ebay doesn't protect the buyers anymore
I bought some pins on ebay and paid within 10 minutes. So, 2 days later the seller printed a tracking number for shipping the pins to me. I waited 6 days after that and the seller still hadn't shipped them. So, I told her I wanted a refund because I was sick of waiting for her to ship. She responded "I still have the item" (this is important later). I told her I still wanted a refund and she lied and said she had been blocked from her ebay account and couldn't print a label for shipping. She forgot she had already printed one that I could see. I told her I wanted a refund and that was it. I opened a case with ebay.
The next day she sent a refund to me. I decided to leave her negative feedback for lying to me and being argumentative. A couple days later she sent a message saying "I was going to regret leaving her negative feedback". The next day I looked and she left a response to my feedback saying that she had sent the pins to me, but I demanded a refund, which she did, and I kept the pins and the refund. Basically saying that I had stolen them.
The feedback and response (before I found out it was a female):
I wanted a refund because the seller took too long to ship. When I asked for the refund, this is what the seller said in PM's "I wasn’t in my account so i had no access to anything" and "Can’t ship it if i can’t print a label". I guess he forgot that he had already printed the label 6 days earlier. So, basically he lied about not being able to ship it that whole week. He doesn't want to take responsibility for his actions and just not shipping it because he didn't feel like it. Unacceptable.
80 Vintage Pinback Button LOT Superman, Batman, Political, Santa, Baseball, Rare (#356008092057)
Buyer: edtiques (4718)
US $107.50
Verified purchase
Past month
Reply from: landofthelost97. Left within past month.
Not sure what people get out of lying but, i was logged out of my account for 3 days and was able to ship the item after 4 days. (Which i don’t think is that long of a wait time) the buyer asked for a refund after the item was already shipped and i told them the item was on its way, they didn’t care and still demanded a re fund. I sent the refund and the person kept the item. They never returned the item, i lost around $100. Then they left a negative review.
I called ebay and talked until I was blue in the face to get her response taken down because it was an absolute lie. They saw the proof it was a lie and acknowledged it. But, they refused to remove it. This is the response I received:
Thank you for contacting back eBay Customer Service about the reply of the seller in your feedback to her. I understand that you want this to be removed because it is slanderous and illegal. My name is Ruby from eBay Customer Service, I'm here to assist you.
Ed, I appreciate your time and effort reaching us. I commend you for taking time out of your busy day to share your experience regarding this transaction. Since request for removal of negative feedback should be initiated by the seller, we’re unable to remove this since we’re unable to open her account for security purposes. Please note that removing the reply of the seller, will remove your feedback to her as well.
Ed, I would like to take this opportunity to thank you for allowing me to assist you. You are a valued member, and we only want nothing but the best for you. We want all of our members to enjoy the best possible experience on eBay. Thank you for being a part of our eBay community, we appreciate your business.
Thank you for contacting eBay Customer Service. Have a great day!
I have all the evidence showing she never sent the pins, including where she sold them on ebay a couple of weeks after that. I have all the documentation showing our messages back and forth, her response and ebay's response.
The response is still up in a forum available to be seen by the public.
I'm at a standstill with ebay. They won't allow me to message any higher ups. No accountability or transparency. I spent well over 16 hours on the phone with them.
I also allowed it to affect my health. I had been obsessing about it and a couple of weeks after I found out about it, I had a doctors appointment. My blood pressure was 200 over 102 which made my doctor concerned especially since I have a pacemaker. She put me on high blood pressure meds because of it.
I went a few weeks and my BP was 127 over 72 which is much, much better. I learned to let it go somewhat. I am very well aware of it, but not obsessing about it anymore.
I've been on ebay for 18 years and have done 1,000's of transactions. I've never gotten a negative or even a neutral feedback response. I try to do business the right way. When she slanders me on a site I do business on, I think it affects it. She's calling my character into question and it's in public view.
I think there's a law that protects social media sites from being sued. I believe if they don't know it has been posted, that would be the case. But, an intentional disregard of removing a slanderous statement should be cause for them to be responsible. Especially when they acknowledge it. At least I would think so.
The next day she sent a refund to me. I decided to leave her negative feedback for lying to me and being argumentative. A couple days later she sent a message saying "I was going to regret leaving her negative feedback". The next day I looked and she left a response to my feedback saying that she had sent the pins to me, but I demanded a refund, which she did, and I kept the pins and the refund. Basically saying that I had stolen them.
The feedback and response (before I found out it was a female):
I wanted a refund because the seller took too long to ship. When I asked for the refund, this is what the seller said in PM's "I wasn’t in my account so i had no access to anything" and "Can’t ship it if i can’t print a label". I guess he forgot that he had already printed the label 6 days earlier. So, basically he lied about not being able to ship it that whole week. He doesn't want to take responsibility for his actions and just not shipping it because he didn't feel like it. Unacceptable.
80 Vintage Pinback Button LOT Superman, Batman, Political, Santa, Baseball, Rare (#356008092057)
Buyer: edtiques (4718)
US $107.50
Verified purchase
Past month
Reply from: landofthelost97. Left within past month.
Not sure what people get out of lying but, i was logged out of my account for 3 days and was able to ship the item after 4 days. (Which i don’t think is that long of a wait time) the buyer asked for a refund after the item was already shipped and i told them the item was on its way, they didn’t care and still demanded a re fund. I sent the refund and the person kept the item. They never returned the item, i lost around $100. Then they left a negative review.
I called ebay and talked until I was blue in the face to get her response taken down because it was an absolute lie. They saw the proof it was a lie and acknowledged it. But, they refused to remove it. This is the response I received:
Thank you for contacting back eBay Customer Service about the reply of the seller in your feedback to her. I understand that you want this to be removed because it is slanderous and illegal. My name is Ruby from eBay Customer Service, I'm here to assist you.
Ed, I appreciate your time and effort reaching us. I commend you for taking time out of your busy day to share your experience regarding this transaction. Since request for removal of negative feedback should be initiated by the seller, we’re unable to remove this since we’re unable to open her account for security purposes. Please note that removing the reply of the seller, will remove your feedback to her as well.
Ed, I would like to take this opportunity to thank you for allowing me to assist you. You are a valued member, and we only want nothing but the best for you. We want all of our members to enjoy the best possible experience on eBay. Thank you for being a part of our eBay community, we appreciate your business.
Thank you for contacting eBay Customer Service. Have a great day!
I have all the evidence showing she never sent the pins, including where she sold them on ebay a couple of weeks after that. I have all the documentation showing our messages back and forth, her response and ebay's response.
The response is still up in a forum available to be seen by the public.
I'm at a standstill with ebay. They won't allow me to message any higher ups. No accountability or transparency. I spent well over 16 hours on the phone with them.
I also allowed it to affect my health. I had been obsessing about it and a couple of weeks after I found out about it, I had a doctors appointment. My blood pressure was 200 over 102 which made my doctor concerned especially since I have a pacemaker. She put me on high blood pressure meds because of it.
I went a few weeks and my BP was 127 over 72 which is much, much better. I learned to let it go somewhat. I am very well aware of it, but not obsessing about it anymore.
I've been on ebay for 18 years and have done 1,000's of transactions. I've never gotten a negative or even a neutral feedback response. I try to do business the right way. When she slanders me on a site I do business on, I think it affects it. She's calling my character into question and it's in public view.
I think there's a law that protects social media sites from being sued. I believe if they don't know it has been posted, that would be the case. But, an intentional disregard of removing a slanderous statement should be cause for them to be responsible. Especially when they acknowledge it. At least I would think so.
edtiques
12 comments
house*of*paws
Hi @edtiques
I just wanted to point out that the listing tells us the location of the ITEM … and not the seller.
Sellers living in foreign countries are allowed to use dropshippers in the US … so their listings would legitimately come up in searches for ‘US Only’ Item Locations.
Do you know whether the seller ships items from the US or Israel? If they have items shipped from the US … then their listings don’t violate eBay policy.
bonanza125
This is something you shouldn't have spent any time on. It's only a response to your feedback you left the seller. Calling customer service for an appeal really doesn't matter in this case. They can say one thing and do another. They are trying to get you off the phone. Just move on from this. You are raising your blood pressure over something that doesn't really matter.
edtiques
OPMy reputation matters to me. A LOT!!
bonanza125
I am viewing your feedback and you have zero negatives and zero neutrals. That is what matters as far as reputation when it comes your buying and selling reputation. You are a great buyer. That's your reputation. Just move on from this. I know for you personally this is difficult. I understand that but it's not going to hurt your reputation.
edtiques
OPPlease see my response to MonteCarlo
chevymontecarlo88
Your health is more important than your reputation.
Relax, drink plenty of water and do something nice for yourself.
edtiques
OPThank you for your response and advice. I'm not obsessing about it any more, but I can't and won't let it go. I don't want my name out there as a thief. Also, ebay needs to do the right thing! The seller should have been banned from ebay when she threatened me. And certainly when she committed an illegal act when she slandered me. Ebay knows it's a lie and allows this seller to continue on ebay. I don't know what it takes any more to get banned. If those don't do it, what will?
gone.c-33
First of all, it would be libel, not slander. But is it really libel if no one knows who the statement is about? Because as was previously mentioned, no one will know the statement is about you unless you tell them.
edtiques
OPPeople understand "slander" much more than "libel" which is why I chose to use the word slander. I know libel is written and slander is oral. The ebay rep used the word slanderous.
. It's not just about me at this point. I want people to see how ebay is covering up sellers bad behaviors. When they allow another poster to threaten and slander another member publicly, it's a real problem. This seller should have been banned from ebay, but they just let it slide.
This isn't the only thing ebay has refused to act on. I have my settings to "US only" when I search to buy something. I ended up buying some blacklights from a seller who was listed as living in Michigan. After I bought them, in the item details it had his address as Israel. He manipulated the search results so he would be included in the US search. That's a violation of ebay's policy. I reported him for doing that and the ebay rep just blew it off saying he really didn't do anything wrong and they weren't going to make him change to his real address.
Ebay is protecting it's sellers because they make ebay money, buyers don't. They don't care what's right or what's wrong as long as the money keeps flowing in.
bonanza125
Ebay will not ban a seller for leaving a reply to a negative feedback which was made against them. Ebay will however remove the feedback if they choose to. When I clicked on your "Feedback left section" right now I noticed the negative feedback you left the seller was removed. So unless I am missing something here your complaint has been resolved. The feedback response was removed.
"Ebay is protecting it's sellers because they make Ebay money, buyers don't. They don't care what's right or what's wrong as long as the money keeps flowing in."
Ebay is a business. They make money when buyers buy things and when sellers list. It's all business. Ebay does give buyers protection. When you make a purchase they have a 30 day money back guarantee. So if you buy something not as described you can return the item within 30 days and that's at the sellers expense. So yes Ebay does protect buyers.
buyselljack2016
@edtiques
Relax.
Only you and the seller know who the "reply" was left for. (ID is masked)
Until you posted here no one was the wiser.
Purchasing a label, and having access to ones account to print the label could be 2 different things.