TOP SELLER STATUS (live seller vs. Store sales)
Summary: almaofaustin expressed frustration over eBay's new policy requiring 100 store sales for Top Seller status, excluding live show sales. Despite having hundreds of positive reviews and sales from live shows, their status was downgraded due to the policy change. disneyshopper and mr_lincoln offered support and suggested lodging a formal complaint. eBay's response clarified the new separation of 'Core' and 'Live' transactions but did not explain the reasoning behind the change, leaving almaofaustin feeling it might be a push towards more promotions.
WHYYYYYY did eBay change this? I am a LIVE Seller and make 99% of my sales in the show. I had top seller before the change and now I have to have 100 sales before I get the TOP Seller status. Even though I've made hundreds of sales already (in the live show), they don't count those and now require me to make 100 through my store in order to get TOP SELLER status back. WHY? It just doesnt make sense to me. I have 100% positive reviews and hundreds of sales. In the end, does it matter? I just need an old school to make it make sense. Maybe if I understood the reasoning behind the change I could process it all. But they don't explain that when answering me and sometimes don't even answer my questions. Does TOP SELLER status really matter? I see that you get certain benefits but it feels awful pushy to require this when I'm already making hundreds of sales. It almost feels pointless to me. ALL that work I put into making TOP SELLER and for what now? They don't explain to me the differences in benefits or if there are penalties for not meeting their standard. Does anyone know where I can read about this?
mr_lincoln
MentorHi @almaofaustin
eBay's Top Rated Seller status requires 100 Domestic sales and $ 1,000 in Domestic sales dollars in the last 12 consecutive months. I see on your Sold list in the last 90 days you have sold quite a few "UNLESTED ITEM" which I assume means via eBay Live.
eBay reviews accounts on the 20th of each month and if a change is necessitated it goes into effect shortly thereafter.
I happen to agree with you, a sale through eBay is a sale. Here is an interesting statement about eBay live, " Owned and managed by eBay: eBay Live is not a third‑party site; it is powered by eBay Inc. and follows eBay’s rules, policies, and User Agreement"
To me that means Sellers using eBay live should be getting credit for their sales with regard to their Seller Status.
Make sure you use the question mark link in the lower right-hand corner of the eBay Live or eBay home page and log a formal complaint.
almaofaustin
OPTHANK YOU! Well, I actually did. I wrote them immediately after receiving the change. They didn't answer my question, though. I am in the process of sending a more formal email and asking that they explain the new change to me as if I am 5 years old because it doesn't make sense.
mr_lincoln
Mentor@almaofaustin
You are more than welcome. If eBay happens to Grace you with a reply please share it here. Not to be a pessimist but don't expect them to rush to answer your question despite how reasonable it is.
almaofaustin
OPlol I've been reading some of these discussions so i see that the majority certainly have a reason to be pessimistic lol I will say that I've not had that problem. They respond but when it comes to answering the actual question, they dance around it.
mr_lincoln
Mentor@almaofaustin
Agreed! In business we used to call that "fumbling" the answer away to a question. Actually, one of the big culprits through all of this is eBay Seller metrics. eBay is fixated on trying to monitor and control Sellers through their very, very subjective metrics. In a perfect world, like eBay being good at juggling one ball, every sale would be ONE item in ONE package shipped on time, delivered on time and NO issues on the transaction after that. Reality is something different and no two sellers are the same so in basic terms the basis of comparison is virtually non-existent especially for used items. Also, while many - most Sellers are completely capable of constructing their own deals eBay is inflexible in letting them do that.
almaofaustin
OPTRUE. Yes, A point I made (or was TRYING to make) lol with eBay today over the phone. i stated that how can they essentially punishing me for not making a sale the same way another seller does? Make it make sense. its a sale for godsake. WHO CARES how I made it?!
almaofaustin
OPI guess I need to stop complaining and figure out a way to stick my tongue out at ebay and increase the sales in the store now. This only lights the fire under my ****. I'll show them i don't need their stinking promotions to make sales..lol
almaofaustin
OPHere is the answer I received: To provide clarity, eBay recently changed how seller levels are displayed and calculated for eBay Core vs. eBay Live. As of October 15, 2026, eBay Core and eBay Live seller levels are separate.
Why you’re seeing “Above Standard” (instead of Top Rated)
In your Seller Dashboard, the metrics you’re currently viewing reflect eBay Core performance. The reason your account is showing Above Standard (and not Top Rated) is tied to the transaction requirement:
To maintain Top Rated Seller status, you need at least 100 transactions (within the applicable evaluation period).
Right now, your dashboard is showing 27 transactions—which represents transactions outside of eBay Live (i.e., eBay Core activity).
So while your overall performance may look great, the Core transaction volume being below the threshold is what’s impacting the Top Rated designation on that screen.
About Promoted Listings / paying for promotions
I also understand your concerns about promoting listings, especially when you’re trying to manage costs. Promotions are completely optional and not required. That said, promoted listings can increase item visibility and help you stay competitive—particularly if others in your category are using ads.
eBay Live onboarding and account management changes
You’re also correct that things have changed on the eBay Live side. eBay Live recently moved to a self-serve onboarding experience. In the past, some sellers were assigned Account Managers to assist with onboarding and account support, but this was not something provided to every seller.
Key takeaway
Your main concern appears to be the transaction count used for seller level—and at this time, since eBay Live and eBay Core are separated, the dashboard view you’re referencing is showing eBay Core transactions only, which is why you’re seeing the change in status.
AGAIN, they didnt actually answer me about why. I already understood their rule by the time I got this email but WHY did it come about in the first place and who does it benefit because it doesnt benefit me. And if it does how? It felt like their way to push me into buying promotions.
mr_lincoln
Mentor@almaofaustin
eBay "Core transactions" ... hmmm, that's a new one. I must have missed the (non-existent) memo on that one LOL!
almaofaustin
OPexactly but somehow we should know this. We are now required to read their minds.
disneyshopper
MentorWhen you started Live selling, did you stop listing and selling on ebay.com? If so, and you did not meet the 100 sales (and I think $1000) then you would lose that top rated seller status.
almaofaustin
OPI never stopped listing. I still list but i don't get sales. I double checked because 1000 sounded wrong but NO, its 100 (according to the customer service eBay rep). I did not have any sales from the site until I started selling LIVE in April. They gave me top seller status in June I believe after I had accumulated the necessary sales then took it away after they changed their policy to not include sales that come from LIVE shows. Which again, makes no sense. its a sale regardless of how it came about. I still get traffic in the store and I'm doing what I can to improve the amount of traffic (also changed how i listed, added more info, better photos, etc). The luxury purses sell easily. its the other items like clothing and jewelry that don't. They keep pushing promotion and I tested it and found that the traffic is higher without the promotion when I'm consistenly working shows. It doesnt make sense to pay the money on the fees when I can get the sales without it. Infact, as soon as I stopped the promotion and started increasing my shows the traffic soared. Granted, they don't purchase from the site, BUT they do come to the shows and buy then. The only thing I can think of is offering Free Shipping when they purchase outside the show. I can probably do this by refunding them the shipping cost, correct? Or is there another way? I want that to be a perk for viewers to make purchases outside the show. Sorry off topic.
almaofaustin
OPby the way, do you know WHY they made this change? Thats really my question.