When will eBay step up and stop the Bid Shielding?!
It seems like an impossible task for the engineers at eBay to implement a very basic bid retraction policy:
Do NOT allow Bid retractions within 1 hour of the auction ending
So why in late 2025 are we still dealing with this nonsense on very high end items (phones, laptops, etc.)?
When you have scammers who can hijack hundreds of eBay accounts and proceed to utilize 2 accounts to artificially bid up an auction only to RETRACT their high bid at the VERY LAST SECOND so their other account which bid before it wins it for pennies on the dollar then you have a MASSIVE problem.
Unfortunately even after reporting this dozens of times, eBay does absolutely NOTHING to stop this.
yokashsan
9 comments
mr_lincoln
Hi @yokashsan
In 2024 67.1% of my sales were from Auctions. Currently for 2025 just over 50% of my sales are from Auctions. While bid retractions are rare the pattern I have seen when they occur is typically an abuse of the Bid Retraction feature. Last month a potential customer retracted a bid on an Auction, when I checked their Feedback history they had 590 Bid Retractions in the last 12 months.
While there may be occasional legitimate reasons to retract a bid the fact is that many members abuse the process. That is what I would like to see eBay address and there are numerous ways this can be achieved. One idea that I like is to give Sellers a block setting similar to Unpaid items with a minimum of say 5 (and programmable above that) Bid retractions in the last 12 months.
But to the point in your title on this tread, eBay has a policy on Bid Retraction but they do NOT enforce it against members who abuse it.
roccotacodad54
That scenario only works if one is susceptable to bidding wars.
I place my max bid late in the game (to not draw undue attention) and then go about my day. If the price is already more than I'm willing to pay I move on.
If I win it will be in my purchases later either awaiting payment or auto-paid.
Either way I avoid the drama of nibble or snipe bidding and only pay up to what I'm willing to spend on said item............................
jonathanbrightlight
The secret is being willing to lose and walk away if it exceeds your chosen maximum price, but also not hold back on what you do think it’s worth to you.
johnrj1226
Looks to me like the OP is a buyer not a seller bases on their profile. Have zero clue if the have a selling account or sold any thing in the last 90 days or received FB as a seller within the last 12 months. Auctions buying is going the way of the dodo bird. Buyer want their items now and don't want to wait several day to buy some possibly unless they don't have any thing to do and wish to spend all 4 time zones and and ending times to see if they won or not
With 18 million sellers and every one wanting just 1 thing for for their personal need would be "impossible".or economically practical to do so.
Never bought . anything via auction. In our neighborhood their were two Frid/St nigh auction houses - they closed up shop to never be seen again.
mudshark61369
@johnrj1226 ,
"Auctions buying is going the way of the dodo bird. Buyer want their items now and don't want to wait several day to buy some possibly unless they don't have any thing to do and wish to spend all 4 time zones and and ending times to see if they won or not".
Auctions do have their advatages in some categories. 95% of the items I list are in the auction format, and I get very acceptable prices for my auctions. I do sell vintage items long out of production, which may be why. I often wonder why some sellers list common and still available in stores items, as auctions, instead of Buy It Now listings. Though some new high demand items sell for well more than the MSRP as auctions especially near Christmas.
mudshark61369
@yokashsan ,
Are you asking about this as a buyer or seller? According to your profile you have not sold anything on ebay, but we know that many who post on these boards do so using a Posting or Buying only ID, as I do.
"When you have scammers who can hijack hundreds of eBay accounts and proceed to utilize 2 accounts to artificially bid up an auction only to RETRACT their high bid at the VERY LAST SECOND.
Since we cannot see an actual auction's bid history we cannot say exactly what you have seen happen. I do not believe this involves Hijacked accounts but depending on the category of listings, it could involve sport bidders, or very inexperienced bidders.
Usually when people post about bid retractions, it is because their highest bid was surpassed, and at the last second the winning bid was retracted or cancelled by the seller AKA shill bidding. A bidder using a 2nd ID to scare off other bidders, with a second high automatic bid which gets retracted, would take a lot of planning.
I think the first reply by ebooksdiva is closer to what is happening, though if it is it shouldn't affect most experienced bidders who do not bid until the last minutes of an auction.
https://www.ebay.com/help/buying/bidding/retracting-bid?id=4013
bonanza125
Unfortunately and I know this isn't what you want to hear but if you already expect Ebay will do nothing then you know that nothing is going to change in the future. So you need to adapt to that reality.
simba6
Sell with fixed price listings. Many sellers like those better as they don't want to wait for an auction to end.
Unavailable member
Bid retraction policy states :
You can retract a bid if (Note: these options are only applicable for up to 1 hour after making the bid when the listing is ending in less than 12 hours)
If the seller significantly changed the description or the bid amount was incorrect, in which case the bidder is supposed to rebid. If the bidder doesn’t rebid you can report the bidder for invalid bid retraction. Basically report the buyer.
So don’t I believe bidders are retracting at the very last second of the auction, the very last second of the 12 hour window is more likely.