Negative Feedback text replaced with "--"
A few days ago, I left some negative feedback for a seller (after having purchased, fully paid and received an item), combined with a fully detailed text about the reasons I did that so (without any personal information of course). All this time, my feedback text was there in place, with no response from the seller. Nevertheless, today I noticed that despite the fact that my negative feedback itself was still there, counted as negative in the seller's feedback rate, the explanation text I had written had been replaced with two dashes ("--"). I never received any e-mail from eBay regarding this fact. Why has this happened and what does it mean?
thanos99
10 comments
bennotbill
It usually means that the seller has submitted a sworn defamation complaint.
eBay generally always grants this by removing the offending words but leaving the red dot.
The drawback for the seller is it often looks worse as they cannot add a reply.
house*of*paws
Hi @thanos99
I had positive feedback I left for a seller show as 2 hyphens for no apparent reason. The seller’s feedback for me also showed as 2 hyphens. [Check my feedback profile to see both.]
The item was an antihistamine, and the feedback comment was banal. [The seller and listing are still active.]
I don’t know if my actual comment had ever shown in my or seller’s profiles, because I didn’t check it immediately.
That experience would make me question any explanation for why that might happen to a negative or neutral feedback comment. It simply defies logic. 🤔
house*of*paws
[Ran out of editing time.]
EDITED TO ADD:
There is one difference I noticed between your feedback and mine: The seller's name is all hyphens on the feedback I received and left ... while yours shows the seller's Username.
That makes it more likely that your comment was removed because of some violation of eBay policy ... but one can never be sure with quirky eBay.
thanos99
OPI definitely can't figure it out either! As it seems that it happens to positive feedbacks too, I tend to believe that the texts can be replaced with two dashes ("--") in case of violation of eBay rules regarding comments, either after seller's report or ex officio. In fact, I doubt if there have been any complaints from the seller's side in both our cases, as we sould have been accordingly notified somehow, as far as I know, when one side of a purchase files complaints against the other.
In my case, I have no idea what that supposed term violation was, as my language was decent, with no offensive adjectives or personal information. More or less, it was a text formed in the typical way of a dissatisfaction message. Moreover, other, fully detailed, negative feedback texts of that seller are still in place, without the seller having used their right to publically state their point of view underneath and that makes me assume they don't even care to pay attention if a customer gets disappointed.
Anyway regardless the facts that lead to a feedback text being erased, I believe that eBay should inform all sides about the clear reasons they procceed to that action. If I have made a mistake, I need to know!
wastingtime101
In your case @house*of*paws , eBay makes the FB private because of the category.
In @thanos99 case, the comment violated policy and warranted removal, but the neg itself stood as others mentioned above.
house*of*paws
Hey @wastingtime101
You're probably right as to the reason why my feedback was masked ... but other antihistamine items (just a different Brand Name) are NOT masked in the same seller's feedback profile.
ALL of the seller's items are OTC meds ... yet only about half of their feedback is masked. Items that I would consider more 'embarrassing/ private' ... like anti-fungal creams ... are NOT masked. [Ah, well ... there I go trying to be logical re eBay. LOL] Anyway, thanks for the tip!
gosimus
@house*of*paws Same here, except mine were ordinary over-the-counter analgesics, Aleve to be exact. It's probably something to do with "privacy" except I've bought hundreds of glucose meter test strips, and Areds 2 vitamins, and other diet supplements, and the comments have never been deleted from those feedbacks. And neither was there any technical violation in either the sellers' comments or my own. Stupid bots.
12345jamesstamps
Words or wordage was removed by eBay or the seller got it removed.
I mean, words like "lier. thief, mafia, etc" be allowed in eBay...probably not. Name calling is not allowed.
I assume there is more to the story we don't know.
Not sure what emails went back and forth which eBay reads all.
And also I assume you tried for a refund? Which would usually get a negative to a seller.
kathiec
Typically when the text is removed but the neg remains it's because it was determined something violated a feedback rule but not so egregiously that it warranted removing the red donut as well. Without knowing exactly what the neg said it's impossible to even guess what the violation was.
lakefor94
That means the seller lobbied eBay to remove the negative. The seller was successful in having the text removed but not the actual neg.
eBay does not ever notify the negative leaver of this action.
Happens all the time. It is a waste of time to call eBay and inquire.
Would not be surprised if the actual neg is removed at some point if the seller is persistent.