Unreasonable buyer
I've been on Ebay for 19 years and this is a new one for me.
I had a buyer purchase a "pick up only" item early september ish 2024 @ 125.00$ .
In december 2024 they asked to cancel . The feedback on the account shows this person does this regularly.
EBay notified the buyer they could not cancel. That it was beyond the deadline but somehow sent me an email that I had initiated the cancellation, which was not correct.
I called ebay and they assured me that I was following protocol and had nothing to worry about.
This morning, 7+ months since the purchase, The same buyer emailed me demanding that I cancel because they couldn't pick it up.
I ,very politely and professionally , told them they were beyond the time limit required , reminded them they tried this unsuccessfully over 3 months ago, offered my apologies and ended with "have a blessed day ."
I just received a follow-up email from this person yelling ( all caps. I think that's considered yelling. Not sure) that I was horrible and rude and he was new to Ebay and didn't know better.
His page shows he's been a member for
six years. At this point it's a bit unnerving.
I certainly don't want a charge back or any funds frozen. I am liquidating my family estate and I myself, am on a fixed income.
Should I just block this person and move on?
Should I report this person to ebay?
Ebay Has always been a positive experience for me.
Bottom line... do I have anything to worry about, or should I just move on and go about my day?
It's just so unusual. I thought I would ask if anyone else has had a similar experience.
Do I need to do anything further to protect myself on this one?
Thank you all.
klhmdg
I would just refund the buyer minus all the fees and be done with it.
I would have done the same at 3 months.
I would never knowingly keep the money and the item.
The only thing you have to worry about is a CC charge back and that the person has your address.
house*of*paws
Hi @belluscioformals
The only reason that 7 months have passed is that you refused to handle the problem when it was brought to your attention at 2 months.
A buyer not realizing that a purchase was for 'Local Pickup Ony' is a very common problem on eBay [It's possible for a buyer to have joined eBay six years ago and still be 'new' ... depending on whether they've been using eBay regularly during those 6 years.]
The buyer probably can still file a chargeback with their credit card company ... depending on which CC they used ... BUT you really should be refunding the buyer (minus any expenses) because it's the right thing to do. I'm assuming that you've already sold ... or could sell ... the item to another customer.
grand-and-glorious-purpose
The "right" thing to do 100% of the time is whatever the seller thinks works for them best.
Maybe the seller doesn't want the hassle, maybe the seller doesn't care, maybe the seller is out of pocket on it for any number of reasons, maybe the seller already spent that money.
If the seller wants to keep the item and the money they can and it isn't wrong for them to do so. They had an agreement with the buyer and the buyer decided it was not in their best interest to hold up their end.
...and if the buyer after 7 months did nothing but capitalizing letters I would BBL and forget them
They can choose for themselves whatever they like. Most likely refunding and moving on is a good choice but it is not the ONLY RIGHT choice.
house*of*paws
@grand-and-glorious-purpose
Well, then ... we obviously disagree. I don't align myself with either buyers or sellers 100% of the time. Nor do I think it's appropriate for either a buyer or seller to keep both the item and money.
grand-and-glorious-purpose
I think it can be.
Again, I don't think that it is always appropriate and you don't think so either because you don't know every single scenario.
What I do know is that it is always appropriate for this seller to decide what works for them best in any given scenario. If a higher authority intercedes, like a credit card company, then that seller gets a chargeback and learns a lesson about what is and isn't appropriate.
house*of*paws
We both are offering our opinions only ... and we disagree.
It may be appropriate for a seller to withhold a refund from a buyer if it cost them money or great inconvenience to keep a sold item in storage ... BUT ONLY if the seller has contacted the buyer and communicated both a deadline AND the amount they will be charged if they fail to pick up the item by that deadline.
The fact that a seller (or buyer) can get away with keeping an item and the money doesn't mean they should do it IMHO.
belluscioformals
OPI'm sorry maybe I wrote it incorrectly. It was over ninety days before they reached out and said they could not pick it up. I reached out immediately after purchase and gave them my phone number address and email.
They did send me an offer. Before accepting that offer, I made sure they knew how much distance was actually involved And had no problem , supposedly, picking it up.
My apologies if I wasn't clear about that.
It was a piece I had several offers/ watchers on and interest in.
No I have not released the item or sold it. I go out of my way for my customers. Your response is pretty aggressive and not very nice. We are all in this together. Would you accept a return after ninety days?
I think I'll just remove the question and go about my happy day. Responses like this are really unsupportive.And you don't even have the facts straight. I really thought the ebay community would be a bit more friendly.
I certainly won't be asking any more questions of you. God bless.
house*of*paws
@belluscioformals
What sellers are usually advised to do when a buyer hasn't made any move to pick up an item is to check with the buyer after a few weeks to verify that they still are coming ... AND to give the buyer a deadline. If the buyer fails to pick up the item by the deadline ... the seller refunds the buyer (minus costs, if any) and relists the item.
I agree my Reply to you wasn't 'supportive' ... as I frankly was put off by the tone of your post ... especially your wishing the buyer 'a blessed day' while you keep the money and the item. That remark was almost guaranteed to elicit a hostile response.
I don't care if it's the buyer or seller posting the question ... I DO NOT defend either buyer or seller keeping both the item and money.
Would you accept a return after ninety days?
Probably not ... but this was NOT a 'return'. You still have the item and the money ... unless I completely misunderstood your post.
belluscioformals
OPI need to clarify this. The buyer purchased the item that was pick up only.
I emailed the buyer after purchase to be sure she could indeed pick it up. I told her I could give her as much time as she needed .
Over 3 months later I was notified by eBay that "my" cancellation request was denied because it was past the 30 days. The end.
I had never tried to cancel it, the buyer had not reached out to me in any way. I didn't understand what had happened. It was not something I initiated . It was the first I had heard that the buyer wasn't able to pick it up. It was the first time I was made aware that the buyer even wanted to cancel or wanted her money back.
Again , I reached out to her and again got no response! The purchase was around late August / early September and this was late November. Left in the dark with a notice from Ebay that made no sense and a buyer who would not respond, I just assumed it was over . Fast forward 4 months later March the buyer finally emails me and says can you cancel this I can't pick it up. This was the first time I had heard from her directly. It was 7 months after the purchase and 4 months after she tried to cancel through eBay without even contacting me first. I have perfect feedback. Obviously I take very good care of my customers. Had she reached out to me ,of course I would have canceled it. It's happened many times with Buyers who don't realize it's pick up only. Everyone on this thread who is attacking me like I'm a horrible seller either is not listening or I did not explain myself well in my first post. At that point I felt was ridiculous of her to ask given the circumstances. It was a very popular item. I had had tons of Watchers and a handful of offers. It was a 125$ item. I did not realist it.
So, she never actually responded to me for seven solid months. Only after seven solid months and an attempt to get her money back through eBay, without ever attempting to communicate with me and you think I should just send her the money? That's ridiculous. I decided to block her and move on.
house*of*paws
@belluscioformals
The facts … as well as your intentions … have been clear from the start. ‘Have a blessed day.’
albertabrightalberta
@belluscioformals
"The purchase was around late August / early September"
But we're now at 10-11 months later, the buyer still hasn't picked up the item and even if you wanted to, you're unable to issue a refund because that possibility is removed from ebay after 90 days.
So even if we go back to the buyer's first time contacting you in late November, by then it was too late for you to have canceled and issued a refund.
"I had never tried to cancel it, the buyer had not reached out to me in any way."
That was your mistake. You should have canceled within 90 days. Buyers and sellers don't have an infinite amount of time to take actions on purchases/sales/cancellations, etc.
"Obviously I take very good care of my customers."
I realize you want to be a good, responsive seller but taking good care of customers doesn't mean allowing yourself to be taken advantage of.
Although you didn't actually lose anything in this transaction, had you canceled, refunded and relisted the item, you wouldn't be having the ethical dilemma you're dealing with.
"Everyone on this thread who is attacking me like I'm a horrible seller either is not listening or I did not explain myself well in my first post."
You aren't being attacked nor being accused of being a "horrible seller" (your words) and you're taking the comments way too personally.
It's NOT personal. Again, ebay has timeframes during which various actions need to be taken and those you allege are critical of you are merely pointing our your mistakes, mistakes you made unintentionally and because you were trying to accommodate a buyer.
belluscioformals
OPAlso, The buyer has never reached out to me in seven months until yesterday.
They reached out to eBay after 90 days after purchase eBay denied the.Request and then let me know about afterwards.
grand-and-glorious-purpose
Yes, the money is yours to do with what you like.
I would BBL and forget about them.
You can refund them if you like but I certainly wouldn't, not after 7 months.
albertabrightalberta
If the buyer paid for the item and never picked it up, presumably you still have it and can relist and resell it.
Although you aren't obligated, I see no reason why you wouldn't issue a refund. You were charged FVF so you can retain that non-refundable amount.
kensgiftshop
Why would you not refund the buyer?