Return dispute
Hello,
I have a buyer returning silver plated flatware ordered at the beginning of December, right before the 30 day limit. The issue is, the buyer says the flatware is "Not Silver Plate" and it is "Tarnished". I can dispute both comments all day long based on the particular item. However, the items are New Old Stock, from an estate, that were in plastic, factory marked, sleeves. The buyer says she cannot return the plastic sleeves because she threw them away when received. To me, the sleeves were a key selling part of the product.
Is a full refund required in this case? Assuming they were not used for Christmas dinner 😞
Thanks
vinwood01
1 comment
wooden_flower
Mentor@vinwood01
Since you are top rated and offer returns, you can hit hold a portion of the refund for the change in condition. There is a chart to help you determine what you can withhold here - https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/managing-returns-refunds/handle-return-request-seller?id=4115#refund_guidelines
Missing original packaging is 5% - 10% deduction. If you issue less than a full refund, your final value fees will not be refunded, so it might cost you less to issue a full refund.