I suspect some fishy seller practices
Summary: thefatleaffarm reported suspicious seller behavior on eBay, suspecting shill bidding, where bids are artificially inflated and then retracted, leaving them responsible for high costs. They expressed frustration with the reporting system's limitations and requested advice. kathiec and albertabrightalberta advised reporting the seller, mentioning eBay's tools for detecting shill bidding. Another participant, mudshark61369, shared past experiences with similar issues, particularly with sellers from specific regions, and offered guidance on identifying these practices.
I have recently participated in a few options from a specific seller and have noticed a distinct pattern with their listings that is giving me concern. It's also left me "holding the bag" on the item a few times after I was outbid and had given up. I did some digging in their feedback and came across a few comments from other people who had also experienced the same thing. I have reported it, but the options in the reporting system don't quite match what is happening or give space to explain, so I'm wondering if there might be an actual ebay employee here that might be able to look into it.
I'm sure this is a common trick and is probably difficult to prove, even with backend admin access to the eBay platform, but the grift involves using shill bidders to jack up the price of an auction, then canceling their highest shill bid after the auction ends and awarding the item to the next highest bidder the winner-- if their bid meets their minimum expectations, like an optional reserve price. I know that bids are sometimes legitimately canceled, and it didn't raise any flags to me the first time it happened, but this occurred to me 4 times in the matter of about 15 minutes with this seller that had multiple auctions closing within minutes of each other. It's very suspicious, unethical, and a violation of the ebay terms. Not to mention, very stupid, considering they could just put a reserve price on the item if they have a minimum they want for it. Is this a blatant ripoff? Not really, because bidders still commit to paying a up to a specific price when they place a bid, but if a seller has multiple auctions and a user gets outbid on one then places a bids on similar items the seller has available with the hope they win ONE of them, they could end up having to pay for ALL of them and doubling, tripling or in my case, QUADRUPILING what the user intended to pay for the item.
Is there anything that can be done about this besides using the empty abyss of the automated Reporting system?
This seller still has multiple auctions happening now, and I'm sure they will be doing the same thing on all of them. I'd prefer not to put them on public blast here over a suspicion, but I can provide links if someone is able or interested in looking into this further. I'm out almost $600 because of this trick.
1950rek
thefatleaffarm,
The About link at the top of this page, will provide accurate information regarding eBay employees on this Community:
"The eBay Community is made up of sellers, buyers and eBay employees coming together to share, connect and learn."
"While the value of peer-to-peer discussion is at the heart of the community, there are plenty of questions and comments that require attention from eBay staff. "
Your comments might require attention from eBay staff.
They don't provide direct customer support to you via these boards, so don't expect them to post here.
"While eBay staff are present on the boards, this is primarily a peer-to-peer support Community, and eBay cannot provide direct customer support to you via these boards."
mudshark61369
@thefatleaffarm ,
What you have described was fairly common with China based sellers several years ago. It was hard for ebay to prove the shill bidding back then when they had live people checking reports and now that the reports are looked at by A.I. they would probably say they couldn't find anything wrong. Even the human reps back in the day couldn't get the absolute proof needed for ebay to kick the seller's off the site. Because most of those sellers were located in China even if one got kicked off, they'd just start a new ID with their device connected to a new IP address which is what ebay uses to try and connect shills to sellers.
If you were to post the ebay item number of one of the auctions you won, we could look at it and tell you how to avoid them in the future.
Some of the indications were auctions starting at very low prices usually .99¢ The ending prices were usually under $20. The shill would join in usually about halfway through the auction duration and clicking on their a***b (5) username in the bid history, would show a high percentage of bids on the seller's auctions and a high number of bid retractions, keeping their feedback number low. Some might place an automatic bid set at the minimum price the seller wanted to get in hopes that others would outbid it. Other times they'd bid against others automatic bid until they uncovered the price and would retract their last bid.
albertabrightalberta
If you suspect shill bidding, you can report the seller and listing.
https://www.ebay.com/help/action?topicId=4850
tkw7v-0
I'm new member. number of my store listings is only 25. Are there any methods that can help me open more stores with a higher quantity? Thank you for your help.
kathiec
@tkw7v-0
You need to stop posting this exact same question (albeit under different user IDs) on random totally unrelated threads. If you want answers, start your own post. It's rude to hijack other people's threads.
albertabrightalberta
OMG! Good catch @kathiec ! 8 identical posts made by 7 IDs.
kathiec
@thefatleaffarm
Sorry, eBay doesn't actively monitor the forums. With suspected shilling all you can do is report the seller. EBay has tools, such as IP addresses, to determine if shilling is happening. On the surface it sounds like it might be in this case. In the past eBay took shilling reports more seriously than many other violations as it's not just a violation of terms, it's a federal crime. Don't know if that's still the case.