Made offer, ebay automatically charges credit card !!@$#!$"#
I do not understand how making an offer can give ebay the right to charge my cc if seller accepts. That should never be allowed and I would never agree to that. I decide when my card is charged!
Consider if your making offers (not bids) on multiple same items, or maybe items that are close to the same, old model newer model, trying to get a good price, and three offers are accepted, eBay is going to CHARGE YOUR CARD WITHOUT YOUR AUTHORIZATION for all 3 of same item, buying all three of the same item. That is ridiculously stupid policy change. I don't see how this is possible. No wear did I agree to that and it happened today. Checked my offers and one already shipped without my knowledge and the newer model was the better deal for only a little more money.
Buyer beware! This is **bleep**!
I still don't even see where it says this on the offer side.
The reason ebay told me is because people make offers and don't pay. That is **bleep** also, a simple communication "I retract my offer, or just purchased elsewhere message should be good. Cause this is an offer not a bid! "make offer!"
Anyone else have thoughts on this!
kh-urvashi
Hi everyone,
Due to the age of this thread, it has been closed to further replies. Please feel free to start a new thread if you wish to continue to discuss this topic.
Thank you for understanding.
terrycece62
If in fact you are making serious offers that you intend to pay for this autopay policy should be a good thing imo normally less hassel
only drawback I have experienced with this policy is that I may miss an item I want if my account does not have the funds available for a day or two. I do not get the normal leeway that eBay allows with other payments.
If this a not acceptable to you do not make an offer it is your choice you ca buy it now or place a bid depending on the listing options
steady2304
@vaz019
You are the exact type of buyer that this system was put in place for by eBay. You do not get to make multiple offers to different sellers of the same or similar items and then if the seller accepts your offer you pick just one and don't pay the others.
When you make an offer to a seller you are entering into a binding contract should said seller accept your offer. Make an Offer is not a comparison tool for you to use to decide which seller to buy your item from.
Thank you very much for posting as I can see you being added to a bunch of sellers Best Buddies Lists. You are exactly the type of buyer that needs to be removed from eBay.
vaz019
OPNot sure how you brought me back into this a year later. You needed to read all of the posts. Later I realize the sellers position when as a seller you would only be able to accept one offer then the item would be froze waiting for buyer to pay. If buyer wouldn't, then seller loses out on other potential offers and time. That seems like why the policy changed.
Unfortunately, the first time a buyer doesn't catch the small line on the top about your card getting charged automatically you get upset. It's there though? Since that day I changed how I did offers pretty simple.
Don't put me in the category of people that bid/offer on stuff and don't pay. That is not me.
I have 100% approval rating. Been a member since 2003 +20 years now. I don't see why I should be removed, that's pretty harsh.
Remind you that ebay is still shopping especially with buy it now and make offer! .... anytime sellers have the same item, buyers then shop.
It just a communication problem in the end on how offers work in ebay.
Jeez they way some of you sellers would have it I should get charged if I Iook at the item or put it in my cart for later.
bonjourami
All buyers have a 100% approval rating because sellers can only leave buyers positive fb.So its really nothing special.
avastcosmicarena
This is a horrible policy. PayPal Credit is currently doing a promotional offer that allows 0% APR for 12-24 months, and I wanted to take advantage of it, but then was hit with an automatic payment unexpectedly, immediately charging me and not allowing me to take advantage of the PayPal Credit promotional offer that I wanted to use. This is a horrible policy for buyers and needs to change.
anteek-r
Absolutely agree! This just happened to me as well! I am incredulous that they can do this . I wonder when this policy was started because first time ever for me that this has happened, How can we issue our complaints?..what channels do we go through?
25thstreetpeddler
Then buy something else! I have an entire eBay shop of things for sale. 😉
evry1nositswindy
@mysharona714 It is being rolled out, so not everyone is included just yet. I agree with you 100%.
mattum-0
That is literally what the offer you made is for..."if you are willing to lower your price to this, then I will buy it from you" Not "then I will think about it some more" It is an official offer. Not a DM about a hypothetical situation.
Thank goodness ebay doesn't allow offers to be an annoying way to kick the tires. It's bad enough how low most of them are compared to asking price.
ajs_coins_and_alchemy
...you've been a member for over 20 years... 😳
ajs_coins_and_alchemy
You apparently don't understand the concept of "make an offer". If you want to know if a seller will take a certain price, message them. If you're willing to buy the item at that price and will commit, make the offer.
You should not be making ANY offers you don't plan on paying for. You have literally spelled out the reason for this policy change. You have just explained yourself to be the reason for the policy change. So thank you for making it more difficult for the rest of us who actually pay for our items.
Also love how you claim its without your authorization, when you authorized it prior to confirming/submitting the offer
"The reason ebay told me is because people make offers and don't pay" ... you = people.
captsilvuhkokk
indeed. esp where shipping is involved ebay helpfully pays full shipping on all the items involved if there are multiples. you have anywhere from 4 to 30 days to pay contingent on seller. on a bonafide auction. why is an 'offer' paid upfront . what a jerk move by ebay i guess it wants maximum fees.. as soon as possible. not a good sign for a mere 20% it will screw you out of combined shipping savings worth a lot more to you
buyselljack2016
guess what? Some buyers are also in the "test" where preauthorizing is needed before "bidding" on auctions, and payment is automatic if they win.
evry1nositswindy
No problem. Only sellers would know this.
captsilvuhkokk
ohh.. you special elite sellers ..said NO one ever
katz.paw
My thoughts are that I don't understand what your complaint is.
Common sense is that an offer is an agreement that you will buy it if they meet your offer price.
The seller accepts your offer, and then you complain about that?
Also you complain because they ship it quickly?
Advice: Don't offer unless you intend to buy it. Then be happy they ship it fast.
captsilvuhkokk
its clear that you have given this much thought.
station40rescue407
Ok my complaint is this lets say you see an item for $6.99 and you put an offer in for $6.00 then the person turns around and declines your offer then you say forget it bit this person went ahead anyway charge your credits card for $6.86 so is this allowed in ebay those are the rules the seller declines your offer but 2 days later the seller charges your credit card for $6.00
albertabrightalberta
It doesn't work that way.
Your card is there for payment if the seller accepts your offer. When the seller ignores or declines, you don't get charged. (And for the record, it's not the seller who charges your card; it's ebay and again, only happens if you and the seller agree to a price.)
25thstreetpeddler
No, doesn't work that way. What you describe is not even possible. Once a seller declines a buyer's offer, or a buyer declines a seller's offer, it's over - no further actions take place, automatically or otherwise. There's no charge until after an offer is accepted by the seller. And in reverse, if the seller makes an offer to a buyer and the buyer accepts, the buyer is prompted to checkout and pay for the item. Now, the buyer or seller could opt to make a counter offer. But again, unless the party receiving the counter offer accepts it, the deal is dead in the water. No further action occurs.
klhmdg
@vaz019 - my thoughts on this is, you are the type of buyer that made this change happen.
Every "offer" and "bid" is binding.
Its not "offer" and the pick which you really want.
Doing what you are doing causes multiple sellers to stop and look to see IF they can accommodate your offer.
If all 3 approve the offer, then they sit and wait for you to decide if you want to pay for any.
If you chose 1 to pay then the other 2 have their items off market for 4 days until they can give you an unpaid item strike.
Thanks for posting!
mtgraves7984
Thanks for posting!
@klhmdg
Whoops! There goes another ruBBer tree pLant!!!
vaz019
OPOffer and bid are not the same. Offer is in a for sale scenario, a bid is for an auction. Two completely different processes. Bid is intant to pay and someones bid will end it. An Offer starts the process.
If you as a seller can only accept one offer, as you say then your "item is off the market" then there is your problem. I dont sell a lot.
You should be able to accept multiple offers and who pays first gets the prize. You say it's a buyer payment problem, But you don't have to reply to an offer either. So when that happens I'm not going to stop shopping....and wait for 4 days.
That's what it is shopping
captsilvuhkokk
derka and derka are not the same derka derka!
evry1nositswindy
This practice of making several offers and only accepting the best one and not paying for the others is the very reason eBay implemented this new payment plan. When you make an offer, it is an intent to buy. Far too many buyers do not pay after a seller accepts their offer. Then they must wait 4 days to cancel the transaction before relisting.
captsilvuhkokk
not true, this is a 'folk tale'
evry1nositswindy
Not sure what you think is a folk tale, but everything I typed is true. As a seller for 10+ years, I know how sales work.
zgnisaer
Instead, you can work it in reverse like in the real world.
This has the added benefit you have sellers that are actually awake, and you can buy just the best choice, more than one since all of the prices were lowered, or all of them.
graceprof_67
Are you so ignorant that you have not heard of making a deal. That is literally how the business industry works. You choose the lowest price unless you are an entitled wealthy person. If you price too high it sucks to suck.
albertabrightalberta
In addition to what was stated above, I'll add another point.
Whether being charge immediately or making payment later, when making an offer, you are agreeing to complete the purchase if your offer is accepted. And since so many buyers weren't following through on their obligations, ebay made it so now, sellers will be paid and can avoid non-payers.
vaz019
OPI understand, so let me ask this, the way this sounds is that a seller can only accept one offer. That is why you all are saying this is a buyer/paying problem. Sorry I don't sell much.
If you could approve multiple offers then the first person who pays gets the prize. You snooze you loose. This sounds like once you accept an offer the item is off the market, but it shouldn't be until payment is received
evry1nositswindy
@vaz019 The system doesn't work that way. Once an offer is accepted, it is off the market. Then we have to wait 4 days before we can cancel the transaction and relist. If we cancel before that, someone else can buy it, but the original buyer could also pay. This creates 2 sales for 1 item. Nightmare! Then the seller is penalized for cancelling a paid order. Sorry, but this is the way it works. I actually like your idea better--first person to pay gets it, but we don't have a screen for that. Just paid and ready to ship or unpaid waiting for payment.
vaz019
OPAhh hah. That makes sense now.
That's messed up! No wonder.
Appreciate the info
captsilvuhkokk
methinks the problem is that paying for all items in advance without any say so from the same seller upfront with full shipping negates a combined shipping discount
smart sellers could alleviate this by simply refunding excess shipping after paying actual cost, but wont. they jealously covet every dollar .. yes dollars sometimes as much as ten on a item selling for half as much ...as if they earned it or something. shipping has become a 'profit margin sideline' i give negative feedback for this action, even if the item was as expected
albertabrightalberta
You are assuming a lot.
If I have a buyer who purchases and pays for more than one item, I combine the items, ship in one package and issue a partial refund for a portion of the overpayment in shipping costs.
mysharona714
Hi, I see you posted this in September, but just last week I had a buyer make an offer on my item and never completed payment. This has been the third time a buyer has recently done this on one of my listings, so I don’t know if that’s true, but I hope they do change it because it is extremely frustrating for sellers and not fair to others who are interested in the item! If you make an offer you are committing to purchase the item, so they SHOULD automatically charge the buyer!
albertabrightalberta
No buyer would have the opportunity to do this to me 3 times because if there's an NPB, I block them then cancel for non-payment. It will never happen a second time (or third).
"Do it to me once, shame on you. Do it to me twice, shame on me."
americanresalecompany
Prior to you sending any offers, there is a prompt that you must agree to in order for ebay to charge your card upon acceptance of an offer. You may have agreed without reading it in full. Every buyer receives this at some point when adding payment details or when trying to purchase items.
I hope that is helpful.
You can also reach out to the seller to cancel but some sellers will not extend that as it is not required of sellers to do. That would be your next option.
letamarie1979
This is not my experience. I just made an offer and within a half an hour of that I got a message from Ebay that my card was charged as the seller accepted my offer. I did not get the option of completing the buy myself. While I am not a fan of this and this is the first time I have encountered this in all my many years of buying on Ebay, I am now aware and will decide if I even want to make an offer from now on.