Sales tax improperly applied to shipping cost
Summary: jleiser-half raised a concern about being charged sales tax on a shipping fee for an item purchased on eBay, questioning if it was an error in eBay's sales tax calculation. eburtonlab clarified using information from TaxJar, explaining that in Indiana, shipping charges are taxable if the item is taxable, even if listed separately. jleiser-half acknowledged the explanation and shared further corroborating information from an Indiana Department of Revenue bulletin, noting the complexity of the issue.
I bought an item for $64.07. The listing indicated that the item could be picked up from the seller's Oregon, Illinois, location for free, or it could be shipped to me in Indianapolis, Indiana, for $57.93. I elected shipping (total item + shipping $122.00). At checkout eBay added $8.54 (7% of $122.00) as sales tax. However, since shipping was optional and the shipping cost was separated out from the item cost in the listing, sales tax should have been applied only to the item cost, i.e. 7% of 64.07 = $4.48.
First, what caused the error and is this is a problem intrinsic to eBay's sales tax calculation algorithm?
And second, if this sales tax error occurred with other buyers who also had the option of direct pickup but chose shipping, how will they be reimbursed for the overcharges (which, when summed up, may be a large amount of money).
eburtonlab
Mentor@jleiser-half
According to TaxJar, unless the separate shipping charge was only the actual USPS shipping and nothing else (no handling charge, no packaging fee, no UPS or FedEx charges), in Indiana shipping is taxable if the item is taxable, even when separately stated.
https://www.taxjar.com/blog/retail/sales-tax-on-shipping-in-indiana
jleiser-half
OPEburtonlab, thank you for your correction and reference. The item is being shipped via Fed Ex, so taxing shipping to Indiana is proper. With further research I found this 2025 Indiana Dept of Revenue Sales Tax Information Bulletin (#92) https://www.in.gov/dor/files/sib92.pdf. So convoluted.