Item was sold and listed as New and Factory Sealed, Seller send me item not as described and used.
Hello, I recently bought an item from a seller. The listing showed that it was new and Factory Sealed. The photos the seller provided on the listing showed new and factory sealed. Seller also mentioned that it was new and factory sealed.
This is the image that was used on the listing.(It even shows the black microphone.)
This is the image that was used on the listing.
This is the image that was used on the listing.(It even shows the black microphone.)
This is the image that was used on the listing.(Tape in good condition.)
The item I got delivered was not as pictured nor as described in description. It is not new nor was it factory sealed. Both of the tape has been open and is crinkly, old, and dry, as if it has been open a long time before before it was shipped to me. Microphone is the wrong color. It is obviously used!
This is what I recieved.(No black microphone like in the photos before.))
This is what I recieved.(Tape has been open and is dry and crinkly.)
This is what I recieved.(Tape has been open.)
This is what I recieved.(This is what the micrphone should've been.)
This is what I recieved.(Both ends where tape is are open, crinkly, dry, and old.)
This is what I recieved.
Even the listing the seller selected that it was new under the "item specifics."
Even the listing the seller selected that it was new under the "item specifics."
The problem is that the seller is saying that the factory seal is on both ends and it was sealed when shipped. I pointed that it was not, it was already used and open when I received it and they are still being adamant about that. When I went to the return page I added photos that I took and the 3 photos from the listing to compare them. (I even mentioned it on the return page about this!)
Message exchange.
This is what I sent for the return page, this inlcudes photos I took and the last 3 pics are from the listing to compare to my photos.
Now I'm thinking and worrying that this seller did this on purpose to use their return rules in their description to steal 50% of my total purchase under the pretense that I did something to the item once I send it back. I've never had to deal with something like this before, never needed to return an item before and it's horrible! I just want a full refund since I never received the item that was listed but I don't know where I can get Ebay to step in because this is just disgusting how premeditated all of this is.
sapphire_studio
Reach out to Ebay on Facebook and report this all to them there.
You will get your 50% back one way or another. Keep trying ebay before you go to Paypal.
bluegreywolf
OPI was noticing that I couldn't dispute it on Paypal until I could get documentation that I already messaged and tried with Ebay. I'm thinking of just contacting Ebay by phone or chat tomorrow to hopefully help me on this. If not, I'll go with the dispute with Paypal.
nenu-5410
And you did. Simply upload this "Refund summary" from the seller @bluegreywolf as that documentation.
PayPal wants to see that you've already worked with eBay, and now you're moving on to PayPal. And you can do that right now, instead of waiting 2 weeks until Mar 14 to ask eBay to step in.
albertabrightalberta
The seller is wrong in multiple ways.
If you opened a NAD case, the refund must be 100%. (Did the seller pay for return shipping?)
Although the listing states, "ALL RETURNS WILL BE SUBJECT TO A RESTOCK FEE STARTING AT 15 PERCENT, AS LONG IT IS RETURNED IN THE SAME CONDITION AS RECEIVED.," restocking fees aren't allowed.
For TRS-plus sellers, they can deduct for items not returned in original condition, but that doesn't apply to NAD returns.
ETA: Based on the screenshot you showed @bluegreywolf , you can ask ebay to step in on March 14 and request the other 50%.
bluegreywolf
OPOnce I put in the return for the NAD case, I was provided a QR Code for the return at my local post office. And for Ebay to step in, it says to ask them "by Mar 14." Am I not able to open the case again before Mar 14? That's such weird wording by Ebay since it sounds like I have an allotted time before they dismiss the case.
nenu-5410
I'll admit that I'm not too bright, but isn't "Doesn't match description or photos"
under "Return Reason" actually the "the refund must be 100%" that you wrote? So how was the seller @albertabrightalberta able to deduct 50% plus keep the original shipping? Doesn't match description or photos is a NUD case so a 50% deduction is not possible, as it must be a 100% refund for all the NUD cases here on eBay.
The buyer paid -- $71.65
The item was -- $49.95 plus shipping plus sales tax
The seller deducted 50% -- ALTHOUGH THE BUYER OPENED A NAD CASE.
So the buyer was only refunded -- $27.34
way less than 50% of the -- $71.65 which they paid.
bluegreywolf
OPHello, I have an update on this. The seller used their arbitrary 50% refund rule under the pretense that I did something to the item. They only refunded me 50.01% and lied in their refund comment.
Now the problem that I'm having is I was trying to use the "Open a Case" but when I put in the comment for Ebay to step in it just send me back to the page on the photo here. I didn't receive any confirmation that Ebay was going to look into it. Is this because the refund went through? If that's the case then I might as well go with Paypal and dispute this because this is just not right.
papa486516
Exactly, this is happening more often now: If they are a top-ratted seller @bluegreywolf, they will parrot your complaint as their reason to keep 50% of your item cost AND YOUR ORIGINAL SHIPPING.
For example, $80 item plus $20 shipping
-- gets no refund of the $20 shipping
-- so only $40 (50% of $80) back.
So many buyers may get much less than 50% of their payment back.
First, don't talk to you seller again. KEEP YOUR RETURN TRACKING NUMBER. When the item arrives back and as feared, you get a 50% refund for the item and no refund of the original shipping, DON'T CLICK THE LINK to ask eBay for the remainder of your refund as if approved it will be paid by eBay, while the seller gets away (as premeditated) with your money, 50% plus shipping.
Instead, either file another Not As Described dispute here, or with your card issuer however your paid.
When you do, eBay will send an alert that your eBay return has closed, as you went to your payment institution.
Give your return tracking number to PayPal or your card issuer, and ask for the missing remainder of your payment. Again, if the seller contacts you now, do not respond. You returned the item as you received it, and tracking shows it was returned, so just wait for PayPal or your card issuer to get your refund for you.
krazzykats
Something else I noted that says it's a different item.
The seller's picture does not show the white anti-theft tabs.
Your pictures show anti-theft tags on the top and bottom of the box.
sapphire_studio
It's pretty easy for a buyer who only gets a 50% refund to contact eBay and get the rest of their refund. EBay usually fronts the money for the rest of the refund but they will keep track of how often that seller takes off 50%.
Just ship the item back with the return label they provide and if they do reduce your refund contact eBay about it.
bluegreywolf
OPI'm going to send it back tomorrow and hopefully things turn out well. Thank you.
soh.maryl
The way to handle an item that's not as described is clearly outlined in eBay's Money Back Guarantee. All you need to do is open an item not as described case. Do not just randomly return it without first opening a case. Seller is required to either send you a prepaid return label or reimburse you in advance for the return shipping.
Please read the MBG.
aprilmoviebuf2000
They did. It's in the post. What they are concerned about is the seller's 50% restocking fee.
fab_finds4u
They need to stop worrying their pretty little head.
The seller is allowed to deduct from a buyer's remorse return if it's returned in used or worse condition, missing tags, etc. For a not as described return they're supposed to refund in full. They can ask eBay for the rest of their refund if they don't.
They should report the seller for the 15% restocking fee.
soh.maryl
To the best of my knowledge, eBay forbids sellers from charging a restocking fee.