Is there anybody who can help? Accidentally bid on and paid for wrong item.
Hello,
I accidentally bid on the wrong item and did not realize it until after I paid and printed my receipt later that night. I contacted the seller right away, explained and apologized for my error and asked if they would please cancel the transaction. The seller apparently did not see my message (or ignored it?) and issued a shipping label with UPS. When saw the shipping notice I immediately contacted the seller and BEGGED them not to ship. I even told them that I would pay for the shipping label, if it can not be cancelled.
I contacted UPS and was told that this label has not been used, yet, and that it can still be voided. The seller would then get their money back for the voided shipping label.
I even told the seller I will buy something else from the to make up for my mistake and the inconvenience I have caused.
But the seller's response was (approximately) "Sorry I can not change it anymore. The sale is final, nothing I can do about it. You can sell it yourself later". So basically, I am stuck with a very overpriced item that is impossible to sell for anywhere near the price I paid.
Is there nothing that can be done? I know the seller can still cancel the transaction as long as the item is not in the possession of the shipper (UPS).
I tired to contact eBay, but with this new system there seems to be no way to get anybody to talk to or to message with.
Does anybody here have any ideas what I can do?
Thank you so much for your help!
kh-cathy
Hi everyone,
Due to the age of this thread, it has been closed to further replies. Please feel free to start a new thread if you wish to continue to discuss this topic.
Thank you for understanding.
simba6
One must take care when bidding and buying. Your the one who clicked..............
johi_5529
I did the same thing is there any one who can help???
dryophelia
@johi_5529
It’s always better to start your own thread. Old ones that get dredged up are generally locked when a moderator notices.
If the seller won’t work with you, then maybe you can sell it yourself.
What is the return policy on that listing? Maybe you can return it at your expense.
nobody*s_perfect
@johi_5529
You should immediately send a message to the seller, asking them to cancel the transaction.
femmefan1946
The cost of tracked international shipping is very high. If the seller is new, they are going to have an awful shock paying shipping both ways from Canada.
A 1500gr (~three pounds) Tracked Packet USA would be $27.02Cdn. by Canada Post which is much cheaper than any of the commercial couriers.
If as you say the seller is a newbie, it will be interesting to see if they have a complaint about all this on the dotCA seller boards.
catromancer
OPThe seller has about 50+ feedback, all positive, except one neutral - an issue the buyer had about having to wait over one month before the item was shipped and non-communication and/or incorrect communication about when the item will be shipped.
This seller often lists so called "pre-sale" items, meaning they don't have the actual item they are selling on hand and are using stock photos only.
Now, if I had any say here at eBay, I would not allow "pre-sales", as the pictures posted usually violate eBay policy.
nenu-5410
Since it still has not shipped @catromancer if the outfit finally arrives after the ORIGINAL* latest estimated delivery date currently shown on your Order Detail page
Exclusions and special coverage when the item doesn't match the listing
The item arrived after the latest estimated delivery date
Covered
The return is treated as if the item didn't match the listing.
Click RETURN THIS ITEM to start a return request for "Didn't match the listing" because eBay considers that that date is part of the seller's listing.
After 3 business days and you still don't have a full refund or a prepaid return label, go back to click Ask eBay to step in. Then if the seller clicks that they cannot issue a return label, come back here for help.
*the estimated date will move forward when it finally ships
catromancer
OPThank you for this detailed information.
The latest est. delivery date is June 29, so the seller still has plenty of time to take the shipment to UPS.
sdneped
A scrap of info @catromancer -- unlike USPS, both FedEx and UPS labels are inert until after they are actually shipped, when the carrier will carefully measure and weigh the label, to figure out how much to bill.
Preceding, the labels can be printed or corrected and reprinted or tossed and nothing is billed if they are never used.
catromancer
OPThank you. That is basically what UPS also told me.
The seller apparently ignored my first message (asking if they would please cancel the transaction) , which was sent many hours BEFORE they issued the shipping label.
In response to my second message, AFTER they issued the shipping label/tracking number, the seller told me this (copied and pasted here):
"Hi … I just see the note a few minutes ago .. but the shipping process was already started and will not able to cancel it .. and it’s already paid .. and shipping label also .."
This sounded to me like it was not possible the cancel/void the shipping label.
I rarely use UPS or FedEx and I wasn't sure if this is correct, so I called UPS.
PS: The item still has not been shipped.
soh.maryl
What is the last estimated delivery date?
And, BTW, an UNUSED shipping label can be cancelled.
catromancer
OP"What is the last estimated delivery date?"
It's a range from June 13 through June 29.
The seller has given him/herself plenty of time.
It is coming from Canada and going to the southernmost State in the US.
"And, BTW, an UNUSED shipping label can be cancelled."
Yes, thank you. I learned this from the other responders.
sdneped
Pointing this out to those responders tap-dancing around the eBay picture policy: The seller violated policy.
It's one reason why eBay has the policy so it's confirmation, small phone or no, during checkout what we're buying.
catromancer
OPThank you!! Maybe tonight I will finally get some sleep.
albertabrightalberta
When I originally responded to your situation early in this thread, I wasn't sympathetic to you and thought you should eat the purchase.
However after looking at both listings, seeing (almost) identical pictures and nearly identical descriptions, I'm less understanding of the seller. (Yes, the title did mention "outfits only" but the gallery picture showed the doll wearing the outfit. THAT, IMO is quite misleading (at worst) and a mistake on the seller's part (at best).
Although I do understand that buyers like to see what the outfit looks like on the doll, the main picture in the listing should have shown clothes only and in the description, she should have stated (in bold colored font), "although this listing doesn't include doll, picture #____ shows a doll wearing the dress so you can see what it looks like."
My opinion is that neither the title NOR the description show enough differentiation between what is and isn't included.
If the seller lists clothing items sans doll but isn't clear in pictures, she will continue to have confusing listings and unhappy buyers.
Understand that I'm not excusing @catromancer 's lack of careful reading of the title and description but in this case, that error was less than the misleading nature of the way the listing was pictured.
catromancer
OPThank you for taking the time to view the auction details and for making an effort to understand why I made the error.
I did not come here to get sympathy. I clearly messed up.
I started this thread because I hoped one of you could give me some hints how to get in touch with an eBay representative who might help me to try and convince the seller not to ship the item.
I don't want the seller to get hurt by having to pay shipping fees both ways because I made a mistake. Maybe they are not experienced enough to know about the eBay picture policy? I'd like to give them the benefit of the doubt - that they are not posting pictures that violate eBay policy on purpose.
At the same time I would like to avoid being stuck with a grossly overpriced item that I did not want to buy.
You referred to the seller as "she", so you seem to have access to information that mere mortals don't have. (Right now, I only know the seller's ID, nothing else.)
No, I don't want to know how or why, but I was wondering if you have the ability to let the seller know what is about to happen if they ship the item.
I thought about telling the seller what I learned here, but I'm afraid it will be interpreted as a threat and would only anger them (her).
albertabrightalberta
LOL! I referred to the seller as "she" because of the category of item. I just assumed it's a female because I can't even imagine my husband knowing the first thing about dolls and doll clothes. (I also sell in the handbag category and I would usually refer to handbag sellers as "she" too.) I'm very progressive but I guess my gender assumptions on ebay are indicative of my generation.
I'm really impressed by your lack of defensiveness, admission of your own error (though understandable why you made the mistake) and mostly, your patience and empathy for the seller and the possibility that the seller is new and not clear on ebay policy rather than the seller purposely being misleading. You are far more worthy of sympathy in this situation than I would be!
catromancer
OPThank you for your kind words.
You would be surprised how many doll collectors are male, especially for these types of "fashion dolls" that come with miniature versions of high fashion designer clothes (or variations thereof).
About one third of the dolls I purchased here on eBay in the past 8 or so years came from men.
Remember, most of the hugely successful fashion designers are male.
wes-4507
If you significantly overpaid for an auction item, that means someone else was also willing to significantly overpay. Run a fixed price listing for a few dollars less than what you paid.
catromancer
OPI bet my right arm that at least some, if not all of the other bidders who bid over US$ 350.00 were also mislead by the picture(s) that the seller posted, showing the entire doll in her outfit, and not just the outfit without the doll.
I wish there was a way to contact those bidders and ask them.
Worldwide, the current AVERAGE selling price for the outfit only (clothes and accessories, like shoes & jewelry) is approximately $235.48, excluding shipping fees.
Current offers for sale (worldwide) for the outfit only range from US$ 175.00 to US$ 358, also excluding shipping fees.
I paid US$ 562.50, plus shipping and sales tax (7%), thinking I was buying the complete doll.
simba6
You can always resell it yourself if you don't want it. After all, it was not the seller's fault.
ms.rodriguez*
When second Ebay seller account was the result of the many, many mistakes that I made when I started on Ebay in 1998. I bid on identical items and did not even realize it.
When you get the item, if there is a fault or something does not match the description, open an item not as described case. Now be honest. Do NOT do this just to get a refund. I truly believe in karma and you don't want a buyer opening a false claim on something you sold.
Try selling it. Even if it's a loss, well that gets you a tax deduction expense when you fill out next years tax form.
Sometimes, sellers will not cancel for any reason. He/she must've needed the money. As a seller, I would have refunded you fully. Goodluck.
catromancer
OPThank you for your message.
I am not exactly making a ton of money with the items I sell - yes, some are profitable, but others are a loss, and that is ok. But I really don't need a $400+ loss for tax purposes.
catromancer
OPYou said that maybe the reason the seller refused to cancel is because they need money.
I was curious if that could be the case, so I checked what they sold in the past month:
Total sales was approx. US$ 4,475 , per eBay's currency conversion, so not a large volume.
Cost of the items sold was approx. US$ 2,350, including shipping fees to the seller's location.
I know what the cost is because I am a member of the manufacturer's membership club, as must be this seller. Otherwise they would not have been able to obtain the dolls they sell in general, and the doll/outfit from the auction(s) we are discussing in particular. This is a very limited edition lottery doll and only members who won the "right-to-buy" lottery were allowed to purchase them. Obviously, I did not win a doll at the lottery and therefore tried to win one at auction (this usually means the buyer has to pay a huge markup and he seller is making a very nice profit).
The seller's shipping fees to customers are a bit on the high side, compared to some other sellers in Canada, so, subsidizing their shipping fees is not really an issue. The only major cost they incur are eBay's selling fees (you all know what they are).
Members of the manufacturer's club often sell some of the dolls they ordered to help pay for the purchase of their own dolls - the ones they want to keep.
Anyway, I don't believe this seller is in desperate need for money. He/She is just a jerk, if I may say this here.
Once again, I thank you all for your contributions, your valued opinions and advice.
kathiec
This is a common issue when a seller is selling an item they don't have in hand. They post the advertising photos. But the listing for the outfit only says in the title, in large bold letters, NO DOLL, outfits only. Further, in the description it states exactly what's included. So I really don't see how you can pin this on the seller.
catromancer
OPI never want to pin anything on anybody. I clearly made a mistake. I had simply hoped that the seller would work with me and would cancel the order. It still has not shipped, per 7:38pm EDT.
They do have a different doll I was looking to buy, soon. Their price is about $50-60 higher than from a few other sellers, but I would have gladly paid that extra money for their inconvenience.
I guess it's just my luck that I run into a seller who has zero compassion and is not willing to help in any way. And no, I would never do this to my customers. Never!
catromancer
OPAnd one more thing: I was aware that the seller had two different auctions, I simply bid on the wrong one of the the two by accident.
kathiec
Please understand that no one is accusing you of any malice at all in this situation. Accidents happen. Unfortunately you can't always transfer the consequences of those accidents to someone else.
catromancer
OPWell, you sure sound like it.
What consequences does a seller have for helping a buyer correct a mistake, especially when the buyer takes full responsibility for the error, offers all kinds of help, offers to pay shipping fees, offers to buy another item from the seller? Anyway, there are just too many nasty people here on eBay. I will start looking for a different venue to sell my items and I will eventually stop buying here.
Thank you all for your help.
catromancer
OPThe letters were the same thickness as the rest of the text
kathiec
You seem to keep coming back to how you'd handle things as a seller. While I applaud your attention to customer service, every seller has their own way of doing business. So you can't just say "this seller should cancel the order because I would". Sellers aren't required to accept cancellation requests. Period. Contacting eBay won't change that.
I also don't feel it would be ethical to open a 'not as described' case. First off, if you discover you bought the wrong thing by re-reading the description, by definition it's as described. Beyond that, I've been buying dolls and outfits on eBay for more than 25 years. I actually became a member because eBay was becoming a huge market for vintage Barbie, and the vast majority of my 1000+ purchases have been doll related. I learned early on that sellers photograph outfits on dolls because buyers want to see how it looks on a doll. So you quickly learn to look at descriptions for those standard phrases: "doll not included", "stand not included", "accessories not included", etc.
I'm sorry that you were in hurry and misread the listing. And I agree that the seller should have agreed to cancel, particularly given how willing you were to make up for their inconvenience. But sometimes you just have to accept the consequences of your actions.
catromancer
OPThank you for your opinion.
There were no photo of the actual item(s). Only stock photos.
ma-647837
eBay probably has a good reason for the picture policy -- that the photo shows the actual item you're about to buy -- but the reason escapes me right now, can't think why eBay would instate such a policy.
ma-647837
Cat, the eBay policy is:
What is the policy?
The following are not allowed:
Nothing more to add. Return the package as Not as described, seller pays return shipping, get your full refund, and @catromancer don't ever buy from that seller again.
Or if you paid with a credit card, refuse the UPS package, which cancels your eBay coverage.
Your credit card considers a refused delivery to be a valid return. File a chargeback, provide the UPS tracking number, and get your refund.
catromancer
OPSo, what you are saying is that the fact that this seller posted pictures that did not accurately represent the item is a valid return reason?
I will try to post a few pictures here so you know what I'm talking about. Please give me a few minutes
ma-647837
eBay has repeatedly stated not to to include anything in the photos, which the buyer will not receive. The responders here understand this, so much so that we joke if the cat is included, or the soda can or coin added in the picture to compare with the size of the item.
This is not a skate: You wanted the doll, you saw the photo of the doll, you bought that listing with that photo.
catromancer
OPI could not post the pictures, but here are the eBay item numbers:
This is the listing for the complete doll which I wanted to buy: eBay item number: 134594245350
This is the listing for the outfit only: eBay item number: 134593705859
The only difference to the pictures of the complete doll is that in the 3rd photo the head of the doll is cut off. Other than that the pictures are basically the same. And, most importantly, the first photo of the outfit is identical to the first photo for the complete doll. The first photo is the one you see when you do a search, it is also the only one you see while you are paying during checkout. On a small mobile device you can not read the entire description, so I find it important that the first picture is the one that shows the actual item being sold.
catromancer
OPI understand. Thank you very much for your help!
catromancer
OPThank you for posting this policy excerpt and the other info.
I did pay with my Amex.
stuff4divas
@catromancer assuming the seller accepts returns, once rec'd, open a return item case with the reason 'changed my mind'
u will have to pay for return shipping
catromancer
OPSeller does not accept returns
stuff4divas
@catromancer well, there u go. paying for your mistake.
after 15 years on ebay, according to this ebay id, u already know what to do.
keep it and move on, file a paypal return or dispute the charge.
LOVE ur cat photo 😺
catromancer
OPThank you - regarding my cat picture. That was my beloved companion, Rumrunner. Sadly, he's gone over the rainbow bridge. I miss him very much.
albertabrightalberta
Yes, you are correct that the seller can cancel and can also do so as "buyer requested" without any ding to his account. But clearly, this seller doesn't want to cancel and doesn't have to do so.
But since you state that you're a seller also, the seller's suggestion that you list and sell it yourself is reasonable.
ETA @catromancer
I see that as a seller, you don't accept returns either. Presumably you understand your seller's point of view!
catromancer
OPYes, I could accept my fate and try to sell the item, which will be a roughly $400 loss after shipping cost and fees. Obviously, I am not thrilled about loosing that much money. That's why I pleaded with the seller, offered to buy a different item from them and also offered to pay for their shipping label if they help me out with the cancellation. I would have gladly done all that, because I felt bad for making this stupid mistake and I never want to cause any problems for anybody.
The reason I currently don't accept returns is because I meticulously photograph and describe my items. And I only post pictures of the actual item I'm selling. If I ever post a stock photo, it will be the very last picture posted and I write that this picture is for reference only. It has nothing to do with a particular point of view.
femmefan1946
As a seller you should know
No Returns does not mean NO REFUNDS.
If you open a Claim, the seller can demand the return of the item, even with a No Refunds policy.
The only question becomes who pays for return shipping.
Since you were the one who made the mistake, the seller can make you pay for the return shipping, but must REFUND when they get it back.
If the seller does not refund voluntarily, eBay will refund the buyer, and then go after the seller for their money. The seller also gets a Defect and does not get FVF refunded.
If for some reason eBay does not accept the Claim, the buyer is still covered by Paypal's strong Buyer Protection program for 180 days from payment.
However, the buyer pays for return shipping if the seller demands return before refund.
And of course the credit card chargeback, although card policies vary, most allow 120 to 180 days for chargeback claims.
You might politely remind the seller about the Money Back Guarantee and your other consumer protections.
And don't buy with a phone. Seriously.
catromancer
OPThank you for your input. I appreciate it.
Regarding using the phone: I will avoid it as much as possible, but I'm not always on a regular computer when auctions I'm interested in are ending.
Can I put in a request with eBay that auctions only end at night, when I'm at home? 😸
safetyfirst5-91
A seller should never ship to a buyer who does not want the item, it only opens the door for problems like bad feedback and INAD returns. As mentioned above, eBay almost always takes the side of the buyer.
catromancer
OPI agree with that. As a seller myself, I would never insist on shipping something to a buyer if they made a mistake and ask me to cancel an item. It's not worth the potential hassle.
stuff4divas
@catromancer totally agree, if a buyer asks to cancel, i don't care what the reason is, i immediately approve it and move on.
tinsoldierunderground
The seller CAN cancel the transaction, but is under no obligation to do so as far as ebay is concerned.
How did you not see that you were bidding on an item you didn't want, and paid way too much for?
You can try opening a case with ebay after you receive the item. Most of the time they side with the buyer no matter who is at fault.
soh.maryl
What kind of a case could the OP open with eBay?
catromancer
OPI would be interested to know this, too.
The seller DID post the same pictures for two different items. This is something I would never do.
If I sell a doll outfit only, I post pictures of the outfit, and not of the complete doll. If you do as this seller did, it can cause confusion.
catromancer
OPHi,
Thank you for your message.
I sell on ebay myself and I do know that the seller can cancel a sale for various reasons. This particular seller just seems very stubborn and unwilling to help.
If i'm allowed, I will post the 2 eBay item numbers, so you can see why I made this mistake. The pictures the seller posted for the 2 different items were identical. Please also read my response to albertabrightalberta
stuff4divas
@catromancer u don't need to explain or justify why or how u made this error, everybody makes mistakes.
since u r both a buyer and seller, u know what to do. i already posted for u just to return it.
catromancer
OPWell, I'm not a very experienced seller. I only just started selling again a few weeks ago.
A lot has changed here on ebay since my past selling experience and I'm trying to re-orient myself.
What really bugs me is that it's virtually impossible these days to get somebody from customer service if your question, or request does not fit the cookie-cutter reasons/options for why you need help.
You said to just return it, but the seller does not accept returns. So what reason for return should I choose? Not as pictured?
soh.maryl
Have you contacted the seller and explained that you made a mistake and would like to return it since it's already shipped? You have stated here that you would be willing to pay the return shipping cost. Is your seller aware of that?
catromancer
OP"Have you contacted the seller and explained that you made a mistake and would like to return it since it's already shipped? You have stated here that you would be willing to pay the return shipping cost. Is your seller aware of that? "
Yes, I have contacted them multiple times, the first time last night, many hours before they issued the shipping label. Then I contacted them again, after they issued the shipping label (item was not in possession of carrier (UPS) at that time (and still is not per a few minutes ago).
Then I called UPS and asked if an unused shipping label can be voided, which they confirmed. Then I sent another message to the seller and explained this to them, as they seemed to think that they can not void the shipping label. I earlier offered to pay for their shipping label, in case it can not be voided, but that is not necessary, per UPS.
SO, even now it is still not shipped.
My first order of action was to try and get the order cancelled BEFORE it gets shipped, so I did not make any statements regarding return shipping to the seller, yet.
stuff4divas
@catromancer the true reason is 'ordered by mistake' but this is considered a remorse return and does not qualify for the seller to have to accept the return.
Not knowing how the listing was laid out, it may qualify for a non remorse reason 'doesn't match description or photos' if what u say is the doll was photographed wearing the outfit and so u thought u were bidding on the doll and the outfit.
also, u haven't rec'd the item yet, so u don't know if it has issues. I would just wait for the item to be delivered and see how it looks.
BTW - r we talking about a significant amount of $$ ?
catromancer
OPI will try to post the item numbers here, which should enable you to look up both auctions - the pictures posted and they way they were laid out.. Give me a moment
The item cost 750 CAN$, plus shipping and sales tax, so approx. US$ 625
catromancer
OPThis is the listing for the complete doll: eBay item number: 134594245350
This is the listing for the outfit only: eBay item number: 134593705859
The only difference to the pictures of the complete doll is that in the 3rd photo the head of the doll is cut off. Other than that the pictures are basically the same. And the first photo is identical to the first photo for the complete doll.
These are all promotional/stock photos from the manufacturer, Integrity Toys. They were not taken by the seller. There are no photos of the actual doll or the actual outfit.
Here is how the photos for the outfit only should have looked like, if you want to avoid confusing buyers and creating errors:
Please view the pictures in these two listings:
eBay item number: 185933049947
eBay item number: 314636186491
stuff4divas
@catromancer None of those item numbers come up for me, but it doesn't matter, u've made ur own case right here on the community posts.
It sounds like your return reason should be> doesn't match description or photos
Not only did they photograph the doll, which was misleading, they did NOT photograph the actual item being sold bc they used stock photos only, so that alone will win your case.
I think u should just chill until u receive the item then take it from there.
If the return case is not working for u, come back so we can help with that.
BTW- now I know y the seller would not cancel, it IS a significant amount of money u paid.
And, condolences for Rumrunner ^;^ I just lost 2 of my cats in the last year 😢 so I know the feeling
kathiec
So just to be clear, you're suggesting that the OP open a fraudulent 'not as described' case with eBay because they side buyers no matter who's at fault?
albertabrightalberta
@catromancer
When you make a purchase, there are several steps you take confirming your intentions and prior to making payment so I'm not even sure how you can "bid and pay for the wrong item by mistake." In fact, ebay policy does state that you're obligated to complete your end of the transaction even though neither ebay nor the seller can force you to do so.
Sellers aren't obligated to cancel when buyers request it. Most sellers do so but again, they aren't obligated.
If the seller has a return policy, you can request a return, choosing the reason that you bought by mistake. In that case, you'll have to pay for return shipping and if the seller had a separate shipping charge on the listing, that may be non-refundable.
If the seller doesn't have a return policy, you can request a return but again, he can deny it.
Learn a lesson from this experience and double and triple check your intentions BEFORE buying and paying for an item.
catromancer
OPHi, Thank you for your response.
The seller had 2 separate listings with the same picture of the complete doll. One listing was for a doll outfit only, the other was for the complete, brand new doll. I had them both on my watch list. Things got a bit hectic and a was distracted, so I accidentally bid on the outfit instead of the complete doll, which was what I wanted to buy. The headline for the 2 auctions was also very similar. That's why I did not realize my mistake right away or even during the payment process. Keep in mind that I did this from a cell phone with a small screen. Only when I printed my receipts later in the evening di I notice my mistake and contacted the seller right way, asking in a very friendly mea culpa message for cancellation.
stuff4divas
@catromancer lesson learned re cell phones and money transactions
catromancer
OPIndeed. A very expensive lesson.
nilukabeygunawardhan-0
🙄