Seller selling fake Silver Eagle coins
I recently ordered 10 Silver eagle coins. Today I removed some of the coins from the plastic round containers they were in and could immediately tell they were fakes. Coins were too thick, to wide, weighed to little and the details were off. I just requested a refund from ebay and sent the coins back to the seller. Also, I see that the seller sold 138 lots of the same counterfeit coins. Is Ebay going to cancel the sellers account. Is Ebay going to notify all of the buyers to check their coins. If not, shame on ebay.
I spent a good amount of time on ebay today trying to figure out how to get hold of a live person at ebay to no avail.
cphwebmaker
71 comments
kh-stanley1
Hi everyone,
Due to the age of this thread, it has been closed to further replies. Please feel free to start a new thread HERE if you wish to continue to discuss this topic.
Thank you for understanding.
candkfix
Ebay does NOT care. They allow this fraud as they make money from it. However, if you were to try and sell these coins, knowing they are fake, you'd be removed from Ebay and the FBI would pay you a visit. You, like me, are stuck with the fakes we unknowingly purchased and cannot get rid of them.
gbowland1974
I also received fake counterfeit US Silver Eagles. Treasury Dept should investigate
tim24ch_3
No eBay hasn’t done nothing to stop the sale of counterfeit coins I have reported 20 different sellers selling counterfeit coins and they said they weren’t doing anything wrong eBay doesn’t care about us just money.
candkfix
What would be the result if one of us listed our known fake silver eagle coins for sale at say 5 dollars each? We obviously didn't make them, we are simply listing what we have from fraudulent sellers that we have dealt with on their own site. We can in fact prove we bought fakes and would be selling them as such for others to use as decoy coins for thieves. I wonder if there's any legal or criminal issues for doing it. Any media attention from any intent to ban or prosecute would blow the lid right off ebay and China’s fraudulent operation.
krazzykats
Selling fake or counterfeits is still illegal.
No matter where/who you purchased them from.
18 U.S. Code § 485 - Coins or bars | U.S. Code | US Law | LII / Legal Information Institute
Cornell Law School
mojito4u
eBay is still happy aiding and abetting Chinese counterfeit bullion sellers. Report every listing and they just reply that it doesn't bother them at all to get a percentage off the scammers sales.
stephenmorgan
Did you actually get a reply from eBay that stated "it doesn't bother them at all to get a percentage off the scammers sales" or something similar to this? Can you post a copy of their response to you?
These fraudulent items should be reported to the FBI
Internet Crime Complaint Center
You can do it here
https://www.ic3.gov/
A complaint to the Secrete Service would help also.
If there are enough complaints made, it will be investigated.
andrewjsantucci
I have had THE SAME PROBLEM. Like tell me you are selling silver eagles under spot and I can actually guarantee malfeasance. BE VERY CAREFUL OUT THERE PEOPLE not sure how ebay can effectively prevent this though either. there has to be some sort of way to combat those listings. As of right now, 10/10/24 at 10:40am there are scam listings up for eagles. I wish i could report or something without having to buy
benhog82
I recently recieved fake 2024 silver eagles from ebay. The way I could tell was they failed the ping test, and the missing tooth security feature was in the 2023 location. This proves that the scammers were slightly behind in their design copying as they used the previous years design with this years date. If they had been dated 2023 they would be more convincing. The design details were also lower resolution compared to real coins.
selsa84
Here's another, American Silver eagle for 11$. What's really odd is the seller has 203 total feedbacks at 91% but yet has 19 negs.
 
drey983
Walmart Website is selling fake Silver eagles
brightstar7
Use the "Report Item" link on any listing that looks to be too good to be true scam item. If you have been scammed use the "item not as described" to get refund. Also as soon as possiby after discovering scam items, leave Negative feedback describing what you found as people buying coins are usually smart enough to check feedback. If they see negative feedback on one listing it will tip them off to other scam sellers. Since the sellers have low feedback numbers they probably sell a large batch of coins then stop using or cancel the account and open a new account. They may even put out some real coins to first buyers to get a few positive feedback then after this start selling the fakes.
rob_414
Over the last few days I have reported numerous examples of the fraud to Ebay. Not getting much from them other than AI looked into it.
I notified the local branch of the Secret Service - this is counterfeiting U S Currency - I thought. If they are selling fake U S Coins, I learned, it is surely Counterfeiting.
I've reported several examples to Ebay.
I am Planning on writing to Ebay's Executive team tomorrow.
Please goggle Silver Eagle Scam
Surely, you have heard of drug mules. Is Ebay a counterfeit U S Coin Mule for China???
I am Very concerned for the unsuspecting buyers who may be spending their hard earned money for what they think is part of their retirement.
If I, a little old fat man can see this - why doesn't Ebay???
candkfix
Agreed. When I contacted ebay they said that they investigated my case and found nothing wrong, so they must be in on it, or simply taking their "cut" and do not care. I suppose the only solution for now is deal with established sellers who have been dealing for years. Even if the price is higher the risk of a worthless counterfeit is too great.
echotech_equipment
I see a lot of silver Canadian Maple Leafs and Silver Eagles going to $22 dollars from China when the price of silver is 10 dollars higher. Certainly, these are fakes, but there they are on eBay. I have come to understand that eBay is all about making money, and they really don't care about the Chinese sellers.
candkfix
texashumvee
So I am looking for silver and I see this: https://www.ebay.com/itm/135064664454?_trkparms=amclksrc%3DITM%26aid%3D111001%26algo%3DREC.SEED%26ao... - 10 ounces of silver (high end US silver Eagles about $425 US dollars) being sold for $180.00. I sent the info to the Ebay BOTs and of course bots don't know the difference between the sale of silver and the actual price of silver, so it did not raise any flags. Anyway, they have sold about 18,000 of these in the past few days...maybe more under different ebay accounts. The silver they are selling cannot be real. China has been making fake US silver coins (plated) for over 20 years, and we have found 100's of them just using a magnet. Anyway, Ebay knows this is going on or they would have stopped it. The thing is, people won't even know what thewy have bought isn't silver until it's tested, and very few people do that. they buy these, put them in their drawer or safe, and forget about them. This is absolutely a crime, and as long as Ebay makes money from the sales, they don't care. When you see precious metals being sold for half price, please don't be a moron and buy it. Just like all the other scams going around, if it's too good to be true, it isn't!
candkfix
Only bought two, and the bid price was 25.99. This was when silver was 27 dollars an ounce. If someone was looking to liquidate their coins for quick cash, I would expect such pricing. They were described as American silver eagle coins, .999 fine silver. They are however counterfeits, and the listing was false. Ebay is condoning the sale of counterfeit US currency, so an accessory to the crime, since they will not shut the seller down.
wsoxman1
In the real world "If the price or deal is to good to be true".......................
My father would always say "A fool and his money are soon parted"
candkfix
Same scam here. Ebay says a customer service representative reviewed my claim and said there was no violation of ebay policy. **bleep**? THIS IS A SELLER OF COUNTERFEIT US CURRENCY! How can ebay say this is okay? I'm still pursuing this as it's really pissing me off. Ebay CANNOT allow a violation of Federal law with their own "policy".
krazzykats
I purchased off another well-known site several silver coin collection series. All were encased in little plastic cases. I thought buying through a well-known site I was receiving the real things. All were fakes. I filed with my credit card to get my money back and was instructed to return them to the seller. I tried, and a couple of months later, after I received my refund, I received the coins back, with most plastic cases smashed...I reported the fakes, and would gladly hand them over to an official, but I don't think anyone cared as I received no response.
topnotch12006
I recently bought a five dollar Indianhead 1910 S gold coin when I received it, I did not check or take it out of it little package right away when I did it felt lite I put it on a scale. It only weighed a little over 4 g it should have been almost 8g and it didn’t look right and I brought it to a friend of mine he put it on a machine. It showed it was like 90% copper with gold coated! I sell and buy on eBay this is the second time I’ve been burnt on a coin I am sending it back to the seller for a refund. I sent the Coin back. I wonder how many coins they have sold that are fake? they have quite a bit of feedback really no negative. I think eBay is gonna have to start having sellers have their coins checked out to certified. Any coins I have I have checked out prior to selling them. Best of luck to all Ebay buyers! And Sellers
an-57470
I never received a Coach purse I purchased from a bogus seller who made off with the $$.
Ebay promptly refunded my credit card as they could never find the shipping!!
They were good about it.
jklidoc_1
Can you tell us the name of the seller so others won't get caught in the same scam???
4pawsup*
Never never ever buy silver or gold from china or any other country other than the USA.
cesarmor
I only buy from trusted eBay sellers. If it's too good to be true it usually is.
sapphire_studio
Never ever buy eagles on ebay that use stock photos
Edit: oops I already said this earlier in the thread. (Its an old thread)
bulldog82566
I wish I would have read this post before I purchased mine. eBay is a joke.
bulldog82566
I purchased 5 Silver Eagles from 4 different sellers on eBay. All 5 are fakes. Tried to contact eBay and they are impossible to great ahold of. I contacted the secret service office in Phoenix. They told me they had a couple of other complaints. I was told to go ahead and destroy them. DO NOT SEND THEM BACK. If you send them back knowing they are fake you are committing a Felony. At that point you know they are counterfeit and the secret service should be contacted. Since I know the ones I have are fakes and was told it was to destroy them I cut them into pieces and tossed them in the trash. All 5 together may have come to a total of .50 worth of brass. If I didn't have experience with real ones I never would have known they was fake. These coins, even though they are worth much more than the face value are legal tender. If yours is a fake it should be reported to the secret service. Maybe if enough of us report them they will do something to keep eBay from selling them. eBay is allowing this to happen.
stephenmorgan
I am surprised the Secrete Service in Phoenix did not want the coins as evidence. I thought they were the government entity responsible for investigating counterfeiting of USA money? Maybe they do not care since these are collector items that would not be put in to circulation causing a disruption to the flow of money. But then again this is causing the US Mint to loose out on sales and profits of the legitimate coins. Maybe the US Mint should investigate?
worldcoinauctions
I was told the threshold for prosecution is about $50,000 in fraudulent sales. Can happen easily but you won't know. I've reported some fakes brought in over the counter and the feds did send someone to talk to the guy trying to sell them.
4pawsup*
Bulldog,
Can you tell me what country the seller that sold you the counterfeit coins was from?
garlicrules
I recently received a terrible example of a fake eagle. Seller had 100% positive feedback. I asked for a refund and was told I would receive it. Then eBay told me that the seller couldn’t print a return label. eBay eventually came back to me and said I was going to receive a refund. The seller closed his account, and then I got a message to return the coin to some other destination that had some very odd feedbacks Buyers like one coin and E coin from places in Morocco and so forth. There’s definitely a lot of fraud on eBay. My suggestion is that we only buy coins from actual dealers with thousands of sales and are located only in the US
waxu_93
The Chinese government doesn't care what the people rely on to live, the epidemic covid19 has been going on for 3 years, and the subsequent economic collapse.No government official has ever asked ordinary people how to live.So, it is best not to buy from the Chinese even they sell the real ones.How could the Chinese export American silver coins to the United States?
waxu_93
Some of the photos are real products, and the ones shipped to you are fake products🙄
worldcoinauctions
There are tons of these and they are all over the net. Buy your silver eagles from reputable sources and if you are mail ordering take them to a local coin shop if you can for checking. If you are buying silver make sure you have a scale and know how to do the magnet test. (see youtube if you don't). I've seen magnetic and non magnetic, good and bad fakes in the past year, and those sneaky silver bars with "100 mills fine silver" (plated copper). I've seen fake silver eagles, fake morgan and peace dollars, fake walkers, franklins, barber halfs, mercs, and barber dimes. Of course I run a coin shop so garbage comes in the door for checking.
The most highly faked coin I've heard of is the 1/10 ounce gold eagle. Best part is it is often faked in pure gold. It's the US eagle premium they are after.
classictrimbandera
What were the companies m
names. We also received fake coins and can't get ahold of anyone. 2 separate companies but same contact site. Feeling lost. What did you do?
krazzykats
There are a bunch of fake coins sold on the internet, period. And fake stamps. I have a bunch of those fake Silver Eagle coins I purchased probably two years ago.
I did not buy mine on eBay though, so beware they are everywhere. Not sure I would even be comfortable purchasing any more silver dollars online.
nectarinesink
There’s a bunch of fake coins from China being sold on eBay. Only buy from a reputable seller and if it seems to cheap there’s probably a good reason.
indigohut
I spotted one completely new seller out of China yesterday selling 5 2023 Silver Eagles and another seller out of a different city in China with the same listing who had about 100 stars.
I don't think reporting it to eBay will do any good... There is an active and strong seller who keeps using the best pictures possible for Morgan dollars stating that it is the coin the bidder will receive. The last I looked, they had over 350 revised feedbacks (if a customer calls them out on the fraud, they bribe the customer to revise the feedback). same thing here--eBay makes money off their fraud, so not much action.
7339billy
Why shouldn't these Chinese nations keep selling counterfeit coins on ebay? I bought bad coins as well on ebay and know the drill. If you complain, the same old system that has protected counterfeiting for 30 years kicks in and they get away with it gain. NO CONSEQUENCE. NO SECRET SERVICE AGENTS KICKING DOWN THE DOOR. No FBI investigation, no fraud alert, no news medi investigation, just guys like us venting to each another. Ebay is getting rich of the fees. They think there as smary as the counterfeiting rings selling on there site.
They think their reputation is still intact. But counterfeiting on ebay is slowly destroying there / our credibility as sellers, buyer's, and is slowly destroying the price of goods for legitimate dealers. Untill there's a class action suit or the feds or maybe the media get involved, it's business as usual on ebay.
stemcc-5538
I just received a fake 2023 from this  Individual. Weight is 31.01 g. Diamwmeter is close, but it's a little thicker. Details are off. It fails a ping test, as well. Wrote seller an he immediately sent me a refund... but it prevents me from leaving feedback.
bigredman24
I just got a 2022 “silver Eagle†that didn’t use stock photos but when I got it I thought it was off. So dad weighed it and despite the anti counterfeit mark being right, it’s not weighing enough. Gonna take it by the coin store tomorrow to verify before I report to eBay. Just curious what year yours was?
ms.rodriguez*
Ebay is not going to notify anyone. Ebay would lose their commissions. There isn't much that you can do to alert others. Bidder's IDs are hidden now. Years ago, I would contact winners of diecast cars that they won and I knew that they were repainted. Now, you can't warn anyone. I truly believe that is the reason that IDs are hidden by Ebay. Open an item not as described case. Follow the prompts. Get your refund. If the possibility is available to post a negative and you know 100% that the coins are fakes, then give the seller a negative but do not mention refund or return or Ebay stepped in. Just write, " Seller is a scammer selling fake coins." That's it.
couturehomecollection
“There isn't much that you can do to alert others. Bidder's IDs are hidden now. Years ago, I would contact winners of diecast cars that they won and I knew that they were repainted. Now, you can't warn anyone. I truly believe that is the reason that IDs are hidden by Ebay.â€
I agree 100%.
bjbur_16
I bought so called silver coins on eBay a few week ago. When I got them I had them tested at a local coin shop on there SIGMA tester. They tested negative for silver. Dealer flabbergasted at the almost perfect quality. He said they were so good he would have never removed from the plastic. Called the CIA and they said good luck, buyer beware. the listing said US dealer and gave a US address. Waiting for eBay to return my money. Dealer nowhere to be found. Here's how this will play out. When silver and gold goes up in price a lot of unaware folks will want to sell their coins they bought on ebay. The coin dealer will say sorry but you've been had not real. This will be long after there 30 day return date has expired. When it gets out say on TV or the net that thousand of people over the years were scammed, some bright law firm will start a class action sute. I can see it now, if you have been burned buying misleading counterfeit goods on eBay call this number now.
stephenmorgan
You should actually report them the the Secret Service. Here is a link from the FBI warning about the fakes and they provide links to report them to different agencies.
You have name and address of who you got them from so it should be a fairly easy report to submit. If you do this you may want to hold onto you coin because you may need to turn it over to them. The Alert advises you to report this to your online payment provider or credit card company.
https://www.ic3.gov/Media/Y2021/PSA210909
September 09, 2021
I-090921-PSA
Questions regarding this PSA should be directed to your local FBI Field Office.
Local Field Office Locations: www.fbi.gov/contact-us/field-offices
The FBI Warns the Public of Counterfeit Coin Scams
The FBI and the Department of Treasury are warning the public that counterfeit coins are being sold on various online auction, social media and retail websites, targeting investors and collectors. There are three types of counterfeit coins: transactional coins (quarters, dimes, etc.), numismatics (high value collectables), and bullion (precious metals). Online advertisements used by scammers claim the coins are authentic; however, consumers are receiving fake coins and precious metals.
Online estimates reveal that consumers spend millions of dollars buying valuable or rare coins, but most receive near-worthless foreign-made counterfeits. An increasing number of counterfeit coins are being seized at US ports-of-entry. For example, in April 2021, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) officers at Chicago’s international mail facility seized 279 shipments from China containing counterfeit coins and currency. In 2020, CBP seized over $1.64 million in counterfeit cash and coins at Chicago O’Hare International Airport.
Scammers capitalized on the financial uncertainty and nation-wide coin shortage brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic to take advantage of amateur investors online. Many victims find purchasing online an easy method to make investments, as they can easily find what they are looking for, pay cheaper prices and have their investments delivered right to their door. Do not let online scammers rob you of your investment. Protect your wallet and your personal data by purchasing from reputable, registered coin dealers. If you decide to purchase outside this venue, ensure that the coins are tested by a certified organization, before making a purchase.
The FBI reminds readers to always research online sellers before buying coins and precious metals online. Check online reviews and Better Business Bureau complaints before making a purchase. Protect your investments by dealing with reputable companies and dealers.
If you believe that you are the victim of a counterfeit coin scheme, immediately report the activity to the online payment provider or credit card company used for the transaction. All identified Counterfeit coins involving U.S. currency should be reported to your local U.S. Secret Service office which can be found at https://www.secretservice.gov/contact/field-offices. You can also file a complaint with the U.S. Treasury Office of Inspector General at https://forms.treasury.gov/treasuryforms/Form?templateID=a1Qt00000028jF0EAI. All non-currency coins and bullion should be reported to the Anti-Counterfeiting Task Force at https://acefonline.org/counterfeit-alert/report-a-counterfeit and all cyber-related scams at the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center at www.ic3.gov.
soh.maryl
So, can't tell from your message, but did you actually open an item not as described case?
cphwebmaker
OPYes I did open an item not as described case and I mailed the fake coins back to the seller. No response from the seller. As I stated above, 138 other people bought the same auction I did. Coins came in individual round plastic holder and small zip lock type bag. That's $40K+ theft.
rusty_bottoms
Since it was silver eagles, It is definitely a counterfeit case and should be reported to the Secret service. Your action could help the general public from getting scammed. If you don't feel comfortable reporting. let me know the sellers ebay username and I can take care of it for you.
bandoasis
The exact same situation happened to me today. The fake ASEs was in a plastic case and comes in a small ziplock bag.
dogin9627
yep. He got me too. I was greedy and looking for a good deal on silver. Immediately Tried to cancel, but the crook didn’t allow. Bought a test kit and waited for the delivery. It’s silver plated copper. Amazing that people do this
candkfix
My seller said "It must've been a mistake at the factory." The only legal producers of genuine US silver eagles is the US MINT! EBay is absolutely no help with this issue so aiding and abetting the trafficking in counterfeit US currency as well. Have to stick with reputable dealers with a thousand feedbacks or more. If you used a credit card, the issuer may still be able to help, but doubtful since you got a product but not as described.
suejeff-3
Can we post these sellers names? I was scammed too at full price
krazzykats
No. Naming and shaming on the boards is not allowed. You can report them though.
suejeff-3
I got scammed to. I bought 3 silver eagles and they came in a plastic case and bag. I had them tested and tried reporting it to eBay with no response and then his website was taken down off eBay! I couldn’t get my money back either! I have bought coins for years and had no issues. These weren’t even a deal! I don’t know what to do now! I kept the coins. I doubt his name or address are not fake either
stephenmorgan
I would not buy any US Gold or Silver Coins made in China. They are probably only gold or silver plated.
This has been going on for years and years.
Here is an article from 2014 showing the difference between one made at a US Mint and one made in China.
https://www.coinworld.com/news/precious-metals/fake-proof-silver-american-eagles-from-china.html
Can you tell the real from the fake?
brmcki6963
The top one is fake
snhsru-iuv6bao
Top one is fake?
stephenmorgan
The one on the left is the fake one.
lgmo-95
Well that's just common sense,, coins are minted at 3 mints in the USA, America does NOT have coins minted in China or ANY OTHER country. Duhhhh,!! So if someone buys a coin from China & expects it to be authentic , deserves to get scammed, I mean how Dumb does someone have to be to not know this.!!!
krazzykats
It's not always clear where counterfeit items are sourced from. My own encounter did not involve a coin purchase from eBay or TEMU, but rather a deceptive push advertisement on a search engine. The coins, unbeknownst to me at the time, were from China. The ad was crafted to mimic those of reputable companies like Bradford Exchange or Franklin Mint, with impressive presentation.
It's a reminder that the true source and the entity behind an advertisement can be obscure.
This incident occurred 4-5 years ago, and while it was an oversight, it certainly didn't make me feel foolish. It's a common misconception that only the gullible are deceived, but in reality, anyone can be misled by a well-crafted facade.🤔
lalalk_0
The real point has a dub on the u, take one dozen.
sapphire_studio
Never buy American Eagle coins that use stock photos and I would argue just avoid American Eagle coins on eBay all together and stick to like junk silver and other less counterfeited choices.
jackmillerlv
I just bought 3 counterfeit silver dollars from a seller in china. After I made the purchase I looked up the coins and they should have sold for from $400 up. I paid less than $40 so that was the first red flag.
The description said they were uncirculated and the item said they were UA+++ another red flag.
I contacted eBay and tried to get them flagged but got letter that nothing would be done to this seller.
When the coins came I went to a coin mart and they did a spectrograph that revealed the coins were 52% copper and the rest a mixture of plating and cheap metal.
I tried to leave feedback but now Ebay has shut down the site. I reported to Ebay and to paypal. EBay says they can't help me now that paypal is involved.
I got email from the seller that if I am not happy they will refund half if I keep the coins or all if I sent them back. I wrote back that under no circumstances would I return the coins to them to resell to another innocent person. These coins are not just an unsatisfactory item that I want a refund on. They are an illegal counterfeit made to cheat the public. To sent them back is to join in a conspiricy to defraud.
The coin mart said they get a dozen or so of these coins every week and more lately.
I believe that Ebay is complicent in this illegal activity. The ads are easy to spot and there are many of them selling every day.
suejeff-3
How do you spot the illegal adds by these people?
suejeff-3
I believe eBay is going along with them. They wouldn’t respond to my dispute of my 3 fake coins either and they removed the website and I couldn’t get my money back or a response from eBay to help get my money back.
I won’t buy from eBay anymore! I used to buy silver all the time. Never had a problem until this border issue
maxine*j
Just use eBay's ironclad and automated Money Back Guarantee. Open an Item Not As Described Case and get a full refund.
eBay is not going to do anything based on a phone call or a report, for a number of good reasons. But eBay does note INAD cases, and they do negatively impact a seller.
-
sonomabarn67
Hi Maxine!
mschr_61
Dear Maxine , I too bought some fake silver eagles but my seller has said to send them back, TO CHINA , that's not where they came from they arrived in a couple of days . Can I open a refund request also ? But how can we stop this person from doing business in the USA?