All PostsDiscussionsBlogsIdeasQuestions
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
  •                    
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               
Discussions
eBay Community logo
  • Home
  • News & Updates
  • Buying & Selling
    • Buying
    • Selling
    • New to selling on eBay
    • Seller Tools
    • Shipping
    • Returns
    • eBay Advertising
    • Payments
    • Mobile Apps
  • Explore Categories
      • eBay Motors
      • Electronics
      • Collectibles & Art
      • Home & Garden
      • Clothing, Shoes & Accessories
      • Toys & Hobbies
      • Sporting Goods
      • Books, Movies & Music
      • Health & Beauty
      • Business & Industrial
      • Jewelry & Watches
      • Specialty Services
      • eBay Partner Network
      • Accessibility
      • eBay Developers Program
      • eBay Cafe
      • eBay Live
      • Community Mentors
    • Ask a Mentor
  • About
    • About the Community
    • Share Community Platform Feedback
    • Report eBay Technical Issues
    • About eBay
  • Community Events
    • Events
    • Seller Circle Hosts
    • Seller Circles
  • eBay Help
    • eBay CategoriesChevronRightIcon
    • Collectibles & ArtChevronRightIcon
    • Postcard Collectors GroupChevronRightIcon
    Depressing postcards on eBay

    Too often, I come upon a postcard listing on eBay that just makes me feel sad.

     

    Listed as a “Buy it now” for $199.  Condition - “ Minor wear and tear on front”  See photos.

    Card probably has a value of $20-30.

    IMG_6450.jpeg

    gloopy01
    gloopy01
    14585View listings
    Posted 7 months ago·Last reply 7 months ago
                                           
             
    13 comments

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       
                   
    deltilogical

    deltilogical

    ·7 months ago
    10679View listings

    IN this case the videos trailed the market - Halloween cards are extremely popular and values continue to remain solid.  

                                           
    gurlcat

    gurlcat

    ·7 months ago
    1969View listings

    Vintage Halloween greeting cards were one of the things I remember on numerous Youtube 'BOLO for eBay reselling' type videos when I first started selling here.  I guess those videos have the potential of fetching the creator more money from views on Youtube than they could make with the limited number of such BOLO items that they can find and resell themselves.  But the problem it so often causes is viewers doing exactly as instructed, being on the lookout, finding those items, and flooding eBay with them, so that scarcity is no longer part of the demand equation, and value drops drastically.  

    The seller of this^ card probably saw one of those videos and thought they found gold, even with the damage, and they don't know how to research actual recent comps. 

                                           
    deltilogical

    deltilogical

    ·7 months ago
    10679View listings

    The sale prices of certain Halloween cards the past couple of months have been outstanding.  If a good copy was $2000, wouldn't this be worth $199?   Not to me, but maybe to someone.  Personally I'd auction it starting at 99 cents.   

                                           
    gloopy01

    gloopy01

    OP7 months ago
    14585View listings

    Well, cards that sell in an auction setting at a high price are rare and highly sought.

     

    This card is neither.  It shows up fairly regularly on eBay

                                           
    tobaccocardyahoo

    tobaccocardyahoo

    ·7 months ago
    5503View listings

    The condition of this card is depressing.

     

    It is solely suitable as a placesaver in a collection or for use by a scrapbooker.

     

    No way I would have that card in my store. And I have some placesavers in my store.

                                           
    gloopy01

    gloopy01

    OP7 months ago
    14585View listings

    I understand your

                                           
    gloopy01

    gloopy01

    OP7 months ago
    14585View listings

    I do have placeholders, but not $199 placeholders. 🙄

                                           
    krazzykats

    krazzykats

    ·7 months ago
    5712View listings

    Could just be a signpost so people look at it, then look at the other listings the seller has. 

     

    You looked, right? 

     

    So did I, but I'm not into collecting those types of damaged items regardless of perceived value.

     

    ᓚᘏᗢ

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

                                           
    gloopy01

    gloopy01

    OP7 months ago
    14585View listings

    When I see a card in that condition, listed for such a price, I do NOT want to see the sellers other cards.  No thanks. Hard pass.😬😒

     

    With the mass exodus of postcard sellers and buyers on eBay over the last few years, this type of listing really doesn’t help.

                                           
    gloopy01

    gloopy01

    OP7 months ago
    14585View listings

    Pricing and condition.  Minor wear and tear?!  

    Absolutely absurd.

                                           
    t*jack

    t*jack

    ·7 months ago
    1773View listings

    Based on the pricing? If so I agree 100%

                                           
    lbigfoot

    lbigfoot

    ·7 months ago
    1239View listings

    The title is not very good. 
    I buy and sell depressing postcards showing pre Nazi period antisemitism.

     

    I would say that the correct title for this topic would be dubious items or sellers

     

    Lawrence

                                           
    gurlcat

    gurlcat

    ·7 months ago
    1969View listings

    Depressing?????

                                           
                                                                                     
    •                                                              
    •                                                              
    •