Return on Pokemon card
I’m a new eBay seller going into my 3rd week and host a store selling used sports/Pokemon cards. I recently made a sale and shipped it off immediately. The Pokemon card arrived yesterday and I received a notification that the buyer was requesting a refund. Initially I thought it may be due to the condition of the card, even though I felt I had correctly labeled it for its used condition. The notification stated that the Pokemon card the buyer had received was a counterfeit and would like to return the card and a refund. He attached pictures of both the front and back of the card in his request. The back looked identical to what I sent to him, but the front of the card had peeling on one of the corners and one of the corners actually looked better than the card I had sent. My fear is the buyer is requesting a refund to return a card that is not the same card I sent to him so he ends up with a better conditioned card or maybe a real card and he sends me back a counterfeit card. Does anyone have any experience dealing with a situation like this and how to handle it? When I listed the card, I thought I had turned off returns. I now know I need to check these things before listing an item. Any guidance or help is greatly appreciated.