25 YEAR RANT
You old timers have seen and heard it all, and yet maybe not.
I have fond memories of sales and dealing with people all over about items I sold and bought. I haven't sold in years, since the draconian banking stranglehold was put in place. We suffered through the paypal only years, got trained on that and then it changed again.
I loved getting Postal money orders for payment. I took personal check and even received cash payments.
My first sale was a Blue Oyster Cult "mother" and it took me quite some time to configure that listing. I had to get digital photo, picture hosting, learn HTML to configure the listing. No bank account needed, back when Ebay was a real venue and actually an auction site.
I enjoyed the "sniping" topics, so sad anymore.
Times a changing and now I am just that crusty fool talking about the "good ole days". Passing the torch to you newbies. Enjoy!
fbusoni
@piggysplace
I loved my old manual typewriter, the newspaper printed in black and white newsprint, and my landline rotary phone... and also my parent's 1964 Rambler with the pushbutton radio.
bad_box1
"Silly humans, given the gift of self control only to squander it and act like animals."
What have you sold since, you have been a member since 2009?
broto_64
Looking at the distant past with rose tinted glasses.
a-lotta-stuff
You're talking about when ebay was new and fun and better then 'before ebay' - you made me think about before ebay.
Before ebay we were [and still are] a used record store that had consignment accounts at three places for stuff we didn't sell in the store [videos, books, comics, toys, etc.] along with a truck left packed that we did shows with [insurance, registration, parking rent], and advs in magazines for mail order.
Then we discovered ebay - First ten listings all sold. Very first item listed sold for $2700 to a doctor in Germany who mailed us 28 consecutively number brand new $100 bills. That record had been in the store at $8 for six, seven years. Part of a lot, paid a quarter for it. Sold first ten listings for $3600.
Never did another show or mail order adv. Sold the truck. Closed the consignment accounts.
Ebay was and still is so much better.
piggysplace
OPI bought a huge lot of albums and related music at auction. I did real good, and still have some great collectables left.
Before ebay, it was the recycler, thrifty nickel and flea markets. People were whining about the fees back then, threatening boycotts every fee hike. I had people use paypal an I didn't have it. That was when there was a $5 reward for getting new paypal users.
wirkaholic
25 yr Ebay Veteran here... took a little break to start another business at one time. Yes, they were the good ole days but it is also a different world now. Everything is digital currency and a whole lot of scammers out there. I myself like managed payments and the new International shipping. I definately don't miss spending hours on HTML or photo hosting services. So much easier now.
Yes, Ebay still needs to address and fix issues but all in all, if you use all the tools they give you in the hub you can keep sales flowing. Old dogs CAN learn new tricks. You just have to do your homework and learn how to use the tools to your advantage. I still learn new things all the time. I learned you can only print 5 labels for one order. It was a very large order. Thank goodness I've kept my postage account all these years so I could print a 6th label.
I know we've all had to jump through hoops lately with all the changes, but sometimes change is good. I have my own confilcs with AI and bots taking over customer service. Not a fan but willing to watch and see what goes down. I don't like the idea of a bot deciding the fate of a seller when a problem arrises or placement of listings. The search functions are garbage lately.
In this world you have to adapt and overcome if you want to succeed in any business. I can say that with experience. That's just my 2 cents.
piggysplace
OPCorrect, and if adapting means finding another way without ebay, that is fine too.
Ebays search used to be top shelf, now it is total garbage. How do you adapt to that?
annadryl
Congrats! You've aspired to get old-timers bickering and you've achieved just that! It was great back when vs. It is better now.
(i am more on the safer side of now)
I am soon to face just that at my family reunion in August...
simply-the-best-for-you
I started in 96. There were good things about it then & there are good things about it now. I remember having to borrow a digital camera from the library to take pics! I like how much easier it all is now, but sure there are things that drive me nuts too.
johnrj1226
Sound like a take off of the late Ricky Nelson hit song - Garden Party
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nT6bgyimP8g
Like the last two stanzas (aka verse)
I learned my lesson well
You see, you can't please everyone
So you got to please yourself
Learned my lesson well
You see, you can't please everyone
So you got to please yourself"
bankress
I agree 100% with you! Of course, the eBay cultists will disagree but this is what they're used to and don't know when eBay was fun.
paxilill
I don't think Bruce Springsteen is going to write a song about the glory days of eBay.
theofficefan4life
I don't miss taking pictures with my "analog" camera the things I wanted to sell which I then had to have the film developed at the grocery store only to then take the physical photos and scan them in a scanner to convert them into digital. Still running on dial-up internet. Those were the horse and buggy days of ebay!
glorybells
That’s how I started out! (Remember the “boing-boing-static†sound of dial up connecting?)
animal-house-8
I have been here since Auction Web turned into ebay, started with autographs and sports memorabilia, all we did was auctions, did really good in the beginning then came all the forgeries, had to change. Have had about 10 different stores in the past, I thought paypal was a god send to tell you the truth, I hated waiting and holding items for checks to clear and the money order scams. But as you get older it is easier to see and feel the evolution of online selling, it still works but yeah it's totally different, managed payments seem to work ok and photos are a thousand times better. Just got to hang in there now and have as much fun as you can as everything just keeps moving on and you got to move with it.
meme6253
I was expecting a much larger or longer rant after 25 years.
inhawaii
It seems like even the most minute change can scare people away.
Remember when they recently changed the messaging system?
It was like the end of the world......
tex-421
Scared, what who.... I am not afraid of managed payments ...I'm not really.
sfau
26 years here -but still hands down beats a garage or consignment sale every day. But hey I invested in decent clothes/toys for the kids when they were little and we are able to recoup most of that money and just kept rolling to keep kid expenses down. I just wish we unloaded sooner and were not saving stuff to pay the college bills. I miss the days you could almost recoup everything spent at Gymboree. Only thing that made me nervous was once getting paid by Western Union and I had to go to K-Mart to pick it up. Luckily it was not a scam.
bonjourami
" Only thing that made me nervous was once getting paid by Western Union and I had to go to K-Mart to pick it up. Luckily it was not a scam."
Yes, I had many WU payments from several foreign buyers,all paid without a hitch. And this was fine jewelry! Wouldnt go back to that today!
luckythewinner
I loved getting Postal money orders for payment. I took personal check and even received cash payments.
Times a changing and now I am just that crusty fool talking about the "good ole days".
I hated sending checks or postal money orders or cash and then having sellers not send the item. I got scammed by sellers back in the day far more than I get scammed by buyers now.
johnrj1226
Am a '44 model adjusted to the many changes of eBay - change is good, reading and learning is good, worked 41.5 years in tete-a-tete selling all in the same industry. Tried to learn 3 things every day 2 about my career and 1 about my self. First started on a laptop PC when I was 50 - it was swim with Micro Soft Office or find the exit time with a pink slip in hand (2 hour of instruction - mostly on how to use and IBM Think pad and how to unlock it.. Cut the mustard. Still learn stuff from my 6..8 year old Grandson and "She Who Must Be Obeyed" children, neighbors and friends.
reallynicestamps
Getting cash in the mail made me nervous. Sending cash in the mail made me even more nervous.
Getting a personal check in the mail meant a 10-15 day delay while it cleared, or a nervewracking wait when the check was in the international banking system and my shipment in transit.
Money orders pushed the cost of my items higher since they had to be purchased. The price at the time was $3.50 and most of my listings were $9.99 with Free Shipping.
American buyers had a hard time understanding that they could not send green domestic postal money orders outside the country.
Then there was the "Western Union" money order scam (which did not involve WU) where a scammer sent an email telling the seller to ship becauses the money order was on its way. It wasn't.
Billpoint, and later Paypal, and now Managed Payments, allowed eBay to punish scammers who did not pay or did not ship.
The site was all the better for it.
By the way, it's worth remembering that eBay did not want to spin off the very profitable Paypal. It was forced on them by venture capitalist Carl Icahn.
And the cost of using PP has risen since the split.
bonjourami
I remember those days well, but no smart buyer today would pay with check or money order, and absolutely no buyer protection. Welcome to 2025! Actually I like Managed Payments, tho Im just an infrequent seller now.
dnasilver
Plenty of buyers pay with cash, bank wires, and checks on a regular basis. These are buyers who are smart and savvy investors. No, they do not buy on eBay like that. But at physical stores, auctions, businesses websites, and trade shows they do all the time. Of course, one might say multi-millionaires are not smart since they do not by secondhand clothing, but that is just an opinion. There were 379,000 brand spanking new millionaires in 2024 in the USA alone.
bonjourami
" But at physical stores, auctions, businesses websites, and trade shows they do all the time."
Sure, of course, we've all done it.But thats not a safe payment here anymore.
tex-421
ahhh, the good old days, when water was free and electricity and toilets didn't exist. People were real and shopping involved horses rides, trade and or cash. And a select few made gazillions of $$ from oil they found when they drilled the water well. None of this banking stuff, no one had IDs, not even birth certificates. No one had even heard of federal law. Malaria and TB really weren't that big a deal.
bonjourami
Oh gosh, doesnt appeal to me at all!!!
tex-421
I remember one of my distant ancient relatives saying, they thought FDR was a god when he brought electricity to rural Texas. Silly federal government getting involved in people lives.
adamcartwright
@tex-421
And back then you didn't have to changes a bunch of passwords every year or so because of some massive data breach.
tex-421
Not only no passwords, couldn't afford locks much less keys
johnrj1226
When I was a young guy in the mid 50s used to send 50 cents, two quarters taped to a cereal box top placed in a USPS3 cents stamped envelope for some trinket like a Captain Midnight decoder ring or a mood ring. Always received what I paid for w/o a hitch.. Yeah people ran a game back then - but there were a whole lot less of them. In fact some one stole my rather new bike out of our garage during the day time - never found an it was licensed and registered with our city - go figure..
kensgiftshop
Loosing Pay Pal was no reason to stop selling.
Managed Payments works just fine.
grand-and-glorious-purpose
just fine is what my boomer parents use as a descriptor when we are in a active direct conversation discussing things that are in fact not fine.
doc-holmes
What about managed payments do you find troublesome?
kensgiftshop
Whats not fine about it?
You sell and they send the money to your checking account.
luckythewinner
Okay, I'll clarify - I like managed payments. I hated having to log into eBay to see what I owed, and then log into paypal to see how much I had, and then do math to see how much money I had to spend. With MP, every Tuesday I get an email from each of my accounts telling how much money I have to spend.
itsjustasprain
Aaargh. I remember when my Paypal payment date for the month in my selling account was coming due when I would have to pay all my FVFs and listing fees... and too often I would find myself having to list some big-ticket auction item and hoping it would sell so that I would have enough money to pay the bill.
Basically PayPal would make all your funds available quickly but it would be up to you to set aside enough to pay the monthly Paypal bill. Some months could be nail-biters if I had spent the sale money on something else.
So now that Adyen is handling the money and Ebay is deducting their fees before releasing the rest of the funds then things are less stressful. Once I receive the proceeds from my sales I know that I will not have to send them back in to cover a monthly bill. (I know stores have a monthly fee but I am talking basic sales here.)
adamcartwright
I don't know what the GenX descriptor is, but I'll piggy back on the Boomers.
Managed payments really is just fine. I'm happy with it.
piggysplace
OPIn theory the new system should be fine. I had to setup my bank account to allow ebay access, but not access the my main funds.
So I got all that setup, and then they demanded I list the LLC owners and give photo ID. After I completed each new demand, they added yet another, more distasteful "rule", worse than the previous hoop I jumped through. And they hide these steps so you get invested in the process before walking away.
The reason to get a corporation is for that separation of entity, and once you co mingle personal with corporate, the corporate protection is VOID. All my corporate banking and tax status is LEGAL.
The "law" ebay cites for this is working its way through the courts and is a violation of states rights. My corporation is a "state" approved entity, and the federal law violates that entity approved and created by the state.
If ebay were to decide to protect the sellers by instituting a photo ID for buyers, I might consider selling on the personal account side of things. Ebay is not serious about stopping scams and fraud.
glorybells
I don’t know why you had such problems trying to set up managed payments. It only took me a couple of steps (including adding my middle initial to my eBay account, as the names on the eBay account and the bank account must match EXACTLY. Believe me, if I can do it, everyone can . . . If they follow the steps correctly. I’m rather computer illiterate, and it takes me awhile to figure out online things. LOL, anytime I’m able to do anything online, I know it is probably a piece of cake if I can do it.
piggysplace
OPI'm glad things work out for you. I was a seller, I sold, I had my bank connected. EBAY iced me out, I did not change a thing. They went to the new system, and I was actually quite optimistic that this would be a good deal. I spent HOURS on the phone with help. Finally found a guy who knew what was going on, or should I say had a work around to verify my already in use bank account.
But yeah, I had a good run in the day, lots of good stories, some not so good. I was Ebays biggest cheerleader in the day and helped my friends all get on board.
It's all good....until it's not.
johnrj1226
Looks like you have not sold anything in a while and only 39 items since '02. Feedback is largely form which is from Sellers in recent histor - no sales in the last 90 days - that is far back eBay goes for detailed public info goes.
piggysplace
OPNope, this posting ID started in late 2000. I have had a few name changes over the years. I have my other account, and haven't sold on that one in even longer times.
Back in the day, I even met up with other posters who were local to me. Great people. When ebay did away with truthful feedback for buyers, things really got ugly.
bonjourami
"Back in the day, I even met up with other posters who were local to me. Great people. When ebay did away with truthful feedback for buyers, things really got ugly."
Looking back now, I think Ebay did the right thing. There was too many retaliatory negatives left by sellers who had been negged by buyers. It was an unfair playing field for buyers.
johnrj1226
I called it "interet muscle" kind'a like a case of beer muscles that start after midnight at the corner bar..
piggysplace
OPI get it, but you have it backwards. The negative doesn't hurt the buyer, but it does hurt the seller.
bonjourami
"I get it, but you have it backwards. The negative doesn't hurt the buyer, but it does hurt the seller."
I dont have anything backwards, it did hurt buyers who were blocked by other sellers because of their unfair negative feedbacks.
johnrj1226
This is an direct copy and past of your
Feedback profile
piggysplace
Feedback ratings
Detailed seller ratings
fashunu4eeuh
@piggysplace wrote:
“When ebay did away with truthful feedback for buyers, things really got ugly.â€
Buyer feedback went because things were already getting ugly, with chronic retaliatory negatives becoming commonplace. It was those sellers attacking buyers for leaving honest ratings who are to blame for the loss of buyer feedback. It unbalanced the honor system that feedback was initially based on. Good buyers were lost because of the practice.
piggysplace
OPThat is the story the bad power sellers are promoting. But the reality is good sellers left because scammers proliferated due to the no neg for precious scammer.
It's interesting to me how things are changing since I don't visit ebay much. Now the newest ebay scam is free returns for 30 days in ebay motors. There will be abuse. I used to sell on Amazon too, and they are not asking for the information ebay is.
I should look into that again.
albertabrightalberta
If you don't like ebay's requirements (whether required by law or just by ebay), no one is forcing you to sell here.
piggysplace
OPThank you for sharing.
tex-421
Federal anti money laundering laws are "federal" laws and the Feds do force money service businesses like eBay (eBay is a licensed Money Service business in all 50 states) and PayPal to positively identify its customers both human and corporate. All corporations are "citizens" of states where they are registered and just because a corporation is a "state entity" doesn't mean it can ignore federal law.
There is no "case working its way through the courts" challenging any of this.
piggysplace
OPThat is still working its way through the courts. It will be shot down due to "states rights" and corporate law under the UCC.
Ebay has always tap danced on that edge. The "internet consortium". Remember that? Yep they lobbied to keep themselves out of jail while breaking sec and other banking laws.
The funny thing is the little guys who actually work and provide service are the losers in this, while the elite still haven't gone to jail for breaking the laws already on the books to stop what you claim the average business is doing.
They want to know who has the money because then they can come steal it from you.
itsjustasprain
What case are you referring to?
piggysplace
OPhttps://www.reuters.com/legal/us-supreme-court-allows-anti-money-laundering-law-take-effect-2025-01-23/
tex-421
Did you even read this? The Supreme Court denied the injunction and upheld the law.
piggysplace
OPThere most certainly is. The supreme court just recently ruled on the injunction to keep the law from going into effect. They sided with the big money grabbers. The lawsuit is still waiting for the courts slow walking.
The sad thing is the abusers of the corporate structure will never be brought to justice. Just squeeze the little guy for all it's worth.
tex-421
The Supreme Court upheld the law, plus the issue before the court is so narrow, that even if it had upheld the injunction, the practice effect on financial institutions like eBay to require users to provide IDs would have no effect, nothing would change for eBay users.
piggysplace
OPWere you on the ebay boards when paypal was forced on everyone? There was plenty of discussion on the topic.
tobaccocardyahoo
I was there then, and one of the Billpoint adherents who thought PayPal was the amateur hour, and lied when it denied all of the times it was hacked.
Ebay managed payments is a return to sanity and safety which Billpoint had provided.
bonjourami
"Were you on the ebay boards when paypal was forced on everyone? There was plenty of discussion on the topic. "
I was, been selling since '99, Ebay didnt have to 'force' Paypal on me, I had a merchants account at the time, and was happy to get rid of it.