Anyone else noticing strange bot activity?
Summary: manwithnofear85 noticed an unusual spike in views on their eBay listings, suspecting bot activity, which prompted a discussion about the accuracy and nature of eBay's view counts. mam98031 argued that the views could be organic due to the large number of potential buyers online, while others, like puremichigand, expressed skepticism about the legitimacy of these views. Many participants shared similar experiences, with some attributing the anomalies to potential technical tests by eBay. Concerns were raised about the impact on seller decisions, highlighting doubts about whether views translate into actual sales. Several suggested reporting these issues to eBay for investigation.
Today I listed a few things and within 10 seconds, they had like 5, 6 views, which is very unusual for me. I thought a few years ago eBay tried combating bots on this site? Anyone else noticing this on their listings?
roastedsaurus
The same day I give Nifty's automated relisting a trial run eBay starts counting bot views. Well for a second there I really thought it was really working-LOL!
manwithnofear85
OPIt’s like raaaaaaaaaiiinnnnn…
bgt_masters_of_tiki_d
Anyone else's impressions look like this? My sales have absolutely tanked with my first 2 days in a row without a sale in a LONG time. I believe I average 6 a day.
gurlcat
No but I have a very goofy little store.
chapeau-noir
That looks like the elevation map of the race I did today. I was on my lips coming over the finish line.
gurlcat
"on my lips" -what does that mean?
authentic*vintage
Just throwing my hat in the ring on this one because I've noticed that immediately upon listing my items I have 1 or 2 views already and it reminds me of how it was a couple of years ago before ebay actively went in there and said they were gonna control bot views.
manwithnofear85
OPLike someone else recommended, report it to eBay. If enough of us tell them, then maybe they’ll do something about it.
Unavailable member
OK – I guess we’ve reached broad consensus that these are bot views. The only other potential cause is just errors in the view counts. Clearly, there’s no way that a massive number of people are actively hitting these items within a few seconds. Even if a handful or a lot of people have a search saved those notifications come out at specific times – it isn’t a real time update. Even if it was no way that all these people are waiting by their devices to click on a link in an eBay message.
I suppose that the only question remaining is whether these issues or errors are fixed in a week or two or a couple of days or a couple of hours, etc.
OK – one more question. Would it have any real positive or negative impact on a seller? I suppose it could if sellers are making decisions based on stats. A lot of views with no sales mean something. Sellers might tweet their listings because of it – I suppose there could be a harm.
manwithnofear85
OPFor me, yes. I do make decisions based on views and impressions. Like others, in the last couple years my views on items plummeted. In the past I've posted comics for sale I know are highly sought after, and hardly got any views. And that was after I did everything eBay suggested to boost my visibility, including the Promoted Items feature (which lets be real, they basically forced sellers to use or else they get buried in the search results.)
So now, if I get like 20 views on an item out of the gate, but 0 actual eBay views and it stays at 0, what good does that do me? For me it a privacy thing, cause I want to know what other sites are showing my listings.
pinkfloyd1961
I having been selling on EBAY for some time. Within the past four days, I have noticed the same issues. Never seen it in the past. Called EBAY and even filled a technical report. No resolution at this point. Everyone should call or file a technical report if they are experiencing the same issues.
manwithnofear85
OPI did earlier tonight. I got a ticket number so I can follow up.
mam98031
This post is purely informational and offered simply for additional info you can consider or disregard. Your choice.
The link for where I found the above graph was from Capital One..
selsa84
Irrelevant. Newly listed item don't get 29 external views the moment it goes live. It's a tech issue.
burningrubbertoycompany
Yep they are running the same scam again. I listed over 1000 products last month just to see the views continue to drop. Almost had no views on most items for days. This month listed a few hundred more and almost all items have views of the bat, listing view count finally increased. (still nowhere near what they should be) Its obvious things aren't well (except apparently for eBay live) when they take away your money counter on the awaiting shipment page and use bots to show fake views they are just trying to cover their incompetency
manwithnofear85
OPAn odd thing I just noticed when I looked at the traffic part in the seller hub, "Promoted Offsite views" is at 0, even though I have a combined 93 "external views."
Also couldn't help but notice when they do the ad fee, (I use the promoted listing tool cause they basically forced us to use it or else our listings get lost on the site. That's another shady thing for another post) they now include the shipping cost and sales tax in the ad fee instead of just the sub total. So if I sell a set of comics for say $20, and charge $13.90 for shipping and tax, instead of taking away $2 for the 10 percent fee, they now take around $5. That might not sound like a lot, but on top of the other fees they charge, and if I sell a lot, that adds up.
linenandlaceltd
Dealing with this same thing, apparently for the past 3 days. Today I listed several new listings and all had between 1 and 6 views within a minute. I have a lot of external views. It's very strange.
manwithnofear85
OPI'm wondering where these external views are coming from. Is eBay trying to cook the books with how many views listed items get? Cause all the items I listed in the past could days don't have any views within eBay.
chapeau-noir
Since they're apparently not showing when viewed incognito, I suspect testing. And they NEVER tell us until after the fact...maybe.
manwithnofear85
OPUPDATE: Just listed another item and 13 external views out of the gate. Yeah, weird stuff is happening.
chapeau-noir
@manwithnofear85 Just a quick FYI - eBay didn't start 'combating' bots, what they did is change the method by which they count impressions and views, disregarding bot views so that what we were looking at are organic views.
It's what makes this sudden increase in external views so odd. One individual found that they did NOT appear when they searched incognito, which I find quite interesting. So it's not suddenly lots o' people finding out items on external sites and looking at them.
But I also don't think it's going to hurt anything - it's just strange.
manwithnofear85
OPI was told by an eBay customer service rep a few years ago when I began noticing the view count on my listings tanked was cause they were "combatting bots" from the website.
And since they were "External Views" according to the Seller Hub, I'm wondering what sites viewed them.
chapeau-noir
I think they were either confused or doing a little creative marketing - eBay themselves issued bulletins describing the change to give more accurate reporting. I welcomed it, though a lot of people didn't like losing the window dressing.
manwithnofear85
OPI'm just glad to see it's not just me noticing these weird things going on.
chapeau-noir
eBay runs a lot of tests, so I'm rarely surprised at seeing odd twitches like this on the site. I can see where this one would raise eyebrows, though!
chapeau-noir
Probably eBay running some tests - similar to the 5% fees thing that rippled through here. Why they do them on live listings beats me, but I'd keep an eye out and see if they all drop off in a few days, or at least the phenomenon stops.
As this has rolled on it seems improbable to me that it's all 'people looking at our stuff'.
manwithnofear85
OPNo, I’m not that popular of a seller that I get all those views instantly haha.
inhawaii
Yes, I hate it when I see strange bot activity.
tealt
@manwithnofear85 I did notice a ridiculous 635 views pop up on an item I listed 11 days ago.
This is a niche item. Even with eBay's hundreds of millions of members, I can't believe that those views were being done by humans.
manwithnofear85
OPSame here.
chapeau-noir
https://community.ebay.com/forum/selling-57920/topic/absurd-amount-of-views-on-newly-listed-486454/
hartungcards
Isn't bot activity "strange" by definition?
stainlessenginecovers
It's called 'Web Crawling' which google and the likes do when there is something 'new' (and yes, it's done by their computer/bot system).
In fact, everyone remember when ebay said they wouldn't include those 'bot crawls' on something??
manwithnofear85
OPI was told that was why my view count tanked a few years back by an eBay customer rep.
Guess not!
chapeau-noir
Web crawling is decades old - these are reports of suddenly increased external hits.
mamacassidy
I think they're tinkering with the code. I noticed today on the app (android) when I click on my active listings, it now shows the impressions, views, and watchers. It didn't show all that yesterday.
I don't know if/ how that would affect your data on the website, but I always assume when they're tinkering with the code it'll show up in multiple places.
ladybugmls
Same thing happened to my new listings today
manwithnofear85
OPHow many views in how many seconds?
ladybugmls
4 views instantly
kandf_vintage_finds
yep...happening here too. Tomorrow they will disappear.
mam98031
What has that got to do with bots? There are millions and millions of potential buyers on the site at any given time. They look at all kinds of things. I'm not sure I understand what you are concerned about.
hartungcards
I'm not sure I understand why you can't admit that weird unexplainable stuff happens on eBay.
mam98031
I don't usually make blanket statements like that, which is why you likely have never seen me say anything like that. With that said, I do not see what is strange about what the OP wrote. It happens all the time and none of us knows how many buyers are looking for a certain thing any given second of the day. It could easily be the numbers they stated.
It is important to keep in mind that Ebay's view count has never been 100% accurate. Not since the day they started it. But something can be view a million times and if it doesn't sell, it doesn't mean anything to the seller. Well maybe that they should take a hard look at their listings to see what might be wrong with it in a buyer's eyes. But other than that, views aren't what most sellers are after, they are after sales. And all that takes is a single view by the right buyer.
I can't tell you how many times over my years here that I've had something sell that says it never had a single viewer. We all know that isn't possible. But it does happen.
hartungcards
What has that got to do with bots?
mam98031
Nothing. That is the point.
manwithnofear85
OPWithin 10 seconds getting 7 views is strange.
Plus I looked at the Traffic Data just now and the views were “External Views.”
mam98031
An External view isn't anything unusual. We want them. The more the better off we are. That just means that the potential buyer found their way to the listing from a different site like Google or something. That is good news.
Unavailable member
Seven external views within ten seems highly unlikely - darn near impossible. Hinky stuff. Yes, clearly something is off.
mam98031
I understand why some would have that opinion. I see it a bit differently. Per the darn AI, there are over 2.7 Billion people worldwide shopping on the internet at any given time for something. For me, I don't find it hard to believe that out of all those people a couple didn't find their way to a listing on Ebay. But again, just my point of view.
Unavailable member
A couple in the first hour? maybe. Depends on the listing. Several in a handful of seconds? Not likely. Darn need impossible. I don’t really don’t need to get into the math. But you could draw out just how unlikely this is.
mam98031
We just disagree, not a big deal. Math is important, but again, we don't have to agree.
Unavailable member
I’m not sure if you’re being serious or sarcastic – but OK and thanks.
Unavailable member
Can you check the source on that? 1/3 of the earths population shopping at any given time seems like a little bit much. The math doesn’t work out from a common sense standpoint. Are you sure that isn’t how many people shopped online all of last year?
mam98031
You can search for the answer just as easily as I can.
Unavailable member
Sure – I can. The numbers looked so off from anything that could be close to realistic.. I did a quick search. I was trying to give you a little bit of an out. I knew there was no way that many people were searching for something to buy online at anyone given time.