Have any of you buyers had your credit card co-opted -- for a sale you didn't make?
So my husband recently found his credit card had been dinged for $500-plus for an item he didn't buy. It was a type of item he had never, ever looked into buying . . .
My husband has purchased many, many items over the years -- he is a serious collector -- but, again, this particular item, and items of its type, had never been on his agenda. So . . . that's a red flag.
When he informed the seller, who immediately shipped the item off to him (a collectible trading card!), explaining he never made such a purchase, and therefore wanted to return the item for a refund, he got a breezy kiss-off. A, hey, we don't accept refunds. Happy holidays.
The seller had no curiousity, at all, about the buyer's allegation of a co-opted credit card . . . umm, another red flag?
My husband is presently trying to deal with eBay and PayPal over what appears a fraudulent exchange . . .
But, because I have had many dealings with law enforcement over my career as a writer (who has covered a lot of true crime), I am thinking this is something perhaps bigger than a single issue of a bizarre credit card transaction, and a seller -- who benefitted from that transaction -- who flat-out doesn't refund, no matter the facts of the situation.
Has anyone else out there had something similar happen? Did you find yourself buying an item you didn't know you'd bought -- and were subsequently denied a refund?
If so, please let me know . . .
Thank you.
house*of*paws
Hi @popculture-a-go-go
I’ve had my credit card compromised several times. The theft usually was discovered by my CC company before I realized it even happened. [They obviously have great algorithms that can detect an atypical expenditure instantly!]
When I am the first to notice being charged for a purchase I didn’t make … I immediately phone my CC company, rather than the company from where the purchase was made.
eBay sellers do not have access to buyers’ financial information. Were one to gain access to someone’s credit card info … I can’t imagine why they’d use it to purchase an item they are selling and have it shipped to the owner of the CC card holder. THAT makes zero sense to me.
It doesn’t surprise me that an uninvolved seller might disbelieve your story about the unauthorized purchase, however. Sellers hear a lot of B*S excuses from remorseful buyers who’ve changed their minds.
I recommend you contact your CC company about the unauthorized purchase … and then find a way of getting the card back to the seller AFTER you have the charges reversed.
popculture-a-go-go
OPHi, thank you for your response. Yes, we are dealing with credit card co. now . . . in hopes of getting the charges reversed. We would love to return the card -- which is something we never would have ordered.
(I was somewhat disheartened by the responses re. my husband trying to trick me into thinking the sale was erroneous. Like something out of a TV sit-com! But, there's nothing funny about finding out your card was used to buy something you didn't want -- or purchase. And then being stuck with the bill and a product that has no meaning to you.)
Again, thanx!
tinsoldierunderground
I'm not seeing where post #30 provides any clarity, it's essentially a regurgitation of the original.
Suggesting strongly that the seller is behind all this is bordering on defamation of character per se.
popculture-a-go-go
OPOkay, to clarify: my husband would like to return the card he did not buy -- to the seller.
He wanted to return it, immediately after receiving it; but the seller said no refunds, no returns.
And though my husband protested that he did not, himself, buy said item -- something he had never before perused, a type of item he never before bought -- the seller essentially said, tough luck. And wished him happy holidays. There was not an iota of curiousity over the situation . . . or my husband's claims.
It IS a weird story; the only reason he now has the card is because . . . the darn thing was sent to him and our charge card was dinged for it.
If and when a refund is made the card would surely be returned to the seller (we certainly don't want it) -- who I think is acting odd and, yes, suspicious . . . re. a curious sale.
That's it; no hidden agenda here.
However, if this happened to us, it could be happening to others . . . that's what I'm scouting around for. Buyers who wound up with something they don't recall buying . . .
Why does this kind of thing happen? The only one who benefits, outright, is the seller . . .
At least until someone starts speaking out . . .
Okay, I'll wrap the dialogue here.
Thanx for sharing your thoughts.
participatrophy
@popculture-a-go-go
Does your husband's Purchase History (https://www.ebay.com/mye/myebay/purchase link to that page if you need it) show any other purchases having been made on the same date as the trading card purchase? If so, click through to "View order details" on each and look at the topmost line where it says "Time placed" and compare the timestamps. See if they are the same.
Second question: Did he get any emails from eBay notifying him that a new device was using his account?
popculture-a-go-go
OPHi. Yes, he checked his purchase history; nothing else puchrased that day . . . but I don't know if he's gone thru all the page views. We'll get on this!
Thank you. And, yes it's a baffling issue.
(I didn't realize I'd get so many unsympathetic/snarky responses to the situation! Tough crowd! We just want to return what we didn't order and get the $$ back. And, agreed, it's a weird situation. Which is why I posted about it. )
Again, we'll try to track the page views.
kathiec
In your haste to make them the bad guy you're not looking at this from the seller's point of view. As explained earlier the seller doesn't benefit to any greater degree than they would if the card sold through a regular sale. I can't see any reason a seller would go through the almost impossible task of hacking a credit card to make a sale. Then the seller, whose 'no returns' policy is clearly stated in their listings, has a buyer wanting to bypass that policy with a story about their credit card being stolen, but oh yes, the card was delivered to them. It makes no sense, so it sounds like a buyer just looking for a way around a 'no returns' policy. Many, many sellers who have no returns policies never make exceptions to them. And it's a trifle disingenuous to suggest the seller is a crook because they won't.
And to answer your question, I've been active in the forums for almost 20 years, and I've never seen a case where someone's card was legitimately hacked and they actually received the merchandise.
bdmh-enterprises
Were I the seller here I would have given the same "no returns" reply and immediately blocked you. Sellers have no interest or need to be involved in buyers nonsensical drama. And your story probably came off as some kind of scam attempt.
Furthermore, this card would have gone through authentication making it non returnable by eBay policy.
The seller has not benefited beyond making a sale and cards of that value are not hard to sell. The one that is benefiting is your husband that will come out of this with a $500 card AND (presumably) an unauthorized use refund from the CC company.. Suspicious indeed..
tinsoldierunderground
Excellent point - nice catch!
r_lresale
Maybe OP is getting intel/ideas for her next "true" crime book.
tinsoldierunderground
Someone correct me if I'm wrong here, but I was under the impression that no seller has access to any buyers payment info/provider... Nothing happens until someone hits the 'pay now' button, ebay (or paypal) accepts payment credentials, then ebay places funds in sellers account. Seller never sees this and has no ability to arbitrarily scam a buyer by secretly delving into their CC or bank account info. And why in the hell would it be sent to the account holders address if it were a scam??? As others have noted, who would possibly benefit?
This tale is bordering on ridiculous.
soh.maryl
Yes, more than a few of us are questioning this story for several reasons. And the OP has not returned lately, so we may be left to ???
jonathanbrightlight
You're completely correct. Sellers have not ever had access to the actual payment method, since the wild west days of just accepting payment outside of eBay.
kathiec
@popculture-a-go-go
If the card was delivered to your address the seller didn't "[benefit] from that transaction" anymore than they would have if they simply sold the card through normal channels. Certainly not enough to go to the trouble, and risk the consequences, of hacking a credit card number. Had this been a scam on the seller's part they would have used the fake tracking scam to send a worthless trinket to a random address in your zip code. Then they would have both the card and the money.
And if a third party hacked your credit card they certainly wouldn't have had the card shipped to you, as there would be zero benefit to them by doing so.
Something here doesn't pass the smell test.
stainlessenginecovers
What is 'co-opted'?
Sounds like the ebay account was 'hacked' using your credit card already on file;
Afterwards the 'thief' can then 'change the ship-to address'
soh.maryl
However, it sounds like the card that the husband did not buy has been mysteriously delivered to him. Don't see where the ship to address has been changed, if I'm interpreting the OP correctly.
stainlessenginecovers
@soh.maryl After re-reading the opening post, it wasn't clear to me that the item was even delivered to them?
But, I still have NO IDEA what 'Co-opted' even means??????????? (neither does google)
kathiec
Ummm, according to my perusal of Google there are pages of entries for 'co-opted', the first of which is the definition: "divert to or use in a role different from the usual or original one".
12345jamesstamps
If a person cancels a credit card before the refund...well...where will the refund go?
We are assuming the credit card of the bank gave the refund and then later...much later the credit card was cancel.
Sounds like this didn't happen lately.
Banks do not refunds customers immediately of a dispute.
bdmh-enterprises
Let me get this straight. You think this seller somehow hacked your husbands account and rather than send the card to friend or something, bought it for your husband like a gift to himself, all to just make a sale?!? Pardon my skepticism, but that sounds a bit far fetched. You sure your husband didn't really want this card for himself?
FYI 'no returns' is standard for trading cards, you get 3 days to make a 'not as described' claim. A card of this value should have gone through authentication though, making it final sale. Did the card have the authenticator seal on it?
Those suggesting a NAD return here are absolutely wrong. The problem is not the card or the seller, but the eBay account potentially being compromised. That's what needs to be dealt with here. Why make the seller a victim too?
I'm quite curious what the card is though...
mamacassidy
@bdmh-enterprises
You are correct about the INAD return. I do not think it applies here.
I should clarify that I am NOT saying that she should use INAD return here.
I was just letting her know that when she stated in her original post that the seller "flat out doesn't accept returns", that doesn't mean she's not protected with ebay's MBG when shopping on ebay.
hotwheelsbum
After reading more, that's what I'm kind of leaning towards too. Husband found card he'd been wanting for a long long time. Asked wife here if he could buy it. Wife said $500??? Hell No. Don't you dare do it. Hubby thought about it for a day or 2, then said to heck with her, I WANT THAT CARD. When $500 card arrived, wife blew up, so Hubby came up with story that some Hacker hacked into his account, bought that card for him using his credit card, had that card sent to him.
Now, wife bought that story. Wife is now going all over the internet trying to figure out HOW this happened. Want to know where Hubby is while Wife is trying to figure this out? Hubby is back in his Man Cave walking around in circles muttering to himself, I hope I get away with this....I hope I get away with this.....I hope I get away with this......
😂😂😂
bdmh-enterprises
A story as old as time LOL. 30 years of TCG selling I've seen this exact scenario many times, even with friends.
This stands out as well: "As for the trading card: it is sitting on his desk. A $530 card we did not want!"
So it's ON DISPLAY?!? Is all I can think LMAO.
I sincerely hope this went through AG like it should have and the seller is fully protected from any bank action coming their way.
le-5262
I didn't realize your husband had the actual card that was purchased.
What I would do...
is contact the no refund seller again
explain to them that they will either take the card back you didn't purchase
or they will, more than likely, lose the card when you file a chargeback.
...but I am unclear as to what the point of this scam would be...
and who is the perpetrator.
popculture-a-go-go
OPHi, agreed, truly weird.
Pls. see my reply, above, to mamacassidy . . .
He has dealt with the credit card.
As for the trading card: it is sitting on his desk. A $530 card we did not want!
Definitely an odd scenario.
soh.maryl
He's keeping the card and being refunded?
roccotacodad54
"As for the trading card: it is sitting on his desk. A $530 card we did not want!"
You do realize that statement along with your husband disputing payment with his Credit Card makes him look like the scammer not the seller. That is unless my understanding of what is transpiring is wrong.
Just curious as to who discovered this purchase first, him or you?
This whole scenario makes me think of Occam's razor.
Odd scenario indeed...........................
tinsoldierunderground
Ditto!!! 😂 I'm having trouble making the original post add up.
hotwheelsbum
Suggestion.....
Might have your Husband check the "Addresses" on his account to make sure they didn't hack that too.
Why would a thief scam your ebay account, use your CC to make a $500 purchase, then have it shipped to your Husband?
On top of my ebay account getting hacked a few years ago, I've also had my Amazon account hacked too. They got into it, added 8-9 different addresses, then went on a buying spree buying Laptops and Iphones ($6000 worth), and were having them shipped to all those new addresses. AT THE SAME TIME, they bombed my main email address to throw me off from catching the emails coming from Amazon. Want to know what it's like to be getting 1000 emails a minute for an hour or 2. Pure Hell. I got over 100,000 emails within 2 hours that day. I got Lucky because my Bank started Texting me alerts about all the purchases. I ignored all the emails and got on the phone with my bank. Bank and Amazon Fraud started working on my case, cancelling orders, stopping shipments, so on. I lost nothing on that ordeal. I think Amazon lost 2-3 of those purchases. It was easy to get fixed, but pure hell when it happened.
So, have you Husband check everything on that account. No thief is going to hack your account. then Buy your Hubby a $500 item. That $500 item may be going somewhere else.
soh.maryl
"That $500 item may be going somewhere else."
Nope, that $500 item has already been delivered to the OP's husband and is on his desk.
hotwheelsbum
Yeah. We learned that after I posted the first comment. Then she said card was sitting on Husbands desk. That's when people started questioning this.
Plus, she hasn't posted for a while. I wonder if Hubby came clean, and she's helping him pack his bags. 😂
tobaccocardyahoo
Whatever occurred, the unauthorized use of your credit card is best resolved with your credit card issuer,
They may decide to cancel your card and send you a new one, as well as credit you and reverse the charge.
The longer you wait, the more risk of further problems you face.
popculture-a-go-go
OPThanks. He has changed credit cards. And is staying away from any eBay purchases. (Yayyy!)
mamacassidy
I don't understand what happened here.
Someone used your husband's account and credit card to purchase an item and then have it shipped to your husband?
Who would have access to his ebay account?
If you think someone hacked into your account, I'd be taking steps to cancel the card and bank account associated with it and changing any passwords that are the same or similar to this one. And disputing any charges you think are fraudulent.
As far as refunds go, sellers can say "No Returns", but that doesn't mean "No Refunds". You can always open an INAD return and get your money back. That's a return that the seller can't deny.
popculture-a-go-go
OPWhat is a INAD return? Not familiar with it . . .
Yes, very weird that the item was purchased on his account and sent to him . . . despite his protests.
The only person who makes out, here, is the seller . . .
My husband has made hundreds of purchases . . . I am wondering if there is a fraudulent system targeting such buyers.
I want to be careful what I say, here . . . because this could become a legal matter (pursued by Yours Truly).
It is a decidedly odd situation. Once in a while, in a TV newscast, you'll see a story about some kid who went on his parent's computer and bought stuff using their accounts. (Those are usually considered "cute" stories!) There's no kid in our family; and the dogs and cats don't know how to use a computer! And, again, there is absolutely no history of purchases of trading cards. And now we own one that cost $530! And the seller is adamant: no refunds.
Strange. And, I think, suspicious.
mamacassidy
@popculture-a-go-go
INAD stands for Item Not As Described.
When you go to open a return, there are a few reasons to choose from. Some of them the seller can not deny, like INAD or Damaged.
When you open a return with one of these reasons, the seller has to provide a shipping label for you to send the item back at their cost and then refund you, or they can choose to just refund and not have the item sent back.
If after a couple of days the seller has not responded to the return claim, you just ask ebay to step in and they will process the return.
This is all part of ebay's Money Back Guarantee.
Edited to add: I do not think INAD return applies here if your account was hacked. I was just replying to your original post stating seller "flat out doesn't accept returns".
le-5262
No. Thankfully, I have never been on either end.
If it were me...
I would go to my credit card company so fast.
popculture-a-go-go
OPYes, he's already cancelled that card . . .
Thanx.