Handling Damaged eBay Purchases and Maintaining Seller Ratings
Summary: ladygolfer7777 shared their experience of receiving a damaged item from a seller on eBay and being offered a partial refund. They were unsure whether to accept the offer or report it to eBay due to concerns about maintaining their seller ratings. soh.maryl and christworks emphasized understanding eBay's Money Back Guarantee and advised opening a return case, which doesn't impact seller status. christworks also highlighted the importance of fair dealings between sellers while addressing listing and policy awareness. Other participants expressed concerns about common misunderstandings regarding eBay's policies and the impact of seller feedback.
Hi everyone,
I've recently encountered a situation where I purchased an item on eBay that arrived damaged. After reporting it to the seller, I was offered a refund, but the amount was less than expected. I'm contemplating whether to proceed with reporting this to eBay, which might affect my perfect seller ratings, or to accept the seller's offer to keep things off eBay's records.
I'm curious to hear your experiences: Have you ever bought something on eBay that arrived damaged? How did you handle it? Did you report it to eBay, and if so, what impact did it have on your ratings? What would you recommend in terms of ensuring fairness while also maintaining a good standing on the platform?
Looking forward to your thoughts and suggestions!
Thank you.
mod-paul
Topic locked per OP's request.
tobaccocardyahoo
As @christworks has stated you should not be contacting the buyer about items which are not as described or damaged. You should request a return, through Ebay, under the Ebay MBG.
It is easier, begins the process faster and starts the clock on the process and automates much of what follows.
It is more impersonal, more responsive, and less likely to lead to misunderstandings - intentional or unintentional.
1950rek
The sheer number of sellers that advise buyers WHAT they should have done or
known, AFTER the fact seems like closing the barn door after the horses have bolted...
christworks
@ladygolfer7777 You describe yourself as the buyer in this transaction, but you are also a seller. You should know about eBay's Money Back Guarantee. Buyers can return an item that is not as described, including an item that arrived damaged. This is true even if the seller says they do not accept returns. This means you don't need to contact the seller. By the way, this applies to all the items you are selling that you have listed as "no returns." No returns does not equal no refunds.
As an example, let's say I order that D3 supplement. (You cannot ship that first class mail, which is what you have it listed as.) You don't have the expiration date in the listing, which is a policy violation. If I get it, I can open an immediate INAD and say it is expired. That means you will either have to fully refund me or send me a free shipping label so I can send it back. Getting it back will eat away at all your profit, so more than likely you'd have to refund me and I will get to keep the item. I'm suprised you've not run into these INAD returns because many of your listings are poorly set up and are vunerable to INADs.
Anyway, in your case as the buyer, there is no need to contact eBay. Just go to the order page and open a return and select the reason that it arrived damaged. The seller will either have to send you a shipping label and you'll have to send the item back, or they will have to refund you the rest of the way.
None of this has anything to do with feedback. As a buyer, you can only have positive feedback. As a seller, you can get negatives. This brings me to my last point: You are also a seller and in my view sellers should show other sellers some grace unless they are truly a scammer. You don't say if the item arrived damaged because it already had the damage that wasn't described in the listing, or if it looks like the damage was caused by the carrier, or was poorly packed by the seller. I say all that to say if you bought from the seller using your selling account, they could get ticked off with you for opening up a return after offering you a refund that you apparently initially accepted. I'm not saying they will turn around and buy from you and do the same thing to you, but you should consider that a possibility. Also, I just find sellers who nitpick at other sellers will eventually get whats coming to them for being that way.
Your time is better spent learning how eBay works. You've been on here since 2022, so you should know about eBay's MBG, what can be shipped First Class and what cannot, and what information eBay requires sellers to have in the listings. These are all things that will help you both as a seller and a buyer.
grann-4629
It really is a war out there in eBayland when a seller will buy something just to retaliate against someone s/he doesn't like with a few words in feedback.
What is wrong with people's brains these days?
Anybody remember 'sticks and stones' or have we become wimpy little crybabies because someone hurt our feelings?
soh.maryl
The sheer number of people, both buyers and sellers, who do not understand the MBG, is disheartening.
soh.maryl
Have you read the Money Back Guarantee? ANY time that ANY buyer receives an item that's not as described, all he needs to do is open an NAD case with eBay within 30 days of receipt. Opening a case does not affect your status as a seller. ALL eBay buyers and sellers need to read the MBG, preferably BEFORE beginning to buy and/or sell here.