Reviews of purchases
I am not inclined to leave a review anymore because it seems that unless you leave a five star review then the seller is very disappointed. I have been contacted to change my review from neutral to something better. I don’t want to hurt anyone’s business, but I do want to be truthful. if an item is labeled 3X, and my measurements equal a large, then a 3X should fit. I ordered much larger because I knew that the country of origin usually had no idea what an American large is. If I state that the item run small, that is perceived as negative. Five star, to me, means above and beyond excellent. Four would be great, three would be adequate, good, acceptable, I’m going to keep it.
lsbe63
2 comments
inceptions
MentorThere are three ratings you can give for feedback - positive, neutral, or negative. Positive does not mean "five stars" or "above and beyond excellent." Positive means not a negative experience (i.e. a really terrible experience with the seller that others need to know about so they are forewarned to stay away and protect themselves) or a neutral experience (some things bothered you about how the seller performed, but not bad enough to rate him negatively).
For clothing items, I won't buy them unless the seller lists the dimensions in the listing so I know how it will fit, and I won't buy from sellers with a no-returns policy. I will at all costs stay away from buying from sellers in China unless the seller has a long track record of 100% positive feedback that looks legitimate (and I haven't found one of those yet, but then I don't look very hard to find one) because I don't want sub-standard quality, counterfeits, or materials that don't meet US standards for safety. (I'm not talking about items made in China for American manufacturers which do meet quality standards set by the US and also the companies own manufacturing standards).
In 19 years on eBay, I have never had the need to leave a negative or neutral feedback because I vet the seller before I buy. If I have a problem (and I've only had one), I work it out with the seller and/or use the Money Back Guarantee.
house*of*paws
MentorHi @lsbe63
In my experience, most companies that request 1-5 ratings consider ratings less than 5 to be problematic.
For that reason, I usually don’t rate items that I’m uncomfortable giving a 5.
eBay’s feedback is supposed to rate the ENTIRE transaction … not just the item. IMHO, an item running small does NOT warrant neutral feedback if everything else was satisfactory. Request a return if you wish.
BTW, I believe there is another place to rate the ITEM alone.