canada.
I think you posted the answer you are looking for. It makes sense to me. No mon, no fun.
gurlcat
OPIt wasn't even a yes/no question. đ¤Ŗ