AI descriptions are lazy and useless
Summary: The discussion centers on the use of AI-generated descriptions by sellers, primarily on eBay, with participants expressing mixed opinions. total_pakaj criticizes AI descriptions as lazy and lacking in detail, while others like christworks argue that AI can save time and is a valuable business tool if used correctly. The conversation also touches on the potential pitfalls of AI, such as inaccuracies and the need for users to provide guidance to avoid generic outputs. Some participants express their refusal to purchase items with AI-generated descriptions, emphasizing the importance of personal input from sellers. Despite these concerns, others highlight AI's potential benefits in streamlining operations and generating useful insights when properly configured.
AI written descriptions are lazy and uninformative. If you use them, you are lazy and deserve all negative feedback you might get. Take some time and note important details
timelesstreasuretrove25
AI, I believe, is a tool that you can customize to pretty much be a reflection of yourself. You have to train your AI...give it rules...preferances....directions....etc. Chose an AI platform and stick to that AI only when you need to research. For example, I use ChatGPT, I pay for he professioal version and I use ONLY that AI for anything and everything. It learns YOU....over time it becomes your very own personal assistant. I love it!!! It has saved me thousands and thousands of hours of time that I simply didn't have before. If you AI jump then you'll get garbage information because that AI has not learned YOU. Unless you give AI specific instructions or direction you're going to get a generic version with poor quality answers. Trust me, I've learned the hard way. I've made mistakes with listings and it has caused me negative feedback but being new to all of this...I have to learn so I look at it as a lesson learned. But I truly believe AI can be an EXCELLENT research tool if you actually know how to use it. To each his own....Good luck!!
roccotacodad54
One of the weirdest I've encountered was for a listing of a warthog tusk (legal). "Showcases the majesty of marine life".
Warthogs are wild African swine known for surviving in very arid conditions.........................
chapeau-noir
Oh gawd - as Gen Z and alpha says (disparagingly), that is so AI!
chapeau-noir
This comment has been approved.
onlinecentral
You should compose the description manually to ensure there are no mistakes. Then embellish it with an AI phrase such as "A must have for any Collection", or "Sure to be a conversation starter".
inhawaii
AI descriptions are NOT lazy, the people who use them are.
P.S. It's not Ai anymore. It's SI.
chapeau-noir
And I understand 'fake news' is now 'artificial news'. Also up is down and truth is false. Maybe we should start calling AI "FI", i.e., fake intelligence.
gurlcat
I'm literally going to start doing that.
bashort
Yes ebay ai written descriptions are terrible.
I have not tried it but I would bet if you used something besides ebays super cheapo defective version of ai that it could draft a very nice bullet point type description with just pertinent facts.
In any case it definitely needs to be fact checked
ten_o_nine
Don't blame the tool, blame the user. AI is one of the best tools out there today for almost anything you can imagine. Feed it garbage, and it'll give you garbage. Give it clear commands, and it will give you exactly what you need. You can't jump into a pool without knowing how to swim and blame your drowning on the water.
chapeau-noir
Give it facts and it will hallucinate (I've worked in the field) when the facts don't jive.
bennotbill
As this is the American forum shouldn't we all be referring to SI, super intelligence.
Sorry I couldn't resist mentioning this.
As for the AI descriptions I assume most do as I do. Scan past the "you need this wonderful blah blah" to the last line where sellers with any sense at least add a line of their own about the items condition. If they don’t then I move on, just as others have said they do.
grann-4629
It's good for items like recordings on DVD or VHS as the content of the recording has probably been reviewed and rated on many sites, AI has summed them up, and the seller doesn't have to type it in. Just edit out the garbage like 'you have to have this for your collection'.
chapeau-noir
I can usually write that gubbins myself in less time than it takes to fix the artificial SUPER intelligence nonsense that gets spit out.
gurlcat
So basically you could just find a decent existing listing and do a sell similar from it.
tobaccocardyahoo
Some items need no description, others do. Omitting the field or copying the Item Name into the description is tackier.
I use AI descriptions for items which are clearly defined by the Item Name, Condition and the images. They are no more risk to the buyer than the descriptions with grammatical and spelling errors some sellers post.
Like so many issues we face, it depends on what you sell.
lawnmowerpartsstore2
I am a buyer and a seller on Ebay.
When im looking for something to buy because the price is right i will click into it.
I look at the pictures the read the description and when i see the description is AI, that tells me the seller has no idea what they are selling and i back our right away.
Then i move on to the next higher priced item to purchase.
ruby_c_took
This is my exact procedure as well. I do check the end of the description now, because sometimes a seller uses the AI description and then puts their own at the end. Which is a mistake imho but if the information is there I will consider buying the item.
lb23cavaliersmvp
Recently used google lens to try and determine the maker of a pottery napkin ring. Made sure it was photographed clearly on end so that the hole was obvious and received the snarky reply..."Actually it is a bowl...".
pickapaper
@lb23cavaliersmvp When you use Google Lens, there is a little space where you can ask a follow up question. If it misreads a photo, all you have to do is give it additional info to work with and it's amazing what it comes up with. For example, you could have said, "it's a napkin ring" and it would have corrected itself. Then in the follow up box you can ask "maker" and it will give more info. Then you can ask "value" and it will give you a general estimate. If an item is common, it sometimes comes up with a lot of info up front, but if it is something less common, you have to give it more "clues" to work with. It's not going to know everything about everything but I've been really happy with the results I've gotten. I also understand that not all info may be correct but what I have double-checked has been good.
I've used it a lot and I'm always amazed at the things it comes up with. If I think that something isn't correct, I tell/ask it. I once showed it a photo of a train which a previous owner had identified on the back as a "model 14". AI told me it was a "model 12" and when I asked, "are you sure this isn't a model 14?" it said it definitely was not a model 14 and then explained all the differences between the two models. (The previous owner had incorrectly ID'd it.)
lb23cavaliersmvp
We did and received the same answer. To date the info is useful ~ a 1/3 of the time.
gurlcat
Lens can be pretty awesome. But one of the problems I frequently run into with it is how much it obsesses on COLOR. Like say I have a jewelry piece that I suspect may be an unsigned design by a popular brand, and say it's gold with blue rhinestones ... then all the results will be gold/blue rhinestone pieces even if the designs are barely similar, and it WON'T show pieces with the exact same design, but in silver or with different-colored stones (which costume designers do all the time, always have).
grann-4629
Sometimes having a discussion with AI can be fun and informative, not like eBay uses when you ask for help.
btw, I am in Canada where our Intelligence is still Artificial.
japaninmotion
ai reads like a JRHS student's book report on the book they never read
christworks
@total_pakaj
Sellers who do not embrace AI will be left behind. I'm not saying that's the way it should be, but that is a hard truth you and others need to accept. Of course AI is not perfect, and sellers should review the data. They certainly risk an INAD if the AI should get something wrong and the seller does not catch it.
I've been using AI in some form or another to list for over two years. It has come a long way. I don't use eBay's AI, because I think there are far better 3rd party ones out there. I don't use AI to write marketing fluff because I don't think that gives the buyer any information they actually need.
I don't write descriptions, even when I manually list. eBay does not prioritize descriptions and honestly many buyers don't look at them. I consider it a waste of time and it slows down the listing process if you are going to manually do it all. For about two years I simply copied and pasted the title and condition into my description box and added the standard text that goes in all listings. I would use ChatGPT to write my condition statements either based on what I told it as I reviewed a pile of items or by uploading pictures of the items to it. I then manually copied that over to the listing.
A year ago I started using an AI to list similar items in batches. There were times I listed 100 items in a couple of hours. I did not review all 100 of those listings. I've never had a buyer complain. Even if 5 buyers out of the 100 complained, that is a well within my risk tolerence.
Because I also crosslist, a couple months back I decided to ditch my old crosslister and move over to Nifty since it is basically an AIO solution. I like their AI. It is customizable and has been very accurate. I rarely review what it does anymore because I've only needed to change something once or twice out of my first 300 listings. As I have time I've been having it go back and redo old listings using AI. It will probably fix more of my own mistakes than it will make mistakes.
The people who AI dumbs down are people who were dumb well before AI became mainstream. If you were likely to look something up on Google and take it as the truth before AI, you are doing to do the same when it comes to AI.
@chapeau-noir mentioned graphics and I do agree many people take the first thing AI gives them and don't take a few extra minutes to have AI make it nice looking. I have created my own graphics for dang near 30 years, going back to when I was a teenager. I don't have the time to do that very often in this season of my life, so when I need a graphic, I use AI to generate it outright or to create elements I can put into my graphcis program as I build the main design.
I've always created my own cards to give to people for birthdays and such. Today I use AI to help me with that. Everybody always asks me where I bought the card. They are stunned when I tell them I used AI to create it.
Many people don't know how to make their own graphics. Small business owners often cannot afford a graphic designer. AI gives them the ability to have custom made graphics on a whim. I don't know why people get bent out of shape about that, and feel the need to state publically they won't ever buy from someone who uses AI. Nobody cares. Business owners don't care. They are going to be perfectly fine without your business.
Some AIs are so good you won't even know there is an AI behind the curtain.
I do appreciate that many of the anti-AI crusaders signal to me they are nutcases, so I know to avoid them. 😁
chapeau-noir
The difficulty with AI is all of us who had our worked ripped off to create it.
christworks
I can understand why you feel that way. Questions about permission, credit, and compensation deserve serious answers from the companies building these AI systems.
Still, I don’t think recognizing the benefits of AI means dismissing what artists have contributed. Both things can be true: AI can be valuable, and the people whose work helped develop it can have legitimate grievances about how that happened.
chapeau-noir
Yes - I use AI for simple compiling tasks, but there's no copyright violation there. There do need to be strong guardrails or we all become just product. I'm still hassling with google who has misattributed one of my publications to another writer - so even keeping simple attribution straight seems to be beyond it.
grann-4629
AI is like a really fast internet search engine that collects information, right or wrong, then paraphrases what the majority of the sites searched agreed on.
Sometimes, the internet gets things really wrong (the fake news syndrome) and AI reflects that by also being wrong.
Sometimes AI can be like a wonky GPS system in your car that drives you off a cliff or strands you in the middle of a desert.
It's going to get interesting when AI finds out about that red button on POTUS's desk.
gurlcat
The one for Diet Coke?
ice*angel*1
I have been an a buyer and seller (occasionally) on EBay since the beginning. I read your blurb and I just want to say that as a buyer “descriptions” are so incredibly important!! It really annoys me to have to repeatedly msg sellers, especially nearly all of the recent Japanese sellers who seem to skip the descriptions all together when I just want basic information!! I do understand that sometimes it could be a language barrier, but… it is not that difficult to write a brief description with the relevant facts for buyers!!! 😩
christworks
@ice*angel*1 I hear you. Let me explain it to you from a business standpoint.
I do this to make money. Some people don't like that - I'm not saying you care one way or the other. My time is valuble to me though and I want to make the most money I can and invest the least amount of time possible. Part of the reason for that is because I don't have a ton of time. My full time "job" is taking care of an elderly demential ridden parent and helping with my sister who is awaiting a lung transplant.
With all of that in mind and seeing that eBay actually makes buyers take an extra step in the app to find the description, it made sense to me to stop investing time into writing descriptions that many buyers - maybe even most buyers - don't read. I understand some buyers do read descriptions. You are obviously one of them. In fact, I am one of them as well. I never buy anything without reading the entire listing and reviewing all the pictures. You and I, I think, are in the minority though when it comes to absolutely needing a description before we make a purchase. Many buyers want one, for sure, but if they don't see one it seems to me most are happy to look at the item specifics and review the pictures. So that is where I focus my time.
I don't leave buyers hanging though. I have 30-day free returns, so my buyers know if something does not work for them, they can send it back and get their money back. That policy goes a long way to make up for my lack of descriptions.
I can say as a seller that my decision to not invest much time or thought into descriptions paid off. I can list much faster, which allows me to list more in the time I have available to do it. This has translated into a significant sales increase for me. Of course I will lose some buyers who want descriptions. I'm okay with that trade off. That's the benefit of running your own business as you get to run it in a manner that works for you.
I alluded to this in my post, but I've made some adjustments in the past month or two. The new AI program I'm using is highly customizable, meaning it can be set up to do pretty much whatever a seller needs to do when it comes to the description. It took some trial and error on my part to get it how I want it. It can be set up to do all the marketing fluff, which I'm sure we'd both agree is garbage. The way I'm using it is for it to copy the item condition statement at the top of the listing, then up under it provide bullet points about the item. It pulls that information from the pictures. For example, it can state the measurements, whether they are on the package or taking it from my photos with the ruler in them. As long as AI can do this accurately, I'm okay with using it. So far so good. I realize it may not be perfect. Again, I have free returns so if it misses something from time to time and I don't see it, I'm okay with that because in the overall grand scheme I can grow my business faster with the limited time I have to list.
grann-4629
It's like those DVD sellers who show a picture of the front of the disc case only and offer no description of plot, actors, running time, etc.
chapeau-noir
It's as bad as the lazy slop posts and graphics people are using - it's literally sucking away human creativity and brain power.
As for Sellius, you still have to prompt it.
chapeau-noir
This comment has been approved (just after another of my comments was disapproved).
ten_o_nine
Good sellers use it to start a draft, not finish it.
stainlessenginecovers
AI is the way of the 'new' world.
It's everywhere.
It DOES stand for 'Artificial' (which means fake/pretend/close to but not really)
Nothing new here.
grann-4629
Artificial really means something made by humans, ie not a natural thing. Therefore, artificial items are not necessarily fakes or made to fool someone (except those flowers used by lazy gardeners). 😎
j_tibby03
Have you tried Sellius AI feature? Whatever you are selling, it gives so much detail and item specifics for the item.
janet9988
Promoting?????
j_tibby03
It’s the truth
ruby_c_took
You mean it searches and finds data on the item for you that you didn't have and would have had to look up yourself? Now that could be useful.
j_tibby03
Exactly and saves you from typing it.
gurlcat
Bulllllshhh...
ghum2
j_tibby03
Yes it can all you have to do is take accurate photos. Theres a box that lets you put any additional info that helps Ai by telling it info that it might not know. Like Page 95 is highlighted...
bolensparts-360
I wont buy anything from a seller who uses an AI description
annadryl
I agree. If they won't bother to describe it I won't bother to consider it, especially on a pre-owned item.
twk
I am doing that more and more. AI means they are lazy and expect me to contact them about the item specifics including things like size, height, etc.
I also think it is like the "seller" just writing "it's for sale" and that is it.
squinkercat59
I'd like to know the percentage of SNAD claims on items that were listed with AI descriptions. I'll bet it's significant compared to otherwise.
pickapaper
I don't think you will get any arguments from the 300 or so people here on this board. The problem is getting your message out to those of the 18 million sellers on eBay who are using AI.