Request for Mandatory Packaging Photos
Thurs 12-12-2025 8:22 a.m.
Over two decades of purchasing items on eBay, 90% of the items have come in to me with minor or major shipping damage. Sometimes the item is a total loss. This is unacceptable. It takes considerable time and effort to address this problem (that is, mental stress associated with unpackaging badly damaged items, correspondence, requesting a partial refund, packaging up an item for a return, transporting the item to a carrier, etc.). It currently remains a severe problem. I need to see things improve in the future.
To begin to address this problem, eBay needs to do a better job of instructing eBay buyers on appropriate packaging practices. I have recommended this many times over the past 10 years. Perhaps some kind of video could be developed for eBay sales training purposes. It would be mandatory for eBay sellers to watch the video and be certified / tested on its contents. The video needs to contain simple information. For example, items must not rattle inside of a shipping box once packaging is completed.
After appropriately training eBay sellers, I think that mandatory photos need to be taken of internal and external packaging efforts.
I think that eBay is hiding the truth about how many items get poorly packaged and have to be partially refunded or returned for a full refund. eBay has indicated how easy it is to sell things on eBay. I think that eBay is hiding how distressing it is to have to return items for a refund.
I submit that when 90% of my eBay purchases come in with shipping damage (caused by poor packaging practices and not by the carrier) there is a need to get this problem corrected.
Regards,
ag01
articulatedgeared01
OPFri 12-12-2025 6:32 p.m.
This evening, I sent out a series of packaging photos to one of my buyers along with a tracking number. This shows the buyer what to expect. It also covers me with eBay because they want photos of damaged items. Carriers may also want to inspect damaged shipping boxes. So, the photos show what the contents of a package looked like prior to any damage which occurs.
I think that the photos are a selling point if included in an original eBay listing. That way buyers know if they are dealing with a competent seller / packager or a turkey.
And, it's a lot more convincing than saying, "Oh, I know how package safely."
Regards,
ag01
tobaccocardyahoo
I do not buy on Ebay for resale on Ebay because there has to be something wrong if the seller is selling for a price which allows me to resell at a profit. Often the problem is the seller himself and that can translate into the product.
I do not buy many items for my own use on Ebay. Most of what I buy is new and in production. If it is a major brand product, I want the warranty to be in effect and for it to be new, not b-goods, open box or liquidation stock, that means I buy elsewhere.
If it is a Chinese commodity product, my goal is the lowest price, since if it fails I will throw it away, Ebay is no longer the lowest price.
Most of the items I buy on Ebay are from sellers on my Saved Sellers list. The rest are from sellers I am aware of for other reasons, including the Ebay forums.
It works for me. I have many sources of product to choose from, and a low tolerance for retailers who offer little value.
You will not find me waiting on line at Dollar General for the one cashier to check me out.
articulatedgeared01
OPtobaccocardyahoo:
I felt that you provided some valid and worthwhile information. However, the information did not address the subject of eBay seller packaging improvement.
b-goods / open box or liquidation stock: It is my belief that most of the premium garage sale items and liquidation stock were sold off years ago on eBay. Based on my specific interests (used / pre-owned electro-mechanical items), my concern is that there is too much distressed junk in the eBay pipeline (perhaps as much as 50%). If you need parts or can repair items, then what is available on eBay is probably a feast. However, premium items may be more famine than feast.
If items are poorly packaged, then that increases the junk in the eBay pipeline. Let's say for discussion e that poor packaging accounts for the loss of another 16% of pre-owned / used items. That means that only 1/3 of what is on eBay may be useful as a potentially complete / finished item.
I have previously tried to make an argument for more manufacturing in America. This is neither a democratic or republican issue. It is an American issue. Without more manufacturing, the pipeline will eventually run dry.
I have a major concern about packaging issues. Unfortunately, most of the respondents to my post provided no specific feedback on how to improve eBay seller packaging practices. No discussion about cardboard boxes (type, thickness, domestic vs. foreign cardboard), no discussion about internal cribbing inside boxes to prevent crushing, no discussion about the best type of fill material, no discussion about the stand-off distance between the item being shipped and inside of the shipping box, no discussion about how to keep items from rattling / shifting / vibrating inside shipping boxes, no discussion about how to provide unpackaging instructions for packaged items, no discussion of electro-static issues associated with Styrofoam peanuts, no discussion about waste handling / repurposing of packaging materials, no discussion on handling potentially dangerous materials (for example, lead and or white lead oxide from corrosion or zinc and zinc oxide from corrosion), etc. Therefore, I can only conclude that packaging problems are much more of an issue than I previously thought.
Regards,
ag01
articulatedgeared01
OPFri 12-12-2025 6:23 p.m.
albertabrightalberta:
Many years ago, I received a shipment from a lady in the Midwest. She did something interesting when she wrapped up one of my items. Instead of wrapping a rectangle of tissue paper around the item where the edge of the tissue paper was parallel to the item, she wrapped it diagonally. Then she put a single piece of 3/4-inch wide 3M Scotch tape on the corner of the tissue paper. I thought this was cool because it was extremely easy to unwrap and it allowed for reuse of the tissue paper for other eBay shipments.
This is the kind of clever information I am seeking to pass on to other ebay seller providing packaging in a video.
I am not so interested in "my way or the highway." I am interested in optimizing packaging efforts to save time and money. Most important, I want to find things that work and protect items being shipped.
Come folks, this is a chance to share your experiences and make eBay a better place to buy and sell.
Regards,
ag01
bonanza125
If a seller does a poor packaging job then leave appropriate feedback letting other buyers know that the seller did a poor packaging job. You can also file an "Item not describe" claim and return the item for a full refund if it's damage in the mail. It is the sellers responsibility to package correctly. If the item gets damage it on the seller. More claims towards the seller might give them the hint. Ebay can't really police packaging nor train sellers to ship to what's ok to you. They are not a babysitter either and will not require videos of packaging job. That's just not happening. If sellers have to upload videos to show the package guess what they will find another website to post on. You personally can message the seller and ask will this item be packaged up in a box or safely packaged. I get buyers from time to time asking and I tell them straight up how it will be shipped.
house*of*paws
Hi @articulatedgeared01
Is it only eBay packages that have such a high percentage of damaged items? I’m frankly astonished by your findings.
Rather than instituting a world-wide system of certifying package-wrapping abilities … which seems infeasible … I would recommend against choosing ‘Free shipping’ options, as well as purchasing the cheapest item listed of its kind. I guarantee that alone will reduce shipping damage greatly.
articulatedgeared01
OPI was talking with a mechanic who lives down the street. He told me two things. He indicated that [some] auto parts coming in from foreign countries are junk or don't meet original specifications. He also indicated that practicing mechanics are upset about this.
The mechanic indicated that he stopped purchasing auto glass locally. He started having glass shipped to him instead. The glass supplier indicated that their typical shipping damage rate was 40%. Years ago,I read an article about India's shipping damage rate - also 40%.
I visited a dumpster at a Ferrari dealer in Denver. There was a Styrofoam container for shipping auto glass in the dumpster. The thickness of the Styrofoam around the molded glass cavity was nominally 6 inches thick. I have also studied packaging crates for shipping sensitive analytical instruments (big buck stuff) from Germany and Japan. I still have a lot to learn about packaging.
The cheapest: I was tutored by a senior engineer at work many years ago. We were talking about cheap taps and dies utilized for machining metal parts. He indicated that you do not want to use a cheap tap when you are machining a $10,000 part.
When Robert Goddard was firing off rockets in New Mexico, he was doing something which might have been considered "impossible." Goddard understood rocket theory / rocket science. When the head of the WWII German rocket program was asked how his team of rocketry experts learned about the technical side rocketry he replied, "Robert Goddard." I have read about Robert Goddard.
As a discipline, packaging might be compared to rocket science. Some packaging efforts fail and some rockets fail. Some packaging efforts succeed and some rockets succeed.
Regards,
ag01
grand-and-glorious-purpose
Are you at least 90% certain that the problem is everyone else?
hotwheelsbum
Read the Feedback they're leaving for all these Sellers they're buying from. Pay close attention to the false positives. Looks like it may be a 10% poor packing problem with these Sellers, and 90% imaginary problems, problems created in their own mind.
articulatedgeared01
OPFri 12-12-2025 1:20 p.m.
grand-and-glorious-purpose:
I did not come in with the last load of watermelons.
Some time ago, I heard from an eBay community member who indicated that he had considerable packaging experience (that is, technical experience). And it was clear that he did have some technical experience. I was impressed with his knowledge about cardboard. Unfortunately, there were limits to his technical experience and I could see some of the weaknesses in his knowledge. Sometimes experience and pride can get in the way of doing a good job.
Prior to WWII, Japan had some of the most capable fighter pilots in the world. Japan also had some very capable sailors working in gunnery positions. However, Americans thought that the Japanese were "inferior" to Americans. America paid a high price for being arrogant.
After WWII, the Japanese wanted to find out why they lost the war. They traced their failure to US Military Standards and statistical quality control expert, Edwards Demming. Demming was invited to visit Japan and teach the Japanese about statistical quality control (Demming's 14 points). So, the Japanese learned.
Now you understand why so many Americans are driving around in Japanese cars.
I am an engineer who was schooled in Demming's philosophy. Admittedly, I still have much to learn. However, I am a life-long learner.
Regards,
ag01
simba6
I have found some sellers that don't pack very well but it's not all that often. Buyers are protected and after they give a few refunds they learn to pack better. Back in the days of snail mail payments I once had a buyer send by instructions on how to pack. Not just written, this a purchased not copied reprints from a hobby magazine. Complete with pictures. Back then there was NO buyer protection.
I have found less then 1% of purchases gets damaged in shipping.
articulatedgeared01
OPFri 12-12-2025 1:10 p.m.
simba6:
Learn to pack better: As I responded previously, there are slow learners out there in eBay-land.
I remember reading something about architect Frank Lloyd Wright. Wright liked to hire older craftsmen to work on building the structures he designed. the older workers were slower, but they were experienced. The younger craftsmen were faster but tended to make mistakes. In some cases, the younger craftsmen never learned to do a job correctly in the first plac.
I am not extolling the virtues of older workers or picking on younger workers. People are individuals and are raised by caring / uncaring families, educated poorly / well, or hired by caring / uncaring employers. There are turkeys and genius-level folks out there in eBay-land. I have dealt with both and those in between.
Regards,
ag01
klhmdg
Buying online isnt for everyone.
Neither is selling.
Sometimes if the stress is too much it is better to find other alternatives.
dirk12955
And then some members,
manage to send to ebay buyers and receive 1,000s of orders from ebay
sellers and do so without issue.
hotwheelsbum
Have you read the Feedback this Buyer here has been leaving for others for the purchases they are making from these Sellers? It's self induced stress they're causing. If there's people on this planet who DO NOT need to be buying online, this Buyer here is one of them.
articulatedgeared01
OPFri 12-12-2025 1:33 p.m.
hotwheelsbum:
No comment.
Regards.
ag01
hotwheelsbum
That's OK. After reading all these other comments you're leaving with these other Members, I don't really want a long drawn out jibber jabbered response to what needed to be said.
Did notice though, you claimed to be an Engineer. While well educated, Engineers are some of the most ignorant people out there when it comes to simple solutions. They tend to overthink things. Lack common sense when it comes to the simplest of tasks.
For years I had a warehouse that I sold used Industrial Equipment and Business related items out of. I'd occasionally sell Used Office Furniture when I ran across it. My "uneducated" Contractors that I used to do pick ups for me, and do my deliveries, could load and unload a 28ft Budget Box truck in an hour, less an hour, a little over an hour, just by looking at the Furniture and knowing how to Jig Saw Puzzle the furniture into the truck to get the maximum about of Furniture into the trucks per load. They did it by eyesight, not using measuring tapes measuring each piece of Furniture, then diagramming it into the Box of the truck.
One day I had this 30 something year old Doctor come in who setting up his own Clinic/Office. He bought 3-4 Desk sets, 15-20 chairs, some filing cabinets, a break room set, other misc office stuff. I offered to set up delivery for him with my Contractors. He declined, said him and his Father will just rent a UHaul to save money. OK with me. Well, couple of days later, him and his Father showed up. Small talk before they started loading it was revealed 60 something year old Father was an Engineer. I offered to give them hints on loading (I don't assist when Customers pick up on their own. I just line up their items outside the doors. THEY load. Covers Liability issues after they leave) Father told me "No, we got this", then he pulled out a notepad and a measuring tape from the front of the UHaul and started measuring the furniture, and diagramming it out on that pad on how they were going to load that UHaul. 4 1/2 Hours later they finally drove off my property with their load. I watched this in awe at how ignorant Father had been "diagramming" this load, THEN watching them struggle to get the pieces to fit right. It was quite comical.
From reading all those False Positive Feedbacks you've left for the Sellers you've bought from over the years. The Complaining, the detailed problems with each item you bought, you are that "Father" I dealt with that day. And I stand by what I said, you are one that does not need to be buying online. You just don't.
articulatedgeared01
OPFri 12-12-2025 1:00 p.m.
klhmdg:
I agree about the buying and selling.
Stress: I spend some of my time repairing and rebuilding items which were poorly packaged where I received a partial refund. This applies to items accumulated over the last 20 years from eBay sellers. I will be dead before I finish all the work. What I don't need is more poorly packaged / shipping damaged items with attendant partial refunds. Therefore, I am trying to be proactive about sellers providing packaging photos and eBay providing packaging tutorials (maybe U-Tube style).
Regards,
ag01
albertabrightalberta
If you aren't exaggerating and 90% of your items coming with damage and sometimes items are a total loss, then my belief is that YOU own some of the responsibility of not vetting sellers carefully enough. In my 20+ years of buying items, I've had way less than 1% of issues.
Ebay's help pages do advise sellers on listing, describing, photographing and packaging but sellers are presumably adults and it's not ebay's job to hold hands.
Sellers who package items poorly eventually get so many NAD (not as described) returns that they're either booted from ebay, they quit or they learn to do a better job.
Yes, it's an inconvenience to have to file claims and repackage and return items but it happens when buyers make online purchases. There's a price to pay for the convenience of clicking a few buttons, making a payment and waiting a few days for the item to be delivered to your door without having to get out of your chair.
Yes and you grade your purchases like you're the teacher: "A" for description, "B" for condition, "C" for cost and "F" for packaging. You even grade sellers on price! Items are worth what a willing buyer pays for it and should not be graded.
This isn't school and you aren't the teacher.
articulatedgeared01
OPFri 12-12-2025 12:30 p.m.
albertabrightalberta:
Your "unqualified" 1% damage rate. You did not describe what you have been purchasing on eBay - for example, Snap-On box wrenches made of chrome-plated steel, pantyhose, sweaters, Nerf footballs made of flexible foam, etc. What about items like dishes made from glass or porcelain or Hummel figures, or tail-lights from a Subaru, etc.
Vetting - eBay sellers will tell you they package well (for example, I package "safely" with no technical packaging details) and then don't do what they say. They will also sign up to follow the packaging instructions I send them and then they will package things their normal way (less than adequate). Besides, items get dropped, kicked, thrown, and vibrated as the packages travel across the Country. The static environment for a package sitting on your kitchen table is one thing and the dynamic environment in a delivery truck is another thing.
eBay's job to hold hands: I disagree. It's my money on the line and my goods which I paid for as advertised. eBay is a "facilitator." However, they are not doing their job. eBay doesn't care if a rare piece of crystal (two in existence) is damaged, they just crank up their return software. Now there is only one rare piece left in the world unless number two is glued back together.
NAD returns - Please consider slow learners in your argument. Also, the economy is in rough shape. Do you really think eBay is going to boot anybody off? eBay needs all the revenue (selling fees) it can get. Have you noticed the rating system (generally between 99% and 97%). I have never seen a 70% (average rating) on eBay in 20 years.
Convenience: I went to the grocery store a couple of years ago and noticed a Barbie doll on the sale table for $2.97. What captured my attention was that the doll was splint packaged (paperboard with punched holes) in a paperboard box with plastic ties around the doll legs, waist, arms and neck. If China can do it for $2.97, why can't I get a fragile $100 item packaged that way? There is reason for the American rust belt and 434 industrial plants closed down in Pennsylvania alone. Johnny can't read, write or spell either. I remain hopeful, but I am often disappointed.
Regards,
ag01
albertabrightalberta
"Your "unqualified" 1% damage rate. You did not describe what you have been purchasing on eBay - for example, Snap-On box wrenches made of chrome-plated steel, pantyhose, sweaters, Nerf footballs made of flexible foam, etc. What about items like dishes made from glass or porcelain or Hummel figures, or tail-lights from a Subaru, etc. "
I can say that in my entire 20+ years on ebay, I've had less than a handful on claims on 3 different IDs as a seller and as a buyer.
As a buyer:
1. I filed a claim for non-receipt from a seller who I believe died. Before my first purchase, I'd checked his feedback (from buyers) and all was great. I'd purchased from him previous times over several years without issue but the last purchase did not arrive. After getting my refund, I noticed a lot of negs from buyers claiming non-receipt. I assumed he'd died.
2. Another claim as a buyer was NAD for an expired health care item
3. The third claim was for a seller from Kenya who used a fake tracking scam. Item showed delivery to the correct city but the package wasn't addressed to me or my address.
As a seller:
have sold and shipped Hummels in 2 dozen different sales and have never had a complaint about packaging or damage. But I pack well and many feedback comments state that.
The one damage complaint I did have to refund was postal damage and I filed an insurance claim with USPS and got reimbursed.
"Vetting - eBay sellers will tell you they package well (for example, I package "safely" with no technical packaging details) and then don't do what they say."
That's not vetting. You look at sellers' feedback for comments describing how well or how poorly they ship. Sellers don't usually state that "I throw items into an envelope and don't care if they break." Of course they tell you how good they are, how well they pack stuff, etc. But feedback is a way more transparent way to get a feel for the seller.
"eBay's job to hold hands: I disagree. It's my money on the line and my goods which I paid for as advertised. eBay is a "facilitator." However, they are not doing their job. eBay doesn't care if a rare piece of crystal (two in existence) is damaged, they just crank up their return software. Now there is only one rare piece left in the world unless number two is glued back together."
No, ebay provides the venue and the MBG policy. Sellers are independent contractors so it's not ebay's job to control sellers.
"Do you really think eBay is going to boot anybody off? eBay needs all the revenue (selling fees) it can get. Have you noticed the rating system (generally between 99% and 97%). I have never seen a 70% (average rating) on eBay in 20 years."
Every day there are sellers who come to these boards complaining about ebay not allowing them to sell any more.
As for feedback percentages, numbers don't lie. For a seller to have a 70% feedback rating, they're either new with very few feedbacks or they're awful and would be booted if buyers had complained.
And in fact, a 97% feedback score is not good. (This isn't a high school test where 97 is almost perfect.)
articulatedgeared01
OP6:10 p.m. 12-12-2025
albertabrightalberta:
Some interesting comments - particularly about sellers being booted off of the eBay platform.
However, I was looking for more educational information which might help with packaging issues - particularly for less experienced eBay sellers.
I have a major concern about packaging issues. Unfortunately, most of the respondents to my post provided no specific feedback on how to improve eBay seller packaging practices. No discussion about cardboard boxes (type, thickness, domestic vs. foreign cardboard), no discussion about internal cribbing inside boxes to prevent crushing, no discussion about the best type of fill material, no discussion about the stand-off distance between the item being shipped and inside of the shipping box, no discussion about how to keep items from rattling / shifting / vibrating inside shipping boxes, no discussion about how to provide unpackaging instructions for packaged items, no discussion of electro-static issues associated with Styrofoam peanuts, no discussion about waste handling / repurposing of packaging materials, no discussion on handling potentially dangerous materials (for example, lead and or white lead oxide from corrosion or zinc and zinc oxide from corrosion), etc. Therefore, I can only conclude that packaging problems are much more of an issue than I previously thought.
Also, no discussion on how to simplify unpackaging (for example, finger holes in cardboard cribbing sheets inside shipping boxes), no discussion about placing items directly next to the inside the wall of a shipping box or zero stand-off distance to protect item inside shipping box (bad packaging practice for fragile items), no discussion about top or end / accordion crushing of shipping boxes, no discussion about the potential for shipping box punctures.
I think a video could help eBay sellers address some of these important issues.
I saw a couple of eBay-provided packaging tips today and found them to be useless (too general with no examples / images).
Regards,
ag01
stainlessenginecovers
So ebay needs to now certify sellers? Who certifies buyers?
I would think a couple of refunds for items broken will teach sellers much better than any 'video/certification' can.
articulatedgeared01
OPFri 12-12-2025 12:05 p.m.
stainlessenginecovers:
eBay needs to certify sellers after they view the packaging video I requested.
Given the damage I have seen due to poor packaging by eBay sellers over the past 20 years, it appears that buyer's expectations of eBay sellers is very low. Why buyers accept damaged goods is beyond me unless a partial refund is provided to offset shipping damage.
I do not believe that a couple of refunds will do the trick. I think a couple of hundred refunds will do the trick. Poor packagers are most likely slow learners too. I know of a seller in California who obviously needs the hundreds. However, his packaging eventually improved recently (as reported to me by a fellow eBay buyer).
The next time you get on an airplane, go to the hospital, or drive a car made in Japan, ask yourself what kind of training and certification pilots, doctors / nurses, assembly line technicians receive. Also ask yourself why soldiers go through basic training so they know their job and don't panic on the battlefield.
Regards,
ag01`
kathiec
There are about 17 million sellers, in dozens of countries, on eBay. How do you propose eBay can force them all to watch a video, much less certify them all after they purportedly do? I would add that I've been getting packages from eBay sellers for nearly three decades, and fewer than 1% have had packaging issues. I would echo others that perhaps buying online isn't for you.
The next time you get on an airplane, go to the hospital, or drive a car made in Japan, ask yourself what kind of training and certification pilots, doctors / nurses, assembly line technicians receive. Also ask yourself why soldiers go through basic training so they know their job and don't panic on the battlefield.
I hardly think shipping an eBay package is in the same class as pilots, doctors, and nurses, so it's kind of ridiculous to think the same standards should apply.
articulatedgeared01
OPFri 12-12-2025 1:57 p.m.
katiec:
Ridiculous: I watched a video of a team of Japanese engineers examining a microswitch. They handled it, examined it, played with it, etc. until they were satisfied with it. In contrast, an American engineer just specifies a microswitch for an application. Who's right?
Regards,
ag01
kathiec
I have absolutely no idea how this applies to anything I said. It does seem apparent from your penchant for arguing with everyone who posts that you have a "my way or the highway" approach that allows no one but you to have a valid opinion. To which I would parrot, "ridiculous".