Bad Situation: Shady seller, Incompetent Ebay
Okay so here’s the deal…
I purchased a high priced item yesterday and immediately paid for it. This afternoon, the seller sent me a message asking me to PayPal him an additional $75 because he decided to get a label outside of eBay because supposedly eBay did not have an insurance option for the value of the item (2100). He said he would ship it tomorrow after I paid the additional money. Keep in mind, I paid for the item already through ebay.
The whole thing sounded super shady to me and I decided I no longer want to go through with this transaction. I would have been more than willing to pay another $75 if it was built into the original price on ebay, but the fact that he asked me to do it after the fact, outside of eBay was really sketchy.
I sent a cancel request as soon as he sent the message and reported the message. He refused the cancellation. I then called eBay’s customer service to explain the situation that this guy circumvented policy and that they needed to intervene and cancel the transaction immediately.
Ebay told me all they could do is file a did not receive claim and expedite it to three business days. So basically that gives the seller three extra days to send the item to me. I said that this was incredibly dumb because now he could just ship it priority mail and say he sent it to me and I’m stuck with the item. Again, for all I know maybe the item totally matches what I want and is completely fine. That’s not the issue. The issue is the seller that I do not want to do business with. I don’t trust someone who wants to go the route he did. They said in 3 days, when I don’t have the item, I can push the request forward for a refund.
Well, surely enough, he rushed to the post office to send it. Now it’s in transit and will be here one day before the did not receive request can be pushed.
I told the geniuses on eBay customer service that this will probably happen. They claim there was nothing they could do and then I could just try to return it after I receive it. I don’t even want to receive this package. How do I know he’s even sending the actual item?
I sent him a message to please save the headache for everyone and cancel it because I am going to return it regardless. Obviously, he’s taken his chances.
Now, good thing is ebay has all this on record. They have his message of him asking me to send him more money, etc. But I just don’t know where to go from here? Do I have USPS intercept the package?
I can’t believe how useless ebay can be sometimes. If he offered to sell me the item outside ebay for less money, they’d have him banned and listing removed. But because there was a sale, ebay doesn’t want to budge because they want their cut. It’s insane.
bfc331
OPWell, I don’t know if anyone is still going to see this thread at this point, but I just wanted to update that everything worked out. The package arrived and the item was as described. He packaged it very, very well. I guess that’s why he wanted a little more money, but obviously that’s a big no-no after the fact. Gotta take care of that stuff upfront, so that’s why I have no regrets about asking to cancel the transaction and seeking the counsel of the community.
So again thanks @mudshark61369 @gurlcat and everyone else who responded. By the way @mudshark61369 , that’s an awful situation you’re going through with that buyer. I hope they do the right thing and send you either the money or item back (preferably the money obviously).
And special thanks to those like @gurlcat who told me not to reject or intercept the delivery. I had no idea this would completely nullify my eBay guarantee. Yikes!
Finally, I would like to NOT thank ebay’s customer service over the phone. What a stupid process that was… and a completely useless solution that was clearly nothing more than a wet blanket to get me off the phone.
Anyways, I know that buyers and sellers alike deal with some serious **bleep** on here. People can just be awful sometimes. Makes you really appreciate the good ones. Take care everybody!
ed8108
Seller requested an additional sum of money from you & that request was unenforceable, seller has placed your purchase in transit for delivery to you
Seller & buyer entered into a contract to complete the transaction
Ebay's position appears to be the contract exists, since seller didn't cancel
You paid, seller shipped, ebay happy
bfc331
OPUPDATE:
First, I want to thank everyone for their input. Really good information from everyone and gave me a lot to think about.
Here’s my plan… the item is scheduled to be delivered Friday. Obviously, given how much I paid, I really wanted it so I am going to go ahead and accept the delivery and if all is well, I’ll just keep it and maybe just give him a neutral feedback at worst, because I don’t like the idea of tarnishing someone’s perfect record, especially someone who has been on ebay as long as him (which again made his request all the more perplexing).
If the item isn’t as described, I’ll just file a claim and return it. I hope it doesn’t come to that though. Either way, the entire situation is needlessly distressing.
Anyways, thanks again. Good info from everyone. I’ll update this weekend.
gurlcat
You've got a great attitude; that's what a couple days' cooling off and sorting things out with peers can reveal.
mudshark61369
@bfc331,
"This afternoon, the seller sent me a message asking me to PayPal him an additional $75 because he decided to get a label outside of eBay because supposedly eBay did not have an insurance option for the value of the item (2100). He said he would ship it tomorrow after I paid the additional money. Keep in mind, I paid for the item already through ebay".
Did you win an auction or was this a buy it now listing? If this was an auction, did the the starting bid price start out below $750 and did the seller have a stated shipping cost? If that happened the seller could not add insurance to the shipping cost, because they did not know what the declared value would be, and ebay would not let them add it after the auction ended.
Before bidding on or buying the item did you check the seller's feedback profile page to see how much experience they have for selling, Especially, selling high value items? They might have a high feedback number and a good percentage, but mostly for buying not selling, and not for selling high value items. While what the seller did does violate ebay policy, it may have happened because of the seller's inexperience at selling high value items, not because they were being "shady".
Were this me, I would wait to receive the item, If there is a shipping cost on the label then you may see the seller did pay for insurance, and if was as described and didn't suffer any damage in shipping, I would keep it. After all filing a not as described dispute would tie up $2100 for at least 4 days, plus the time for the refund to be transferred back to your payment method.
Then you would have the options of leaving positive, neutral or negative feedback stating what happened or not leaving any feedback at all.
Since you also sell on ebay, you should be happy that ebay offers some seller protections if a mistake is made on your part, because in most cases sellers are thrown under the bus.
gurlcat
Those are actually some great points ..... however, insurance is inherently on the seller because they're who would suffer the loss in the case of lost/damaged item. Sure it makes sense to build the cost of insurance into the item's price (or starting bid), and sure inexperience could explain why that didn't happen here, but that doesn't mean the buyer should have to pay for seller inexperience, especially after they already paid for the order.
And then the real 'd' move was ignoring the cancellation request. That's just wrong. Not to mention stupid! -Just think what the OP could do in retaliation if they were the kind of hothead buyer some of us have dealt with a time or two.
All that said, I still agree with your final assessment; if the item is satisfactory I would just keep it. No real reason to go through more trouble just to get back to where I started.
bfc331
OPAgreed @gurlcat
Not a fan at all of how he’s gone about it all… but if the item is okay I’d rather just avoid the trouble.
I told him this morning that I won’t return it if it’s okay, but I didn’t appreciate him asking for more money after I already paid.
He said he “made the request through official ebay channelsâ€
😕
Oh well. As long as the item is good.
nobody*s_perfect
If you receive the item and don't want it, file a claim for item "not as described" and the seller will have to pay for the return shipping (and insurance if he wants it). eBay sides with the buyer in 99.9% of "not as described" claims.
As noted in an above post, do NOT just refuse the package, since that will void your buyer protection. Likewise, a package intercept request might be interpreted by eBay as a refusal, so that's not a good idea.
For reference, here's a link to eBay's buyer protection policy, which they call the "Money Back Guarantee":
https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/ebay-money-back-guarantee-policy/ebay-money-back-guarantee-policy?id=4210
gurlcat
Just in case you didn't know -definitely don't 'refuse/return to sender' the package. Then you'd just be out $2100, end of story.
fbusoni
@bfc331
If the item is what you want, I would leave the buyer neutral feedback, with a long and detailed explanation of what transpired.
If the item is unsatisfactory for whatever reason, file an INAD.
stevescho
I don't think eBay can refund you for a seller refusing a cancellation and shipping item. If you paid the $75 then yes, that's definitely NAD bcz it wasn't in the listing. But you didn't. Right? Find another reason for filing a NAD, not in original packaging, a nick, any flaw, anything. Don't expect seller cooperation.
mtgraves7984
"Again, for all I know maybe the item totally matches what I want and is completely fine."
@bfc331
I feel ya... but try to concentrate on ^^^ that statement for now. Life's too short. Godspeed.
bfc331
OP@mtgraves7984
I mean, you’re not wrong.
That being said, I just feel all trust was immediately eroded when he wanted me to pay him more money outside of eBay after the listing was already paid for the price he set.
bfc331
OP@gator0804197
That’s what shocks me… he’s been a user since 1999 (me since 2006).
He should know better. He has a 100% record as well. I’ve dealt with shady sellers and even buyers before, but none with the record like that.
I think he’s just turned this into a pissing match basically. I still think eBay is incredibly incompetent. As soon as they saw the message where he asked for more money, which they did acknowledge on the phone call that he broke policy, they should’ve canceled it right then and there. He would’ve never raced to the post office to drop it off if they had done that
gator08041971
@bfc331
Well in that case, yeah, this seller should absolutely know better.
Ugh.
Not sure what else to do. Which method did you use to contact eBay?
Have you tried their Facebook contact? I have heard that it may be more useful:
https://www.facebook.com/eBayForBusiness/
bfc331
OP@gator08041971
I spoke to them on the phone.
The first rep’s solution was the item not received route. I asked for a supervisor (yes I totally became one of those people)
The supervisor said that was also the only thing that could be done, however, she did go ahead and override the delivery range. The seller had an original estimate for September 24-26 or something like that.
She was able to override that and set it to the earliest possible date of September 21, meaning that on September 21 I can escalate the item not received request for a refund. But of course he ran to the post office and shipped it right before five so it will get here for September 20th.
I don’t know why he’s being such an ass about this. Like he messed up and I clearly don’t want to do business with him. He could save us all the headache by just canceling this. Now this has to drag out. Again, the item was over 20 times so what he’s asking for extra. It’s not the money itself, it’s theprinciple. Asking for money after the transaction is completed. It’s just a big no-no in any business deal.
This makes me never want to buy on eBay again. Like the fact that somebody can blatantly violate policy and seemingly get away with it is insanity.
soh.maryl
Have never heard of a "supervisor" being able to override the delivery range" in response to a call from a buyer. So, if I see the item that I bought has an EDD of, say, October 5th, I can contact eBay and have them change that date to Sept. 20? Pretty sure this is a case of whoever you contacted told you what you wanted to hear to get you off the phone.
reallynicestamps
which they did acknowledge on the phone call
Well there's your mistake.
The phone reps have a terrible reputation for getting you off the phone as soon as possible even if that means giving you the advice you want to hear instead of the advice you need to have.
Here are your options for contacting Ebay Customer Service. Please be aware that for social media CS, you send them a Private Message and briefly explain what your problem or issue is. Feel free to leave your Name, address, phone number and/or your email address in this message. It is private and secure and it may help to speed up the response for you.

https://www.facebook.com/ebay— Message button in upper right on landing page.
#204760888466
https://www.instagram.com/ebayforsellers/

https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/How-do-I-contact-Customer-Support/m-p/32016431#M1783851 -> Automated Assistant, type AGENT -> enter. You will then get more options.


The social media Chat accounts are covered by trained eBay employees with some authority.
And you get a transcript so you can compare what you heard with what you were told.
gator08041971
@bfc331
Yeah, this puts you in a bad spot for sure. If for some reason the item they ship is not what you paid for, you should be able to return it under the item doesn't match description or photos. (not as described)
Not sure why they asked that, but I have a feeling it was because they didn't account for the shipping costs beforehand. But asking for money outside of eBay is against eBay policy, and as a seller its a big no-no.
Does this seller have a good history or are they a new seller? Can you provide just the item number?
I have one I'm dealing with as a seller that is now 3 weeks ongoing. I shipped out an item, took forever to get to a hub in FL, then got stuck in that hub for nearly 2 weeks. During that time the buyer canceled as it was taking so long, I filed a trace, USPS couldn't find it, told me to open a lost package claim, did that, refunded the buyer. Now the **bleep** thing is moving through the system and will probably be delivered tomorrow. And I'm out the item, the shipping, and the buyer got their money back. Fun times.
Seller's don't have it easy either, but there are some shady ones out there.
kraftique
gator Flordia Postal is a nightmare- expect it to be that slow..
BFC.. when it arrives- just file a not as described. You will have to decide what to put down. The seller will have to pay for the postage to have the item sent back.
gator08041971
@kraftique
I know it is at the moment. But till that particular transaction, never had an issue going to or coming from FL.
Anyway.
fab_finds4u
Don't recommend he return something using not as described if he receives it and it matches what he purchased.
The seller tried to get $ to insure it after the fact but the buyer didn't bite. Maybe the seller wasn't aware he couldn't ask for additional money.
He shipped and now the OP needs to look for it when it's expected to be delivered.