Fraud
Bought an item from China. Seller created 2 shipments. Shipped me 4 tires immediately after the order. The "real" order doesn't have a valid tracking number. eBay support apparently can't spot the obvious fraud, claiming "the order has been marked as received" Funny enough, it wasn't sent to my address, the shipping address just sent the item to my town so the 4 tires ended up at some random persons house.
sepup-69
38 comments
raglen39
The very same has happened to me. Mine was sent to a address in Germany, ebay told me it was delivered and NO REFUND. I hope you used paypal because they will refund because the can see. Then ebay is in the clear, where they want to be. Stay off this sinking ship.
mudshark61369
@sepup-69 , @mr._bob , @pastimpressions ,
The China based sellers on this site are responsible for many of the scams, and unfortunately eBay has not forced them to put their actual country of registry on their profiles, so it can be hard to weed them out, especially since they often ship from U.S. based warehouses. There are ways to figure out if a seller is China based despite country of registry and item locations. To learn how, Open the link below and click on Go To Best Answer,
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Buying/Why-is-Ebay-Backing-China-Sellers-with-a-lie-in-there-post-there/m-p/35168893#M526369
annadryl
Would the money you saved be worth it if you did receive those things and paid to install them only to have a blown-out tire a week later?
twmcgill3
Yeah, I think I'm done with eBay unless I can afford the risk. This is getting silly.
They don't delete fraudulent listings. They don't care about fraud.... at all. Preventing it? Lol.... they enjoy it. More money for them.
I'm out. It's just as bad as Kickstarter now.
mr._bob
I was wrong, there aren't 1-2 buyers who are also backing me up that this seller is a scammer. He immediately listed 3-4x again as soon as I bought it (checked his completed listings). He sold 5-10 grand in collectables in 4 days after 20 years of doing a few hundred dollars a year in business on eBay tops...
There's easily 6 people reporting him for the same scam RIGHT NOW.
AND THEY CLOSED MY COMPLAINT IN HIS FAVOR.
This is BLATANTLY criminal behavior on eBay's part.
*casey*
@mr._bob
eBay's fully aware of fake tracking scams!
Have a look at this thread, #5 in particular
The thread's not new but nothing's changed.
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Buying/How-exactly-to-beat-the-fake-tracking-number-scam/td-p/35069031
"Understand that this scam can be traced back in the forums for over a decade"
"One can also file a credit card chargeback. Again, the buyer should not claim INR, but rather Fraud/fake tracking scam. Otherwise the INR claim will be forwarded to eBay, who responds with the same phony delivery confirmation, and the buyer will lose again"
krazzykats
Why are you buying tires from China?
ᓚᘏᗢ
bonanza125
@mr._bob
Ebay is not the criminal. Ebay is a selling platform which allows sellers to use its platform for a fee. There is no possible way for Ebay to know what the intentions of each seller are. Ebay gives a 30 day moneyback guarantee. Ebay only goes by tracking number which is provided which if delivered then yes the recommendation is go file a chargeback. Now in regards to your feedback removable you need to read the feedback policy. Just because you claim its valid doesn't mean that it doesn't violate feedback policy.
mr._bob
I sent eBay customer support a screenshot proving the tracking number was for a package that was not sent to me. The seller uploaded a different tracking number. I sent eBay customer support a screenshot proving that one was ALSO for a package that was not sent to me. They stopped responding to my emails and closed the case in the seller's favor.
Wanna try to argue they aren't criminals again?
bonanza125
Ebay stopped responding to you due to the case being closed because the tracking number stating delivered. They are not the carrier. They are the selling platform. So what you needed to do which you did was go to your payment source and start a chargeback. When purchasing items it is recommended to review negative feedback received, avoid international transactions, and avoid sellers with little to no feedback. You will want to purchase from sellers who are established. Ebay has nothing to do with the actually seller selling the item. If there is an issue then report them. The more folks who report then the seller eventually gets suspended and permanently banned. Which we get a lot of sellers in here complaining about that as well. Yes I understand that this is a well known scam and unfortunately sometimes buyers can't get around it. Now that doesn't mean it can't happen on other sites either. It can happen on any site.
mr._bob
Seller been on platform for 26 years with 200+ positives and 2 negatives and claims to be in Denver.
eBay is DELETING his negative feedback for him
There were 4 items listed in this listing. I bought 2 of them. I can almost guarantee there's 1-2 other buyers RIGHT NOW telling eBay he's a scammer.
You are bending over backwards to pretend eBay isn't complicit when it is patently obvious they are.
Been shopping on the internet since online shopping became a thing... I've NEVER had a scammer be protected by the platform like this. It's INSANE.
HOLY HELL, all his other listings just went down. Apparently I made enough of a stink they're doing something about him!
So now they know he's a scammer... but they've still closed my case in his favor.
Explain to me how that's not criminal?
bonanza125
@mr._bob
Ebay has no idea if the seller is a scammer or not. They go by tracking number only. So far I haven't had the same experience you had but have run into issues before. Was this the only time this happened? I wouldn't worry too much about the overall picture of Ebay. Majority of transactions go smoothly with no problems. Online purchases aren't problem free. There will eventually be an issue. Ebay deletes feedback for multiple reasons. They either found the seller to right which that is Ebay's decision or the content you wrote in that feedback was subject for removal to name a couple.
mr._bob
See, what your explaining could MAYBE fly if eBay didn't claim to have a "Buyer guarantee" that you get what you order because that's the service they offer and is WHY they get to charge a 10-20% commission.
I was guaranteed BY EBAY to get the item I purchased.
I did not.
They defrauded me.
"eBay Money Back Guarantee covers most transactions on eBay. It means buyers can get their money back if an item didn't arrive, is faulty or damaged, or doesn't match the listing."
How often do you see this splashed across eBay? I see it on darn near every page.
Does it say I can get my money back so long as NO package was EVER shipped to ANYONE in my zip code?
No it F'ing does not. But that is exactly the metric they are using to claim the item was delivered.
And yes they CAN confirm more than that. Tracking number + my street number (They have both) into a Fedex API and in 10ms, they know that this item was not delivered. THEY CHOOSE NOT TO.
bonanza125
Ok well Ebay isn't the carrier as I explained to you they are the selling platform. You personally may claim the item didn't arrive but Ebay doesn't know that. Which then it is advised to call your payment source to get a chargeback going. The moneyback guarantee is only covered as an "Item not received" if the tracking number doesn't state delivered. If it doesn't state delivered then it's considered an item that didn't arrive. In your case and the OPs case the two of you were scammed. It happens.
gator08041971
@mr._bob
How often do you see this splashed across eBay? I see it on darn near every page.
While that is the main thing they state, and yes most of the time this isn't an issue, this is one kind of scam that is difficult. Here's why:
Seller is using a tricky way to get the package shipped, knowing how eBay tracks their items, mainly just by the zipcode. Sellers have the option still to buy labels elsewhere and input that tracking into eBay. If they bought the label on eBay it will have the correct address and cannot be changed. However the seller could alter the label manually, and this has been done before as well.
On the other side:
Buyers have also tried to claim this scam happened or claimed to have had other issues that didn't exist, just so they can force a refund/return to the seller, get to keep the item and their money.
eBay has a hard time knowing which party is guilty in every situation. And with millions of transactions on eBay every day, this is pretty much an impossible thing to adequately cover for.
It would be one thing if eBay sold the items and shipped them directly, but they don't do any of that. They are simply hosting random sellers, and unfortunately, some are bad. The only way to fight these, is to report them when encountered. Eventually they will get picked off, but more will replace.
Greed is the baseline for sellers like this. How much reward can they get for as little effort/cost as possible. They don't care about anything else, and will do whatever it takes to scam and cheat for a few bucks. Even with the systems in place that eBay has.
All you can do is be vigilant, do your research as best you can, and know what to do if a scam happens. In your case, it sounds like you took the appropriate steps and are being made whole, even if it was a annoying experience to deal with.
I have ran into bad sellers on here too. I don't blame eBay for all of them, but I have made suggestions about what to do to deal with various issues.
Like this type of scam. I would say that sellers that are new, sell rarely, or have a history already of troubling transactions, or are shipping to a country different then their own, should be forced to use labels provided by eBay only. Why? Minimize the risk of shipping scams by sellers like this one. Might not 100% fix it, but it wouldn't hurt either to try either. I would not mind that feature, even though I have used places like PirateShip in some cases. Small sacrifice to ease the mind of buyers.
Good luck.
*casey*
@mr._bob
Everything you've said is 100% true.
I've been reporting fraudulent listings on and off for over 20 years.
Chinese scammers registering fake accounts in Italy, France, Germany, Spain, Italy, Austria etc
who are listing thousands of $$$ worth of NON EXISTENT items are now being contacted by eBay and are
ending the listings themselves. Any negative feedback is removed.
The FRAUDULENT listings are NOT being removed by eBay.
The SCAM IDs are still registered, 20 or so in just the last two weeks.
eBay are fully aware of these scams and fake tracking scams !
mr._bob
Do a chargeback.
Just got scammed in a similar way.
Seller gave them a tracking number that I proved to eBay was not from his state, or to me (signed for by someone else), and was not the right size or weight.
He just submitted a second tracking number.
I proved to them it also was not from his state (or the same state as the first one), or to me (Fedex chatbot shows that it wasn't shipped to my address by refusing to allow me to open a case about it) And also was not the right size or weight for my item
I also left him negative feedback explaining all this.
They closed the case in his favor, started ignoring my emails and deleted my feedback.
eBay are criminals.
bonanza125
Next time purchase within the US. Now you know why to avoid China. Prices are cheaper for a reason.
roccotacodad54
"Bought an item from China"
Lesson learned?................
mr._bob
I've spent thousands on Temu and before that Alibaba.
Never had ANY problem that the platform didn't IMMEDIATELY remedy with a full and unconditional refund.
eBay is the problem, not China.
Hell Temu sends me refunds for stuff I don't even realize was delivered late.
ryry-jj
To eBay, the tracking shows as delivered. Btw, no tires were ever sent, just a small envelope large enough to carry a label. If you need more info to help with the charge back, go to the carrier and request a statement showing the GPS location of the delivery was not your address. Doesn't hurt to get size and weight of delivered envelope either. The claim you want to make with your bank's fraud department is "victim of the fake tracking scam"
Also, since you contacted your bank, no point in trying to return for missing parts or INAD, too late for that
kathiec
@sepup-69
The easiest way to address this is to open a 'missing parts or pieces' return. If the seller demands a return, and is willing to pony up the postage to do so, you return an empty envelope, which is what you received.
Alternatively you can simply dispute the charge with your credit card. With the fake tracking scam the best way to do that is through the card issuer's fraud department. This is a common scam, so they're going to be aware of it.
sepup-69
OPThanks. Just filed a complaint with Wells Fargo. Already wasted 2 appeals and 2 weeks with eBay for a case that is obvious. Honestly I should be payed damages for dealing with this crap.
tobaccocardyahoo
The most effective way of dealing with this problem is the one you have followed. A "chargeback dispute" cuts through the **bleep** and requires proof of delivery to the address associated with your credit card.
mr._bob
EXACT SAME THING HAPPENED TO ME.
eBay is WORKING WITH THE CRIMINALS.
Think about it... They side with them... they get their 15% fee. They refund us? No fee.
eBay is a criminal agency.
If they weren't they wouldnt delete valid negative feedback EXPLAINING THE SCAM THE SCAMMERS ARE PULLING FROM THEIR FEEDBACK
"Should be paid damages"
Yes, you should. This is ludicrously criminal on eBays part. But it wont matter. We'll both get a check for 8 cents from a class action suit ten years from now, after they make billions working with the scammers.
stephenmorgan
Sounds like a Altered Address Scam where the seller sends a random insignificant item to an random address within you same zip code so that it appears to eBay you received the item or items.
This scam can be overcome with some effort on your part to prove to eBay that you did not receive item.