Offers shown to interested buyers don't include sales tax - and cause transactions to be cancelled
When an offer is sent out to interested buyers of an item for sale on eBay, they are shown the basic price without any sales taxes added. This is both confusing and, for some countries (like the UK), not standard practice on pricing.
As a result, when the accept the offer, the price they thought was a good price suddenly becomes not so good as the sales tax gets added, and they feel misled and often will not go ahead with the purchase.
Given so many items that did not have sales tax added (such as "used" software licences being transferred) are now having sales tax added to them, for reasons I can't frankly understand, this is making selling such licences through eBay more and more difficult - and is upsetting purchasers by setting unrealistic expectations of the actual price that they have been offered for the item.
Surely, if sales tax is to be added, this information should be shown in any offer price sent out to the buyer so that they see the total expected price as well as the base price.
kh-stanley1
Hi everyone,
Due to the age of this thread, it has been closed to further replies. Please feel free to start a new thread HERE if you wish to continue to discuss this topic.
Thank you for understanding.
mallo-9289
I got hit with this yesterday on my most expensive Ebay purchase. For four years I have only purchased items <$30. The price advertised is the price I always pay. I've never seen taxes added before. I have never made an offer for which the price changed afterwards, but I've only made one or two offers before for relatively inexpensive items, no more than £20 price. Yesterday, however, I made an offer on an expensive second hand fountain oen, which the seller had advertised for over $500. I knew I'd have to pay +20% VAT on importing it to the UK, so I wanted to keep the price to what I could afford. I offered him $377, which equates to about £300. Allowing for +£60 VAT. However, when my offer was accepted and I went to pay it, the total amount due was $520, which was £420. I paid £120 more than the advertised offer price of £299. I was on the phone to Ebay for over an hour before they managed to explain what was happening, with sales taxes for both the US and UK being added, plus delivery even though it was advertised as free delivery. I will not bid on any more expensive US items. I have literally no idea what the price will actually be if they accept my offer and then I'm duty bound to pay.
buyselljack2016
Seems that should be a "rare" thing, as unless the buyer is new to purchasing, they should be aware that more charges will apply by the time they get their item.
lacemaker3
@andrewlmacaulay,
As you are based in the UK ... buyers who are searching on eBay UK www.ebay.co.uk will see the purchase price inclusive of the VAT because that is how it is supposed to be shown in the UK. There should not be any surprizes with either offers or at checkout.
If UK buyers are browsing on eBay.com, which is based in the USA, then the VAT is not included in the sales price because in the USA sales tax is supposed to be separate, and added as a line item at checkout.
andrewlmacaulay
OPThis may be true, but if you send out an offer to interested people (in the UK) then from what I understand from buyers in the UK the base price, not the VAT included price, is sent out to them - confusing them as they see a far lower price than they will actually pay. It is only AFTER the accept the offer that they see the actual VAT inclusive price.
albertabrightalberta
When a seller sends offers, they don't know who they're sending them to nor where the potential buyers are located. They have no idea whether it's US buyers, UK buyers or buyers anywhere else in the world. SIO (seller initiated offers go to people who may have looked at a listing, may have added that listing to their watch list or sometimes, they may not even have looked at the listing but still get an offer.
And every offer sent out clearly states that the offer price is from the item only.
lacemaker3
@andrewlmacaulay,
I do see something rather unusual (in my experience) on your two auction listings (see below). In the search results, your auction listings have a notation that "20% VAT will apply". This is only on the auctions, not on the fixed price listings.
I haven't seen this on listings on eBay UK before. I wonder if this is because you are registered as a private seller, not as a business seller? I believe that means you are not VAT registered, so you must be inputting your purchase prices as exclusive of VAT? When your purchase price is exclusive of VAT, then eBay has to add the VAT to the price as displayed, but perhaps they don't do that with auctions because they don't know what the final price might be.
I don't know how this would affect sending offers on your items. I'm not in a position to be able to investigate this, because even if I use a shipping address in the UK, I am not able to make an offer or go to the checkout page with any of your items. I get an error message that says you don't ship to West Yorkshire.
You might have a better chance to get an explanation if you ask about this on the eBay UK community board.
https://community.ebay.co.uk/
andrewlmacaulay
OPThanks
That's really odd - as the only exclusions I have for these are PO Boxes and Africa!
lacemaker3
Your listings are only showing shipping to the UK. There are also a few exclusions, which are pretty much moot as they are not in the UK. Since you don't offer shipping to the USA, I was using a made-up address in the UK, to see how the VAT was displayed. This address has worked in the past, but not this time.
This error message has been reported before on eBay.com. It's a known glitch, and I'm not aware that an explanation has been found for it. But I don't believe this has anything to do with the issue you asked about.
If the only listings that are affected are the auction listings, which don't appear to show VAT inclusive in the displayed bidding prices, then I think that the issue is probably happening because eBay can't display VAT-inclusive prices in the bidding process. Perhaps because they have no way to know if the bidders will need to pay VAT at all, or at what rate, because the shipping address is not available until after the auction ends.
lacemaker3
@andrewlmacaulay,
I put several of your listings into my watchlist, to see what would happen. I received an offer on one of them, a fixed price/BIN listing, which does show the VAT separately from the purchase price. Could you confirm if, as a private seller, you list your items with or without the VAT included in the purchase price?
This may depend on which eBay website the buyers are on when they view the offer. When I view the same offer on eBay.com, the VAT is not shown, even though the primary shipping address on this account is currently in the UK. This is the standard way to show prices on eBay.com.
If you want to send an offer on this auction listing, https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/335454562862 we can figure out if auction-format listings are different. (I won't buy it of course.
lacemaker3
It appears that it is only the "free flat rate freight" postage items that cause this error message. When I added a physical item to my cart as well, then I was able to go to the checkout page.
However, it appears that eBay is not adding VAT to either of these purchases, as the purchase prices have not been increased. So I would not be charged VAT if I purchased the Plugin alliance license as a BIN, but I would be charged VAT if I purchased it as an offer.
I guess the rules about when VAT has to be charged are more complicated that I thought.
1786davycrockett
@andrewlmacaulay
"Given so many items that did not have sales tax added (such as "used" software licences being transferred) are now having sales tax added to them, for reasons I can't frankly understand"
Some states charge sales tax on services, such as software licenses.
And most if not all states charge sales tax on used items.
Individual states legislate what items may be charged sales tax, and not the Federal government.
Hope that answers your questions regarding sales taxes on services and used items.
kensgiftshop
The tax can't be figured until Ebay now where the item is being shipped to.
Buyers should know their tax rates and should know about what to expect on the taxes.
slippinjimmy
If you are sending an offer to a US buyer (and others) there is no way to know the Sales Tax amount until the item is purchased and the delivery address is confirmed.
Unless things have changed the VAT rates in Europe are the same for anyone in a specific country. In the USA there are literally thousands of different rates dependent on the actual delivery point.
In some places in the US your rate could be different than the rate on the other side of the street if it happens to be in a different municipality. The US does not have a standard rate that covers the country, not even a standard rate that covers individual States, even at the County level rates can be different.