Tracking Matrics and Hold on Funds
Summary: icarve is an experienced eBay seller facing issues with a $400 fund hold due to not uploading tracking information for several orders. They have a high success rate with 1,400+ sales and 100% positive feedback but found their "Tracking uploaded on time and validated" rate is at 84.62%. They reached out to eBay for a manual review but received unclear responses. icarve seeks advice from other sellers about handling payout holds and improving tracking metrics. disneyshopper advised against shipping items using stamped envelopes without tracking.
I’d really appreciate some input from other experienced eBay sellers.
I’ve been selling on eBay for years and have consistently maintained Top Rated Seller status. I have 1,400+ completed sales and 100% positive feedback, and until recently I’ve had no significant problems with my account or payouts.
Recently, eBay placed a hold on approximately $400 of my funds. Customer Service told me the hold is related to tracking not being uploaded on certain orders. My normal payout schedule would have made those funds available to transfer to my bank account.
I checked my Seller Performance dashboard and found that my “Tracking uploaded on time and validated” rate is currently 84.62%, with 33 of 39 shipments meeting the requirement. Six transactions are showing as “Not uploaded.” Three of those six were small items I shipped in stamped envelopes without tracking. All three were delivered, and the buyers left positive feedback.
Interestingly, eBay also confirmed that the two transaction defects currently showing on my account are NOT affecting my seller status. However, eBay says my account is currently projected to drop from Top Rated to Above Standard at the October 20 evaluation because of the tracking metric.
I’ve contacted eBay Customer Service several times and specifically asked whether those six transactions could be manually reviewed, particularly the ones that were successfully delivered. I haven't been able to get a clear answer as to whether a review was actually submitted or whether there is any way to appeal those tracking metrics.
eBay also told me that the payment holds are temporary and that my account will eventually be reassessed after I establish a “consistent and positive selling history.” When I asked what that actually means—how many transactions, how long, or what specific criteria are involved—the agent ended the chat without answering the question.
So I'm curious about other sellers' experiences:
Has anyone else had eBay place payout holds on an established seller account because of tracking metrics? If so, how long did the holds last, and what did you have to do to get back to your normal payout schedule?
And has anyone successfully gotten eBay to manually review or remove tracking-related transactions from the “Tracking uploaded on time and validated” metric when the items were actually delivered?
I'm not necessarily looking to bash eBay. I'm trying to understand whether what I'm experiencing is normal, whether there's something I'm missing, and what my options are. I'd really appreciate hearing from sellers who have been through something similar.
disneyshopper
MentorDo not continue to ship out items using a postage stamp. There is no tracking for those envelopes. If the items qualify, you can use the ebay Standard Envelope (trading cards/post cards/decals/coins/etc).
icarve
OPMy bad... I should have referenced this fact in my post. Thank you for pointing out this valuable info. I learned this lesson 'after the fact'. My take from your comment is that because I didn't spend the extra dollar to purchase the eBay shipping option, I deserve to have my sales from this point forward flagged and held until delivered. Additionally, I lose my top-rated status. With 100% positive feedback, this feels like eBay doesn't care much about looking-out on its 'bread-n-butter' sellers.... just my opinion.