Seller offer cancelation
Buyers are always warned that a bid is a contract and are expected to honor their bid by paying. But a seller is allowed to cancel a payment from an offer they made, which is also a contract, because they now obviously realize they can now get more money because market prices are going up and they do not want to honor offer that was accepted. eBay should do more to these sellers, orher than simply allow a buyer to leave a poor rating that only lasts a year. No honor among so many of the sellers.
ckinkead
23 comments
mudshark61369
@ckinkead ,
"The email I received said they no longer wanted to issue offers for the item. Aka, the market shooting up, and I wanted to get more for it".
Why is it that so many buyers jump to the conclusion that sellers actions are nefarious and based on greed?
In this case it may be that wholesale prices have gone up and the seller can't afford the automatic discounted offers being sent out any longer. They may not know how to get out of the Promoted/Sponsored listing program.
" eBay should do more to these sellers, orher than simply allow a buyer to leave a poor rating that only lasts a year".
When the seller cancelled the transaction, depending on the reason they chose that was given in the cancellation message you received. Not only did they get a defect on their account, but they may also have had to pay the final value fee for the sale they cancelled.
Depending on the seller's volume of sales, their defect percentage could cost them their listing discounts, eventually lead to limiting the number of items they can list, and finally being banned from selling on ebay. We could tell you more about the seller if you posted the ebay item number for the cancelled sale.
As for negatives only counting against a seller's percentage for the last year. Do you really think they should do that forever? Mistakes are bound to happen no matter how good a seller is or how long they've been selling. There are those who leave negatives when things a seller cannot control go wrong, items lost in shipping, weather events causing shipping delays... Sellers have received negatives for using styro peanuts or bubble wrap to pack items in, because the buyer is an environmentalist. Some received negatives when a seller ships in previously used boxes or used Amazon boxes. Even though there was nothing wrong with the item they received.
"If you read enough comments from sellers responding to unfavorable comments about sellers, you will see yours are right out of the playbook".
Buyer's have the Money Back Guarantee (MBG) on their side. Sellers do not have the same quality of protection from bad buyers. All a buyer has to do is claim an item is not as described. They do not have to prove it, but the seller is left with 2 choices. Pay the return shipping cost, or issue a full refund and let the buyer keep the item.
Buyers do claim Not As Described to avoid paying the return costs when:
They find out they ordered the wrong thing by mistake.
They only needed to use it once.
They misused or damaged the item.
They found another listing of the item for less money.
They already had one of the item that they broke and return that one.
They just plain decided for some reason that they didn't like the item, not that there was anything wrong with it.
None of those buyers can get negative feedback on their account, because it isn't allowed. So your (588) - 100% positive rating is shared with thieves and scammers.
house*of*paws
Hi @ckinkead
I’m very sorry your sale was cancelled. It’s happened to me, so I know how it feels.
eBay doesn’t ‘allow’ sellers to cancel orders any more than it ‘allows’ buyers to skip payment. eBay has no legal way of forcing a seller to ship any more than it can force a buyer to pay. eBay can only ‘penalize’ buyers and sellers who don’t follow the rules.
Your seller received a defect on their account for failing to ship your order. Buyers receive a strike on our account if we fail to pay.
It’s possible that your seller didn’t send out the offer you originally received. I understand that some offers are sent out automatically … but I’m not up on all the recent changes made to ‘offers’.
[BTW, I am a ‘buyer only’. Buyers can only receive positive feedback … so our having a 100% rating doesn’t mean what it did prior to 2008 (when we could receive negs and neutrals). The only way sellers can evaluate buyers is by checking the feedback we’ve ‘Left for others’.]
ckinkead
OPThank you, this was a well-thought-out and clear comment.
My comment did indicate some form of penalty, as I am well aware that they cannot force a shipment from a seller or a payment from a buyer. I do think the penalty to a seller should be made stronger as it appears to be very little of a threat to larger sellers like this for what would have amounted to a minimum loss. In fact if they had honored the sale, and informed me of their sacrifice, I would have left them a glowing review of their honesty. But the desirr for such comments seem to be second to maximizing their profit. I have mostly limited my negative comments to the few scammers who were able to fool me, but the more feedback and defensiveness for sellers this post has brought, the more I think that I owe it to buyers to post a negative review that might help other buyers to know what kind of seller they may be about to deal with. I know i have chosen not to buy from a seller because of a well-worded negative comment(s).
Thank you again.
house*of*paws
@ckinkead
You’re very welcome. 😊
If you’ve read many posts in the Community … you may have noticed that eBay buyers are favored about 97% more than sellers (my guesstimate as a reader).
But the choice of feedback is your call alone. Do whatever you think is right.
mudshark61369
@ckinkead ,
"... But a seller is allowed to cancel a payment from an offer they made".
We need a bit more clarity here. Are you saying you received an offer and went to accept it, but were unable to do that? If you are referring to, The seller sent you a special offer and you were unable to accept it and pay. That can happen if someone beat you to the punch before you tried to accept the offer. Those offers are usually sent out after a predetermined number of people have viewed the item. Then all of them are sent the offer and see the banner below.
I've tried to buy from an offer on a few occasions, but was told I couldn't pay because the item was no longer available. meaning someone accepted the offer first. There is no contract UNTIL a payment is made.
ckinkead
OPNo, as indicated, I received an offer, I accepted and PAID, I received eBay automated emails showing order received, and payment completed.
Then I received notice from seller that refund was issued and they no longer wanted to issue offers for it.
I am sure they will relist the item after they wait a while.
soh.maryl
What reason did this seller use for cancellation?
ckinkead
OPThe email I received said they no longer wanted to issue offers for the item. Aka, the market shooting up, and I wanted to get more for it.
reallynicestamps
, or was the offer cancelled before you paid?
Sellers are not required to accept offers.
Many sellers even automate this by having a Reject price under which all offers will be politely refused.
And buyers have only 96 hours to pay, after which the seller can open an Unpaid Item Dispute and the entire transaction is cancelled.
reallynicestamps
because they now obviously realize they can now get more money because market prices are going up and they do not want to honor offer
There are many reasons why a seller might cancel an order.
A higher price offered is one of them
But the seller might not want to ship to your address (many will not ship to freight forwarders or post office boxes or military addresses.).
Or they may look at the winning bidder's feedback and gasp. Or will not ship to buyer's with private feedback
Or they may have lost the item.
Or they may have a reason to think there will be a problem with the sale or with the buyer.
If you want to prevent this, only buy through the 85% of eBay listings that are Fixed Price.
That seller knows what is their acceptable price.
ckinkead
OPThis was a fixed price sale.
I have 100% 500+ rating
I am sure the item will be back for sale soon.
I live in the U.S.
Sorry, your reasons are what seem to be the go to answers to protect sellers. Unfortunately I believe the bad sellers are rising quickly and eBay is doing little, as they are making too much money.
As I said, some sellers are not honorable, this is not a scam seller, this is a greedy seller giving eBay a bad rep. And others sellers should request eBay to take it more serious and do something about it.
gosimus
@ckinkead
< I have 100% 500+ rating >
That's all very fine, but sellers are interested in the feedback you leave for others. However, sellers can't see your feedback left for others because you set your feedback to private. Maybe the seller concludes that you have something to hide, and wouldn't want to take a chance on you. If this is the reason, the seller should have checked that feedback before making an offer, but people make mistakes.
ckinkead
OPI have read that "Private" line in the community listing for decades, and it certainly might be true for someone with a low percent. But a 100% rating with high reviews should tell a seller everything he needs to know. In addition, I have Never had a seller ask me to change my setting to complete sale.
Just another classic response to protect sellers who are not honorable. We are not talking about a lot of money, it is not like they put a decimal in the wrong place on a $80,000 car. if a successful seller can not eat a $10 or $20 loss of profit vs the profit they would have made 2 or 3 months ago because they did not watch their listings and the market closely, then they deserve to be penalized by eBay, and to be known as not being honorable. ....karma baby!!
gosimus
@ckinkead
< a 100% rating with high reviews should tell a seller everything he needs to know >
Well, it doesn't. I would want to know what kind of feedback, style and tone, had been left for previous sellers, especially now. Anyway, whether the number of received feedback is high or low isn't evident because the feedback number isn't displayed on your feedback page, although it is here.
< Just another classic response to protect sellers who are not honorable >
How is it you know my motive? Divine inspiration? Magic 8-Ball? Projection?
ckinkead
OPIf those are my choices, I will go with the Magic 8-ball.
If you read enough comments from sellers responding to unfavorable comments about sellers, you will see yours are right out of the playbook. Or to put it another way, If it walks like duck, and it quacks like a duck, it's probably a duck....
gosimus
@ckinkead
< comments from sellers responding to unfavorable comments about sellers >
I'm not a seller, never have been. I thought maybe if I kept on responding, I might stumble into the right combination of words that would light the bulb above your head. My Magic 8-Ball tells me it's probably useless to continue working at it.
12345jamesstamps
Apparently seller doesn't care about a possible 'repeat buyer'...which are like gold to me.
I would never cancel a sale.
ryry-jj
Im not clear, are you saying you accepted an offer, paid for it, then it was cancelled, or was the offer cancelled before you paid?
ckinkead
OPPaid for then cancelled
See my recent other comment.
Thank you.
bonanza125
Ebay does do something. Sellers get dinged on there seller performance level under transaction defect. It is never wise for a seller to cancel out just because they didn't get enough for an item. It is always recommended for a seller to ditch auctions and go strictly fixed price due to that. To be fair majority of sellers are fine. They go through with the transaction smoothly and don't cancel out. So really the issue you are having is from a small minority of sellers who have the "I don't care" attitude. Those people don't last on Ebay if they continue to do what they do.
ckinkead
OPThanks for replying. Since the seller cancelled an "offer", and not an auction, and they have large numbers in their reviews I have to believe they are not new, so they are probably safe from dings from eBay. As long as they limit how many times they do it in a year before the negative reviews start to show a pattern.
janet9988
Offers can expire or another buyer can buy it before you accept and pay.
ckinkead
OPPaid for then cancelled.
See my recent other comment.
Thank you.