Return arrived damaged, box was fine, and I lost the case on appeal. How do other sellers handle this?
Summary: theparts-0 seeks advice from other sellers regarding a situation where a returned item, a $220 board, arrived damaged inside an intact shipping box. Despite submitting photos and appealing, the decision was in favor of the buyer, resulting in a loss for theparts-0. They are asking for experiences and strategies other sellers have used to successfully handle such cases, including whether taking photos or videos upon opening returns helps, and if there are any seller protections for high-value items.
Hello everyone,
I would like to ask for advice from other sellers about a situation I recently went through.
A buyer returned a $220 board because it was not compatible with the item they own. When the return arrived, the shipping box was in good condition, but the edge of the board inside was damaged. Because of the damage, I can no longer resell it.
I submitted photos of the box and the damaged board and filed an appeal, but the decision was made in the buyer's favor. As a result, I have to absorb the full loss.
I have been losing money on returns that arrive damaged like this, and I am trying to understand what else I can do.
- Has anyone successfully won a case like this? What evidence worked for you?
- Do you take photos or video when you open returns?
- Are there any seller protections or settings that can help with high-value items?
I would really appreciate any tips or experiences you can share. Thank you!
fashionsandbeauty4u
Mentor@theparts-0
I would encourage you to offer returns.
Sellers who are Top Rated and offer 30-day returns or are Above Standard and offer free, 30-day returns, are eligible to deduct up to 50% of a refund if the Buyer returns the item in a different condition than as sent.
Sellers who do not offer returns do not have that option.
Top Rated Sellers who offer 30-day Buyer-paid returns also qualify.