Won an auction, family emergency occurred, can't pay for item, seller ignoring cancellation requests
I did just spend an hour searching for an instance of this exact situation having already been discussed and I read everything remotely related but found nothing relevant to it.
I was the high bidder in an auction that closed with only one bid. Around the time of the auction closing I received news that forced me to make travel plans, change my schedule and reallocate funds. When I saw that I had won, I took a moment to contemplate what the best way to handle this situation would be. I have been active on eBay for 20 years and do almost as much selling as I do buying. I have never cancelled an order after winning an auction, but I've had buyers who have. It's not a pleasant experience and I was more than hesitant to do it to this seller, but it was financially necessary. I found the "cancel this order" option, but was informed that I was too late to do so, and that asking the seller was my only option. The item was in my cart and the reminders to pay from eBay were coming in.
In a short message to the seller I explained my situation and asked them to please cancel. A day passed and no reply. More reminders to pay. I sent another message and, again, asked them politely to cancel the order. Another day passed, no response, more payment reminders. In my third message I was not so polite, informing them that ignoring my requests was, indeed, quite aggravating, but that was all, and it was not going to affect my ability to pay for the item. Still no reply.
I understand that this is not as extreme a situation as it would be had I already paid and was being ignored, but I do try to play by the rules, and having this unresolved issue lingering is proving to be a real nuisance when added to the actual, important situation I'm trying to work through. I'm not sure if this is going to create a negative mark on me as a buyer, or if there is something the seller has to gain by dragging this out for a certain amount of time? I would've thought that getting this over with in order to relist the item would be their primary goal here, but apparently not.
So, I guess I'll be penalized for failing to pay for my item after three days? Will it then be automatically removed from my cart and the sell free to leave me negative feedback? Do I have absolutely no control over the outcome of this situation? As a seller, I've always felt that the buyer has the upper hand in most cases, and, if compelled to, could actually screw me over pretty good. I have no desire to do anything like that to this seller, but I'm being made to feel as if my only options here are to either beg and plead or do nothing at all.
Am I making a mountain out of a mole hill? Am I free to just move on in a carefree manner?
Thank you if you took the time to read this.
stevescho
To answer more succinctly than others
1. Yes (making mtn from mole hill)
2. Yes (don't pay, don't msg seller anymore, take strike, move on)
Bye.
bonjourami
"So, I guess I'll be penalized for failing to pay for my item after three days? Will it then be automatically removed from my cart and the sell free to leave me negative feedback?"
Unfortunately, sellers cannot leave any feedback for deadbeat buyers, other than positive.
nobody*s_perfect
You can be pretty sure that the seller has decided to wait out the 4 days so they can cancel the transaction based on nonpayment.
The seller might have chosen to do this in order to punish you, since you'll get a nonpayment strike, but more likely they want to protect themselves from getting bad feedback, based on your attitude. If they cancel based on nonpayment then you'd be blocked from leaving feedback; canceling for any other reason (including "Buyer requested") would leave the seller vulnerable to receiving a negative or neutral feedback based on your aggravation and impatience.
sosmachines
OPIf I'm understanding this correctly, when a buyer asks a seller to cancel an order that has not been paid for and the seller honors this request, the buyer will still be given the opportunity to leave feedback on the seller? If there was never any money or item exchanging hands, then there was no transaction to comment on. If the order was cancelled, then there's nothing to rate or review. It doesn't seem right that a seller should need to protect themselves from anything in this scenario, and that any vulnerability they may experience is actually the byproduct of a flaw in the system. What am I missing here?
wastingtime101
Welcome to the world of illogical policies sellers have to deal with around here.
gurlcat
I always get the sense that the site's features come down a chain of command like a game of Telephone, down to geeks who do nothing but create programs and play video games, no actual eBay buying or selling experience. In this case it would seem (all post-60 minute) cancelled transactions were left open to feedback review because of the fact that some sellers do frustrating cancellations that buyers should be able to voice their opinion about. Like if they won the auction for less money than the seller wanted and expected, or even something like a Buy It Now sale because the seller was out of stock or couldn't find the item to ship it, but didn't communicate anything to the buyer for multiple days, then just cancelled and refunded.
But when it was the buyer's request, yeah that never should have been left open to feedback. One of my neutrals is "Order was cancelled by myself" -LOL it doesn't actually bug me because I know it doesn't make me look bad, but considering how often I sell something AWESOME to somebody, pack it nice and ship it lightening fast .... and they don't leave feedback at all ..... why does somebody who cancelled think they HAVE TO leave some kind of feedback??? 😆
wastingtime101
eBay sends a lot of feedback reminders and many buyers come to this forum saying they leave FB just to make the constant reminders stop. They don't realize they can turn off those notifications in their account settings.
frankenhobbit
I think it's eBay that sends the reminder, not the seller.
The issue is that so many people claim 'an emergency' to back out of an auction, that when it happens for real, no-one believes it, so the seller is probably just going to just cancel after 4 days and you'll get a strike, but that's it.
BUT
There's a reason that you need at least TWO strikes to be negatively impacted. Things happen, so if someone is genuinely impacted by an emergency, they essentially get a 'freebie' before anything negative happens. So don't sweat it. You won't be blocked from buying, you won't get negative feedback and you won't have to go through with the purchase.
house*of*paws
Hi @sosmachines
I would guess that your seller is waiting the necessary time to use ‘Buyer hasn’t paid’ as the reason for cancelling your order … perhaps to protect themselves from receiving bad feedback from you. [Seller may have picked up a ‘tone’ in your messages that concerned them.]
Sellers cannot leave bad feedback for buyers … so you are at no risk there.
You must receive 2 or more nonpayment strikes (within a 12 month period) for it to affect your ability to buy on eBay … and you say this is your only nonpayment.
You can either pay for the item or move on. I’m not sure about the ‘carefree’ part if you have a ‘family emergency’ to deal with. 🤔
[I’m curious about the number of ‘reminders’ you received in what sounds like only 3 days. It seems like you received at least 2 a day … for a total of at least 6, which would be highly unusual.]
sosmachines
OPThank you.
There have been 3.
house*of*paws
@sosmachines
You’re very welcome.
One thing you didn’t mention is whether you offered the seller a sincere apology for requesting the cancellation. I would try doing that if you haven’t already. You’d be surprised how far a little humility can go in warming up a chilled heart. Good luck! 😊
sosmachines
OPMy first message to the seller:
"I need to cancel this order. An emergency has occurred which requires the reallocation of funds. My apologies."
Perhaps not apologetic enough? Insincere sounding?
I was actually on the fence regarding canceling and was very close to submitting a payment that would impede my ability to cover other, more crucial expenses...not because I wanted the item or to prevent a strike on my record, but because of the inconvenience it would create for the seller. I've been on the other end of this more than once, and it did compromise me financially, but I still allowed the buyers to cancel. Maybe I should have done what this seller did, but I wouldn't feel very good about it.
house*of*paws
@sosmachines
Since you asked, your clipped apology sounds fine had it been made before the auction ended OR during the time period eBay gives buyers to request a cancellation.
But since you were already past the time period we’re given to request a cancellation … you might have stated your understanding that you were inconveniencing the seller more transparently.
My mentioning an apology was not for the purpose of critiquing what you’ve already said … but rather a suggestion as to what you might still do to increase the odds of receiving a ‘Buyer requests cancellation’ versus a ‘Buyer hasn’t paid’ one … especially since you said your last message was less than friendly.
Anyway, I wish you well in dealing with the emergency … and hope you can move past the last few days. 🙂
gurlcat
No you were right to cancel those orders as requested, if not for giving them the benefit of the doubt then for the fact that a refused cancellation could have resulted in more trouble for you. Like you said before, buyers do have the upper hand, and some will go out of their way for vengeance when they feel slighted.
As for your apology, I agree with @house*of*paws -the fact that it came after the 60 minute mark makes it seem a bit less sincere, along with not sounding very sorry. -I'm not saying I would ignore your request like this seller did, but I'd be miffed.
You don't have to take this as a model but I tend to go the opposite route and practically prostrate myself in apologies, LOL. I would have said something like, "I am so sorry but a family emergency has come up that makes me unable to afford this item at this time. I'm extra embarrassed because I'm a seller myself and I know how disappointing it is to wait 7 days for an auction to close and then have to start all over again. I hate to ask for a cancellation but I have no other choice; I hope it wouldn't cause you too much hardship to honor this request. Thank you in advance and again I'm really sorry."
msha3839
Instead of being not polite to seller, have some emergency funds saved just in case you need it…good luck..🙉
doc-holmes
That's not always possible.
msha3839
That’s life..buying on eBay for any reason or to have emergency funds for many reasons…
doc-holmes
Not everybody has extra money lying around. That's life.
msha3839
Indeed..your life and your problems..🤧ðŸ¸
gurlcat
How do you know the OP didn't have emergency funds but just not enough to cover both expenses? Are you so lacking in empathy you'll think of a way to blame people for their problems no matter what the scale?
wastingtime101
In my opinion: yes.
1. Sellers are not required to agree to buyer cancellation requests (though in my opinion if the seller has not yet shipped, best practice is to agree to the cancellation).
2. If the seller does not cancel as buyer requested, one of 2 things will happen:
2.a. The seller will cancel after 4 or more days for non-payment. You will get an unpaid item strike on your account. This strike will age off after 12 mo. Seller block settings can't reach a buyer with 1 single strike. You have to have a min of 2 strikes for sellers to block you for non-payment. (Though this seller can add you to their blocked list which is a separate type of block.)
2.b. The seller will do nothing, you will do nothing, and after I think it's 32 days, the transaction will time out with no strike on your account. This is possible, but less likely.
3. Sellers cannot leave negative feedback for buyers - not since 2008. It's a policy violation for sellers to leave neg comments with a pos rating so if that happens you can contact customer service and get the FB removed.
TLDR; Stop messaging the seller. Take the unpaid item strike if it comes. And don't give it another thought.