Selling silver coins on ebay
My family member has aaked me to sell a considerable amount of silver coins for him on ebay. My question is:
Is sales tax applicable in all states?
Will I need to report the sales on my year end tax return?
Would it be a capital gains tax? Does anyone, with some experience, care to weigh in on this subject? thank you in advance.
kikimosgold
6 comments
kikimosgold
OPThank you all for your response! You have given me a lot to think abot! Good day!
ajs_coins_and_alchemy
@kikimosgold
EBay based Coin dealer (buyer/seller) here. What are you selling? Feel free to message me.
Sales tax aren't your problem. They are the buyers problem. Some states charge sales tax, some don't. What hajnick said is correct but kinda irrelevant about sales tax because it quite frankly isn't your problem.
Yes you pay capital gains / income tax.
Edited to Add: It will be reported to the IRS for capital gains tax. However it isn't YOUR tax liability if you are selling for someone else. When I sell on consignment, I don't pay income tax because I "sold it for what I bought it for" because I pay out the entirety of the revenue. So if I sold it for $100 and netted $85 after fees and shipping, i paid out $85 to my family member, so the $85 in reportable income is null as that was my "cost of goods".
That's how I operate at least. The basic principle stands, my way of explaining it just makes sense in my head.
hajnick
Most states do not require paying a sales tax on selling coins. However, eBay will frequently levy a sales tax and complications begin after that… unfortunately. I have avoided selling coins on eBay because of that. Luckily, I have found two dealers that are great. Also I have avoided a dozen of other dealers in my area that are literally sickening. My biggest problem on eBay is the sales tax levied. Most of what I sell is at a loss so I don’t even bother with Schedule D. If you do not have a record of how much your family member paid for the coins, it will be difficult to figure out if you’re taking a loss or making a profit. In most cases, sellers take a loss, generally, in my opinion. Filing Schedule D can be complicated. Since you likely will be taking a loss, I suggest you forget filing Schedule D. Just because you are selling coins and you will be encountering difficulty trying to find out how much your family member paid for the coins. Selling silver coins now will be most favorable IF you find an appropriate honest coin dealer. Many dealers on the other hand can be far worse than eBay.
maxine*j
The long-winded answer:
You do not need to worry about which states tax what, because eBay collects and remits all sales taxes for you. You must be very careful in listing the coins to get them in the right categories, because that affects whether or not sales taxes are applicable.
eBay will issue a 1099K for the sales, with a copy to the IRS, so you will have to file a tax return that accounts, clearly and in detail, for the fact that only a portion of that income is yours; otherwise, the full net amount will be considered yours.
Usually, holdings in precious metals are taxed as capital gains when they're sold. However, that can also depends upon the nature of the silver coins (collectible versus bullion, for example), why the silver coins were purchased in the first place, and how long they were held, among other things.
If they are not taxed as capital gains but as business income, the allowable expenses differ, by the way, and that is something else you need to know about.
In other words, you need to consult a tax expert on all this. It can get a bit complicated.
In general, selling for others has a lot of problems. The first problem is that people often have an unrealistic idea of the values involved, so emotional drama develops. Then there are questions such as: "How will you and the seller handle the refund when a buyer waits 179 days and then files a claim with PayPal or does a credit card chargeback?" Are you willing to wait 180 for your money? If not, will you guarantee to cover the loss if this happens? How will you guarantee that? Or, "Who eats the loss if a buyer gets a refund but the returned item is damaged or a sorry substitute is sent?" And those are just a couple of issues, out of several equally serious ones.
I think you need to think long and hard about this, and get some good advice on the tax situation, too.
-
soh.maryl
To the best of my knowledge, if you sell on your account for another party, that income will be YOUR income and will be included when you do your Federal tax return.
Plus there are other considerations, YOU, as the seller, will be responsible for refunding in the case of an item not as described case or not received case. Paypal gives buyers 180 days to open cases, so you could be refunding for 6 months or so after the sale.
If I were in your shoes and considering this, I would certainly be soliciting replies from anyone who has actually done this, how they did it and how it worked out for them. One thing I need to mention, but I'm sure you've considered this, is that any bad feedback you get for any reason is yours if you do this on your own account.
kensgiftshop
Not all states have sales tax.
As far as the income, yes, you'll have to report it.
If you sell more then $600, Ebay will also report it.
Have you signed up for Managed Payments, providing a checking account and your SSN?