Stanley plane listing error corrected
Sold Stanley number 1 plane. $1535 with two bidders was the final price. The problem is that I goofed up the original listing - listed it as Type 1 (1867-1869). Community feedback during the listing period directed me to find it was a Type 4 (1874-1884). Listing was updated twice - both before the bidding ended (obviously) - a day ahead of the end - which was immediately after I had been told about the correcting information. I included all the updates as well as the link to the typing guide I had originally used to show how it was an honest mistake. Also stated that no misrepresentation was intended. Winning bidder says he was never notified of the listing updates. He paid. He received the shipment. He then says he re-read the listing description and states that he would like a refund. The listing was a “returns not accepted†but, I get that there may be some room for discussion here. Buyer would like to streamline the process if I were to agree to a refund - I send a check, he mails it back. I said I can’t do that. We must to go through eBay. That’s the only way I would do it if I agree. This is not an inexpensive item. Not sure if eBay would refund the 15% sellers fee. It’s a chunk of change.
Please advise if you have had similar issue. Thank you in advance
extra info- Typing early stanley planes is apparently harder than it seems. But, it’s all done by examining the parts - all of the parts were in the pictures of the listing. That’s how I got the original feedback to update the listing. So, I am surprised that the buyer was “shocked†when he examined the plane on arrival and discovered it was a type 4 - describing to me in detail things that would have been visible in the listing pics. It’s a little frustrating.
rfmtm
MentorYou should have not been able to revise the listing, if there were bids on it. So don't know how that would have occurred or buyer notified.
If not what was in the original listing buyer purchased from, no-returns is overridden by buyer opening an Item Not As Described dispute for not matching the original listing description. Unless buyer wants to accept a partial refund for the mistake, accept the return and do not refund until the item is back.
tfritz6
OPThe listing updates are available when there are bidders. People ask questions, want more pictures, even in this case provided helpful information to update the description. You can’t change the Title, or the original description- True enough. But, you can add information that updates the listing content. I have received updates as a bidder in the past, pretty sure about that, including price changes, and information updates. Is the only right option to cancel a listing with active bidders if you find a mistake that you need to correct? Maybe I should have done that. Thanks for the answer. Help is greatly appreciated.
rfmtm
MentorIt is only the title and original description that counts and that can't be changed (revised). The additions (updates) you make really don't count when a dispute it filed. I don't ever remember getting an alert when any listing had added information applied, but that may have changed.
Yes, when a serious error is found it is best to cancel the bids and end the listing. Or before shipping to ask the winner to be sure they understand the changes and still want the item or whether they wish to cancel.