FeeBay, fees on fees on fees...
Summary: justintymeecv expressed frustration with eBay's fee structure, highlighting how fees are calculated on sales tax and shipping costs, impacting thin profit margins for low-value sports card sales. They emphasize the crucial role sellers play in eBay's success and propose a more reasonable fee structure focused on the actual sale value. In response, kensgiftshop asked about payment processing fees, while shire123 and shado-x pointed out sellers' acceptance of the fees and suggested USPS is more to blame. 1786davycrockett appreciated eBay managing complex tax payments, seeing it as a convenience.
I’ve been selling on eBay for a couple of years now, primarily sports cards, and there is one thing that continues to frustrate me: it feels like there is a fee attached to nearly every part of a sale.
Let’s break it down.
There’s the final value fee. There are shipping costs. There can be promoted listing fees. Then there’s the part that really bothers me: eBay states that its final value fee is calculated on the total amount of the sale, which can include the item price, shipping and handling, sales tax, and other applicable amounts. [ebay.com]
Think about that for a minute.
As a seller, I don't collect sales tax for myself. I don't get to keep it. Yet the amount collected can still increase the total used to calculate my selling fee.
For low-dollar sports cards, the situation can become almost laughable. I can sell a card for $1.29 with $0.73 shipping and end up pocketing around $0.28 after the associated costs of the transaction. At that point, you have to ask yourself whether selling inexpensive cards individually is even worth the time required to photograph, list, package, and ship them.
And low-dollar sales are especially vulnerable to fixed charges. eBay currently states that the per-order portion of its final value fee is $0.30 for orders of $10 or less and $0.40 for orders over $10. [ebay.com]
Promoting listings can push the cost even higher. eBay's Promoted Listings General program charges an advertising fee based on a percentage of the total sale amount for a qualifying sale. That total can include the item price, shipping, taxes, and other applicable amounts. [ebay.com]
That's where I believe the system has gone too far.
I have no problem paying eBay a reasonable fee for providing a marketplace and helping me sell my card. That's the cost of doing business.
What I have a problem with is repeatedly applying percentages and charges to money that doesn't represent the actual value of the item I'm selling.
If I sell a $19.99 sports card, why should fees associated with that transaction be calculated using amounts beyond the $19.99 value of my card?
Charge me a reasonable percentage of the item. I'm fine with that.
But charging based on shipping and even taxes makes sellers feel as though every additional dollar moving through the transaction represents another opportunity to collect a fee.
Sellers are the inventory
Here's the bigger issue.
Without sellers, there is no eBay marketplace.
We buy the inventory. We photograph it. We research it. We create the listings. We answer questions. We package the products. We ship them. We deal with returns and customer issues.
The millions of items sellers list are a major reason buyers visit the marketplace in the first place.
So why shouldn't the fee structure reflect the importance of keeping those sellers profitable?
I understand that eBay is a business and needs to make money. I'm not asking for the platform to operate for free. I'm asking for a fee structure that feels proportional to the service being provided.
For sports-card and TCG sellers in particular, margins can already be thin. Once platform fees, promotional expenses, postage, packaging and the original cost of the card are considered, an apparently profitable sale can quickly become a break-even transaction.
For example, a third-party trading-card fee calculator illustrates how a 13.25% percentage fee plus a per-order charge and a 5% promoted-listing rate can make the platform-related cost of a $100 transaction approach 19% before postage, supplies or the seller's cost of acquiring the card. [sellerfeecalc.com]
Increase the advertising rate and the economics become even harder to justify.
I'm not against fees. I'm against fees on fees on costs.
That's an important distinction.
I am perfectly willing to pay a marketplace for connecting me with millions of potential buyers.
Charge me for selling the item.
But why should the percentage be calculated on sales tax that isn't my revenue?
Why should shipping collected to get the buyer's card to them increase the amount used to calculate my final value fee?
Why should sellers increasingly feel pressured to pay additional advertising fees just to make their listings competitive?
At some point, sellers start asking a very simple question:
Is the marketplace still working for me, or am I working for the marketplace?
That's where I am today.
Closing my store and moving hundreds or thousands of listings somewhere else isn't easy. That inconvenience is honestly one of the reasons I haven't done it. But there are other platforms competing for sports-card and TCG sellers, and every additional fee makes those alternatives increasingly attractive.
I don't expect eBay to eliminate seller fees.
I expect the fees to make sense.
Charge a reasonable fee on the product I actually sold. Give sellers a reason to grow their businesses on the platform rather than making successful sellers eventually look for the exit.
Because ultimately, the sellers supplying the inventory are a fundamental part of what gives the marketplace its value.
Take care of those sellers, and they'll continue bringing inventory and buyers to the platform.
Keep squeezing every possible percentage out of each transaction, and eventually sellers will decide that the reach eBay provides simply isn't worth the price of admission.
janet9988
F
Exactly why are you selling such low cost items and blaming eBay??????
1786davycrockett
@justintymeecv
I would rather pay eBay the additional fees, rather than have to figure out where to pay the thousands of additional individual state, metro, district, "special service," delivery, etc taxes and fees, scattered across all 50 states, as well as wasting hours every day filling out hundreds of different weekly, monthly, quarterly, semi-annual and annual financial reports to all of those individual agencies on my own.
To me, that's quite a bargain.
shado-x
After all that writing, you could have listed 10 items and made money. Again, your complaints should be focused on the US Postal Service, they are the gougers, not eBay.
shire123
Ebay is very upfront what gets "fee'd". You agree to that when you start selling.
You may not like it but it is what it is and almost all sellers here accept that.
kensgiftshop
Did you have a problem with it when Pay Pal was processing payments and doing the same?