Seller called me a liar when I left honest negative feedback
Summary: hannahcollins4 shared their experience with a seller on eBay, where they received an item late despite receiving an initial shipping notice earlier. After confronting the seller about the delay, they received a tracking number and eventually got the item. hannahcollins4 left feedback explaining the situation, but the seller denied the issues and accused them of false feedback. hannahcollins4 sought advice and assistance on getting the negative feedback from the seller removed. Eventually, with help from other participants and contacting eBay directly, the negative comment from the seller was successfully removed.
Hello everyone,
I purchased an item on October 9th. On October 11th, I get an email from eBay saying “The seller just shipped your order! Estimated delivery Oct. 15th-21st.” But, no tracking number. Maybe the seller just forgot to put it into eBay or it hasn’t updated yet. I waited to check in with them (since USPS takes awhile to update).
On October 19th I realized I had forgotten about my order. I check on it, still no tracking number…okay I’ll message for an update then.
I say: “Hello! I wanted to check to see if you had a tracking number for my order. It’s been a while since it was marked as shipped so I was just curious to see if there were any updates. Thanks!”
Seller messages back the next morning “Went out today” (as in the 20th...not the 11th)
I reply with “Oh! Okay, thank you. Don’t know why it told me it was shipped on the 11th then.”
Got no reply.
So NOW I have a tracking number and it’s moving. It finally got here yesterday (26th). Fortunately item looks good, is as described, etc etc.
I leave my review explaining what happened (pretty much exactly as I just did in this post) and included a screenshot of our conversation. And I noted that if they had just communicated that there’d be a shipping delay, I would’ve been understanding and be leaving a better review.
Seller replies with: “This did not happen and the buyer made up the entire review. This item shipped within 3 days and was delivered on time. There were no issues and the buyer did not send any messages to me. What is the issue? Not sure.”
Like HUH??? I literally have all the proof of this happening??
I sent a follow up to the feedback and said: “Seller is now accusing me of lying even though I have provided a literal screenshot of our interaction (and have more screenshots with proof of dates, etc.). I definitely wouldn't trust this seller and regret making this purchase.”
Then I notice that they left "positive" feedback on my profile that says "Buyer left false negative feedback twice for an item that arrived on time and was exactly as described. Not only is this a violation of EBay's policies. She has been reported for false feedback left"
So. I reported them to eBay and provided all the proof. Do we think they'll remove the feedback the seller left for me?
gosimus
@hannahcollins4
< Seller replies with: “This did not happen . . . >
If none of the earlier suggestions works to your satisfaction, at least you can have the last word, to refute the seller's reply. Click the "Follow up" link alongside the feedback in contention.
kathiec
Sellers aren't allowed to leave negative statements in a positive feedback (which is all they can leave for buyers). So yes, if you report it the comment will be removed. Their responses to your feedback for them won't be.
hannahcollins4
OPOh good! Ugh what a ridiculous situation...
Thank you for the reply!
momtoabeautifuldaughter
Report their feedback left for you. A seller cannot leave a buyer feedback with negative wording.
hannahcollins4
OPI keep getting turned around while trying to navigate the feedback page! So I ended up clicking on the question mark in the botttom-right corner of the page, then "submit report" and then said it was communication abuse/defamation. Is there a better way of going about reporting the feedback? Since it's positive and I'm the buyer, I can't see it when I go to the "request to remove feedback" page.
msha3839
No need to worry..seller’s response to you coming in negative light for him/her …I would simply give follow up feedback and indicate dates it was shipped and delivered..this is not your job to remind seller to ship item on time…
momtoabeautifuldaughter
Have it removed:
Contact ebay by chat (type in AGENT) or callback here:
https://www.ebay.com/help/eua?id=5275&mkpid
Send a private message for further help here:
https://www.instagram.com/ebay/
https://www.instagram.com/ebayforsellers/
hannahcollins4
OPYesss, thank you so much!
momtoabeautifuldaughter
You are so welcome! I hope it gets removed. I see its still there though